Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Britain and the US are poor societies with some very rich people- Average Polish family to be better off than the average UK family by 2024 (a far cry from the time when the UK was the biggest economy in the world when Queen Elizabeth was crowned)

109 replies

onthefencesitter · 23/09/2022 11:21

Very interesting article from the FT-

www.ft.com/content/ef265420-45e8-497b-b308-c951baa68945

'Its a similar story in the middle. In 2007, the average UK household was 8 per cent worse off than its peers in north-western Europe, but the deficit has since ballooned to a record 20 per cent. On present trends, the average Slovenian household will be better off than its British counterpart by 2024, and the average Polish family will move ahead before the end of the decade. A country in desperate need of migrant labour may soon have to ask new arrivals to take a pay cut.

It’s a similar story in the middle. In 2007, the average UK household was 8 per cent worse off than its peers in north-western Europe, but the deficit has since ballooned to a record 20 per cent. On present trends, the average Slovenian household will be better off than its British counterpart by 2024, and the average Polish family will move ahead before the end of the decade. A country in desperate need of migrant labour may soon have to ask new arrivals to take a pay cut.'

I wonder how patriotic Brits feel about this. Do they comfort themselves with the fact that they are better off than African countries (which have often been looted and invaded and suffered from extremely unstable political environments as well as war) despite the fact that the UK is relatively politically stable and is at peace? yes in the past, the british working class suffered great poverty but it was not poorer relative to the poor in its colonies or other 'developing countries' . Certainly for the average UK person to be poorer than the average polish person who were liberated from communism a mere 32 years ago is quite a feat...

OP posts:
pointythings · 25/09/2022 09:43

@Georgeskitchen you are wilfully missing the point here. The point is that in terms of wealth and quality of life, Poland will overtake the UK in the next few years. Wages are rising in Poland. Polish people are leaving the UK because life here is getting worse. If you can't see where the UK is headed, you've got red, white and blue Tory blinkers on.

FrenchBoule · 25/09/2022 09:43

”Average” should give a clue.
1 person earns 100kk
4 people earn 10k

Average wage in this group is 28k.

The future of Poland in 2024 doesn’t look too rosy with current populist government fucking up economy and clinging into power so I’d not take seriously what they’ve written in this article.

It’s true though that British society is getting shafted- rich are getting richer and poor are getting poorer. Seems like “I’m alright Jack” attitude is present in all aspects of life. Only the strong survive?

As somebody earlier pointed out there’s no responsibility and consequences anywhere now. Avoidance and passing from pillar to post is everywhere.

Tory have no qualms in destabilising the country for personal gains.
Britain needs the government that would act in best interest of the country and its citizens. This one is certainly not.

Georgeskitchen · 25/09/2022 09:22

If Poland is such a utopia why are so many of them here living in shitty accommodation and doing shitty jobs?
Please explain that

Georgeskitchen · 25/09/2022 09:20

If Poland is such a utopia are so man

cakeorwine · 25/09/2022 09:02

Of course, if you mention this, you are accused of talking the country down.

This country is not bad, but it could be so much better for a lot more people. But if you don't know how much better it could be, then you just don't know...

The figures for household disposable income tell a story.

1 in 5 households have NEGATIVE disposable income of £60 a week after they spend on things like housing and food.In other words, they fall £60 a week short of money they need to spend on essentials

1 in 5 households have £7 a week

1 in 5 households have £78 a week.

And 1 in 5 households have an average of £775 a week of disposable income.

That is such a difference

corporate.asda.com/media-library/document/asda-income-tracker-july-2022/_proxyDocument?id=00000182-34a3-d424-a1fa-7ee36f4b0000

Britain and the US are poor societies with some very rich people- Average Polish family to be better off than the average UK family by 2024 (a far cry from the time when the UK was the biggest economy in the world when Queen Elizabeth was crowned)
EmeraldShamrock1 · 25/09/2022 08:57

Polish people also worked (and work) in Ireland, Germany, Netherlands, France, Denmark, the US, etc.
Indeed you're correct.
The UK alone didn't boost the Polish economy.
They've spread wide and worked hard.

pointythings · 25/09/2022 08:49

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 01:58

Agree, @Choopi
There seems to be no appreciation of how wide the Polish Diaspora has been since WW2 (but starting a hundred years before that). Many assume since they have personally encountered many 'Polish plumbers' that half of Poland decamped to the UK. Wrong. Poles are everywhere. The Diaspora consists of about 20 million people.

