Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really want to be a SAHM

267 replies

Wanttostayhome · 23/09/2022 20:08

I work PT, but I really don’t want to, I’m saying this here as I can’t stay at home. It wouldn’t be good for my career or pension and there are so many sensible reasons to work. But I don’t actually want to! Does anyone else feel the same?

OP posts:
pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:52

@3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens

Well yes it depends on earning potential

As said in my first post the OP is currently PT so clearly not the most ambitious human to begin with, so going from that to SAHP isn't going to be that big an issue.

But for many they want to work, they want to be good role models to their children (daughters in particular) and that should be something people view positively

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 14:48

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:37

Your last line is exactly what I think some SAHPs don't quite understand or appreciate

I benefitted so much from seeing my mum and dad work, I learned that women can earn as much, if not more than men, I have so much respect for my mum and out of all those I went to secondary school with those with the SAHPs are the ones with the lower paid jobs now as adults.

Yes a selective sample, but my year group was over 1000 kids so a pretty decent sample

That only works if you have a decent earning potential in the first place.
For example, those of us in childcare are paid a pittance, so going back to work and paying someone to raise our children when we are uniquely qualified for it makes no sense at all.

Bottom line is different things work for different people. I have an accountant friend who earns more than I would working full time in two days work. She needs to keep her skills sharp. It works for her.
If I went back to work my wage wouldn't cover one child, let alone two and I'd be looking after other people's children for a wage and then paying for someone to look after mine and being financially worse off.
It's going to be very unique to each individual's.circumstances and the endless judgement from so called feminists who don't value raising children is actually pretty patriarchal.

You can also be thrown massive curve balls like having a child with a disability, pnd, grandparent childcare falling through and suddenly your plans can change.

People need to stop putting a value judgement on everything and help.others with constructive advice to work out what is best for that particular family.

Belladonnamama · 24/09/2022 14:45

Im a SAHM, DC are 10,12 and 14. I left a good career. I went back when youngest started school for a couple of years but it wasn't worth it after childcare was paid for. The stress of running around dropping collecting was a hassle too. I'm much happier at home. I do receive a substantial income due to ill health not UK based which pays for the weekly shopping my car payment,diesel and gas and electricity. My DH has a very good job ,we bought out house 12 years ago so the mortgage is very manageable. My DH also gives me 200 euro a week for myself. I also have two pensions that I have continued to pay into. They won't be worth a huge amount but will be a bit extra when the time comes. It works for us. I love being able to drop and pick them up from school. They come home to a nice clean,cosy home and a nice dinner. I have time for them because I'm not trying to juggle a job.

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:43

You have misunderstood pickledeggnog.

If, as a man, you are not willing to fully support a family (or if you are one if these marvels of men who wants to retain his own bank account), then you had better find a woman who looks like she would rather eat her own arm than SAH.

If you are a man who does not want a wife who is going to prioritise her career, or who isn't sure, then you'd better be prepared to financially support your family then. Have a plan.

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:38

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:35

Why are men supposed to look out for women who want to work?

Not sure

That was your point though wasn't it

That men who don't want a SAHM as a wife need to make sure they only breed with women who want to work

But now all men need to be prepared to have to support a SAHM

Which is it?

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:37

Nachobutt · 24/09/2022 14:23

I took a year's break while the DC were very young and I work flexibly now. I can understand the value of being around when DC are young and I would also argue that there is a need to be present when they're teens, but I would struggle with the idea of not working at all.

Why a woman in this day and age would leave herself so at the mercy of another person for her day-to-day financial wellbeing is beyond me. Aside from the risks of a relationship break-up what happens if your partner becomes ill. I want my DC to see me contributing equally to the household financially as DH, if only for them to see that women can earn the same as men.

Your last line is exactly what I think some SAHPs don't quite understand or appreciate

I benefitted so much from seeing my mum and dad work, I learned that women can earn as much, if not more than men, I have so much respect for my mum and out of all those I went to secondary school with those with the SAHPs are the ones with the lower paid jobs now as adults.

Yes a selective sample, but my year group was over 1000 kids so a pretty decent sample

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:35

Why are men supposed to look out for women who want to work?

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:34

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:32

Yes I know women don't fall into categories and neither did babies which is my whole point that if you're going to have a family, as a man, you should be prepared to financially support them - if need be. Have a plan. Otherwise wait.

I thought men were supposed to look out for women who want to work?

But now all of them need to plan for their wife deciding to become a SAHM?

Good lord

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:32

Yes I know women don't fall into categories and neither did babies which is my whole point that if you're going to have a family, as a man, you should be prepared to financially support them - if need be. Have a plan. Otherwise wait.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2022 14:29

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:24

By 'type' of woman - a man would.hopefully know who he is about to get pregnant and have a conversation. If he wants a SAH wife, but it's obvious she is not that way inclined, then that won't work will it? Similarly, if he wants s wife to bring money in, don't get involved with a woman if she tells you she would want to look after the baby herself. Different strokes for different folks.

But @thecrunch women don’t fall neatly into these boxes you know?

Some women are incredibly career oriented until they get married and stop forever after children. Some have multiple children and go back to work after long career breaks. Many women are forced to work out of financial necessity. Most are somewhere in the middle.

The idea that you identify a woman as “the working type” versus “the SAHM type” is ludicrously simplistic.

TheMoops · 24/09/2022 14:26

Supporting your family financially is something that men should expect to do for a given period because they are better placed to do that in the early years if a child's life.

What have I just read??

