Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

... to be appalled by this point in today's 'mini budget'

107 replies

SafferUpNorth · 23/09/2022 12:14

Abolishing the upper income tax bracket of 45% which applies to incomes of £150,000+...

I mean WTF? WHY? Do these people need help? Why blow a hole in the country's tax revenue to help high earners??? I know the answer, of course... because it's the Tories. But goddammit, this is so blatantly favouring the wealthy at a time of crisis, it's absurd.

OP posts:
PestorPeston · 23/09/2022 16:45

Pound at $1.09 and falling. Do you think they are aiming for parity?

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 16:37

Skolo · 23/09/2022 16:19

All these outraged, non-Tory voting, high earners can overpay their tax by 5% or as much as they like., I’m slightly surprised that they don’t know about this already!

True

DownToTheSeaAgain · 23/09/2022 16:27

So the basic philosophy is that the rich are taxed more because they have more. This is then redistributed in the form of the welfare state.

The problem comes when the rich, particularly the revenue generators that run businesses and invest in them, leave the country and take their money elsewhere to protect themselves from high taxes.

I get that. What I don't get is how we are able to print or borrow billions to subsidise our tax revenues and pay for stuff and this not have a far more negative impact on the economy and the country in the long term. That's far more worrying to me.

banhmi · 23/09/2022 16:27

The Tories can get away with this sort of shit because most people (including some on this thread) don't understand how marginal tax rates work.

As a PP has said, 45% was only ever levied on earnings above £150k. Everything earned under that was taxed in the same way, so 20% basic rate then 40% higher rate over approx £50k etc.

www.vox.com/policy-and-politics/2019/1/7/18171975/tax-bracket-marginal-cartoon-ocasio-cortez-70-percent

Skolo · 23/09/2022 16:19

All these outraged, non-Tory voting, high earners can overpay their tax by 5% or as much as they like., I’m slightly surprised that they don’t know about this already!

MushMonster · 23/09/2022 16:12

I agree, whole heartily.
But at least you are thinking of the rest of us! I would say, if you can, spend the money on local shops, go for an extra coffee, gift shop and so on.
So it does actually trickle down to us.
But.... many people who earns high figures do not even "live" in UK, so they may be just moving to savings or investments abroad and how is that going to work for us? I cannot understand it really.
If they were going to up benefits, but they actually cut them!
As you say, the NHS is lacking.
Education is not coming out well either, not so long ago newspapers were stating that the quality of education may come down as to pay for teacher's payrise as there is no further funding to pay for it.
Regarding energy, things are grim, we are extremely dependant on other countries.
The prices keep going up, with huge inflaction, which if they do not tackle pronto, will bring the economy to a real shrink! People cannot expend any extra money that they do not have, so busineses will suffer, in a domino effect.
The only way I do see forward is to find innovative products, on the scale of amazon, facebook, super powerful batteries, 100% green energy, super medical advances... new things that make UK top on the investment league, patents, new companies...
But it does not look like we are going crazy in R&D either.
I am not understanding the path these guys are following at all.

lannistunut · 23/09/2022 16:01

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 23/09/2022 12:24

Entirely pointless. If they wanted to benefit that bracket they could have rased the limits instead and benefitted everyone.

Quite! This budget has deliberately been targeted so it only benefits the top 5%.

pointythings · 23/09/2022 15:59

@ClocksGoingBackwards it isn't 45% taken off all earnings. It's 45% on everything over £150k, which is a pretty massive wage. So pardon me if my violin is a bit too small for you.

amicissimma · 23/09/2022 15:58

drpet49 · 23/09/2022 15:47

What do you expect? Tory toffs keeping looking after their rich mates.

Strange idea. They're returning to the situation under Blair and Brown, who I believe weren't Tories.

And the legions of higher-rate tax payers who are apalled at this can simply pay the extra to HMRC - there is a facility for voluntary payments. Surely there won't be a whole slew of posts explaining why each particular poster can't/won't do this ...

JellyJaba · 23/09/2022 15:57

ChilliBandit · 23/09/2022 13:01

@BrendaHope - I’ve already seen tweets saying they are purposefully running the country into the ground (again) to leave Labour to pick up the pieces ala 1997. They need a new party trick.

I think they are trying to push us into a recession to try and tackle the cost of living. People seem to forget the cost of living is a global issue that governments can't solve themselves. Turkeys rate of inflation is something ridiculous like 50%

ClocksGoingBackwards · 23/09/2022 15:54

45% tax is a huge amount of earnings to be taken away from someone, I’m not sure anyone deserves to have nearly half of their income taken away, especially considering public services are so shit atm.

The people who don’t agree with it are free to donate the money that would have been taken in tax to a charity instead. The money would probably do much more good that way, and those that do feel they need to keep as much of their own earned money as they can will be free to do so.

Peopel who earn a high wage deserve to be considered by their government too. The way some on here talk it’s as if the government is only supposed to exist to service those on low or no wages.

User98866 · 23/09/2022 15:53

The whole lot is appalling. This only saves the very richest and big businesses money. I’m curious to know why scrap the cap the cap on bankers bonuses when ‘the cap doesn’t make a difference to overall remuneration’ as Kwarteng himself said. Why on Earth make a headline out of something that sounds awful and will obviously be unpopular Hmm. I think it’s because they know we are all going to hell in a handcart and they want to throw their mates a few bones before it happens.

