Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be completely confused by the mini budget?

288 replies

towelhammer · 23/09/2022 09:57

Just baffled really, how is it going to boost the economy & improve public services?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
verdantverdure · 23/09/2022 22:07

Financial Times: Pound slumps below $1.09: Larry Summers tells Bloomberg: Britain 🇬🇧 will be remembered for having pursued the worst macroeconomic policies of any major country in a long time.”

To be completely confused by the mini budget?
UsernameHistories · 23/09/2022 20:32

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 18:33

the very rich are being subsidised a whole lot less than everyone else.

Not after today they’re not. They’re getting a whole lot more than any universal credit claimant.

They are not- can you provide your calculations to support that?

Dave20 · 23/09/2022 20:19

I’m going to play devils advocate here. If bankers earn bigger bonuses, they’ll get taxed more. So effectively, the big bonuses go back to the coffers?
Secondly , is it better for businesses to settle here and pay a bit less tax, rather than go abroad? Atleast the UK would benefit from the tax it pays. The UK wouldn’t benefit at all if a company sets up camp abroad.

If a business is attracted to set up here because it pays less tax,it still employs people who work here and pay tax and NI. So still benefits the UK?

I think the chancellor said that if you ask businesses to pay a bit less tax, they are less likely to avoid paying it or look at leaving the UK.

Again, devils advocate.

Dave20 · 23/09/2022 20:05

Ronald Reagan tried this in the 1980s.Cutting income tax and de regulation. Giving business tax cuts . The idea of Reaganomics was for the wealth to trickle down to the less well off. It didn’t happen.
Instead we got the Greed is good culture ( remember the film Wall Street?).

It similarly happened here to ,when Thatcher privatised everything. The big bosses got greedy and the working class got poorer.

In four decades it’s like nothing has been learnt.

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 19:56

Pity no-one has tried stimulating the economy then.

Isn’t it? The Tories have only had 12 years to do it.

Cillery · 23/09/2022 19:54

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 18:16

Thatcher carried the markets with her.

Not sure about the prosperity stuff, we had some pretty awful recessions in the 80s and 90s plus we had the best of NS production tax receipts.

Trickle Down was first coined by a Hollywood actor and has never been an economic theory.

We don't have the time to tell, there are proven ways to stimulate an economy in a sustainable way.

Pity no-one has tried stimulating the economy then. We know Labour’s plans (from experience) will produce stagnation. So what do you suggest?

Cillery · 23/09/2022 19:52

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 18:12

What makes you think trickle down will work this time when all the evidence from previous experience points to the contrary?

What ‘evidence from previous experience’?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 18:39

I agree that it's incorrect to say that high earners are being subsidised by other tax payers. Technically, they are keeping more of their money while the government borrows more to cover the shortfall in tax take.

However, high earners would be foolish to think that they are not heavily dependent on lower earners in many other ways. Who do they think empties their bins? Who produces their food? delivers their shopping? Who teaches their children? Who will care for them when they're elderly?

Nobody in our society is independent. Nobody can function without the contributions of others. Some people contribute financially through their taxes. Some contribute by providing essential services, often on very low wages. Some people in other ways. We all need each other.

Eastangular2000 · 23/09/2022 18:37

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 18:33

the very rich are being subsidised a whole lot less than everyone else.

Not after today they’re not. They’re getting a whole lot more than any universal credit claimant.

No they really aren't. The borrowing is to fund the public services in lieu of their money which they now get to keep. The borrowing would not be required if we just slashed services to match. Universal credit claimants cost the state a huge amount, people earning 150000+ a year don't, no matter how you try to spin it.

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 18:33

the very rich are being subsidised a whole lot less than everyone else.

Not after today they’re not. They’re getting a whole lot more than any universal credit claimant.

Eastangular2000 · 23/09/2022 18:31

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 18:26

because you are subsidised by the state, the state being other members of society.

High earners are now being subsidised by other tax payers as their cuts are being funded with borrowed money which we’ll all have to repay - and our children and grandchildren.

