Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel guilty about this?

33 replies

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 14:17

We moved recently and live very remotely.

I don’t regret this as such but it feels like in order to do anything we have to drive so far. Today, toddler group and a supermarket trip and ds has been in the car seat for going on two hours Sad

Is it just me? I really feel like it must be rubbish for him. But if we are going to do anything we have to drive!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NoSquirrels · 23/09/2022 17:19

I grew up rurally - every single day involved a car journey of various lengths. It was just normal to me.

My DC spent their early lives in the city - they never got in a car from week to week. We walked everywhere or took public transport. It was just normal to them.

You just adapt to your environment really. Learn to batch your tasks & errands - pick the toddler group that’s in a convenient place and at a convenient time to fit in a supermarket shop or a different errand etc. Do more outdoors near your house - a walk in the woods rather than a walk to the ducks in the town park. Get a swing set or climbing frame for the garden instead of play park etc. And make car journeys pleasant - audiobooks etc.

I really don’t think young kids are too bothered, though.

Oldrockingchair · 23/09/2022 16:59

I live somewhere similar Op. my dcs are older now but they spent probably 2 hours a day in the car most days (they used to come to work with me, had free childcare) and then another hour or so if we went somewhere in the afternoon. It was fine. Mine would nap a lot, and when they got a bit older (maybe 3-4) we got in-car DVD players so I used to listen to a lot of crappy kid films but never actually watch them.
The worst thing living somewhere like this is the cost of fuel - I drive about 1200 miles a month just to go to work/school run/go anywhere really and it’s not cheap these days. Hundreds of ££ a month.

Thestagshead · 23/09/2022 16:56

Op if you’re struggling with it, and there is no shame on that, then start to find ways round it. Get your shopping delivered or only go weekly to the supermarket, ask In the village hall or church if Any groups you can join, etc

your kid will be fine though.

Lunabun · 23/09/2022 16:50

I agree @Saz12. Also, not every second of life has to be full-on entertainment and engagement.

When my baby was tiny, I stressed myself out about filling every second with something fun. My mother wisely told me that babies need thinking time, just like adults. We all need a little time to decompress and go through things in our head. So when my baby is in the car, that's what I think of him as doing. It also helps that he usually falls asleep in the car after about 10 minutes, so it doesn't feel like time wasted if that makes any sense. Not sure if you mentioned how old your DC is OP, sorry, but if he's of an age when he still naps then perhaps car trips could be timed with that so he just sleeps through it?

Saz12 · 23/09/2022 16:42

I’m not seeing a reason for guilt? Lots of parents go out with a young child in a pram with a rain cover up. I’m not seeing how that’s really more fun or engaging than being in a car: it’s just something that sometimes needs to be done.

Wherever you live has upsides & downsides.

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 16:24

I have clarified during the course of the thread. To get to town it’s around 30 mins. To get to a village where we can buy bread and milk more like 2. But it still seems to involve a lot of hauling a toddler in and out of a car seat!

OP posts:
Thestagshead · 23/09/2022 16:17

I think the fact you said you lived very remotely and just going to toddler group and the supermarket involved a two hour commute there everyone. So basically you are not remotely remote and live two mins from a village?

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:50

Thanks. We aren’t miles away from a village, it’s two minutes in a car. It isn’t really possible to walk around here as it is a country lane without pavements and very fast cars.

OP posts:
Choconut · 23/09/2022 15:38

Why don't you order online (if poss) or do the supermarket at the weekend and your OH have some time with him at home. 30 minutes to toddler group is fine, just put on some nursery rhymes for him to listen to while you drive or something.
I'm sure there are loads of walks you can go on without having to drive, maybe woods to walk through, leaves, sticks and stones to collect, puddles to jump in, mud pies to make, picnics to have, dens to be made as he gets older, trees to climb. Living in the countryside is flipping amazing.

BitOutOfPractice · 23/09/2022 15:37

One of the reasons I moved to a city centre this year from suburbia. I hated having to get in the car to even go and buy a pint of milk. Going to the pub was a feat of organisation with taxis (esp. post pandemic) and my day was based around a driving school run. now my car doesn’t move from one week to the next. I walk and cycle locally and catch the train for longer journeys. It is very liberating not to be a slave to the car.

Sorry OP probably not terribly helpful. Is loving at least to a village a possibility?

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:35

Thanks. It’s pretty hard to spend all day at home with a toddler, he does enjoy the groups and things we do. It’s a bit of a pain that they involve more of a drive than they used to, and so I do feel guilty when it feels like most of the day is spent in the car.