WatchoRulo · 23/09/2022 15:53

akkakk · 23/09/2022 12:25

it isn't a huge impact on tax revenue - but those same people where they feel overtaxed, are leaving the UK to work in better tax environments (almost anywhere!) keeping them here keeps their businesses here and that leads to more wealth generation / more taxes for the government...

Even in 'communist' russia - they realised that to generate wealth, you had to allow entrepreneurs to run businesses and to do so because they saw the opportunity to get rich. Where you cap too agressively people start to see a point at which they don't need to work any harder as they don't gain enough extra, so they back off and that is bad for the economy.

Good riddance to cunts who don't want to pay their share. Fuck to them.

drpet49 · 23/09/2022 15:47

What do you expect? Tory toffs keeping looking after their rich mates.

Roomytrouser · 23/09/2022 15:45

Remember NI plummets when you get above the basic tax rate level so the difference in tax + NI is only around 10%.

When I had a higher paid job in finance I also got a 20% non-contributory pension contribution. In my current job I pay 5.5% so my deductions are only 4.5% less.

SafferUpNorth · 23/09/2022 15:37

Elvira2000 · 23/09/2022 15:23

It is mostly a fallacy that high earners move because of "high" tax (try denmark - where 50% is the lowest!). In fact i remember paying about 45% in Germany when earning around 30k a year.

It takes years to get to that sort of money and during that time people put down roots and develop relationships. That rate of tax is just part and parcel of living.

I reckon if high-earners are going to move from the uk, it will be more from the decline in infrastructure and the general environment. I have lived in two different countries since the tories got in. Every trip back compares so badly with these other places. I remember one trip in particular to my old uni town. The ground was matted with rubbish to the extent that I thought there was a bin strike, but no. It was normal. The air of general decay was horrible and really saddening.

This is the sort of thing that causes high earners to move, if they do. They may live in lovely enclaves, but they do need to venture out and go through the shitty bits and see the poorer citizens occasionally. And high earners are usually intelligent enough to link tax to quality of living conditions.

Excellent points here. I agree, the general infrastructure decline and worsening inequality will actually drive high earners and investors away. And those are the political decisions being made here.

OP posts:
MorrisZapp · 23/09/2022 15:33

I'm pretty clueless about economics but I'd imagine 'the rich' are very few in number and 'the poor' are vast in number.

I don't support tax cuts but I don't imagine the cost of this niche tax will be anything like it would be for cutting taxes at lower levels?

Elvira2000 · 23/09/2022 15:23

It is mostly a fallacy that high earners move because of "high" tax (try denmark - where 50% is the lowest!). In fact i remember paying about 45% in Germany when earning around 30k a year.

It takes years to get to that sort of money and during that time people put down roots and develop relationships. That rate of tax is just part and parcel of living.

I reckon if high-earners are going to move from the uk, it will be more from the decline in infrastructure and the general environment. I have lived in two different countries since the tories got in. Every trip back compares so badly with these other places. I remember one trip in particular to my old uni town. The ground was matted with rubbish to the extent that I thought there was a bin strike, but no. It was normal. The air of general decay was horrible and really saddening.

This is the sort of thing that causes high earners to move, if they do. They may live in lovely enclaves, but they do need to venture out and go through the shitty bits and see the poorer citizens occasionally. And high earners are usually intelligent enough to link tax to quality of living conditions.

Badbadbunny · 23/09/2022 14:55

If it means some rich people stay in the UK and pay tax, then that's for the good isn't it.

Far too many higher earners, especially "slebs" such as top athletes, pop stars, authors, TV personalities, actors, etc., move abroad to low tax countries/tax havens and then the UK get nothing from them.

40% of something is better than 45% of nothing!

ShirtingForkBalls · 23/09/2022 14:53

It's disgusting op.

obsessedwithsleep · 23/09/2022 14:51

Also the SDLT cut is insanity. Will just ensure overinflated prices and further pressure on supply. I hate this government so much.

Leilu · 23/09/2022 14:51

Suedomin · 23/09/2022 12:38

give your 5% to charity then if you feel that strongly about it.
The PP is missing the point. Giving money to charity isn't going to solve anything. And it's not jealously as I heard a Tory MP say!
The point is if public services are crying out for more funding, children are not getting the support they need. But instead of providing more support to those who need it. This Government decided to increase national debt to make rich people richer and with their new rules on UC poor people poorer. It's immoral.

Well, that’s your view. I think it’s immoral that the highest earners have to work for five months of the year just to pay their taxes before they start earning a penny for themselves and their family.

Were you this upset when the top earners were paying even less for all those years that Labour were in power, and if not, why not?

obsessedwithsleep · 23/09/2022 14:50

Shinyandnew1 · 23/09/2022 13:08

I also have to add that, in fact, my DH is one of those who'll benefit. Honestly, we do NOT need the 5% saving, though of course it's nice.

Just out of interest-are you a Tory supporter? Have you changed your mind politically recently?

We'll benefit from this and it disgusts me. Neither of us are Tory voters and neither of us would ever vote tory. I'd be happy to pay more tax for better public services.

EmmaH2022 · 23/09/2022 14:50

OP "Instead, I would have thought the threshold for the lower limits need to be upped"

agree. I suspect many red wall converts thought they would do this. Raising the threshold by 5k would do wonders and everyone could benefit.

ApolloandDaphne · 23/09/2022 14:47

I've actually realised that DH will still be paying high rate tax as we live in Scotland and the rate is to remain 46% here.