Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's normal for 16/17 year olds to have part time jobs alongside their studies

161 replies

sheepdogdelight · 23/09/2022 09:56

DD (16) has recently started a part time job - she's working 6 hours a week, around her A Levels. Older DD also worked part time when he was 16/17, stopping at the end of March in Year 13 so that he could focus on his exams.

Virtually all their peers also have/had jobs at some point or another at age 16/17 - weekend socialising was often a logistical exercise to find the best time around who was working when.

IMO it's good for them to have a job at this age - it helps them become more self confident, builds independence, allows them to gain some valuable "soft" skills. Plus of course they like the money :)

However, was talking to someone about this who looked horrified that they should be taking time away form studying to work and that her own 17 year old would certainly not be working. She also suggested it was not the norm amongst her DC's peer group.

For the record, we have had the conversation about studies must come first and if the job ever impacts on studying, they need to reconsider. However my DC (and their peers) all seem to be able to juggle perfectly well!

AIBU to think it's normal and desirable for 16/17 year olds who are studying to have jobs around their study? (I'm assuming here that there is suitable part time work available, of course - but at the moment retail/hospitality seem to have loads of vacancies).

OP posts:
Grumpyoldpersonwithcats · 24/09/2022 09:11

My sons both had church organist jobs at our local church from about 14. Much better paid than shop work, and usually only 2-3 hours a week.

DS2 is just off to uni and the church no longer has an organist. Anyone with a keen pianist child who fancies learning the organ on the job (Windsor area) feel free to PM me.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 24/09/2022 08:03

FishAndChipsForDinner · 24/09/2022 07:21

DS works a 10 hour contract around college. HIs college doesnt allow more hours, or allow working both weekend days. It worries me that he has apirations to go to a uni that apparently doesnt allow them to work at all though - what do we do then? We cannot afford to support him!

If you mean Oxbridge they do allow jobs in the holidays and some types of job, e.g. college library shifts. There are also lots of different bursaries and things, book grants and others at different colleges

PorridgePowered · 24/09/2022 07:53

Not unreasonable. I had a job at that age and is massively helped with being assertive and generally helping me to grow up. Not to mention the freedom that comes with having a bit of your own cash.

Don't think there is any conflict around exam prep and working. I personally found it nice to have a couple of hours to switch off from study!

Would suggest that you always give freedom to young people to choose the kind of job they want, and if your yp wants to switch to a different job after a bit that is fine. If anything it gives a bit more variety of experience.

FishAndChipsForDinner · 24/09/2022 07:21

DS works a 10 hour contract around college. HIs college doesnt allow more hours, or allow working both weekend days. It worries me that he has apirations to go to a uni that apparently doesnt allow them to work at all though - what do we do then? We cannot afford to support him!

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 24/09/2022 07:01

DS has a part time hospitality job. Started it when finished GCSEs and is continuing during college. He’s only in college 3 days a week and does between 4-8 hours depending on the restaurants shift decision. It’s great because learning the value of money.

vote here for jobs for 16/17 year olds. No reason why they can’t

WaveyHair · 23/09/2022 18:14

I had a Saturday job and a couple of evenings waitressing. I learnt time management (did not always get it right) and managing money.

Met all sorts of people, saw how a business works, and what was expected of me as an employee.

newjobwhodisperhaps · 23/09/2022 18:09

I remember getting a job aged 16, when I started college. Just a part time shop job that I kept through college and early Uni days to get cash for nights out and clothes. It really helped me get to grips with working life/balancing commitments and of course an advantage in having an actual work reference when looking for my first career job at 21!

Givenuptotally · 23/09/2022 18:04

It’s more usual to work than not, I think. I teach in an independent - I would say 50% have jobs (those that don’t are frequently those that have serious sport/music/dance/drama commitments). In my previous state school, I would say over 90% had at least a Saturday job. My own 18 year old worked from 16.

latetothefisting · 23/09/2022 18:00

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

You can't just use your very limited experience to extrapolate definite fact though. I could say the opposite - I worked more than most of my friends throughout sixth form, at least 15hrs a week, plus did an extra A level 2 evenings a week in a local college because my school didn't offer it, plus had several hours driving lessons and went out a lot, and got the highest grades in my year. In uni I again worked at least 15hrs a week. 2 of my housemates worked pretty much full time. The three of us got better grades than our other 2 housemates who didn't work at all.

Some teens might need extra time to focus on work but realistically most won't spend 6 hours a day doing homework. In my experience working part time just allows most teens to learn how to balance and prioritise their time effectively.