I think he will be very happy here, he is probably more fortunate than about ninety percent of children who were born on the same day as him, so I don’t think anyone needs to actually worry about him (not that they were, just trying to exacerbate my already guilty feelings) but it can be tricky working out the logistics of things at times.

OP posts:
Breezycheesetrees · 23/09/2022 15:31

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:00

Why is everybody trying to make me feel bad about secondary school? Just wondering.

There's a lot of strong anti-rural living feeling here. We live quite remotely and it's bliss - it's true we can't walk to a shop or get a deliveroo or whatever, but my kids have so much freedom and connection to nature that I used to fantasise about as a city-dwelling child. And when they get older they'll be in the same boat as all their mates, they'll have bikes and I'll give them lifts! It's really not a drama. But I do think you have to make remote living a positive thing rather than always driving miles to try and replicate a city existence.

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:29

I think posters seem to think I live about an hour from the nearest town, though, which isn’t the case.

School wise, no definite decisions yet. A lot depends on whether we are able to have a second baby - isn’t looking good at the moment. If we only have this one we’ll probably look at the private route.

But I didn’t really expect to be drawn into a conversation about senior schools when I posted feeling bad because my one year old had spent the morning in and out of the car!

OP posts:
DisplayPurposesOnly · 23/09/2022 15:27

I’m all for planning for the future but it’s not really what I’m posting about!

I think that's the point though - you seem to have moved to a rural location without thinking through the ramifications of that. PPs are suggesting you take a longer term view.

You say you don't mind it for yourself. You don't mention that your child is unhappy. So perhaps you are inventing a difficulty that doesn't exist.

Pinkdelight3 · 23/09/2022 15:23

At least you do feel guilty. There's so many people on here who lament about living remotely and woe is them that their DC can't get a bus to school and have to walk down unlit country roads etc etc like it's everyone else's problem when it was clearly their choice to live that way. Most of them don't seem to drive either, so at least you're more on the ball. Presumably you felt the benefits outweighed all the taxi-ing to and fro, so focus on the benefits, but it's not something I'd enjoy with a little one. It's great them being able to walk to friends/school/park.

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:20

It’s also ten years away, I’m all for planning for the future but it’s not really what I’m posting about!

OP posts:
Hearthnhome · 23/09/2022 15:17

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:00

Why is everybody trying to make me feel bad about secondary school? Just wondering.

Not sure anyone is trying to make you feel guilty

But since your op said ‘very remotely’ people expect it is very remote. Which causes problems for secondary school travel. That’s a far bigger deal than spending 2 hours, broken up over the day in a car seat

Lunabun · 23/09/2022 15:14

I grew up rurally, I adored my childhood and would never want it to have been any other way. Not sure why posters are saying the only thing to do in the country is sit in the house - I spent (and still do) most my time outdoors!

I went straight to uni in a big city with no problems at all, and I have no issues with independence.

I wouldn't feel guilty, it's probably just a bit of a mental adjustment Smile

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 15:00

Why is everybody trying to make me feel bad about secondary school? Just wondering.

OP posts:
Thestagshead · 23/09/2022 14:56

Can’t see how this would be an issue for a kid?

Testina · 23/09/2022 14:44

Save your guilt for when he’s got a really long commute to secondary school, and his social life is a pain in the backside, and he can’t get a part time job. I went to a secondary that was catchment for all the remote villages, and almost all the rural kids, like me, hated it!

Or, don’t buy trouble and just enjoy what you’ve got now and change if you need to. I don’t suppose your toddler cared today! Car journeys are great for chats, music and audiobooks.

10HailMarys · 23/09/2022 14:40

I'd have loved that when I was a child. I loved car journeys and my absolute dream was to live in the middle of nowhere.

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 14:40

For me it is neither here nor there. I just feel bad for DS.

OP posts:
lannistunut · 23/09/2022 14:35

No need to feel guilty, your child is not being damaged.

The reality is if you live remotely you live in the car. Do you like being remote yourself?

Spicycurry · 23/09/2022 14:35

I have probably been a bit misleading without meaning to, we are not in some crazily remote place where it takes two hours to get to a Tesco. However, to get to the local toddler classes, it’s a good thirty minutes.

Then if you want to do anything else like visit a park or feed ducks it requires another car journey.

There is a village within walking distance if needs require it.

OP posts: