Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think it's normal for 16/17 year olds to have part time jobs alongside their studies

161 replies

sheepdogdelight · 23/09/2022 09:56

DD (16) has recently started a part time job - she's working 6 hours a week, around her A Levels. Older DD also worked part time when he was 16/17, stopping at the end of March in Year 13 so that he could focus on his exams.

Virtually all their peers also have/had jobs at some point or another at age 16/17 - weekend socialising was often a logistical exercise to find the best time around who was working when.

IMO it's good for them to have a job at this age - it helps them become more self confident, builds independence, allows them to gain some valuable "soft" skills. Plus of course they like the money :)

However, was talking to someone about this who looked horrified that they should be taking time away form studying to work and that her own 17 year old would certainly not be working. She also suggested it was not the norm amongst her DC's peer group.

For the record, we have had the conversation about studies must come first and if the job ever impacts on studying, they need to reconsider. However my DC (and their peers) all seem to be able to juggle perfectly well!

AIBU to think it's normal and desirable for 16/17 year olds who are studying to have jobs around their study? (I'm assuming here that there is suitable part time work available, of course - but at the moment retail/hospitality seem to have loads of vacancies).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
gogohmm · 25/09/2022 13:52

Completely normal, mine got lucky because they were paid for their hobby but most had jobs

user29 · 25/09/2022 13:50

It depends.A holiday job - yes, but depending on workload.it may nor be possible in termtime.It's difficult to find a job that are just a few hours per week.Dd2 has so much homework with 4 a levels she was getting up at 5.30 am to finish it.catching bus at 8 am. Home at 4.50.it was just too much

Friday123 · 25/09/2022 13:41

Completely normal. You have quite a few free periods when doing A levels so if you use that time to study, there's enough time to do part time work as well. I did flyering when I was 17 then worked three nights a week in a pub when I was 18. I used to do reading/revision in the pub on Monday nights because it was really quiet. My younger siblings worked in a shop, pubs and did babysitting.

NameInUseAlreadyAgain · 25/09/2022 13:29

Not all are going off to Uni. Our DS is doing a practical BTec and his part time job complements that.

plus he’s grown up MASSIVELY since starting work in June.

for me I cannot see any reason why 16+ can’t have a job and go to do a levels or BTec or whatever, and still get a good Uni place. It’s just lazy not to have a job IMO if it’s possible to get one.

Citruszesty · 25/09/2022 13:12

Working at that age is a good thing as it not only helps them to earn money but it looks good their CV and helps prepare them for the world of work. If it doesn't interfere with studies it can only bring benefits.
I worked at that age and it helped with getting a part time job at university when there were 5 applicants per job. It helped with full time jobs after university as well as it showed I could hold down a job and work with other people.
A couple of my friends who didn't have jobs until they left university found it a lot harder to settle into a fulltime job and the expectations it brought. Some found it harder to get a job in the first place (but that might be because of the industry they went into)

justasking111 · 25/09/2022 12:59

One of DS friends since aged four has seen his mates go into college vocational, university. His parents never expected him to work. GCSE results blah so went to tech. Did ok there but the minimum, then went back to bed. He's since done a bit of part time work, pub, shop. Finally he's decided what he wants to do so is an apprentice in a job he should have applied for 5 years ago. Meanwhile his mates are flying, apprentice finished or university done.

I do blame his parents dad university lecturer ditto mum. He was the kid who was late for school most days. Had to finish the cartoon on TV at breakfast time. Had to finish call of duty before home work.

I'd have kicked him out of bed, banned TV, x box which I did at times pushing him into work weekends school holidays

Dixiechickonhols · 25/09/2022 12:44

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 12:19

Sane here - lots of 17yo dd's friends are very comfortably off but choose to work regardless. I would say that it's more like 90% who work though. Or at least, 90% have worked, even if they don't actually have a job at present.

Getting a PT job is considered a bit of a rite of passage here, and those who haven't ever had a job are seen as a bit immature by their friends.

Yes we are a ‘nice’ area and grammar school with mostly middle class intake yet most seem to be working or looking for work in the sixth form.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 12:19

KassandraOfSparta · 25/09/2022 10:38

I have a 17 year old DD. I'd say about 70% of her friends have some sort of job, mostly local cafes, ice cream shops, pizza delivery places, supermarkets, fashion stores. Most doing 6-8 hours a week.

