Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To really want to be a SAHM

267 replies

Wanttostayhome · 23/09/2022 20:08

I work PT, but I really don’t want to, I’m saying this here as I can’t stay at home. It wouldn’t be good for my career or pension and there are so many sensible reasons to work. But I don’t actually want to! Does anyone else feel the same?

OP posts:
Topgub · 24/09/2022 16:28

@3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens

Yes I agree.

Childcare should ge fully subsidised and pay much more than mw

LondonQueen · 24/09/2022 16:26

I'd love to be a SAHM, however it would be disastrous for my career which I've started, and I have bills to pay!

tiggergoesbounce · 24/09/2022 16:24

I wish I was surprised that women still cling on to such outdated beliefs but unfortunately I don't think we'll ever get past them

I wish i was suprised that other women cant seem to understand, its currently happening because alot of women want to do it. So if its a current option, its not that outdated, its a current choice by many women. I do understand for some its not a choice and its a disgrace we live in a society where womens choices are taken away or devalued, but you can see why we dont have change if women are happy to just point the finger at other women for it.

I also wish i was suprised that other women are still trying to drag down those who choose differently to them.

HamiltonFan1 · 24/09/2022 16:23

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 16:07

The current funded hours and the way the government find it means most childcare providers make a loss and end up working for minimum wage.

Exploiting the largely female workforce in this way is not progressive or feminist.

The reason it's predominantly female is generations of those like the OP and others on here driving ambition down in women.

It's women like this that prop up the gender pay gap and perpetuate the wrong assumptions in young girls that they don't deserve more.

Anyone with a half functioning brain can understand this concept, but they keep bleating on about how women are better placed to raise children, and men who won't support a SAHM are pathetic

BigFatLiar · 24/09/2022 16:20

tiggergoesbounce · 24/09/2022 16:17

I certainly wouldn't have had kids if my oh hadn't been willing to parent them equally

Alot that i know do.
They take over the parenting after they finish work and at weekends so just as much parenting as the SAHM, no?

But you're on mumsnet, the home of deadbeat dads and useless husbands.

tiggergoesbounce · 24/09/2022 16:17

I certainly wouldn't have had kids if my oh hadn't been willing to parent them equally

Alot that i know do.
They take over the parenting after they finish work and at weekends so just as much parenting as the SAHM, no?

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 16:09

Less than minimum wage.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 16:07

The current funded hours and the way the government find it means most childcare providers make a loss and end up working for minimum wage.

Exploiting the largely female workforce in this way is not progressive or feminist.

Topgub · 24/09/2022 15:45

@Thepeopleversuswork

Its just the usual sexist bile really, isn't it?

Both parents should be able to provide for and care for their children. Financially, emotionally, physically. As equally as possible

Parenting /childcare should be valued. Id say it is in our society. The govt finances it to certain extent. Provides 'free' education and early years provision.

It is entirely possible to raise children well while working. Good work life balance should be easier to achieve.

I wish I was surprised that women still cling on to such outdated beliefs but unfortunately I don't think we'll ever get past them.

Although, being a sahm is most definitely a minority now and lots of research shows a lot of sahms arent sahms through choice so maybe things are improving.

I certainly wouldn't have had kids if my oh hadn't been willing to parent them equally

@Wanttostayhome

It sounds like you have a good balance. I'd ve wary of giving that up. I'm sure your kid is fine at nursery and will be in school in no time. Think long term.

tiggergoesbounce · 24/09/2022 15:40

OP, you need to do what is right for your circumstances and your family.

Its ok all these people saying their examples for them, but please remember in life, you need to make decisions for you, not someone elses warped view of a whole bunch of women based on one decision they make.

You will still be an interesting person, if you were one before you had kids and if you were before you give work up.
When i worked full time, i never sat around with my friends and DH talking about work for hours, we had outside interests that continued when i stopped work, we all still love eachothers company because of those interests.

I mean, imagine having a DH or mates that if anything happened to you so you couldn't work, would then deem you boring, if thats the case, make better friends or get more interests outside of work.
But if you and friends enjoy talking about thats absolutely great and nothing wrong with that im just replying to someone implying a non working person would be boring.

It is however and should be, a joint decision i dont think you can suddenly put the sole earning responsibilty onto one individual without their 100% being happy with it.
People should be having these conversations before marriage or kids even arrive (where possible) to check you are of compatible values.

Im not sure where it stops with people who believe an equal financial contribution is required for a respectful marriage, do they always need to earn the same as their partner, the same as when they got married, can they drop 20% and still be respected, of circumstances reduces that to a drop of 80% are they then not respected any longer. I dont understand it.

