Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be completely confused by the mini budget?

288 replies

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 09:57

Just baffled really, how is it going to boost the economy & improve public services?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 12:50

I thought misleading parliament and lies told in the house were the worst of sins, but she told a BLATANT LIE in the first few sentences thus wasting everything that followed. "The Chancellor has confirmed that the costs of the energy price cap will be funded by borrowing, leaving the eye-watering windfall profits of the energy giants untaxed."

Semantics. It was perfectly obvious to me that she meant a windfall tax.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 12:49

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 12:40

Low tax investment zones and the subsequent bonfire of worker's rights etc that go along with that = a bloody crime.

I haven't really processed what these zones are all about. Is there an explanation somewhere?

Lower worker protections, lower environmental standards, less planning control and more fraud/criminality, they are expensive to run too.
The Tories scrapped Freeports in 2012 for these very reasons

They don't actually grow the economy, what they do is suck in investment from surrounding areas = Robbing Peter to Pay Paul.

There is also the Brexit WA that has sanctions in place for either side to keep a relative fair competitive playing field.

jcyclops · 23/09/2022 12:47

I am much more disappointed with Labour than the Tories after today's session in parliament. Some of Kwarteng's announcements may prove to be good for the country, many are probably useless and one or two are definitely just in the "reward our friends" area. He did, however, present the opposition with an open goal to really lay into the worst policies. Instead we got Rachel Reeves, who after her first sentence totally wasted the opportunity. You can see the guts of her overlong, waffling response here:
labour.org.uk/press/rachel-reeves-response-to-the-chancellors-fiscal-statement/

I thought misleading parliament and lies told in the house were the worst of sins, but she told a BLATANT LIE in the first few sentences thus wasting everything that followed.
"The Chancellor has confirmed that the costs of the energy price cap will be funded by borrowing, leaving the eye-watering windfall profits of the energy giants untaxed."

The facts are that whilst most companies pay 19% corporation tax, the energy companies pay 30% with a further 10% supplement. Since May 2022 they have also had an extra 25% Energy Profits Levy. You simply can't say that profits are untaxed, and by the way, the only difference with Labour's policy is that they wanted to backdate the tax to January 2022.

butterflycatcher · 23/09/2022 12:45

@towelhammer I don't think it will have the same impact on prices as the previous stamp duty cuts. For starters interest rates are now much much higher than they were 2020-2021 and people can only afford to pay a certain amount each month. First time buyers will benefit most but they are also the most likely to be stung by massive mortgage repayment charges as a lot of people already in the market are on fixed deals and sheltered for a little while.

FatOaf · 23/09/2022 12:41

Low tax investment zones and the subsequent bonfire of worker's rights etc that go along with that = a bloody crime.

On this, at least, they are in agreement with Sunak on the virtue of increasing opportunities for fraud. They still need to make announcements on how they will continue Sunak's urgent efforts to promote smuggling.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 12:40

Low tax investment zones and the subsequent bonfire of worker's rights etc that go along with that = a bloody crime.

I haven't really processed what these zones are all about. Is there an explanation somewhere?

blueshoes · 23/09/2022 12:39

I am not sure how this squares with the Bank of England raising interest rates to cool inflation and this strategy by Liz/Kwateng to spend our way to growth.

Not a very coherent strategy.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 12:37

RewildingAmbridge · 23/09/2022 12:31

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I'm saying it should've been in the budget but wasn't

Thanks for clarifying... seems that we agree!!

LadyFromage · 23/09/2022 12:35

The stamp duty cut is a bit bonkers, imo - because it leads to inflated prices.

The 45% cut is neither here nor there. A bad look for very little gain. Ditto the bankers bonus limit; I don't think the cap ever changed behaviour so removing it won't either, but the PR on it is shocking.

The 1% off income tax & NI cut is good for most, but not all. Care should have been given to those who don't benefit from this. Pensioners likely to be fine via the triple lock but other benefit receivers need further assistance - this could have been achieved via extra help on energy bills, for example. UC is already a disaster so messing with that further is wrong, imo.

Am amazed they havent touched the 40% tax threshold. Not least, because I think that would have been the thing to swing votes back to Tory. It appeals to their typical base and is likely to give those people significant benefit that they will then be reluctant to let go of.

Tax free shopping for tourists - OK.

Freezing alchohol duties seems like it's specifically aimed at bribing Scotland. I don't suppose they will fall for it Smile

Low tax investment zones and the subsequent bonfire of worker's rights etc that go along with that = a bloody crime.