There's also the assumption that this is bad for some reason. I don't see anything bad with people moving to better themselves. Many Brits did it in the early 80s when wages were better elsewhere.

pointythings · 25/09/2022 08:48

@RosaGallica I am not defending the exploitation of workers by landlords running HMOs - far from it. What I'm saying is that the delusional idea that home ownership is the be all and end all has contributed to the UK's utterly dysfunctional housing market. House prices are ridiculous, landlords exploit tenants willy nilly, there is not nearly enough regulation and we have a government that voted against mandating that rental houses should be fit for human habitation. It's madness.

All forms of living should be safe and affordable because housing is an essential - whether that is in a house share because that is what you like, whether it's in a rented home or whether it's owned.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 01:58

Agree, @Choopi
There seems to be no appreciation of how wide the Polish Diaspora has been since WW2 (but starting a hundred years before that). Many assume since they have personally encountered many 'Polish plumbers' that half of Poland decamped to the UK. Wrong. Poles are everywhere. The Diaspora consists of about 20 million people.

Choopi · 25/09/2022 01:36

Sarahcoggles · 24/09/2022 12:51

Surely this is a good thing? Eastern European countries have presumably been difficult to live in, hence so many people coming from there to the UK. It will be great for them if they can stay with their loved ones back in their home country, rather than having to come somewhere strange where they don't speak that language, living in cramped conditions, just to earn a semi decent wage.

Is the point not how poor the poorest in the UK have gotten? How is that a good thing? The poorest in Ireland have a standard of living almost 63% higher than the poorest in the UK. The level of poverty, the reliance on charities to feed people is astonishing and not normal yet no one seems to care? They care more than some polish workers are getting pitiful UK child benefit because they live and work there? I mean ffs some people seem to think that it is down to the UK that Poland is doing well? If you can help an entire country as big as Poland then why can't you help your own poor? Why do you have them lining up begging for food at food banks?

TheLeadbetterLife · 25/09/2022 01:23

cakeorwine · 24/09/2022 16:43

I think that many people in the UK are probably unaware of how their lifestyle compares to people in other similar countries.

I agree this is a huge part of it.

on a political podcast I listen to they were discussing this week how the US is very good at convincing its population that they are much better off than they actually are, and how the U.K. was going the same way.

there’s an exceptionalist attitude in the US and U.K. - a sense of superiority that you don’t find in many other countries. Even the OP in this thread described the U.K. as relatively politically stable. If another country had elections or a new leader every year for 6 years, we’d think it was on the verge of collapse. Not to mention all the shenanigans with the illegal prorogation of parliament, the bad faith Brexit negotiations, Scottish independence gaining ground etc etc. The U.K. is very far from stable.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 01:12

Polish people also worked (and work) in Ireland, Germany, Netherlands, France, Denmark, the US, etc.

mathanxiety · 25/09/2022 01:08

data.worldbank.org/indicator/BX.TRF.PWKR.DT.GD.ZS

Data on personal remittances as a percentage of GDP worldwide.
Poland was at 1.1%in 2020.
In 2006 it was 2.5%.

MongoOnlyPawnInGameOfLife · 24/09/2022 20:49

And Truss and Kwarteng’s answer is to widen the wealth inequality gap even further. Somehow they’re so stupid that they believe we will overlook giving thousands to the 1% as long as there is a (very small) chance we get a fiver ourselves.

AchatAVendre · 24/09/2022 20:31

Chocochops I don't live in the UK, but when I go back to visit family I'm always taken aback at the sheer amount of 'stuff' people seem to own, the flashy cars etc. I don't think people in the UK realise just how cheap supermarket food and material goods have been there for years, certainly compared to Europe. I live in an extremely well-to-do part of a French city, and I don't see anything like the flash Mustangs and 4x4s that are parked outside my father-in-laws apartment, which is on a bog standard Persimmons development in a pretty run-down part of town. I used to love coming back to shop in the UK - for clothes, DIY stuff, household items - they were all so much cheaper than back in France! Plus credit is so easy to get in the UK.

Yes, the UK is much more commercial and consumerist than France. Its a throwaway culture. Even French car taxation is designed to make keeping older roadworthy vehicles cheaper than buying new ones. I always notice how little cheap stuff there is on FB marketplace in France compared to my nearest city in the UK, where you can pick up almost everything you want just as good as brand new for very cheap prices.

mathanxiety · 24/09/2022 17:25

...

Chocchops72 · 24/09/2022 17:05

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 17:49

I can’t square people’s supposed desire for more equality while consistently voting in the Tories

Aside from recent years where they’ve chosen to appeal to the far right, I think a lot of them consider themselves further up the pyramid than they actually are. That uncomfortable truth sits well in buying into those poorer than themselves being the cause of all their frustrations.

I think this is true.

I don't live in the UK, but when I go back to visit family I'm always taken aback at the sheer amount of 'stuff' people seem to own, the flashy cars etc. I don't think people in the UK realise just how cheap supermarket food and material goods have been there for years, certainly compared to Europe. I live in an extremely well-to-do part of a French city, and I don't see anything like the flash Mustangs and 4x4s that are parked outside my father-in-laws apartment, which is on a bog standard Persimmons development in a pretty run-down part of town. I used to love coming back to shop in the UK - for clothes, DIY stuff, household items - they were all so much cheaper than back in France! Plus credit is so easy to get in the UK.

The result, I think, is that being able to afford to buy flash cars, to decorate and redecorate houses, to buy all kinds of 'stuff', has made a lot of people feel much better off than they actually are - they can afford a lifestyle / standard of living that their parents couldn't. But it's all based on cheap imports (of food and goods) and easy credit. And that is coming to an end for all kinds of reasons.

RosaGallica · 24/09/2022 16:55

TheRubyRedshoes · 24/09/2022 12:50

Rosa gallica

Blair also tinkered with access to free legal advise.
There was loads of pro bono stuff years ago.

A good reminder. The legal people before 2010 were concerned and making noise about how access to law and legal representation was becoming the preserve of the rich I remember.

In fact there was a lot of concern about socioeconomic issues being expressed in the 00s. Why does it feel as if no one is seriously allowed to raise such topics any more? As if we’ve lost the language and narratives to talk about them - is it because we lost the educated group who had the tools to do it?

Other forms of living are just as valid and should all be available. Yeah, sure they are, and conveniently they involve massive inequality with some very secure and rich groups building superyachts while poorer groups own only what they stand up in and have no access to healthcare - or even law and order - and no power for change.

AloysiusBear · 24/09/2022 16:48

The problem is, we keep voting in politicians who maintain the unequal status quo.

We don't have to.

People can vote for change and they need to, we all do.

cakeorwine · 24/09/2022 16:43

I think that many people in the UK are probably unaware of how their lifestyle compares to people in other similar countries.

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/09/2022 16:35

It's a good thing IMO we shouldn't be jealous just because Ireland and the UK are failing desperately. 😔

EmeraldShamrock1 · 24/09/2022 16:33

There was never enough people going back to boost the whole economy, that a ridiculous claim. Most people saved up enough to have a deposit to buy or build their house.
Plenty who didn't return regular send money to their family. My neighbour has a brilliant job, she is highly educated she sends money back to her parents, she's staying bought her home here and rents out 2 bedrooms and the living room, she values stability over comfort.

My Dbro employees are married though their families live in Poland they regularly send home money while living in cramped conditions here.

onthefencesitter · 24/09/2022 14:23

Sarahcoggles · 24/09/2022 12:51

Surely this is a good thing? Eastern European countries have presumably been difficult to live in, hence so many people coming from there to the UK. It will be great for them if they can stay with their loved ones back in their home country, rather than having to come somewhere strange where they don't speak that language, living in cramped conditions, just to earn a semi decent wage.

It's great they are prospering but it should also remind us we are falling behind

OP posts:
Cornettoninja · 24/09/2022 14:06

God, we need an election

we need a full blown revolution - there’s just no consequence for anything anymore.

pointythings · 24/09/2022 13:59

@Cornettoninja ending freedom of movement has already cost the UK billions. But some people are so wedded to Brexit and the Conservatives that they don't want to know.

God, we need an election.