Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

new driver snub

59 replies

wheresmymillionaire · 23/09/2022 19:37

My DD has just passed her driving test (yesterday) with only 3 minors. She has been learning and practising and did her test in her own car, so knows the car well.
On Saturdays she volunteers in the morning, then gets the bus to a drama group in the afternoons.

Now of course, she can drive herself there! She had planned to go to a friends house (2 miles away from the drama group) after volunteering, then give a lift to her friend to drama. But friends mum has said friend can't go in the car with DD as she is a new driver.

DD is a very sensible girl, and the girls have been friends for about 11 years, so the parents know my dd well.
I have realised they are protective over their DD in the past, but this has upset my DD as she thinks they don't trust her.

AIBU to think this is a bit too protective?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
nicknamehelp · 24/09/2022 14:38

I let my ds have passengers and drive his sis about from day 1. Had a black box so I could monitor a bit. Yes I was worried at times and there is a risk but he could of been killed walking across a road. I think sometimes we are very risk adverse now but bad things do happen we have to accept that

BuwchGochGota · 24/09/2022 14:37

Turning this on its head, I wasn't happy for my DC to give their friends lifts until they'd been driving for a good few weeks. 17 year old friends are excitable and distracting. Combine that with the slower reaction times of an inexperienced driver and you potentially have a recipe for disaster.

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 24/09/2022 14:24

I must admit, I never even thought of this when DS passed. He’s now been driving over a year so it’s a bit of a moot point really but I think I’d have changed my POV had I seen this thread. I think it’s probably best if your DD gets some experience of driving without any distractions @wheresmymillionaire Has she considered the Pass Plus course?

piegone · 24/09/2022 14:14

@ChelseaRobertsofMalibu

That's not the same as not being allowed to drive the day you pass your test. That's about no longer being insured as a learner.

It is commonplace for people who pass their test to be added to an insurance policy as a full licence holder the same day. Thousands of parents and partners do it.

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 24/09/2022 14:09

piegone · 24/09/2022 14:04

@ChelseaRobertsofMalibu

You're not supposed to drive one the day you pass.

Source?

www.thinkinsurance.co.uk/personal/what-do-i-do-now-i-have-passed-my-driving-test This example cites the fact that your LEARNER insurance expires the moment you pass your test, but ultimately is the same thing. You can make arrangements to get round this but any decent instructor won’t allow you to drive their learner vehicle home due to adrenaline

girlmom21 · 24/09/2022 14:05

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 24/09/2022 14:03

@wheresmymillionaire & @scrufffy
You're not supposed to drive one the day you pass. I believe insurance won’t allow it due to statistics of the excitement & adrenaline of passing being proven to affect your ability to drive safely

My driving instructors back went on the day of my test so I had to drive home after I passed. You're definitely not supposed to drive home after your test because of adrenaline but I think their standard insurance also only covers learners.

I've never heard of not being allowed to drive on your own insurance when you pass though.

piegone · 24/09/2022 14:04

@ChelseaRobertsofMalibu

You're not supposed to drive one the day you pass.

Source?

ChelseaRobertsofMalibu · 24/09/2022 14:03

@wheresmymillionaire & @scrufffy
You're not supposed to drive one the day you pass. I believe insurance won’t allow it due to statistics of the excitement & adrenaline of passing being proven to affect your ability to drive safely

ShowOfHands · 24/09/2022 13:57

Nothing to do with being laid-back or infantilising.

I passed in my 30s and remember the need to concentrate when first passed. I had two children I needed to transport but they knew to stay quiet, I knew not to have the radio on, I knew I needed extra time and patience to truly master the road. All new drivers will have slower reaction times and less experience meaning they are all subject to extra risk. I couldn't have chatted and driven. I had the maturity to be clear about my limitations.

But we are also talking about the adolescent brain. A brain which has more in common with a toddler's than an adult's. A brain that craves pleasure and thrills. A decreased ability to reason and anticipate and a severely compromised ability to risk assess. This is simply fact. A brand new skill with built in risk, the highest stakes and a lot of pressure? It is not worth it

I've been to three funerals of sensible, capable young drivers.

I think it's less an opinion, attitude or being laid-back, I think there's a right and wrong answer. New drivers shouldn't carry passengers when there is a choice.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 24/09/2022 04:40

In my state new drivers cannot have passengers who are not adult licensed drivers for the first year. After the first year they may have related underage passengers (drive siblings to school, etc.).

ClaryFairchild · 24/09/2022 04:26

In a lot of Australian States first year P platers (you move to different p plates after a year or so) can't have passengers under 21 or non- related etc outside of certain times. This is due to friends being a massive distraction and often inciting poor behaviour. Statistically far more accidents happen to newly licenced drivers with friends in the car.

POTC · 24/09/2022 04:21

DS1 has been driving 18mths now. I did let him drive his younger brother after about 8 weeks but more out of necessity as I'd had an op and couldn't drive. I knew he'd be even more sensible with him in the car though, 3 yrs between them but DS1 has grown up as a young carer to me and his brother. DS1 has also been driving since he was 13 on the farm opposite us where he helps with hay harvest and on the road on a tractor for short distances since 14 so he is possibly more experienced than many new drivers. He'd also been driving with me next to him for 6 months alongside his professional lessons as covid meant his driving test was postponed for months. When he was driving to new places for the first 6 months he'd ask if I would go with him, which I did.
Any time he was taking someone else in his car I always asked their parents if they were okay with that.
We're in Suffolk and within 2 miles of our house, on the two routes home from nearest town, I know of 4 teenage road deaths. One was passenger in a full car driven by an extremely new driver. They came round a corner into thick fog, lost road position and hit a van coming the other way then span off into a tree. One was driving his gf to college on the dual carriageway, incorrectly inflated tyre burst, he lost control left road and hit a fence. Gf had serious injuries and he died. Two were being driven on dual carriageway by their friend who had passed 4 mths previously. Going too fast, aquaplaned and left road hitting a tree. The driver was given 4 years in prison for that.
We drive past those spots almost daily, my son is very aware of them and of just how much greater the risks are as a new driver which has definitely impacted (for the better) on his driving.
I don't blame that mother at all for saying no.

