Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

The almost-silent treatment?

61 replies

MeInCoventry · 23/09/2022 17:47

Not exactly the silent treatment, but… staying in his study all day/evening and only emerging for meals. Being icily polite. Not engaging in our usual banter or showing any interest in what I say/do. Leaving the house for periods of time and coming back in without explanation. (Normally we would say "I'm just popping to the shops" etc.) It's been going on since last Sunday — after we had a disagreement about how and when some out-of-date yogurt should be disposed of.

I really should know how to deal with this by now — we are in our 50s and got married in our 20s. We split up for most of our 30s and 40s as I couldn't tolerate his "moods" any longer and then recently we started co-habiting again. His father was exactly the same so he has grown up with this. But I really thought we were through with this shit. We had been getting along so well and being mutually supportive.

But now I have been reading on MN about how the silent treatment is "emotional abuse" and it seems to be fairly common! Does my situation count? It's not as if we're not speaking, but he is being so cold. If I challenge him on it he'll say he isn't feeling very well or that he is tired. He has been diagnosed with depression in the past.

Should I ignore? Tell him to book himself into a hotel until he's ready to talk about it? Go and stay with a friend? Leave him a note?

OP posts:
MeInCoventry · 24/09/2022 11:30

He even said to me once ''well done, we're getting on well at the moment'' @J0y OMG and I get left complimentary notes when I've left the kitchen tidy enough for his satisfaction. Oh my god. How have I been so stupid.

OP posts:
MeInCoventry · 24/09/2022 11:28

I almost find it hard to believe there are men that don't do this! (Are there?)

My father was moody in his younger years but hasn't been now for 30 years or more, since he retired from work. One of my sisters has inherited this behavior too, but we don't see one another enough for it to be a problem. And one of my other sisters was with a man for many years who did this all the time, to an extreme! Once he just walked off in the middle of a sightseeing trip on a holiday abroad and went home! She ditched him eventually.

OP posts:
J0y · 24/09/2022 11:25

My x was like this (and my mum, although I don't live with her) just training you constantly to be no trouble, to never question them, never ask them to inconvenience themself in any small way for you. Obviously my mum did this to me and then I ended up with my x. He is the same. He was training me. He even said to me once ''well done, we're getting on well at the moment'' and it was a week where I felt particularly ground down and I'd been putting up and shutting up as nothing seemed worth defending. And in my ground down lifeless state he thought well done, we're ''getting on''. Wow.

ParentallyUnprepared · 24/09/2022 11:15

Mummadeze · 24/09/2022 08:05

He is acting like this so next time you don’t disagree with his way of not just disposing of the yoghurt, but of everything. I live with someone like this. He has sulked for months / years in the past. But because I refuse to be controlled, he is pretty much in a permanent mood with me now to be honest. However I am past caring now. I used to be in the ups and downs phase when he was nice and then moody, and it was horrendous. Draining, upsetting, confusing. Now we just lead separate lives and only talk about our child it is better. But in answer to your question, yes, he is abusive. And it is no way to live.

This is no way to live either, @Mummadeze

MeInCoventry · 24/09/2022 11:11

Thanks all! This is so insightful. Thinking about it, on a previous occasion I said perhaps it would be a good idea to live apart again and he was really shocked! He said he was just trying to "process" things but you're right, he soon started talking!

But because I refuse to be controlled, he is pretty much in a permanent mood with me now to be honest. @Mummadeze I'm so sorry, this is awful.

In retrospect I think control is exactly what it's about. Leading up to this incident were numerous others where he would correct me on how I was doing something or point out my negligence in some area (leaving a cupboard door ajar, not changing the toilet roll before it was all used up, not chopping things properly)… and I would either agree or laugh it off, but I was starting to wonder why he is even here as I apparently irritate him so much!
So when the yogurt incident happened I just snapped and told him to do it himself.

It's a shame really, because we do connect on a deeper level, to let petty irritations spoil everything. But I guess I have to decide if this is a deal breaker for me. I think it is.

@goody2shooz Yes, he emerges to eat meals that I cook (we have informally assigned roles for household chores). And it's just me at the moment, although this is a standard pattern of behavior in his family.

@CrystalCoco Yes I really thought he had changed!

OP posts:
J0y · 24/09/2022 08:58

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 24/09/2022 07:59

He’s clearly not happy so do the decent thing and set him free. He can get his own house to sulk in.

Yupp. Invite him to leave.

J0y · 24/09/2022 08:57

Rock that boat.

I voted you are being unreasonable but I meant, to put up with it! to have given this practitioner of the silent treatment a second chance! You're only in your 50s you could have thirty years (+) of peaceful contentment left if you get rid of this eejit.

My mum gives me the silent treatment and it is so punitive and manipulative. I am so annoyed thinking about bullies out there controlling their little empire with silent treatments.