Quincythequince · 23/09/2022 17:56

viques · 23/09/2022 15:55

That would be fabulous. Thank you. In return can I direct you to courses which help people with anger management and self awareness?

LOL. My last post re comprehension was about you, you utter plank.

So let me know about the self-awareness course, maybe we can go together 😆

Dixiechickonhols · 23/09/2022 16:41

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

I don’t see that at all. My DD/her peers are all top grade students lots aiming for medicine and she certainly wouldn’t be spending all her free time studying nor is it healthy to do that. If they are needing to study for hours over the recommended then they probably aren’t high achieving students.

viques · 23/09/2022 15:55

Quincythequince · 23/09/2022 15:24

No, but I can direct posters to reading sources so they learn how to assimilate and respond to written information.

And he’s already very charming thank you. More charming than a nameless adult on here who makes an idiotic swipe involving kids

That would be fabulous. Thank you. In return can I direct you to courses which help people with anger management and self awareness?

AngelsWithSilverWings · 23/09/2022 15:25

Keeping an eye on this with my DS who has just started sixth form.

He has a lifeguarding job which was advertised as 12 hours over each weekend. They are so short staffed that they put him on permanent shifts of 8 hours on Sat and Sun and also phone him all the time and ask him to do extra week night shifts and training.

I've told him that if his grades drop he will have to insist on the original 6 hours and stop agreeing to overtime.

It's been amazing for him though as I've seen his confidence and maturity grow and grow since he started working there.

He has started refusing weeknight shifts since he started back at school so I think he's sensible enough to manage his time.

Quincythequince · 23/09/2022 15:24

viques · 23/09/2022 15:19

Can you sign him up to charm school for an hour a week , just in case he has inherited your lack of social skills?

No, but I can direct posters to reading sources so they learn how to assimilate and respond to written information.

And he’s already very charming thank you. More charming than a nameless adult on here who makes an idiotic swipe involving kids

viques · 23/09/2022 15:19

Quincythequince · 23/09/2022 12:39

And I’m case you missed it, he also does gardening too - so your post is pretty stupid tbh.

Can you sign him up to charm school for an hour a week , just in case he has inherited your lack of social skills?

SirChenjins · 23/09/2022 15:13

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

Not so much snobbish as ill informed. If your child is motivated and organised then a combination of a small part time job, sports, socialising and school work helps make them well rounded individuals with a good range of life skills.

Changechangychange · 23/09/2022 15:11

There aren’t always suitable part time jobs available to be honest - most pubs/restaurants won’t hire 16 year olds, supermarkets generally want too many hours plus flexibility for overtime, and clothes shops don’t just want Saturday girls, they want people in the week too. So that’s why it is less common now than it was 20 -30 years ago.

But if your teen has found one that isn’t demanding too many hours, good for them. There’s nothing wrong with having a PT jobs as long as the hours are manageable.

hoovermanouvre · 23/09/2022 15:07

SW London here and mine don't / didn't have jobs. Very pressured schools and that's enough. I'd rather they put their time into school without distractions.

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 15:06

Also has had Eng work experience which I agree is helpful

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 15:05

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

I’m not sure it’s comparable

Tbf none of us had jobs back then (although I was boarding so probably harder)

But Ds does and still doing four A levels for engineering - so the maths based ones. What I’ve seen is that he works, exercises studies and gets a boost from a variety. It probably depends how much you work and what it does to your motivation generally

justasking111 · 23/09/2022 15:05

Term time mine were at school 5 and a half Days a week, but holidays they worked. University breaks they worked. They wouldn't have had the extra money otherwise

mathanxiety · 23/09/2022 15:01

Obv this is anecdotal, but the kids in my school who got into the top universities and courses all had jobs. So did the kids who went straight from school to working in Dunnes.

My own DCs all got into excellent US universities despite PT jobs and sports/ theatre in school. In the US, students are required to show a wide range of activities outside of school and studying if they're applying to private universities (Ivy League and equivalent). The idea is that they are actively preparing themselves for real life, taking on challenges, and demonstrably able to manage their time and priorities.

ReadyForPumpkins · 23/09/2022 15:01

I have never had a part time job at secondary. What I did have is professional summer placements. I have never done a supermarket shift and it hasn’t held me back. (There are other reasons I don’t have a high flying career). It is key to actually get jobs before graduation and jobs in your targeted industry is better than a supermarket stint.

brianixon · 23/09/2022 14:58

At that age I was working full time in an iron foundry.
Never did me any harm.

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

Swipe left for the next trending thread