Everybody is being subsidised by the borrowing and the very rich are being subsidised a whole lot less than everyone else. I really don't agree with this budget but I am astonished that people seem to have just completely forgotten that tax cuts are not giving people money, they are letting people keep their own money. Benefits and services are giving people money, more often than no other peoples money. Tax credits were such a sleight of hand in terms of the way they were named. They are not tax credits they are cash handouts from the state, of monies that are taken from one sector of society and given to another. The narrative that 'people in receipt of tax credits are also taxpayers' is in reality a nonsense as the fact id if you are receiving benefits you are not a net contributor.

Blossomtoes · 23/09/2022 18:26

because you are subsidised by the state, the state being other members of society.

High earners are now being subsidised by other tax payers as their cuts are being funded with borrowed money which we’ll all have to repay - and our children and grandchildren.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 18:16

Cillery · 23/09/2022 18:10

Well it is a radical thing and somewhat of a gamble but 364 experts wrote to Margaret Thatcher and said what she did was wrong at the time. But of course we enter the time of prosperity afterwards. The problem is that nothing else anybody has done has worked. I’m not an economist and neither is anybody else here probably who is commenting. But this is a radical proposal and if the economics have the desired trickle down effect then the economy will recover. Time will tell

Thatcher carried the markets with her.

Not sure about the prosperity stuff, we had some pretty awful recessions in the 80s and 90s plus we had the best of NS production tax receipts.

Trickle Down was first coined by a Hollywood actor and has never been an economic theory.

We don't have the time to tell, there are proven ways to stimulate an economy in a sustainable way.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 18:12

Cillery · 23/09/2022 18:10

Well it is a radical thing and somewhat of a gamble but 364 experts wrote to Margaret Thatcher and said what she did was wrong at the time. But of course we enter the time of prosperity afterwards. The problem is that nothing else anybody has done has worked. I’m not an economist and neither is anybody else here probably who is commenting. But this is a radical proposal and if the economics have the desired trickle down effect then the economy will recover. Time will tell

What makes you think trickle down will work this time when all the evidence from previous experience points to the contrary?

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 18:11

Truss did say she wanted to be unpopular, she will now get her wish.

Indeed!!

Cillery · 23/09/2022 18:10

Well it is a radical thing and somewhat of a gamble but 364 experts wrote to Margaret Thatcher and said what she did was wrong at the time. But of course we enter the time of prosperity afterwards. The problem is that nothing else anybody has done has worked. I’m not an economist and neither is anybody else here probably who is commenting. But this is a radical proposal and if the economics have the desired trickle down effect then the economy will recover. Time will tell

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 18:00

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 17:47

Over the numerous threads, not read a single critic say they want carnage.

No I’m not talking about critics on here wanting it I meant carnage for the Tories

They could have had entirely different headlines without the top cut tax rate

Granted maybe other issues but small tax cuts for all will be subsumed by the largest cut

Fair point accepted.

Yes i agree very odd, this is all very much self inflicted, started with their crazy energy policy and its borrowing demands and cumulated in possibly the worst budget seen since the 1930s.

Truss did say she wanted to be unpopular, she will now get her wish.

StripeyDeckchair · 23/09/2022 17:59

It's not.

If you're rich, you're going to get richer

If you're poor, you're fucked.

So nothing new - the Tories are looking after themselves.

I predict riots this winter

Twillow · 23/09/2022 17:58

sicklycolleague · 23/09/2022 17:56

Can I ask what you do @Twillow? Apologies if you've already said

Retail (but not a glamorous standing behind a counter bit!)

sicklycolleague · 23/09/2022 17:56

Twillow · 23/09/2022 17:49

When you are being paid minimum wage anyway and face the prospect of earning a minimal amount for doing more of the fairly arduous job that I do, I challenge most people to say they would. I don't make the rules regarding benefits, but I do qualify for tax credits that are highly significant for keeping me out of debt. As a lone parent, I have to decide whether, with regards to overtime, it is worth being out at unsociable hours earning a pittance or living very carefully within what I already earn along with what am entitled to under the benefits system and spending quality time with my dependents...