We are not in a deprived area where kids need to work to contribute to teh family funds. These are all kids working for pocket money or savings.

Sane here - lots of 17yo dd's friends are very comfortably off but choose to work regardless. I would say that it's more like 90% who work though. Or at least, 90% have worked, even if they don't actually have a job at present.

Getting a PT job is considered a bit of a rite of passage here, and those who haven't ever had a job are seen as a bit immature by their friends.

KassandraOfSparta · 25/09/2022 10:38

I have a 17 year old DD. I'd say about 70% of her friends have some sort of job, mostly local cafes, ice cream shops, pizza delivery places, supermarkets, fashion stores. Most doing 6-8 hours a week.

We are not in a deprived area where kids need to work to contribute to teh family funds. These are all kids working for pocket money or savings.

ThinWomansBrain · 25/09/2022 10:25

Of my close friends with children, the couple whose children had part time jobs while at school, one child dropped out of uni. but went straight into a management job where he'd worked part time & is now in a successful professional career, the other went straight into a job on around £40k+ from university, has been promoted a couple of times since.

The two pushy families who didn't allow children to do any part time work while at school?
One child had drug and alcohol problems from early teens, dropped out of four universities before settling and graduating, one is still unemployed four years after graduating, another couple have a mid 20s degree educated child living at home and shelf stacking in a supermarket.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 10:24

Romeiswheretheheartis · 25/09/2022 10:23

My dd15 is desperate to get a job but everywhere seems to only take age 16+. Would love to know where all the15 yr olds are working!

Mostly at independent cafes round here.

Romeiswheretheheartis · 25/09/2022 10:23

My dd15 is desperate to get a job but everywhere seems to only take age 16+. Would love to know where all the15 yr olds are working!

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 25/09/2022 10:15

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

@Ein, it doesn't depend so much on your aspirations for your children, but rather the extent to which you're confident in their ability to get top grades without spending every waking hour studying.

My dc has 2 jobs. She is predicted A*s in all her subjects regardless. I am confident that she has the skills to balance both and a very busy social life.

Rosehugger · 25/09/2022 10:09

Heh, yeah, I'd have just spent more time in my room listening to music if I hadn't had a job. If anything having something to do other than sixth form college helped me organise my time better because there was a bit less of it.

DD1 is good enough academically for Oxbridge but has no interest in them.

kikisparks · 25/09/2022 09:51

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

“any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job”- that doesn’t make sense. It’s not a given that teenagers without jobs spend the time they could have been working by studying. They could be socialising/ lazing about/ doing hobbies/ doing chores/ any number of things.

I worked 15ish hours a week and did equally well in my exams as my friends who didn’t work.

Plenty of teenagers could study day and night and still not get straight As. Not everyone is academic and that’s fine, there are lots more paths in life than a first at a top university. Also having a first at a top university doesn’t mean you’ll necessarily do well in the work place, you need life skills too.

Dixiechickonhols · 24/09/2022 11:06

FishAndChipsForDinner · 24/09/2022 07:21

DS works a 10 hour contract around college. HIs college doesnt allow more hours, or allow working both weekend days. It worries me that he has apirations to go to a uni that apparently doesnt allow them to work at all though - what do we do then? We cannot afford to support him!

Can he take a gap year and earn and save. If it’s oxbridge terms are short so plenty of time to work.
I was showing my DD the cost of halls and how much she can borrow for maintenance (much less as we both work) to encourage some saving for Uni.

TockClicking · 24/09/2022 10:31

My daughter is 17 and has had a Saturday job for a couple of years. She's just got another job working in retail that will work alongside her other job.
She loves earning her own money and has great swaths of time between her college lessons so does most of her work then.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 24/09/2022 10:30

latetothefisting · 23/09/2022 18:00

You can't just use your very limited experience to extrapolate definite fact though. I could say the opposite - I worked more than most of my friends throughout sixth form, at least 15hrs a week, plus did an extra A level 2 evenings a week in a local college because my school didn't offer it, plus had several hours driving lessons and went out a lot, and got the highest grades in my year. In uni I again worked at least 15hrs a week. 2 of my housemates worked pretty much full time. The three of us got better grades than our other 2 housemates who didn't work at all.

