Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Can you cope with 6/7% interest rates when your mortgage expires?

308 replies

onthefencesitter · 23/09/2022 21:09

www.bankofamerica.com/mortgage/mortgage-rates/

American interest rates are at that level now and given the level of tax cuts that are going to be implemented, I think we would be at 6/7% at least by next year, perhaps even 8%

Vote YABU for no.
Vote YANBU for yes

OP posts:
AltheaVestr1t · 25/09/2022 09:14

Yes. It won't be fun and would mean serious cutting back, but we'd manage.

BooksAndChooks · 25/09/2022 09:12

@Pineappledpizza I would also like to know more. Do you have any links explaining further?

MargeSampson · 25/09/2022 09:09

I recently took a five year fixed rate to ensure I can afford my mortgage.

There are suggestions you should do this, even if it means an early repayment charge.

LakieLady · 25/09/2022 08:45

MidnightMeltdown · 23/09/2022 23:08

I think a better idea would be to extend the mortgage term. That's what I would do if I was struggling to pay.

I agree, for most people that's the better option. I have friends who went for interest only in the expectation of career advancement, inheritance etc. In most cases, those expectations weren't met for various reasons and their retirement plans have been scuppered by the need to downsize to repay capital.

GreenGreenArse · 25/09/2022 08:40

^Pineapple* please explain further- thank you for this. Any clues as to how long this period of rises could last are helpful for us to factor in. What exactly should we be looking out for?

Pineappledpizza · 25/09/2022 08:28

I think we're heading into an era of higher inflation & interest rates than the past 12-13 years. That said, the best indicator of future interest rates is the bond market which is pricing in the Bank of England (and other central banks) essentially breaking their economy's in order to bring down inflation resulting in them having to quickly reverse the rate rises we're currently seeing from around spring/summer next year. So if you need to remortgage next year it might be worth holding out on the variable for a few months and monitoring the trajectory of the rates before fixing again.

BooksAndChooks · 25/09/2022 08:17

Furries · 25/09/2022 01:32

Thanks - I’m not keen on changing lenders, just due to the whole palaver of new valuations, delving into financial info etc. Am with a well-known building society (which feels “safe” to me). Think I’ll set aside time in the week to actually call them to discuss options and work out various scenarios.

I did do a quick trawl on a comparison site this evening - and couldn’t find anything better than what I’d roughly worked out re new deal with my current lender.

TBH, I think my main dilemma is the term. Half of me wants to do a 10 year and just have peace of mind. The other half wants to do 5 years in the hope that rates come down before the end of it as I hate the thought of paying more when I don’t have to. I guess this is a dilemma a lot of people are struggling with atm.

6/7%+ wouldn't be impossible for us, but it would be very uncomfortable, and we factored that in to our thinking when we chose a 10 year fix. I suppose if you feel higher rates are more affordable for you the balance of risk might be different.

rockyg · 25/09/2022 08:16

Huge drops like that will decimate the economy, look at the state it's in now.

LakieLady · 25/09/2022 08:06

Notlosinganyweight · 23/09/2022 22:07

Jesus Christ. I have been following a chap online who has been in the property game for years and he said house prices could drop by 40% and is expecting recent FT buyers to be in negative equity. I have been following this for a while and expected this, but the rate in which things are declining is quite shocking. I hope you can manage the increase. I hate the way in which home ownership has become a lottery.

That will all sound very familiar to us older MNers. In the late 80s, the value of my house fell by nearly 50%. I'd bought several years earlier, so wasn't in negative equity, but a friend who'd bought more recently was in negative equity for years.

Ironically, it did her a favour as she split up with her partner. If prices hadn't crashed, she'd have had to buy him out, but as there was no equity so he was entitled to nothing!

Iirc, prices didn't fully recover until the second half of the 90s.

The big difference between now and then is that inflation rates fell and remained pretty low throughout the decade. I fear that may not be the case now.

LakieLady · 25/09/2022 07:49

I am currently considering selling and relocating and buying outright if that's possible. I am absolutely overwhelmed with what to do and nobody to share that worry with. I don't know where to start to make that decision. Absolutely terrified with how things are going in this country and particularly after today's horrific budget.

I think I would do exactly that if I was in your shoes, @TheFormidableMrsC . It's a really difficult position to be in.

