Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Emergency Budget

297 replies

Wouldloveanother · 23/09/2022 10:38

What are we all thinking?

www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-62920969

A discussion thread…

OP posts:
Wouldloveanother · 23/09/2022 15:07

Whammyyammy · 23/09/2022 14:54

Correct. High earners work 20 weeks per year to subsidise those that don't work or on low salaries, and have done for years.
How's that fair?

My husband pats more in tax each month than I take home, is that fair? No.

There's too many people taking out of the pot and not putting in, the answer is to not make the ones contributing to put more in

Well it’s the eternal dilemma isn’t it?

I don’t know what the answer is, how to strike a fair balance between personal responsibility/ incentive; and a society which doesn’t punish the disabled/children/low earners.

OP posts:
Whammyyammy · 23/09/2022 14:54

Leilu · 23/09/2022 14:32

Not really. Higher earners have been heavily subsidising everyone else, and will continue to do so, with their contribution just dropping a little bit.

Why should other workers spend more than five months of the year working to benefit other families before they start earning anything for themselves?

Correct. High earners work 20 weeks per year to subsidise those that don't work or on low salaries, and have done for years.
How's that fair?

My husband pats more in tax each month than I take home, is that fair? No.

There's too many people taking out of the pot and not putting in, the answer is to not make the ones contributing to put more in

LongLivedQueen · 23/09/2022 14:46

So, OP appears to be arguing 2 things

  1. IF you haven't saved for your dotage you are a fool who doesn't deserve anything but the most basic care, and even then you're lucky AND
  2. IT's not fair to get anyone working now to pay a few quid per week to pay for elderly care by way of NI because they can't afford it and they're being squeezed too hard.
And doesn't appear to see any issue with those two view points
Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 14:44

Public sector pensions are enormous

Only if they’re based on an enormous salary. The average NHS pension is £7k.

Even though pensions are universal and are thus (a) very expensive and (b) being paid to some very rich people.

And those very rich people pay most of it back through taxation. Means tested benefits cost more to administer than they save.

Pensions have been mandatory for over 20 years. There is no one alive who spend their whole career in the uK at an employer who refused to let women join the pension scheme. It’s been illegal for many decades

How many decades? There are plenty of people alive who didn’t have access to an occupational pension for most of their working lives. Women are particularly disadvantaged.
www.closethegap.org.uk/content/resources/Pensions-briefing.pdf

CaptainThe95thRifles · 23/09/2022 14:41

MsPincher · 23/09/2022 14:20

Public sector pensions are enormous. Also public sector workers are not generally paid less for comparable jobs. I’ve worked in both- paid less in public sector but about the same once you take into account pension. There’s a lack of understanding of how much pensions are worth - eg a pension of about £20,000 a year would cost £500,000 or more if you had to save the money. No one in the private sector is getting those kind of perks.

People suggesting "generous" public sector pensions are a meaningful contribution to the cost of elderly care do not understand the cost of elderly care.

This isn't about private vs public sector perks (many care workers get no public sector perks anyway - which is the original context of that debate) - this is about how to fund the cost of care. If you're on a low wage, your pension contributions will (likely) not fund the cost of your care, whether you're on a private or public sector pension.

Someone who spends their life on a low wage does not deserve to be relegated to second rate care just because their job is poorly paid.

Raddix · 23/09/2022 14:37

Whammyyammy · 23/09/2022 12:38

I'm shocked at the number of people thst haven't made provision for pensions and relying on just the state one.

How can you make provisions for pensions when you can barely afford to survive week to week? I can assure you that those who are relying on the state pension aren’t happy about it and would love to have a private pension, but simply can’t afford it.