Some teens might need extra time to focus on work but realistically most won't spend 6 hours a day doing homework. In my experience working part time just allows most teens to learn how to balance and prioritise their time effectively.

Agree. I worked part time, got straight As and went to Oxford. Most of my contemporaries at Oxford had also worked during 6th form

TimBoothseyes · 24/09/2022 10:11

Ein · 23/09/2022 14:55

In my 6th form class, only two children had jobs. They got significantly lower grades than the rest of us.

I was expected to spend my free time studying, or socialising as a break, but mostly studying. Got straight As, like many of my (non-jobbing) classmates.

So I guess it depends on your aspirations for your children and whether you see them aiming for first class degrees at top universities or not. God this sounds snobby, it isn’t meant to, but to sum up: any child who has a job is by definition studying less than if they didn’t have a job, and that impacts on their future grades.

DD worked part-time from the age of 16 until she finished her A levels and went to uni, when she also got a part-time job.....oh and a 1st class honours degree, so didn't impact her at all.

Abraxan · 24/09/2022 10:11

For the record, we have had the conversation about studies must come first and if the job ever impacts on studying, they need to reconsider. However my DC (and their peers) all seem to be able to juggle perfectly well!

This is the key part to remember if they are wanting to continue their studies and education.

Sadly a lot of employees are happy to take in young people but don't want to acknowledge they can only really work a certain number of hours to give the teens time to study too. Why would they? Ultimately they're a business.

And some teens get very used to the money and take in more and more shifts. This then cuts into school/college time and study time. I've seen this become a real issue and as a result 2 of DD's friends never ended up continuing their education and just moved to working in their 'part time' job full time. They may return to education later, but for now they are working a jib with no real career prospects but enjoying having money that their university friends don't have.

I've also known a couple where it's worked out really well, and they've been able to continue without university due to having work places happy to shift their student employees between home and university locations.

Whilst dd didn't have a part time job (we could afford for her not too and gave her an allowance so long as she was doing useful voluntary work instead) many of her friends did. Whilst all the employees tried the 'just a couple of extra shifts this week only' type thing most of her friends could make it work for them in the end, but not all.

Just keep an eye on the balance and be prepared to have serious conversations about hours when it comes to revision and exam times.

JoshLymanIsHotterThanSam · 24/09/2022 10:05

I started working at 14 (somewhat slightly illegally too but that’s by the by). Dd was expected to get a part time job at 16 (year 11, october born) and so will the DS’s when they reach 16. Important life skills can be learnt in little part time jobs at that age and it teaches them no job is beneath them.

My DD did 8 months at our friends butchery before applying, interviewing and getting a job at our local cinema where she has been now for just over a year.

sorrelandheather · 24/09/2022 09:58

I work with 16-18 year olds every day. Totally normal for them to have a part time job; in fact, it's good for them. We recommend an a max of 10 hours a week so it doesn't encroach on their studies.

AlbaDT · 24/09/2022 09:56

I have a 15 year old who works 5-10 hours a week and a 13 year old who works one evening after school. I couldn’t afford to give them the money they’ve come to expect for socialising, buying things they’d like if they weren’t earning themselves. It’s about prioritising and there is still plenty of time for them both to study. I worked from the age of 13 and did just fine in all my exams.

vivainsomnia · 24/09/2022 09:52

Both my kids worked at 16. The eldest was desperate to do so. Worked 16h and also volunteered. Managed 3 A grades. Youngest had to be encouraged after GCSEs but then loved it. Worked 16h + during COVID and that kept them safe. Got 2 Bs and 1 A.

Eldest continued to work at Uni doing a very demanding course. Youngest got his job back each time coming home during holiday.

Both learned to save and budget. Confidence soared, made good friends. Learned to organise themselves and spent less time on their phone watching rubbish or playing Xbox.

Winner in every way!

deedledeedledum · 24/09/2022 09:40

So did the outraged person think dc should be studying every spare minute of the day?

Swipe left for the next trending thread