DIanaRiggFan · 25/09/2022 07:34

We fixed in Feb (rate booked Dec) at 1.29% for 5 years on a large mortgage. We have loads of work to do to our house (some cash set aside but working on basis the works will take all our spare cash until end 2024). Nursery fees currently 1433 a month but reduce next sept when DC1 starts school and I am going to increase my hours at work. Nursery fees completely gone by sept 2025.

so I think we could afford an increase by time our fixed rate up (may 2027).

That said, I am worrying a bit and plan is that once works over, depending on what is happening with rates then, we save to pay off a chunk at end of fixed rate. That cash was supposed tp be chucked towards pensions but we did buy a large house so plan will be to downsize when in our 60’s

the other option is that once both DC in school I go back to doing what I did pre-kids, don’t really want to as was v stressful job with long hours but would double my salary

so we have options which I know we are lucky to have

we almost bought a house last year which would have been an even larger mortgage and longer term (and it was at a higher rate of interest due to the lender we would have had tp go with to borrow). No works were required to that house but I’m glad we didn’t take on that mortgage now (they pulled out 2 weeks prior to completion)

I do think it’s scary times and we are trying to make cut backs in our daily living costs to save as much as possible - I also suffer from anxiety so am a perpetual worrier!

Furries · 25/09/2022 01:32

BooksAndChooks · 24/09/2022 23:46

Some lenders will let you book their fix 6 months in advance. It sounds like it would mean changing lenders for you though, which isn't always practical for people.

Thanks - I’m not keen on changing lenders, just due to the whole palaver of new valuations, delving into financial info etc. Am with a well-known building society (which feels “safe” to me). Think I’ll set aside time in the week to actually call them to discuss options and work out various scenarios.

I did do a quick trawl on a comparison site this evening - and couldn’t find anything better than what I’d roughly worked out re new deal with my current lender.

TBH, I think my main dilemma is the term. Half of me wants to do a 10 year and just have peace of mind. The other half wants to do 5 years in the hope that rates come down before the end of it as I hate the thought of paying more when I don’t have to. I guess this is a dilemma a lot of people are struggling with atm.

Whatafustercluck · 24/09/2022 23:56

We fixed for 5 years earlier this year and have £87k amd 15 years left to pay. Hoping to overpay a little in Feb/ Mar and every year if possible, so if the financial situation isn't much better in a few years we should still be fine, providing nothing drastic changes and we still have our jobs.

BooksAndChooks · 24/09/2022 23:46

Furries · 24/09/2022 23:34

My fixed deal finishes at the end of May. Terms state that I can move to a new deal free of charges 3 months before that - but am nervous about how rates will have increased by then. Currently trying to decide whether to pay ERC and fix a new deal now. I wouldn’t be able to pay the ERC upfront, would have to add it to the mortgage.

Ive got 14.5 years left on the mortgage - would probably fix for 5 years (to give me peace of mind and hope that rates come back down by then. LTV is around 38%, which sounds good, but equally it’s not a small amount each month for my mortgage.

Am single, so responsibility all on me and no partner to talk it over with. Feel like I’m going round in circles in my head!

Some lenders will let you book their fix 6 months in advance. It sounds like it would mean changing lenders for you though, which isn't always practical for people.

Furries · 24/09/2022 23:34

My fixed deal finishes at the end of May. Terms state that I can move to a new deal free of charges 3 months before that - but am nervous about how rates will have increased by then. Currently trying to decide whether to pay ERC and fix a new deal now. I wouldn’t be able to pay the ERC upfront, would have to add it to the mortgage.

Ive got 14.5 years left on the mortgage - would probably fix for 5 years (to give me peace of mind and hope that rates come back down by then. LTV is around 38%, which sounds good, but equally it’s not a small amount each month for my mortgage.

Am single, so responsibility all on me and no partner to talk it over with. Feel like I’m going round in circles in my head!

Magn · 24/09/2022 19:59

The bank of England base rate has, with some exceptions, been a pretty steady 5ish percent for over 300 years. It seems likely that we'd be able to expect to work towards something like that in the longer term. Looking at the exceptions, they seem to be due to wars and major oil price rises which have caused big spikes. I'm not an economist - this is based on the information the government gives us on past rates.

Personally I fixed recently at a rate that I was comfortable paying. It might cost me more over the longer term than going for a lower rate for a shorter time but I'm expecting to have a fixed cost while my childcare fees are eyewatering and a potential higher cost once they come down massively.