Leilu · 23/09/2022 14:35

Ypsilanti · 23/09/2022 14:11

I warn you not to be ordinary
I warn you not to be young
I warn you not to fall ill
I warn you not to get old

(Neil Kinnock, 1983 - but he could say the same today)

I am aghast and outraged by the comments above suggesting that means to pay should determine the care someone receives in old age. So what if Ken has worked as a hedge fund manager and has accumulated millions? Should he be entitled to better care than June, who cleaned Ken’s house (and those of other hedge fund managers) for the minimum wage. Is she less deserving because she is poor?

Sweet Jesus. What has this country become?

It’s not at all clear what your objection is here. Are you saying that someone with £10m in the bank should not be entitled to spend it on private nursing care in their opulent home on Sandbanks, or that the state should provide that same standard of care for everyone?

Leilu · 23/09/2022 14:32

SafferUpNorth · 23/09/2022 12:57

Actually, the more I think about it and listen to coverage, the more it sickens me.

I am actually feeling quite ill now. Of all the changes to income tax they could have chosen to make (and the next generation pay for).... it's come down to making the rich even richer. SICKENING.

Not really. Higher earners have been heavily subsidising everyone else, and will continue to do so, with their contribution just dropping a little bit.

Why should other workers spend more than five months of the year working to benefit other families before they start earning anything for themselves?

LongLivedQueen · 23/09/2022 14:30

Wouldloveanother · 23/09/2022 12:34

Last response about this because it’s distracting from the point of the thread.

They both go into basic care homes.

So when you said they were different scenarios and should be treated differently, you meant that they should be treated exactly the same as there was no different.

Gotcha.

MsPincher · 23/09/2022 14:29

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 12:37

If they’re living on the basic pension then they have made no provision for their elderly care.

Because

They didn’t earn enough
Their employer didn’t offer a pension scheme
They were a woman who was barred from entry to her employer’s pension scheme

Take your pick, many fell into all three categories.

Pensions have been mandatory for over 20 years. There is no one alive who spend their whole career in the uK at an employer who refused to let women join the pension scheme. It’s been illegal for many decades.

MsPincher · 23/09/2022 14:24

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 13:25

Pensioners are the wealthiest demographic in the country

Wealth isn’t uniform though is it? Much like the rest of the country, the gap between the richest and the poorest is huge.

No but as a whole pensioners are wealthiest. Yet their pensions (and benefits— level of pension credit being tied to pensions) increase by far greater amounts than non pension age workers. Even though pensions are universal and are thus (a) very expensive and (b) being paid to some very rich people.

MsPincher · 23/09/2022 14:20

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 13:11

‘Comparatively generous’ doesn’t mean much unless you’re about to start comparing actual figures.

A low paying career is going to result in a low pension. That’s an issue when so many jobs needed for society to function are low paid. It’s not like the cost of living is (or has been for decades) low enough to compensate.

Public sector pensions are enormous. Also public sector workers are not generally paid less for comparable jobs. I’ve worked in both- paid less in public sector but about the same once you take into account pension. There’s a lack of understanding of how much pensions are worth - eg a pension of about £20,000 a year would cost £500,000 or more if you had to save the money. No one in the private sector is getting those kind of perks.

Popaholic · 23/09/2022 14:19

@Ypsilanti hear hear. You put it perfectly.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 14:12

Ypsilanti · 23/09/2022 14:11

I warn you not to be ordinary
I warn you not to be young
I warn you not to fall ill
I warn you not to get old

(Neil Kinnock, 1983 - but he could say the same today)

I am aghast and outraged by the comments above suggesting that means to pay should determine the care someone receives in old age. So what if Ken has worked as a hedge fund manager and has accumulated millions? Should he be entitled to better care than June, who cleaned Ken’s house (and those of other hedge fund managers) for the minimum wage. Is she less deserving because she is poor?

Sweet Jesus. What has this country become?

I was literally just thinking of that Kinnock quote.