Being a SAHP should be a joint decision. Both parents need to be on board.
You shouldn't just look at your immediate finances either but make sure you've considered how this will impact you in the future.
So many women struggle financially in their later years so protecting yourself is vital.

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:24

By 'type' of woman - a man would.hopefully know who he is about to get pregnant and have a conversation. If he wants a SAH wife, but it's obvious she is not that way inclined, then that won't work will it? Similarly, if he wants s wife to bring money in, don't get involved with a woman if she tells you she would want to look after the baby herself. Different strokes for different folks.

Nachobutt · 24/09/2022 14:23

I took a year's break while the DC were very young and I work flexibly now. I can understand the value of being around when DC are young and I would also argue that there is a need to be present when they're teens, but I would struggle with the idea of not working at all.

Why a woman in this day and age would leave herself so at the mercy of another person for her day-to-day financial wellbeing is beyond me. Aside from the risks of a relationship break-up what happens if your partner becomes ill. I want my DC to see me contributing equally to the household financially as DH, if only for them to see that women can earn the same as men.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2022 14:23

This thread is quite something now. Where’s @topgub when you need her….

ImNotGreta · 24/09/2022 14:22

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:19

Some things are down to men yes - and so they should be. Just like childbirth is down to women. Supporting your family financially is something that men should expect to do for a given period because they are better placed to do that in the early years if a child's life. Men do not give birth, breastfeed or have the same type of emotional responses to having a baby. This hardly needs pointing out. So their primary role at this time is different and they should expect that. That's life.

No, this makes no sense at all. I was on full pay for six months and then went back to work, why would my DH have possibly expected to need to support me financially when I didn’t suffer any reduction in pay?

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2022 14:22

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:19

Some things are down to men yes - and so they should be. Just like childbirth is down to women. Supporting your family financially is something that men should expect to do for a given period because they are better placed to do that in the early years if a child's life. Men do not give birth, breastfeed or have the same type of emotional responses to having a baby. This hardly needs pointing out. So their primary role at this time is different and they should expect that. That's life.

Do you believe only men should work, @thecrunch?

IhateHermioneGranger · 24/09/2022 14:22

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:10

"Kids aren't that interesting."

Better to leave your kids to someone who finds them interesting then.

Aren't parents allowed to view their children as anything other than amazing sometimes?

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:21

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:19

Some things are down to men yes - and so they should be. Just like childbirth is down to women. Supporting your family financially is something that men should expect to do for a given period because they are better placed to do that in the early years if a child's life. Men do not give birth, breastfeed or have the same type of emotional responses to having a baby. This hardly needs pointing out. So their primary role at this time is different and they should expect that. That's life.

Lord knows what you think should happen in same sex relationships, when children are involved.

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:19

Some things are down to men yes - and so they should be. Just like childbirth is down to women. Supporting your family financially is something that men should expect to do for a given period because they are better placed to do that in the early years if a child's life. Men do not give birth, breastfeed or have the same type of emotional responses to having a baby. This hardly needs pointing out. So their primary role at this time is different and they should expect that. That's life.

Softplayhooray · 24/09/2022 14:18

Why should any of us judge? Live and let live. People have different marriages with different strategies that work for them so sometimes that'll be SAHMs, sometimes not, sometimes pooling financial resources, sometimes not. Why the negativity?

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2022 14:18

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:08

If he wants a wife who works, then he should make sure he marries that type of woman. If he's planning a family with a wife who thinks she would want to SAH, or she isn't sure, then he needs to plan accordingly and step up when the time comes. That's life. So many women making excuses for men at their own expense.

@thecrunch

If he wants a wife who works then he should make sure he marries that type of woman.

What “type” of woman would that be then? Do they have tattoos on their foreheads to indicate that they are working women?

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:15

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:13

"Why can't women be expected to fund their own choices?"

Why the hell should she? Yes, save up by all means and that's wise regardless. But why should a married woman have to carry on as if she is single, because a man going to work and supporting his family for a few years, or even indefinitely, is now 'extraordinary' apparently?

Why should people be expected to pay for expensive decisions they've made unilaterally?

Are you for real?

If my husband decides to give up work tomorrow to study for a masters I'd sure as heck expect him to save up for it beforehand and not take from the 'family' pot or my salary

Same applies here

Thankfully most women return to work after having children, the majority of which want to.

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:13

"Why can't women be expected to fund their own choices?"

Why the hell should she? Yes, save up by all means and that's wise regardless. But why should a married woman have to carry on as if she is single, because a man going to work and supporting his family for a few years, or even indefinitely, is now 'extraordinary' apparently?

pickledeggnog · 24/09/2022 14:13

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 14:10

"Kids aren't that interesting."

Better to leave your kids to someone who finds them interesting then.

Still refusing to answer why it's down to men to fund womens choices

Funny that

Softplayhooray · 24/09/2022 14:13

Wanttostayhome · 23/09/2022 20:08

I work PT, but I really don’t want to, I’m saying this here as I can’t stay at home. It wouldn’t be good for my career or pension and there are so many sensible reasons to work. But I don’t actually want to! Does anyone else feel the same?

I did for a while OP and it was as lovely as I thought it would be. So I don't blame you! It didn't really impact me long term career wise (other than obviously not warning anything while being a SAHM). It let me take the leap to become a contractor which I love...maybe others wouldn't as I suppose the job security etc isn't the same but the lack of a permanent boss, feeling like my own boss and lots more flexibility makes me extremely happy!

Swipe left for the next trending thread