I out earned my DH is the past, i didn't have any less respect for him, we are a team, i support him if he wants something i can help facilitate and visa versa.

I agree mostly with @suprima i dont find anything less attractive than a person who places value and respect on anything financial. I would love and respect the people around me no matter what they earnt. I would only loose respect for them because of their treatment of me and others.

Of course SAHM can be just as good a role model as working mums. Its ridiculous and disingenuous to think otherwise. Not having a paid job, alone, doesn't make any better or worse a parent

Both choosing to be a SAHM and working mums are doing what they think is best for their child, they are making themselves the best parents as they are doing what helps their mental health and lastly

One is not better in general than the other, just better for them.

I know it was best for me and my family to SAH, thats not to say the friends i have who went back to work are any less, they are also amazing, they are doing it their way to be the best for them and their family.
Both amazing, both different !!!

OP do what is best for your family, you can study while at home if their is a way to improve your career if you want, but just do whats best and makes you all happy .

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 15:34

It'd be lovely if childcare was more affordable.without it impacting childcare professionals ability to earn.

The only way that is happening is if society and government start valuing the importance of early years.

That would likely mean higher taxes, better wages for childcare professionals.

But is that likely to happen? And if not is it likely because the role is not valued.

Childcare is fairly important because all studies show the first five years have a huge effect on an individual's life and potential.
It impacts absolutely everything.
Being unemployed and normal jobseeking does not have the potential to put back this kind of value into the system.
Being a carer for the older generation is more of an equivalent, but the effects are less far reaching.

No one is asking for sahp to be more valued than working parents. Differebt things work for different families and children at different times. Different stages of child development require different approaches and some flexibility is needed.

HamiltonFan1 · 24/09/2022 15:27

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 15:21

My point being it's not valued though is it? As even those that do childcare for a living are not paid a livable wage, but expected to provide cheap service to accommodate other women's choices.

Childcare is valid. Whether it's a professional or a parent and by insisting we should all be working instead of childcare you devalue the role.of raising children.

Why should someone being a SAHP be more valued than anyone else out of work?

The majority of those in the UK that do not return to work after having children do so because they don't earn enough to cover child care costs. So are no better than someone out of work for any other reason.

Childcare should be made more affordable for parents, and both parents should be empowered to stay at home if they want to

I and others it seems, take issue with posters claiming only women deserve the privilege of staying home with their kids and men not ok being responsible for 100% of their family outgoings are pathetic.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 15:21

My point being it's not valued though is it? As even those that do childcare for a living are not paid a livable wage, but expected to provide cheap service to accommodate other women's choices.

Childcare is valid. Whether it's a professional or a parent and by insisting we should all be working instead of childcare you devalue the role.of raising children.

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 15:19

No idea what your talking about with all this 'more value' complex. I've never heard anyone, SAHM or otherwise, talking about that? Just don't be rude, basically, is what people probably mean.

Topgub · 24/09/2022 15:19

@Thepeopleversuswork

Oh no.

I'm scared to read it now!

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2022 15:13

@thecrunch

I'm not the one who brought up the argument about "valuing" raising children.

The poster @3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens said, I quote: "the endless judgement from so called feminists who don't value raising children is actually pretty patriarchal."

I have no problem with women choosing to stay at home with their children. I'm pointing out that every time this discussion comes up, someone tips up to say: "Why aren't SAHMs valued more?"

The answer is simply that SAHMs are valued as much as the next person. But there's no way to give them more of the "value" they seem to crave without undermining women who don't stay at home.

If the value that they want so much and seem not to get isn't forthcoming, it isn't the job of feminists to confer this intrinsic value on them. That's on them.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 15:11

Whatever gave you the impression I didn't think working mothers did those things of value or other things?
I was making the point that sahp role is of value too.
Fact is there are a lot of people claiming sahp are anti feminist on this thread and others. That's why I said so called feminists because it's not really feminism just judgement.

Fact is, as I stated earlier, different solutions will work for different families. And I would suggest that a family with true equality will work out the best solution for the family, regardless of what outsiders perceive to be best. There are ways to financially cover eachother when one partner takes up the bulk of childcare, without making anyone too vulnerable.
However, this depends on a lot of factors like whether you are married, whether you need to keep up skills, work in a demanding role incompatible with quality childcare.
The point remains. Sahp is a good solution for some. Working full time is a good solution for others. Part time is good if it makes sense for.your family.

