Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be completely confused by the mini budget?

288 replies

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 09:57

Just baffled really, how is it going to boost the economy & improve public services?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 11:25

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 11:20

we need more investment in the economy, better skills & wages for higher productivity, well that my economic understanding.

We do, and also in public services so we have a healthy well educated workforce. I am not sure how cutting taxes increases available funds to invest in those things.

MrKlaw · 23/09/2022 11:24

Everanewbie · 23/09/2022 10:58

Some of the measures are a difficult sell politically. At a time where a lot of us are struggling, reducing the top rate of tax for people that earn above £150,000 doesn't sound great. But the reality is that higher tax at the top end doesn't generate any more income as it pushes talent abroad and encourages creative accounting. The 45% tax rate was always more about appearing to hammer the wealthy than actually generating revenue. And what business is it of government to tell a private organisation what it can or cannot pay its employee? Removing the cap is righting a wrong stemming from politics of envy.

What I am disappointed about is that there has been no effort to increase the higher rate threshold. It was never intended to catch people earning £50k. Also, I'm disappointed that no effort has been made to reduce the burden of the annual allowance and lifetime allowance charges on pensions which are forcing skilled professionals, especially doctors, to retire early to avoid huge upfront taxation, at a time when they are most needed.

the bankers bonus you mean? That was put in place as there was concern uncapped bonuses encouraged unnecessary risk taking - the kind that contributed to the banking crash and the government spending billions bailing out the banks.

Yes you should be able to pay the market rate for people, but clearly without some limits, people take the piss

Woolandwonder · 23/09/2022 11:24

It's totally ridiculous, really unhelpful for FTB, most FTB are buying way under the previous stamp duty threshold. House prices will keep going up, along with interest rates, it's impossible to save fast enough to keep up. Its ridiculous that me and my partner are both on almost exactly the 'average' income, have a £45000 deposit that we have spent 10 years saving for and still can't buy a terraced house, so we are stuck renting.

Badbadbunny · 23/09/2022 11:23

@DadDadDad

If government actually took more tax off all high earners, they could help the poorest

Not if the high earners beggared off abroad, they wouldn't! That's exactly what has happened over the past few decades. The "rich" have enough money and are often flexible enough to be able to relocate. Just look at how many top athletes, pop stars, TV personalities, actors, etc live abroad. There's a reason that some pop stars have moved to, say, Switzerland "for creative reasons"!

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 11:23

@caringcarer but isn't that temporary & not enough plus there are still the salary increases. I heard a school on the radio who's energy bills had gone from 200k to just under 800k

OP posts:
Badbadbunny · 23/09/2022 11:21

@walkingonsunshinekat

WTC introduced by Labour was just a name change for various types on income support

It was far more than a "name change". It was a fundamental change in the administration, qualifying criteria, and most importantly, amounts paid out. People who'd previously qualified for relatively modest benefits (or not qualified at all) suddenly found themselves eligible for huge sums.

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 11:20

we need more investment in the economy, better skills & wages for higher productivity, well that my economic understanding.

OP posts:
DadDadDad · 23/09/2022 11:20

edwinbear · 23/09/2022 11:05

Those of you so furious about this, will you be volunteering to continue paying 20% lower rate? E mail address is right here for you.
[email protected]

Please feel free to carry on paying 20% if you think it's the right thing to do.

@edwinbear

I am angry. I have a high salary so will benefit massively from all the cuts.

But there's virtually no point me paying the difference to HMRC if other high earners are not being asked to. We elect our politicians to collect sufficient tax from all those who can most afford it - to make it compulsory to contribute, not voluntary.

What will I do with the extra? Probably further increase the amount I regularly donate to foodbanks, because they are not going away any time soon with these proposals. Angry

If government actually took more tax off all high earners, they could help the poorest and I would live in a better society where I wouldn't need to support foodbanks, and public sector workers would be properly resourced. That's what I want!

caringcarer · 23/09/2022 11:19

@towelhammer, the government have already announced huge payments to businesses, schools, colleges, hospitals with energy bills. I think 40 percent.

ancientgran · 23/09/2022 11:18

Alexandra2001 · 23/09/2022 10:31

The jury is not "out" at all.

The last Tory chancellor to do this sort of thing, was under Heath/Barber in 1972, led to a very short term boom followed by a market collapse.

Sterling and Gilts have already fallen dramatically, as has the ftse.