LimboLass · 24/09/2022 19:44

Seven years left but to keep some money spare for holidays and a reasonable standard of living we will probably extend the term a little when the fix expires. Yes it will cost more long term but I think worth it to have spare money each month for fun things.

EvenLess07 · 24/09/2022 19:30

We'd be ok at 7%, or even manage at 15% but that would be the bare essentials only. I'm very glad we fixed for 5 years earlier this year. We're early 30s with 22 years left.

I feel very sorry for people who are about to be in serious trouble because of this 😥my parents really struggled in the 90s due to the interest rates and have never been able to afford to buy again once they sold their house at a huge loss. It's truly shit.

Amboseli · 24/09/2022 19:27

wigywhoo · 24/09/2022 19:04

Me too, I set up a spreadsheet, quite an eye opener when the low rate vs. Fee examined closely!

That's exactly what I worked out. When you add the fee to the mortgage and extra interest on it a lot of deals aren't that good.

We're on a lifetime tracker 0.4 above base. Have had it since 2007 so have benefited from low rates. I'm wondering whether to fix as at around 4% I'll be paying more than I am now until my rate reaches 4% and then probably more for x months and then possibly go back down again so overall probably work out to the same.

Sunbird24 · 24/09/2022 19:06

@wigywhoo i should probably do it that way! 🤦‍♀️😂

wigywhoo · 24/09/2022 19:04

Sunbird24 · 24/09/2022 18:57

@HangerLaneGyratorySystem I am generally fairly financially savvy anyway but I’ve made a point of doing my own research on mortgage rates etc - I can spend a couple of hours with my notebook and a calculator doing all the maths to compare different rates and fees combos to work out which one works out better for my finances when I’ve got a rate coming to an end.

For example, I could have got a better interest rate for my newest bit of mortgage if I’d paid a £1k fee, but because of the amount of mortgage I wanted, it actually worked out more expensive over the 5 years I was fixing for to do it that way. With the 3.85% rate, not only do I not pay a fee but I also get £500 cashback from the bank when I make my first payment. Lots of different variables to consider, but I love that sort of problem-solving.

Me too, I set up a spreadsheet, quite an eye opener when the low rate vs. Fee examined closely!

Sunbird24 · 24/09/2022 18:57

@HangerLaneGyratorySystem I am generally fairly financially savvy anyway but I’ve made a point of doing my own research on mortgage rates etc - I can spend a couple of hours with my notebook and a calculator doing all the maths to compare different rates and fees combos to work out which one works out better for my finances when I’ve got a rate coming to an end.

For example, I could have got a better interest rate for my newest bit of mortgage if I’d paid a £1k fee, but because of the amount of mortgage I wanted, it actually worked out more expensive over the 5 years I was fixing for to do it that way. With the 3.85% rate, not only do I not pay a fee but I also get £500 cashback from the bank when I make my first payment. Lots of different variables to consider, but I love that sort of problem-solving.

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 24/09/2022 18:45

WTAF means I think surely not, and clearly I am in the minority - I did ask earlier how do you all know this? I'm 60, I've seen various recessions etc., but everyone seems to have some inside knowledge I don't?

Testina · 24/09/2022 17:42

HangerLaneGyratorySystem · 24/09/2022 17:11

"I am going to assume that I won't see interest rates on mortgages below 5% for the rest of my life time and work out what is affordable based on that."

Really? I mean I'm not doubting you personally but WTAF? Is that what others on here think?

Seems like an excellent approach to me.
Genuinely interested in the reason for your “WTAF” @HangerLaneGyratorySystem

Where do you think interest rates will go this decade?

Can you cope with 6/7% interest rates when your mortgage expires?
Onceuponawhileago · 24/09/2022 17:40

NatMoz · 24/09/2022 05:16

When we first got our mortgage it was £270k, we're now at £193k. Our 1.94% interest rate ends November 2023 and my salary will have reduced due to childcare PLUS we will be paying 2 days a week nursery which we weren't before.

Due to inheritance we will overpay £50k so I'm hoping that makes a dent

@NatMoz Dont pay 50k in a lump. Use it per month thus buying yourself months of mortgage holidays. Use the money you would have spent on monthly payments to save and absorb energy cost increases. By the time you get through 50k the rates will have dropped and you will have kept payments, met interest rate increases and absorbed cost of living through cashflow. Save like crazy.

Swipe left for the next trending thread