Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Would you leave baby asleep in car ?

212 replies

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 09:53

Whilst you took older child to nursery (takes 3 minutes) ? Car is right outside and locked..

OP posts:
Babyboomtastic · 23/09/2022 12:24

takealettermsjones · 23/09/2022 12:10

Risk of car being stolen - yes, a very tiny risk, but if that happened, its overwhelmingly likely that they baby will be dumped outside in its car seat somewhere...

Oh well that's fine then! 🤣🤯

Risk of someone kidnapping. It's only a small minority of paedophiles that kidnap thankfully...

Again... Why would you ever take that risk? Even if it's a small risk, the impact is devastatingly enormous. I'd wake my baby a thousand times over rather than put them at the smallest risk of something like that happening.

Because you'll drive yourself crazy trying to mitigate against every theoretical risk. Your baby has more risk of being hurt by lightening than stolen from a locked car by a paedophile. Should people keep their babies inside in case of a sudden storm, freak hailstones, cars mounting the pavement etc? A lion escaping from the local zoo?

It's not a real risk.
It's paranoia.

CallMeLinda · 23/09/2022 12:24

In a nursery car park, yes, if I knew I was only going to be max 5 minutes and lots of other parents around.
Public street right outside if no nursery car park, no.

takealettermsjones · 23/09/2022 12:22

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 12:19

@takealettermsjones so you were watching your baby every 4 minutes when asleep ? On baby cam etc ? I don't get this. I put my baby down in peace for a couple of hours. Baby camera on. Has a motion sensor too. So surely I would know if something was wrong ?

Somehow they both seem fine and I've had lots of vomiting / spit up in their cot with no issues.

Yes of course, but you don't have a monitor on when leaving them to go and do nursery drop off? Or maybe you do 🤷🏻‍♀️😆

zaffa · 23/09/2022 12:21

There are no circumstances in which I would have left my baby or my now toddler in a car and walked away from it out of eyesight. If I was parked outside the entrance to the nursery with direct line of sight and possibly touching distance to car I'd consider it. I also won't leave her to go into a shop and pay for petrol under any circumstances. She comes with or I pay at the pump.

I would be worried about someone taking her, the car being hit by another car, the keys getting lost whilst dropping off toddler, my child waking up and being terrified at being alone, something malfunctioning on the car or the hand break not being properly engaged, etc. any number of highly unlikely scenarios that I know are almost never going to happen but don't see the point in taking a risk over just in case we are the unlucky ones.

FWIW I know someone who did this and the school reported it to SS as a safeguarding concern.

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 12:19

@takealettermsjones so you were watching your baby every 4 minutes when asleep ? On baby cam etc ? I don't get this. I put my baby down in peace for a couple of hours. Baby camera on. Has a motion sensor too. So surely I would know if something was wrong ?

Somehow they both seem fine and I've had lots of vomiting / spit up in their cot with no issues.

OP posts:
takealettermsjones · 23/09/2022 12:16

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 12:09

I don't think it's likely my baby will choke to death in 3 minutes in his car seat.

When it happened while I was driving and he choked, he had to wait much longer than 3 minutes before I could pull over safely.

He's asleep upstairs right now, so you're telling everyone I need to be constantly worried he's going to choke to death? NO that's ridiculous and it's a way to give a new mother extreme anxiety. Babies can be left for a few minutes to sleep in peace, in a bed, or in a car seat- without you worrying they'll choke to death.

In the case of a cot, they can be left, god forbid, for their nap time or at night time too. Without you constantly worried they'll choke to death. In their car seat, they should not sleep in it for an extended period of time ( especially not newborns, where 30 minutes is the maximum ). However, it's unlikely that my baby will choke to death in 3 minutes in the car seat. My point is, he may be in the car seat for more than 3 minutes at other times where I can't get to him.

Choking starves the brain of oxygen. Brain damage occurs within four to six minutes. Are you absolutely sure you've got your timings right?

Guidance is that you should only be putting baby in a cot in a separate room after six months old, and then this is precisely what monitors are for.

Topgub · 23/09/2022 12:11

Its also 8 years old.

So no, I don't think ss have the resources to be interested in a complete non event.

1 article from 8 years ago where the verdict was overturned doesn't disprove that

Also, I'm sure there was something to do with the road worthiness of the car.