Corporation tax has been at 19% for several years and has not led to an increase in growth.

This is a budget for the wealthy, with no requirement to invest monies saved.

The tories have just very unapologetically decided to make the rich richer & fuck everyone else.

I'm old enough to remember what hell that was. Bought our first house in the boom of 1973, a year later it was worth less and the interest rate had risen 4 times I think in 12 months, fixed deals weren't a thing then as far as I know they certainly weren't offered at our building society.

I was pregnant with 2nd baby and the biggest excitement that Christmas was I won the playgroup raffle of a food hamper. Someone offered to drop it off for me later but I was so excited I loaded it onto the pushchair. I must have seemed like a crazy lady, 9 months pregnant, big hamper in the buggy and toddler upset at having to walk.

I hope we don't get the same sort of boom/bust this time.

Eastangular2000 · 23/09/2022 11:18

Deutschman · 23/09/2022 11:12

@DesdemonaThreethree and @drunkinthebackofthecar I agree the attitude to the nhs is odd, but there are important benefits:

  1. A shared culture of valuing health and public service. Contributes to social cohesion and a willingness to do things like pay tax
  2. People working in the nhs see it as a valuable public duty and therefore give huge amounts of their time free. They also give a part of themselves to patients in compassion etc - workers in the dvla don’t need to do this.
In many ways being valued socially makes up for a lot of issues with poor pay and conditions, although now both have been eroded so much that staff goodwill is vanishing.

Your first point couldn’t be more wrong. The fact that it’s free at the point of delivery means that people don’t value it. Just look at the number of missed appointments and time wasters in a and e. And as for valuing health, have you seen the British population. Fat, sedentary and with all manner of behaviours that clearly show they don’t value health

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 11:18

lemonyanus · 23/09/2022 11:16

Perhaps the aspirational prunes who normally vote Tory will now realise they aren't a member of their 'club' if they aren't earning £150,000+ you're just another pleb to be trod on.

Nah, a lot of the middle earners will be better off as a result of the tax/NI cuts, and they clearly don't give a shit about the people at the bottom getting trodden on, otherwise they would never have voted Tory in the first place.

caringcarer · 23/09/2022 11:17

I think as top Rate income tax now down to 40 percent will attract new businesses to UK so new jobs. Paying 40 percent is still a lot of a wage to lose. It will encourage those who only work 4 days a week to avoid paying the 45 percent to go back to working 5 days a week. Scrapping bankers bonus caps will attract new banks and the best talent in banking into UK. All tax going down from 20 p in £ to 19 p in £ from April will help all those who pay tax. Also reversing NIC contributions by 1.25 percent will help all and also in employers. Cuts on corporation tax will attract new businesses to relocate in UK. Now we will just have to watch and wait if any new large businesses do in relocate to UK. If they do the amount of revenue they generate will offset some of these costs. This seems to favour higher earners and businesses but earlier in year money off council bands A-D helped those with cheaper properties. Those on UC, and with disabilities also got cash help. As a country the UK gets most of its tax from its higher earners and compared to other countries 40 percent is still high.

lemonyanus · 23/09/2022 11:16

Perhaps the aspirational prunes who normally vote Tory will now realise they aren't a member of their 'club' if they aren't earning £150,000+ you're just another pleb to be trod on.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 11:15

@sst1234 If your correct about the mini budget, the markets would want to put money into the UK, they aren't they are doing the opposite.

WTC introduced by Labour was just a name change for various types on income support, first introduced in 1972 under Heath.

KK has done nothing to increase investment in UK plc, instead its just one of the largest tax cutting budgets ever seen, no requirement to invest and totally un costed.

We are heading for hi inflation and interest rates.

Wanttobeanastronaut · 23/09/2022 11:13

smooththecat · 23/09/2022 10:24

Fundamentally, the Tories don’t believe in improving public services. They’d rather businesses bled them dry for profit and, for example, flood the country with raw sewage.

Absolutely. And it should be remembered that a 'streamlined' public sector is what the British public has been voting for since 2010. People have got what they asked for. Only now has the penny dropped on what austerity really meant.

