Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think my daughter has no empathy?

80 replies

clearasnight · 23/09/2022 13:05

My daughter (24) is in her second year of being a newly qualified social worker. She loves her job however I know she has had her challenges since starting. However, she seems to feel nothing towards the children and families she is working with. When I ask her how she can't feel anything when hearing some awful things she says she just 'switches off' and feels nothing.

She was like this in her training also, her advisor told her to crank up the self care as she was going to be reading and watching some really disturbing stuff. She said none of it disturbed her, it's what she expected, she's desensitised to it and she knows it's going on in the world so what's the point in being upset about it all she can do is try to help people and make small changes?

I just feel like if I was doing her job I would constantly be in tears or worrying, she is very monotone and just seems to have no reaction. She relaxes fully when not at work which in itself is a good thing but I worry about her lack of empathy? AIBU to think to be a social worker you must have empathy? She's very cold.

OP posts:
honeylulu · 23/09/2022 14:36

@waterrat yes I absolutely agree about a black sense of humour. That is definitely something I have and many of my colleagues too. We have to deal with things like coroner's enquiries where you hear a lot of awful stuff and gallows humour is a bit of armour that helps us get through it. Another team deals with historic child abuse claims. They are probably the most black humoured of the lot. (The jokes are never about the actual case material or people involved i must hasten to add.) Getting on with the job effectively enables us to achieve some sort of closure for those who need it. Running home in tears would not do much good!

Whichwhatnow · 23/09/2022 14:35

What do you mean by 'cold'? I'm assuming based on what you've said you just mean detached and tbh that's what you need for this job, surely? Same as being a doctor, or a policeman, or a crime scene investigator, or a family or criminal lawyer... you can't let cases get to you all the time or you won't do your job properly.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 23/09/2022 14:35

I think she needs to be like that to do her job. It would be very unprofessional to be in tears and worrying.

She must have empathy or why would she have chosen to do a job that helps people, but is much less well paid than any number of others she could have gone for.

I’m a lawyer and used to deal with all kinds of horrible criminal cases. I can’t say it didn’t affect me at all, but I wouldn’t have done much for a job if I’d been in tears and worrying.

SettingPrecedents · 23/09/2022 14:33

I think you’re mixing up empathy with being personally emotionally affected by something.

I’ve worked in emergency response / child protection / trauma jobs. I think I have lots of empathy. I go out of my way to help others, I’ve always worked in areas that help people, I run myself in to the ground volunteering, I’ve totally turned my life upside down to meet the needs of my kids, I can recognise and identify and allow for all the different influences that bring people to a point in their lives. But I’ve also been called unsympathetic, and standoffish by people who aren’t in dire situations. I’m not warm and cuddly. I have been known to say that I’m very sympathetic I just have a high bar of what deserves sympathy! I feel deeply sorry for people caught up in horrible situations, but it’s rare that I would feel personally affected.

SpiritedSneeze · 23/09/2022 14:32

No she sounds effective and sensible. I used to work in similarly intense and trauma focussed settings. The workers who never lasted long and were the least helpful were the people crying regularly, getting personally upset and angry and constantly commenting on how awful and horrendous everything was . We were all aware it was awful- we were mostly working around abuse of infants- nobody thought this was fine.
But the people who could detach and work effectively were more mentally healthy in the long run and were more efficient and helpful to the actual victims.
They didn't need some random worker crying over what happened to them- that doesnt help anybody- they needed people to be doing their jobs to get everything in place to protect them physically and legally- they needed people to advocate for them and to arrange professional care and support.
Your daughter sounds like one of the good ones

Kinderbuenos · 23/09/2022 14:28

OP are you feeling like she’s not empathetic to you ? Your concern around her job seems like it might me masking something else that is maybe more around you?

