Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain and the US are poor societies with some very rich people- Average Polish family to be better off than the average UK family by 2024 (a far cry from the time when the UK was the biggest economy in the world when Queen Elizabeth was crowned)

109 replies

onthefencesitter · 23/09/2022 11:21

Very interesting article from the FT-

www.ft.com/content/ef265420-45e8-497b-b308-c951baa68945

'Its a similar story in the middle. In 2007, the average UK household was 8 per cent worse off than its peers in north-western Europe, but the deficit has since ballooned to a record 20 per cent. On present trends, the average Slovenian household will be better off than its British counterpart by 2024, and the average Polish family will move ahead before the end of the decade. A country in desperate need of migrant labour may soon have to ask new arrivals to take a pay cut.

It’s a similar story in the middle. In 2007, the average UK household was 8 per cent worse off than its peers in north-western Europe, but the deficit has since ballooned to a record 20 per cent. On present trends, the average Slovenian household will be better off than its British counterpart by 2024, and the average Polish family will move ahead before the end of the decade. A country in desperate need of migrant labour may soon have to ask new arrivals to take a pay cut.'

I wonder how patriotic Brits feel about this. Do they comfort themselves with the fact that they are better off than African countries (which have often been looted and invaded and suffered from extremely unstable political environments as well as war) despite the fact that the UK is relatively politically stable and is at peace? yes in the past, the british working class suffered great poverty but it was not poorer relative to the poor in its colonies or other 'developing countries' . Certainly for the average UK person to be poorer than the average polish person who were liberated from communism a mere 32 years ago is quite a feat...

OP posts:
newnamethanks · 24/09/2022 13:59

A few days ago, I heard a Tory radio commentator, name escapes me, replying to something quoted from the FT describe the paper as "not a business paper". Right.

Cornettoninja · 24/09/2022 13:53

£21 million is literally peanuts in the running of a national economy

I had the same thought, and it wasn’t like there was no economic benefit for the country, there are two sides to any transaction.

Looking at some industries staff shortages I’d happily bet that we’ve lost much more than that with the end of freedom of movement.

pointythings · 24/09/2022 13:18

£21 million is literally peanuts in the running of a national economy Hmm.

My DD1 is living in a house share post graduation. She loves it, the people there are her friends and she has everything she needs. Home ownership is too much of a sacred cow in the UK. Other forms of living are just as valid and should all be available.

TheRubyRedshoes · 24/09/2022 12:53

21 million pounds of UK child benefit also boosted living standards in Poland for children who never set foot here?

The loop hole?

RudsyFarmer · 24/09/2022 12:51

Im delighted for them. They have beautiful countries and they deserve to live there and prosper ♥️

Sarahcoggles · 24/09/2022 12:51

Surely this is a good thing? Eastern European countries have presumably been difficult to live in, hence so many people coming from there to the UK. It will be great for them if they can stay with their loved ones back in their home country, rather than having to come somewhere strange where they don't speak that language, living in cramped conditions, just to earn a semi decent wage.

TheRubyRedshoes · 24/09/2022 12:50

Rosa gallica

Blair also tinkered with access to free legal advise.
There was loads of pro bono stuff years ago.

ThatsNotMyMuffin · 24/09/2022 12:31

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/09/2022 12:20

Naturally the Polish economy was going to flourish when family members are working abroad spending very little and saving hard with enough to return to purchase property or set-up family members.

Builders and tradesmen earn over 20 euro an hour.

I lived in a 2 bedroom apartment, the apartment next door 2 bedroom had 10 men living there.

My Lithuanian neighbours must have 15 people in a 3 bedroom house.

Many have went back in a good financial position if they're smart enough.

If I could go abroad and triple my income I'd go for 10 years.

There was never enough people going back to boost the whole economy, that a ridiculous claim. Most people saved up enough to have a deposit to buy or build their house.

What makes a massive difference is that the maternity pay and the equivalent of child benefit are the same, if not much better than in the UK - by that I mean they get more money (in £) than we get here. It allows families to live comfortably even if they take time out of work to raise a family. That in turns boosts the economy.

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 12:31

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/09/2022 12:20

Naturally the Polish economy was going to flourish when family members are working abroad spending very little and saving hard with enough to return to purchase property or set-up family members.

Builders and tradesmen earn over 20 euro an hour.

I lived in a 2 bedroom apartment, the apartment next door 2 bedroom had 10 men living there.

My Lithuanian neighbours must have 15 people in a 3 bedroom house.

Many have went back in a good financial position if they're smart enough.

If I could go abroad and triple my income I'd go for 10 years.

The difference is that these workers are prepared to move for work and to house share.

UK social media is full of people complaining that their son/daughter had to move to the nearest town because they couldn't afford to buy in the village they were born in, or how they can't possibly be expected to pay a landlord's mortgage to live in a houseshare, and must have a home of their own.

I've lived in several European countries, and students and young people often houseshare in slightly grotty but often centrally located apartments. Here, its looked down upon as some kind of terrible thing where you will come to terrible harm if it isn't licensed and inspected by the state.

I found the standard of living in Scotland to be worse than anything I experienced in any other European country. I can only assume that most people there have never had the experience of living abroad, have inherited substantially or wfh or part time because they don't seem to realise how bad it is.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/09/2022 12:20

Naturally the Polish economy was going to flourish when family members are working abroad spending very little and saving hard with enough to return to purchase property or set-up family members.