Deutschman · 23/09/2022 11:12

@DesdemonaThreethree and @drunkinthebackofthecar I agree the attitude to the nhs is odd, but there are important benefits:

  1. A shared culture of valuing health and public service. Contributes to social cohesion and a willingness to do things like pay tax
  2. People working in the nhs see it as a valuable public duty and therefore give huge amounts of their time free. They also give a part of themselves to patients in compassion etc - workers in the dvla don’t need to do this.
In many ways being valued socially makes up for a lot of issues with poor pay and conditions, although now both have been eroded so much that staff goodwill is vanishing.
Eastangular2000 · 23/09/2022 11:11

Willyoujustbequiet · 23/09/2022 10:27

It's disgusting. Makes me physically sick that they are giving wealthy people more money whilst we literally have children going cold and hungry.

Its morally repugnant . Tories are evil.

Interesting POV that they are giving wealthy people money. Do you come from the standpoint that all money is the property of the state to dish out? Because unless you do I haven’t seen anything today that involves the state giving people money, all it is doing is reducing the amount of money that it takes from some people.

DowningStreetParty · 23/09/2022 11:11

It’s absolutely terrifyingly self-serving of the Tory party and will break what little faith most of us have left in politicians to treat people fairly.

Most adults I know are worried sick about bills and eating and keeping warm enough to get through the winter. While our government just supports its rich mates. It’s disgusting.

Zippedydoo123 · 23/09/2022 11:11

It won't help many people as any extra pounds will need to be spent on groceries petrol utilities and many things have now really shot up in price. Clothing shoes everything is costing so much more.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 11:10

RewildingAmbridge · 23/09/2022 11:01

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves those on benefits should get an increase yes, for working people this will put a little more back in your pocket, also most people on benefits actually are in some form of employment so will also benefit from income tax cut

Not if they earn under the threshold for income tax, which many do - especially those employed in the gig economy, on zero hour contracts etc.

When you say that people on benefits "should get an increase", what does that mean exactly? Are you saying that you agree that this should have been in the budget but wasn't? Or are you saying that they will get an increase that I have somehow overlooked?

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 11:09

MintJulia · 23/09/2022 11:05

I think the theory is that getting rid of the top rate of tax will encourage high net worth individuals to return to live in the UK, and spend and pay tax here.

Also that those who do have money will spend it in the economy, trickling down through businesses. I'm not convinced.

And it still means single parents earning between 50 & 60k have a marginal tax rate of 60% even after today's measures. Patently unfair and high time the govt did something to even it up.

Why would people who have decided to leave the UK want to return to a country facing economic collapse?
They have a life overseas and tax accountants to ensure a far lower rate than even 40%.

The capital markets, at the moment, have lost faith in the UK being able to pay its debts, 10 yr govt bond yields are through the roof.

kegofcoffee · 23/09/2022 11:09

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 10:58

Our kids will pay for it, and probably their kids too.

There's not enough kids though, we already have an huge demographic shift. Immigration isn't so popular either 😆

This is so true. And another reason why investing in childcare would have been a more sensible idea.

sst1234 · 23/09/2022 11:09

This mini budget is a response to spot the rot caused by 25 years of mismanagement of the economy. Here are the lowlights of that mismanagement -

Tax credits introduced by labour government to subsidize low pay and keep wages at the bottom suppressed. Which keeps wages all the way up the pay scale suppressed. It also causes low productivity. Why would employers invest in raising productivity when they can get cheap labour subsidized by the taxpayer.

Refusal by labour and successive Tory governments to invest in any major infrastructure projects. For instance the third runway at Heathrow.

Refusal by successive government to invest in home grown energy, nuclear and gas.

Printing more money to pay for Covid lockdowns than had been printed between 2008 and 2020.

The low wages and low productivity in this are grinding down the economy. And the disastrous lockdowns just brought things to breaking point. All the measures announced today will be a sticking plaster.

The real work would require even more unpopular choices. Green lighting double digits nuclear power plants, Raising minimum wage to at least £15, raising personal allowance to £15k, reducing, corporation tax to 12%, restructuring the NHS, further tax breaks for privately funded infrastructure projects above a certain amount, approve 3rd runway at Heathrow. This would be painful in the short term, but money doesn’t grow on trees, even it is the proverbial magic one. You either print it (we all know how that went), borrow it, or make and sell stuff at better margins than your competitors.

kegofcoffee · 23/09/2022 11:08

FetlocksBlowingInTheWind · 23/09/2022 10:53

I'm weirdly jealous of higher earners now...aren't they effectively 21% better off after this tax cut?

No; it's a cut from 45% to 40% for earnings over £150k. Rather than a cut from 40% to 20%, that jump remains the same.