Pumpkinsanddaisies · 23/09/2022 14:28

I'm a counsellor and have huge empathy for my clients. However I have to compartmentalise. I wouldn't be any help to anyone if I started crumbling every time a client discussed being raped by their dad or their husband physically abusing them.

honeylulu · 23/09/2022 14:27

I think this is how my mother would describe me. She thinks I am "cold" and "hard" and don't care about anyone. That is certainly not true. I've always been stoical and resilient but I definitely care about people a LOT and I have a strong moral compass. Your daughter sounds similar - her comment about it being wrong for anyone to hurt a child or animal is not a remark someone dispassionate would make.

It has actually stood me in good stead in relationships and my career (fast paced and stressful profession). It does not mean I do not feel/suffer anything but generally I am good at coping, including supporting others who need it.

My mother seems to think my sister is morally superior because she is sensitive and cries a lot. In fact she is actually quite self centred because she is always focused on how things affect HER rather than the person they are happening to.

Your daughter sounds ideal for a social worker role. Someone weeping and wailing their way through the working day would not provide the service users with what they need. I have a friend who is a social worker for older people in need of care. She is very efficient and no nonsense, good at leaving the job at the door but she absolutely does care about doing a good job and her managers clearly agree given the promotions she has received.

Funkyblues101 · 23/09/2022 14:26

Bleeding heart social workers are going out of fashion. What's needed now are people to take the facts and get on with the job. Your daughter sounds perfect.
"Empathy" is just the current buzz word for people to boast that they give a shit. They often don't. Your daughter has chosen a profession that helps those who have fallen through the net, and that is to be commended.

scrufffy · 23/09/2022 14:22

I would think she needs to be like that to do her job and she's well suited to her career.

CollieWobble22 · 23/09/2022 14:21

Wish I was more like this! I have too much empathy. Its almost like I feel other peoples sadness too much.

I have aspergers. And a complete and utter emotional wet blanket.

I'm undergoing resilience training. I'm mid 30s.

Good on your DD. She's going to be awesome in her job 😁

UnreasonabIe · 23/09/2022 14:18

The previous poster that mentioned a dark sense of humour is so right too!

Testina · 23/09/2022 14:18

Your daughter sounds fantastic, and I think it’s really sad that of all people it’s her mother criticising her.

OhmygodDont · 23/09/2022 14:17

she would be no good if she was always panicking and upset by it.

I mean could you imagine calling for the fire brigade and the call handler loses their shit panicking? A pilot who doesn’t have the calm and controlled voice? People doing autopsy’s crying onto the cadavers? A police man/women breaking down upset because someone’s been shot, rather than giving case? Wouldn’t be good would it.

UnreasonabIe · 23/09/2022 14:16

I worked in a very similar field and I'm similar to your daughter. These things happen- they shouldn't- but they do, it's no good hand wringing and moping about it. You've got to just get on with helping people to move on and resolve it in the most professional way possible.

If I'd been too empathetic we would have got no where and I'd have had depression within weeks.

happy66 · 23/09/2022 14:14

i’m not a social worker but have worked alongside them. i’ve seen many come and go. Take it for me the only ones that last are the ones that are as hard as nails.

waterrat · 23/09/2022 14:08

I work in a really disturbing field - I speak to people who have been abused/ tortured etc regularly. I actually do generally find I can disconnect from it/ compartmentalise - I know I don't lack empathy as I am choosing to do this work so I can help people. Sometimes something will particularly bother me.

But generally I'm able to think - well, I'm doing what I can to help them and switch off - that's what makes me good at my job!

Being in floods of tears would be supremely unhelpful for a social worker.

Lots of people in these fields have a dark sense of humour or are just quite calm and detached.

TedMullins · 23/09/2022 14:07

YABU. As long as she makes the right decisions to help people she’s working with she doesn’t need to be crying over their situations. I actually find people who get emotional over other people’s problems incredibly annoying as it makes the issue all about them.

I’m like your daughter - I fully appreciate when something is horrific but I don’t actually feel any emotion. The only time I feel emotions really is if something happens directly to me. I’m totally the wrong person to go to if you want a cry and a cuddle, but I’m great at practical honest advice and help.

jumperfromasda · 23/09/2022 14:05

OP, I am not being mean when I ask this but are you quite an emotional person?