Pava22 · 24/09/2022 15:11

Kind of both sides of the coin here. We planned for me to be sahm but actually has turned into having 4 kids and now I work with my husband for his business that he has grow. So instead of home duties I'm doing that with 4 kids on top of working from home at the same time.

So what is your job now? What does your OH do? Can you afford to drop an income? Will it be difficult to go back? Do you want to go back or start something else eventually?

thecrunch · 24/09/2022 15:07

It's not a competition - thepeople. Why are you making it into one? Different roles, different values. You can value the role of a SAHM and also value the role of a working person. The two are not mutually exclusive. I find this a strange and insecure argument.

HamiltonFan1 · 24/09/2022 15:04

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 15:03

You can be a good role model for your child whilst being a sahp. They aren't mutually exclusive.

Modelling being part of the community, self care, valuing domestic skills, developing emotional skills, sharing reading, practicing everyday numeracy like measuring and handling money, facilitating social skills.

You may not value these as an adult, but they are very important for child development and the child actually physically sees you doing a lot of them, so it's an active lesson.

Yes going out to work can be a good model, but it's not the only one.

Do you think working mothers don't also model those behaviours?

TheMoops · 24/09/2022 15:03

It's going to be very unique to each individual's.circumstances and the endless judgement from so called feminists who don't value raising children is actually pretty patriarchal.

I was with you until this ridiculous comment.

HamiltonFan1 · 24/09/2022 15:03

YANBU to want to be a SAHM, but you need to ensure financially you can cope and your partner is ok with taking on the full financial burden of the household.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 24/09/2022 15:03

You can be a good role model for your child whilst being a sahp. They aren't mutually exclusive.

Modelling being part of the community, self care, valuing domestic skills, developing emotional skills, sharing reading, practicing everyday numeracy like measuring and handling money, facilitating social skills.

You may not value these as an adult, but they are very important for child development and the child actually physically sees you doing a lot of them, so it's an active lesson.

Yes going out to work can be a good model, but it's not the only one.

Thepeopleversuswork · 24/09/2022 15:00

@3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens

It's going to be very unique to each individual's.circumstances and the endless judgement from so called feminists who don't value raising children is actually pretty patriarchal.

It is down to individual circumstances and you raise a very good point about childcare and the difficulty of covering the cost if you're in a low-paid job. And its particularly scandalous that childcare is paid so badly and something which is relevant to this debate.

But this comment about "so called feminists who don't value raising children" is completely erroneous. Feminists believe its very important women to have financial independence, because many of us have seen first hand what can happen when they don't.

Whether or not you "value" raising children is worth unpicking: it's always trotted out on all of these threads that people should "value" the work a SAHM does more but no one has yet suggested an efficient way of "valuing" raising children which doesn't undermine women's financial independence. If by "value" you mean acknowledge that raising children is hard and important I think most people do that anyway. If by "value" you mean women who look after their own children are somehow superior women who work and use paid childcare, that doesn't work for me because it leads inevitably back to the idea that its preferable for a woman to remain with her children and not do paid work.

And because feminists believe financial independence for women is important it is always going to be problematic when someone insists that its more "valuable" for a woman to do something which precludes her from being economically independent.

But none of this means "feminists don't value raising children". This is a complete strawman argument.

Dacadactyl · 24/09/2022 14:58

Suprima · 24/09/2022 13:35

Women need to make their own personal choices- but I’d find a man who would be resentful about his wife being a SAHM an utterly pathetic person and a poor specimen to breed with. Any man who thinks ‘WhY sHoUlD sHe STaY aT hOme?!?’ and would be jealous was literally not worth the risk of dying in labour.

The man who would be resentful is not the poor, little, equality-between-the-sexes lamb who you are idealising in your head. He’d probably leave all life admin to his wife, opt out of childcare when he was home and be strategically bad at cooking and using the washing machine.

My husband obviously was very happy for me to return to work and pay nursery fees- but equally sees the benefit and value of a person being at home. I have chosen to be a SAHM for a few years because my well-paid career can be returned to at any time. It was completely my choice.

However, vagina would dry up forever more if he wanted me back at work, pumping in the toilets and doing nursery runs solely because of any perceived resentment, or wanting me to pull my financial weight. That’s a man who will never value any of the invisible work that women do without a single quibble.

I think some people struggle to get their heads around the fact that some women want to stay at home with their kids whilst they are small and that is happily valued by their husbands. But I think that’s a side effect of shagging and pandering to selfish men who would not extend the same courtesy to them if given the chance.

100% THIS