Etinoxaurus · 24/09/2022 03:51

Aconitum · 23/09/2022 20:43

And we wonder why young people these days seem to have no resilience.
Why are you all infantalising your grown up children?
Glad the OP seems to have more sense.

It’s not infantilising to account for a known risk. As pp have said a risk so real that many states and countries forbid new drivers from having other people in the car with them.
Unless you mean infantilising in the same way as laws prohibiting drink drinking, driving without a seat belt and driving a roadworthy car are infantilising.

melj1213 · 24/09/2022 01:12

YABU

When I passed my test I was just a few months shy of being 18 and despite being the youngest of my friendship group I was the first one to pass my test and have a car. So many of my friends expected me to want to drive everyone around immediately and were surprised when I said I wouldn't be driving other people for at least a couple of months whilst I got used to driving solo.

I think it was a couple of weeks before I was even willing to drive my siblings/parents anywhere as I wanted to get to grips with driving alone first and build up my confidence before I added in passengers - things like navigating tricky areas (there's a few difficult spots for driving in my town) a few times without the pressure of passengers; getting used to just driving with the radio on and having to plot the route in my head rather than the car being quiet apart from my instructor directing me on the route he had planned out for our lesson; and even just making silly mistakes like stalling a few times because the clutch/accelerator had a different weight to my instructors car - it took me a few days of driving to just get used to the feel of the car and it's responsiveness - or having to fiddle with the various knobs/buttons on the dashboard to figure out how to demist the windscreen etc.

Nobody is unreasonable to want their child to he safe, and no matter how confident your DD is, if it was my DD being offered a lift, I would be wanting her to have a bit more solo driving experience before letting my DD be a passenger in her car.

1805 · 24/09/2022 00:38

toomuchlaundry
Sounds like we need a rule like that to come in.
My condolences go out to all of you who have lost loved ones in traffic accidents.
Reading these posts, it's a wonder anyone lets their dc drive at all.

toomuchlaundry · 24/09/2022 00:34

I thought in some countries it’s not allowed to have young passengers in a car until a certain time has elapsed after passing your test

MarieInternette · 24/09/2022 00:28

I was not happy about my 16 year old son getting into the car with mates who have recently passed their tests. Of course, he thought I was being totally ridiculous until one of his best mates and 2 other young lads he knew were killed in a terrible accident just a few short weeks ago. He understands now, sadly.

Anyone who thinks that it is being overprotective to restrict teens getting in cars with newly qualified young drivers, who have little experience of driving, is a fool.

HardLanding · 24/09/2022 00:18

And now, as an adult in my 30s finally taking lessons, I won’t be driving my children around until I’ve done further driving courses and hit the 6 month mark.

A car is a weapon, it’s basic Physics. You also cannot predict what the other drivers on the same road as you are going to behave like.

HardLanding · 24/09/2022 00:16

YABU. I was doing lessons at 17, and, in quick succession, I had two friends aged 19 dead (drunk driver ploughed into the side of them at 10am on a Sunday), one aged 18 in ICU after her car skidded on ice and she was impaled on a fence post, another aged 19 was a passenger and killed on impact.

After the first two, I cancelled my lessons. After the second one, I stopped getting in the car with anyone other than my Dad.

A year later, my 16 year old sister and two of her friends were in ICU after a crash.

Don’t be so fucking naive.

ImNotGreta · 24/09/2022 00:11

wheresmymillionaire · 23/09/2022 20:23

ok, I'm clearly out voted! DD is going to a different friends house instead. Her parents are fine with DD driving.
I guess I'm just more easy going. DD drove to school and back (we are rural) after she did her test. Maybe I should get her friends to check their parents are ok with DD giving them lifts.

The statistics are very much on their side, and the reasons are well understood as to why new drivers are higher risk and why having friends in the car increases the risk yet further.

incognitopurple · 24/09/2022 00:08

Why are they deciding for their ‘child’? Who is presumably an adult of 18?

YANBU imo, driving tests are extremely thorough and even the slightest slip up they will fail you for. Not surprised your DD is hurt.

HowVeryBizarre · 23/09/2022 23:59

My kids were not allowed to travel with others who had just got their licences, I would want them to be driving without incident for at least six months. You are the one being precious about your daughter thinking “they don’t trust her”. Her friend’s parents are making a sensible decision to try and keep theirs safe.

Luredbyapomegranate · 23/09/2022 23:45

Probably when she’s been driving for a few months they’ll review. But new teen drivers can be shocking.

solendi · 23/09/2022 23:41

YABU I took all my friends out newly passed, well three weeks after. I crashed. Luckily was only my car totally smashed up but could easily have hurt my friends. I'd never let my dc in a newly passed car if I had any choice over the matter.

FlissyPaps · 23/09/2022 23:18

Just out of interest, what do people put as their timeline before they can go as a passenger in a friends car?

If the friend has been driving independently after passing their test and feels 100% confident, then about 10/12 months.