I am, if someone cries near me I cry too, I constantly imagine how people are feeling about things and if something is happening in my life I find it difficult to compartmentalise.....that is why I am not a social worker.

Maybe growing up in an environment where people are a bit emotional (again, I am not saying it's a bad quality, it's just not always helpful) has made your daughter amazing at dealing with her own emotions and not letting them spill over.

It sounds to me like she'll be an excellent social worker. She obviously cares about people and wants to do her best to help them, but she won't be dragged down by it herself. Unfortunately, I have seen a lot of friends and family members train for similar roles and then sink because they cannot deal with things emotionally.

I would be concerned if she was delighted/ entertained by the awful things she sees or if she said she was fine but was acting differently (started drinking heavily or withdrawing) but from what you have outlined her approach seems quite healthy....unless you've failed to mention something?

PumpkinDart · 23/09/2022 14:00

Also, in the nicest possible way it's annoying as hell to constantly have people saying that they don't know how you do a particular job, oh the poor children, bloody druggies etc. So my tolerance for talking about my job with anyone not in the field has always been pretty low.

PumpkinDart · 23/09/2022 13:59

I'm a SW who's spent the last 13 years working either in front line child protection teams or as a Family Court Guardian where some of the cases coming through Court were just horrendous. Your daughter sounds similar to me when I qualified, young, no children, able to compartmentalise and deal with things without our own emotions clouding things, I think that made me a good social worker. I wouldn't say she lacks empathy as I certainly don't feel I ever did, it's just a case of professionally showing that empathy, actively listening, focussing on the child.
Don't get me wrong the ability to detach was more difficult after I had children and some things do turn my stomach more and upset me but you have to be able to switch off or it's a career that will just chew you up.

Your daughter is also very early in her career, she won't have had the hardest, most harrowing cases yet, she'll very likely need support in years to come when there's something she can't shake off (I still choke up thinking of one of the mothers I worked with 10 years ago). For now I wouldn't press her, if she wants to talk about work she will if she doesn't then assume that she's managing things, we used dark humour a lot when I was in front line and it was a coping mechanism that lots of Social Workers needed, I certainly wouldn't have appreciated my mum badgering me about how I do it, how she'd be in tears etc.

xogossipgirlxo · 23/09/2022 13:58

"I just feel like if I was doing her job I would constantly be in tears or worrying,"

And do you really think care homes etc. need employees like this? Or animal shelters need people crying over little puppies or those who sometimes "switch off" and do their job?

10HailMarys · 23/09/2022 13:55

But I also worry about her 'coldness' and is that a good thing as a social worker?

First of all, just because she doesn't show emotions in the way you deem appropriate, that doesn't mean she lacks empathy. By saying 'That must be hard' when someone tells her they're having a tough time, she is expressing empathy. Empathy isn't about hugging and crying. Empathy is the feeling, not the expression of the feeling.

If she had no empathy then I doubt she would have become a social worker in the first place. She's a social worker because she cares. And being able to keep a lid on emotions and not to let personal feelings influence decisions, and being able to put thoughts of distressing things, are traits you really need if you work with a lot of distressing information or situations. I used to work as a press officer in the criminal justice system and I read and saw appalling things on a daily basis and was present at some extremely upsetting trials. I certainly felt empathy for victims, and even occasionally for criminals, and for the families of the people involved and so on. But obviously I couldn't go around showing anger or distress about anything - neither could the lawyers or the police or the court staff. You have to be professional and calm and if you can't compartmentalise these things in your head, then you shouldn't really be doing a job where you have to work with distressing subject matter.

GoldenSpiral · 23/09/2022 13:52

You should be grateful that there are people like your daughter in the world - otherwise these jobs would not get done effectively!

Your daughter isn't cold, she just isn't as sensitive as you.

iklboo · 23/09/2022 13:50

I work in a job where I have to compartmentalise - clear & separate boundaries between professionalism and feelings. I'd go under if I didn't and wouldn't be able to do my job properly. I'm far from lacking in empathy.