Can I ask what you do @Twillow? Apologies if you've already said

Eastangular2000 · 23/09/2022 17:54

Twillow · 23/09/2022 17:49

When you are being paid minimum wage anyway and face the prospect of earning a minimal amount for doing more of the fairly arduous job that I do, I challenge most people to say they would. I don't make the rules regarding benefits, but I do qualify for tax credits that are highly significant for keeping me out of debt. As a lone parent, I have to decide whether, with regards to overtime, it is worth being out at unsociable hours earning a pittance or living very carefully within what I already earn along with what am entitled to under the benefits system and spending quality time with my dependents...

And, quite understandably, you choose to take the preferable lifestyle option that is on offer because you are subsidised by the state, the state being other members of society.

Twillow · 23/09/2022 17:49

sicklycolleague · 23/09/2022 17:42

I don't know about the tax credits aspect of this, but in non-tax credit situations, being taken over the tax threshold still means you earn more money than you otherwise would've. When I needed extra cash I did this, worked in a bar for £8 per hour at basic rate (20%) as it was a second job and the allowance was on my main job. The extra £200 a month in my hand made a huge difference

When you are being paid minimum wage anyway and face the prospect of earning a minimal amount for doing more of the fairly arduous job that I do, I challenge most people to say they would. I don't make the rules regarding benefits, but I do qualify for tax credits that are highly significant for keeping me out of debt. As a lone parent, I have to decide whether, with regards to overtime, it is worth being out at unsociable hours earning a pittance or living very carefully within what I already earn along with what am entitled to under the benefits system and spending quality time with my dependents...

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 17:47

Over the numerous threads, not read a single critic say they want carnage.

No I’m not talking about critics on here wanting it I meant carnage for the Tories

They could have had entirely different headlines without the top cut tax rate

Granted maybe other issues but small tax cuts for all will be subsumed by the largest cut

myleftventricle · 23/09/2022 17:46

LuluBlakey1 · 23/09/2022 12:05

It is a General Election budget to try to keep Tory voters and anyone who who pays higher rate income tax or might buy a house.
It's shameful- 234billion of public debt- 72 billion of which has been added today - directly into the pockets of the very wealthy and paid back by the rest of the country for the rest of their lives and the lives of their children.

But most Tory voters aren't going to benefit any more than Labour or Lib Dem voters will. A small % of Tory voters will be on mega-bucks and will therefore save £000s but most are on much smaller incomes. My parents - staunch Tory voters until Boris when their opinions have faltered - are pensioners. They'll get peanuts more. I've voted Tory the last 2 or 3 times (reluctantly last time as I wanted Brexit, albeit not the one we got) but I'm only going to benefit by under £1k because I'm on an average amount. To be honest I'd vote Labour in a flash if I thought they had a decent bunch of people capable of running the country and could identify what a woman is correctly. And that's what might give us another Tory govt - Labour being inept again. If they sorted themselves they could romp it with a few half-decent policies.

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 17:43

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 17:32

The headlines will be full on tomorrow. I’m imagining the same without the top tax cut and they’d get away much more lightly. I don’t really get the desire for carnage but maybe it’ll pass or they’re hoping it will

Over the numerous threads, not read a single critic say they want carnage.

But carnage is the global markets view on what can only be called totally irresponsible tax cuts borrowing and spending.

Its not the 45% cut, frankly, thats small beer, not desirable but not important either or even the CT or NI reversals... its the approx 200 billion in borrowing that they are concerned about and so should you be, all of us who love the UK should.
In 18 months time, when gas is still super high, what then? this is what the markets don't understand.

We will be paying for this with hi inflation and interest rates for many years to come but unlike in 1972 when the Tories were last so reckless, there will be no North Sea oil to bail us out.