RewildingAmbridge · 23/09/2022 12:31

@MrsBennetsPoorNerves I'm saying it should've been in the budget but wasn't

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 12:28

but yes long term it will boost prices

OP posts:
towelhammer · 23/09/2022 12:28

No it isn't, because the price of property will immediately rise. Property sells for what people can afford to pay for it. If there's no stamp duty, asking prices go up to match what the previous cost including stamp duty would have been. It's been done before and always has the same result.

not quite so simple as if they have their own forward purchase & mortgage offer they are unlikely to want to risk that.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 12:26

WatchoRulo · 23/09/2022 12:20

National borrowing doesn't work like that. It's not a credit card or a payday loan. I am not a Tory, but getting tired of people regurgitating that over simplistic crap Thatcher started about the nation's economy being like your household budget - it isn't.

I understand that perfectly well, actually, but your argument only works if the borrowing is used to drive growth.

I don't believe that tax cuts for the rich without significant investment in infrastructure is going to result in growth, and if the economy doesn't grow, then yes, we will be saddling future generations with the bills for this folly. How else do you think it will be paid for?

Liz Truss is not borrowing to invest in the future. She is borrowing to get quick political wins right now that won't have any long term positive impact.

HappinesDependsOnYou · 23/09/2022 12:23

The point I was really confused by was lifting bankers bonuses. What we need I a cost of living crisis is to give millionaires more money? 🙄looking forward to the next round of public service cuts when the Government bleat they cannot afford to keep staffing levels/pay staff but its OK because bankers get their nice Xmas bonus and the social care is paid for from taxes which have just been slashed. Was Diane Abbot in charge of the calculator again?

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 12:23

In 1972 Barber delivered a budget which was designed to return the Conservative Party to power in an election expected in 1974 or 1975. This budget led to a period known as "The Barber Boom". The measures in the budget led to high inflation and wage demands from Public Sector workers. He was forced to introduce anti-inflation measures in September 1972, along with a Price Commission and a Pay Board. The inflation of capital asset values was also followed by the 1973 oil crisis which followed the Yom Kippur War, adding to inflationary pressures in the economy and feeding industrial militancy (already at a high as a result of the struggle over the Industrial Relations Act 1971).

In 1972, having said a week earlier in the House of Commons that he had "no reason to believe that the pound was overvalued", he floated it (most of the world currencies were floated at that time) "as a temporary measure". The pound immediately plunged on the markets, and it was impossible during his time as Chancellor to impose a new parity. It has remained floating ever since.

It seems the lessons of history haven’t been learnt.

BorisJohnsonsHair · 23/09/2022 12:22

YABU to be confused. It's quite clear. Fleece the poor to give more money to the rich. Simple.

WatchoRulo · 23/09/2022 12:20

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 10:43

They won't pay for it at all. We will pay for it through our taxes for generations to come. Our kids will pay for it, and probably their kids too.

National borrowing doesn't work like that. It's not a credit card or a payday loan. I am not a Tory, but getting tired of people regurgitating that over simplistic crap Thatcher started about the nation's economy being like your household budget - it isn't.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/09/2022 12:18

Markets seem horrified. Pound dropping to lowest level in 37 years.

GreenLunchBox · 23/09/2022 12:18

Well the FTSE and the pound have reacted the same way I feel about this budget so. . ..well done Liz <slow clap>

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 12:17

Biggest cut since 1972. Anyone else remember how well that went?

FatOaf · 23/09/2022 12:15

The thing is, a lot of people will feel that it benefits them, because on paper, it will - they will pay less tax and NI, and therefore get to keep more of the money that they earn. What they may not fully appreciate is that there will be much less funding for public services, and the massive impact that that will have on our society as a whole.

For most people, the amount they save in tax will be less than the amount they lose as a result of increased mortgage interest rates (either their own or their landlords'). Not to mention the increases in food and petrol prices that will result from the falling value of the pound.

AlexandraPeppernose · 23/09/2022 12:15

Classic Conservative Policy. The rich get richer and the poor continue suffering.

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 12:15

It’s a Rich Man’s World playing outside Parliament now. Spot bloody on.

Dave20 · 23/09/2022 12:13

Topgub · 23/09/2022 12:08

@Dave20

Yeahcause businesses are well known for paying staff more rather than keeping the increase in profit

🙄

Absolutely agree. Big businesses mainly look after their bosses. I’m just saying what the government have said.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 12:12

spicysoup · 23/09/2022 12:06

It's totally mad! I really don't understand why poor people vote Tory. The mini budget only benefits the super rich. How did they think this would be a good idea? I really hope the press trashes them

The thing is, a lot of people will feel that it benefits them, because on paper, it will - they will pay less tax and NI, and therefore get to keep more of the money that they earn. What they may not fully appreciate is that there will be much less funding for public services, and the massive impact that that will have on our society as a whole.

I think the Tories bank on people not seeing those connections in order to keep the middle classes sweet while they're busy making their super rich friends and relations even richer. They don't bother too much about keeping the poor happy, because they are less likely to vote Tory anyway.

Swipe left for the next trending thread