Go to a lovely hotel for a couple of nights while you plan your divorce. x

GroggyLegs · 24/09/2022 08:52

It's a power play. He gets to control the mood of your home while tormenting you.

I'm assuming you talked about why you separated last time? Pull him up on history repeating itself.

You're very willing to make excuses for his behaviour. Make no mistake, he's a grown man who's actively choosing to act this way when he knows it hurts you.

Changemynamee · 24/09/2022 08:35

He is responsible for his behaviour. Most of us have had to learn social skills, in adult life, that we didn't learn in childhood. If you want to get along with someone, you make the effort, you don't use them as your passive aggressive punching bag. Go out with your girls and have fun, then hasta la vista baby. Sorry to quote bojo.

TheYearOfSmallThings · 24/09/2022 08:20

If this has been a long term pattern over decades, nothing will change now. Explain that you've had enough and this time don't change your mind.

Yupsuuuure · 24/09/2022 08:17

Get rid of him. He's never going to change and yes it's absolutely emotional abuse.

LovelyDaaling · 24/09/2022 08:12

Your house in your name- ideal. Does he have a property too? Are you divorced?
Silent treatment certainly isn't the norm.
The choice is his really. Stop sulking or start packing.

Wombat27A · 24/09/2022 08:09

It's a stupid strategy on his part, given he doesn't have security of tenure (assuming not married).

Definitely control.

Mummadeze · 24/09/2022 08:05

He is acting like this so next time you don’t disagree with his way of not just disposing of the yoghurt, but of everything. I live with someone like this. He has sulked for months / years in the past. But because I refuse to be controlled, he is pretty much in a permanent mood with me now to be honest. However I am past caring now. I used to be in the ups and downs phase when he was nice and then moody, and it was horrendous. Draining, upsetting, confusing. Now we just lead separate lives and only talk about our child it is better. But in answer to your question, yes, he is abusive. And it is no way to live.

TestingTestingWonTooFree · 24/09/2022 07:59

He’s clearly not happy so do the decent thing and set him free. He can get his own house to sulk in.

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 24/09/2022 07:56

It's your house? I would pack his bags and tell him to get the hell out of it. If he can't respect you enough to even speak to you then he could fuck off as far as I'm concerned.

You know what, if you go upstairs now and start to pack his things he'll start talking pretty quickly. For me, that would be far too late.

Your mistake was thinking that this man would change. He won't.

RememberWhatMatters · 24/09/2022 07:44

My ex husband used to do this, he liked to do an extended period of silence, usually about 4 days. It was during one of these I decided to divorce him. The back peddling and panic from him when he realised that was his last 4 day-er was kind of sad. Poor soul thought he could carry on like that without consequence.

CrystalCoco · 24/09/2022 07:36

Well I think it's lovely that you gave the re-kindling of this relationship a go, the pull from the past can be really strong and people change and mature over the years, some people put to bed poor behaviour from their younger years.

Unfortunately your DP doesn't seem to be one of them. Back in the sea he goes. He's shown that this is him, take it or leave it, it's a part of him that I highly highly doubt will ever change. You deserve better x

Destinationdestination · 24/09/2022 07:28

Yes, it counts. Ignore him and if he doesn’t stop consider whether you’re getting what you want from relationship.

goody2shooz · 24/09/2022 07:21

You say he’s ‘only emerging for meals’….
Meals that you are cooking , or does he cook for himself? I’m sure you find it hard to imagine that he’s doing this to punish you, but why do you think he’s behaving this way? Because he can? Because he gets something out of it? Is he being like this to friends, family and work colleagues or is it ‘just’ you?
Totally unacceptable behaviour personally, if it’s been a pattern in your relationship, it’s a behaviour he chooses. Just like you can choose to put up with it or challenge it or tell him to leave. Nobody should treat you like that in your own home.

MeInCoventry · 23/09/2022 23:49

Thanks all… I had started to wonder if this is just par for the course with relationships but it really isn't, is it. Brigante9 It's my house, in my name.
I still find it hard to accept that he really wants to punish me or feel superior.

OP posts:
Brigante9 · 23/09/2022 19:53

Whose name is the house in? I couldn’t cope with this sort of behaviour, it’s horrible.

Bloodyusernamechangefailagain · 23/09/2022 18:30

The only thing you're being unreasonable about is putting up with his poor behaviour, bullying and inability to communicate in any adult manner for a guy in his 50s.
Life's too damn short. LTB

MumUndone · 23/09/2022 18:27

MeInCoventry · 23/09/2022 18:13

I can never figure out what he hopes to get out of it!

He's punishing you, that's what he's getting out of it - a sense of victory, superiority, and righteousness.

AtrociousCircumstance · 23/09/2022 18:27

You can blame him, an adult well into middle age, for not taking responsibility for his own dysfunction.

Swipe left for the next trending thread