Ypsilanti · 23/09/2022 14:11

I warn you not to be ordinary
I warn you not to be young
I warn you not to fall ill
I warn you not to get old

(Neil Kinnock, 1983 - but he could say the same today)

I am aghast and outraged by the comments above suggesting that means to pay should determine the care someone receives in old age. So what if Ken has worked as a hedge fund manager and has accumulated millions? Should he be entitled to better care than June, who cleaned Ken’s house (and those of other hedge fund managers) for the minimum wage. Is she less deserving because she is poor?

Sweet Jesus. What has this country become?

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 13:40

the average is less than 5 years for both sexes, at a cost of £35k per year.

£35k a year 😂😂😂

My parents paid £1k a week each and they both died in 2015. God only knows what that care home costs now.

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 13:38

This doesn't quite work, because one of the benefits of most of those lower paid public sector roles (and reasons people stay) is the comparatively generous pension.

Most carers don’t work in the public sector. Social care was privatised decades ago.

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 13:25

Pensioners are the wealthiest demographic in the country

Wealth isn’t uniform though is it? Much like the rest of the country, the gap between the richest and the poorest is huge.

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 13:23

Let’s watch how the pound reacts to the budget - currently at a 37 year low. Initial reports aren’t favourable, because it’s blindingly obvious it’s a shit budget implemented by a bunch of charlatans and dunces.

ilovesooty · 23/09/2022 13:21

Wouldloveanother · 23/09/2022 12:04

But I’m talking about a completely different system where this wouldn’t happen. You’re making a strange hybrid out of what I’m saying and the current system.

Pensioners are the wealthiest demographic in the country. There would be more than enough money raised overall for Ken to stay where he was. Many care home residents don’t live there that long for obvious reasons - the average is less than 5 years for both sexes, at a cost of £35k per year. That means the average person will require ~250k of care. One in five baby boomers in the U.K. are millionaires. Some are poor but most are in between and very able to afford it.

It hasn't taken long for this to become a pensioner bashing thread, has it?

CaptainThe95thRifles · 23/09/2022 13:15

sicklycolleague · 23/09/2022 13:07

This doesn't quite work, because one of the benefits of most of those lower paid public sector roles (and reasons people stay) is the comparatively generous pension.

Bullshit - not all care workers are in public sector roles, and even those that are do not have pension provisions that would make a significant dent in their care bill. The same is true of nursing - relatively decent pensions for a low wage =/= adequate provision for their needs.

Cornettoninja · 23/09/2022 13:11

sicklycolleague · 23/09/2022 13:07

This doesn't quite work, because one of the benefits of most of those lower paid public sector roles (and reasons people stay) is the comparatively generous pension.

‘Comparatively generous’ doesn’t mean much unless you’re about to start comparing actual figures.

A low paying career is going to result in a low pension. That’s an issue when so many jobs needed for society to function are low paid. It’s not like the cost of living is (or has been for decades) low enough to compensate.

Whammyyammy · 23/09/2022 13:08

Kennykenkencat · 23/09/2022 12:43

You forget that paying into a pension didn’t mean you actually got your pension

Asset strippers or a company’s financial difficulties meant the company pension fund was used to pay off company debts.

I paid into a pension. I don’t have anything because the company went bankrupt and the pension fund was used to pay off debts

I'm.sorry that happened to you/your pension. But you still recognised that the state pension is a pittance and made provision for it.

sicklycolleague · 23/09/2022 13:07

CaptainThe95thRifles · 23/09/2022 12:39

What if June wasn't some feckless benefit scrounger (which appears to be your implication)? What if June had spent her life working in social care herself, or as a nurse in the NHS, or as some other lowly paid but highly valuable career? What if June didn't work because she was disabled? Screw them all too and send them to a glorified kennels?!

Lots of people don't amass wealthy before needing care despite being worthwhile and productive members of society.

The OP's comments on this thread are absolutely sickening.

This doesn't quite work, because one of the benefits of most of those lower paid public sector roles (and reasons people stay) is the comparatively generous pension.

BirmaBrite · 23/09/2022 13:04

They both go into basic care homes.

Where are all these basic care homes going to come from ? Who is going to build them ?