Builders and tradesmen earn over 20 euro an hour.

I lived in a 2 bedroom apartment, the apartment next door 2 bedroom had 10 men living there.

My Lithuanian neighbours must have 15 people in a 3 bedroom house.

Many have went back in a good financial position if they're smart enough.

If I could go abroad and triple my income I'd go for 10 years.

RosaGallica · 24/09/2022 12:14

The deep cracks were caused by the destruction of old ways of life with nothing to put in their place: the miner’s strikes and technology change of the 80s- early 00s, along with globalisation. Those issues are still there.

RosaGallica · 24/09/2022 12:11

It doesnt surprise me at all that the average Brit is getting poorer. We've had an ideological war on the poor since 2010

Actually it’s been going on for a lot longer than that. Blair’s New Labour papered over some deep cracks in the economy by giving lots of money to the very poorest and the established middle aged at the time. He afforded it by robbing the then-young of our futures, by continuing to sell off public services, throwing us wide open to globalisation while deregulating markets, mucking up education and job markets by expanding universities and privatising them with tuition fees and mucking up housing with buy-to-let landlords.

That is why people voted in the Tories, and that is why I don’t think I will be voting in the next election, for Labour or anyone else.

Changing colours of political ties means nothing and people need to see beyond that if they really want change. You need to see the economy as it affects those who need to work their way up, not just as it affects middle classes with nice supportive backgrounds and private safety nets and their well-meaning charitable giveaways.

Donotgogentle · 24/09/2022 08:17

FinanceLPlates · 23/09/2022 16:19

I assumed this to be deep sarcasm

Of course!!

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 17:49

I can’t square people’s supposed desire for more equality while consistently voting in the Tories

Aside from recent years where they’ve chosen to appeal to the far right, I think a lot of them consider themselves further up the pyramid than they actually are. That uncomfortable truth sits well in buying into those poorer than themselves being the cause of all their frustrations.

caroleanboneparte · 23/09/2022 17:33

We live in such bubble communities that we only see and compare ourselves to those in similar economic circumstances.

So most people don't see to what extent others are struggling.

(See the thread where posters are saying there's no poverty because marks and Spencer's and airports are busy!!!)

It doesnt surprise me at all that the average Brit is getting poorer. We've had an ideological war on the poor since 2010.

onthefencesitter · 23/09/2022 17:13

sst1234 · 23/09/2022 16:57

Yet there has never been much of an exodus from UK to Poland. Even when were in the EU. I wonder why.

Firstly this is a projection i.e. it hasn't happened yet. But is projected to happen in two years. British incomes have taken a battering in part also due to the fall of the pound

Secondly, many British people are monolingual. norway is richer than the UK and is part of the EEA but British people haven't exactly all moved there despite being able to.

Thirdly, the fact that an average family earns XXX in XXX country doesn't mean that you will automatically earn an average income if you are average in the UK and then move to XXX country. Tell that to the immigrant taxi drivers with PhDs in Canada (as canada allows people with good academic qualifications to move tehre without a job). How much you earn also has to do with whether your skills are valued by the local job market.

OP posts:
SerendipityJane · 23/09/2022 17:12

sst1234 · 23/09/2022 16:57

Yet there has never been much of an exodus from UK to Poland. Even when were in the EU. I wonder why.

asymmetry of language ?

And if you need that pointed out you are thick as mince.

sst1234 · 23/09/2022 16:57

Yet there has never been much of an exodus from UK to Poland. Even when were in the EU. I wonder why.

GobbolinoTheWitchesCat · 23/09/2022 16:55

I'm a patriotic Brit, why do you imply I'll have issues reconciling myself to the article?

Can one only be patriotic if they sit on a certain point of the political spectrum?

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 23/09/2022 16:54

I don’t think most of the antiTories posting here would like it in Poland much. They don’t have much time for DIE there.

idonotmind · 23/09/2022 16:53

It's race to the bottom.

I can't afford heating - put on another sweater is the answer from many people on here!

cocavino · 23/09/2022 16:48

It's appalling and depressing.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/09/2022 16:46

jetadore · 23/09/2022 16:20

Interesting article though.
Particularly this part, “Research has consistently shown that while most people express a desire for some distance between top and bottom, they would rather live in significantly more equal societies than they do today. Many would even choose the more egalitarian society if the total pie was smaller than in a less equal one.”

I can’t square people’s supposed desire for more equality while consistently voting in the Tories.

I don’t think a desire for more equality was the motivation behind people voting Tory. A lot of it was about Brexit and British jinogoism, combined with a residual sense that Labour isn’t fit for office (I am not saying I agree with this but it’s a widely held view).

A lot of people quite like the idea that the Tory party represents the strivers and those who are motivated to advance their status. These people don’t particularly want greater social equality and they don’t care about people slipping through the gaps.

The trouble is that many of these “upwardly mobile” people will be caught out in the general dive in living standards in ways they didn’t imagine.

Ritasueandbobtoo9 · 23/09/2022 16:33

We are being ripped off. Services in were much better when I was young. Show me the money?

HesterAndPearlInBrightSunshine · 23/09/2022 16:29

I can’t square people’s supposed desire for more equality while consistently voting in the Tories

They voted in populists more than anything else.
People vote for populists when they feel their sense of national identity is all they have left. That is the sure fire sign of a society getting poorer...