It wasn't just the toddler being unsupervised in the car

Sianyloo · 23/09/2022 12:11

I personally wouldn’t, and never have for either my 7yr old or our now 7mth old. I’m that person that takes them out when paying for petrol etc every time though. I’d be so conscious of either something happening to them, or as above something happening to me and as a result no one knowing my young baby was left alone in a car on a quiet road. For few seconds inconvenience I’ve never wanted to take the risk…but each to their own.

takealettermsjones · 23/09/2022 12:10

Risk of car being stolen - yes, a very tiny risk, but if that happened, its overwhelmingly likely that they baby will be dumped outside in its car seat somewhere...

Oh well that's fine then! 🤣🤯

Risk of someone kidnapping. It's only a small minority of paedophiles that kidnap thankfully...

Again... Why would you ever take that risk? Even if it's a small risk, the impact is devastatingly enormous. I'd wake my baby a thousand times over rather than put them at the smallest risk of something like that happening.

Mama234567 · 23/09/2022 12:09

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 10:25

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer yes it's true. I don't feel 100 percent about it. But I think all risks around it are very small.

However having seen that most people wouldn't do it, is making me reconsider. Especially the idea that someone could be watching for their chance. So I probably won't do it anymore now.

Glad to see that you're reconsidering OP. Maybe purchase a travel system with a car seat so that you can transfer baby asleep from the car and back again without waking them up?

It also might be worth checking what the actual law is on this subject. I assumed it was illegal and a matter for police/ss but maybe it is a grey area as so many parents leave children in the car at petrol stations? Personally I have always managed to pay at pump but I only drive around my hometown.

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 12:09

I don't think it's likely my baby will choke to death in 3 minutes in his car seat.

When it happened while I was driving and he choked, he had to wait much longer than 3 minutes before I could pull over safely.

He's asleep upstairs right now, so you're telling everyone I need to be constantly worried he's going to choke to death? NO that's ridiculous and it's a way to give a new mother extreme anxiety. Babies can be left for a few minutes to sleep in peace, in a bed, or in a car seat- without you worrying they'll choke to death.

In the case of a cot, they can be left, god forbid, for their nap time or at night time too. Without you constantly worried they'll choke to death. In their car seat, they should not sleep in it for an extended period of time ( especially not newborns, where 30 minutes is the maximum ). However, it's unlikely that my baby will choke to death in 3 minutes in the car seat. My point is, he may be in the car seat for more than 3 minutes at other times where I can't get to him.

OP posts:
SpinningFloppa · 23/09/2022 12:08

Topgub · 23/09/2022 12:05

@SpinningFloppa

1case where the verdict was rightly over turned?

Mmmmm

Doesn’t mean they “won’t be interested” their life was made hell and took ages to clear their name. When it could have all been avoided. Their children was placed on child protection register so yes it might have been “over turned” after months of hell but it’s incorrect to say ss won’t be interested

Xmasbaby11 · 23/09/2022 12:08

I wouldn't do it. I would just take the baby with me in the car seat and they'd probably stay asleep anyway. My dd were 24 months apart so lots of lugging around a baby and toddler. I wouldn't be comfortable leaving a baby out of sight so they got moved when they were sleeping if needed; I never worried about it. I'm also someone who didn't do cot naps so my babies got used to napping out and about. I appreciate not all babies are so flexible and may be upset if woken, I don't know.

Topgub · 23/09/2022 12:05

@SpinningFloppa

1case where the verdict was rightly over turned?

Mmmmm

Babyboomtastic · 23/09/2022 12:01

I wouldn't, but more because society has conditioned me to feel uncomfortable with it, rather than it actually being a risk.

Risk of car being stolen - yes, a very tiny risk, but if that happened, its overwhelmingly likely that they baby will be dumped outside in its car seat somewhere, to be rescued by strangers, rather than coming to harm, or someone throwing it out of the window, as was suggested earlier. Generally the type of lad who nicks cars, has no interest in harm coming to to a baby, and no interest in turning his joyride into a murder or attempted murder charge.

Risk of someone kidnapping. It's only a small minority of paedophiles that kidnap thankfully - its too high risk, even if they want to. So you'd be looking at a small minority of a minority population happening to secretly be in the specific place you do drop off, in case anyone leaves their child around. Think of many Scandinavian countries where babies nap outside shops and cafes in rows, and its not thought of as a risk.

I'd guess (given cases I've heard in the media these last few months) that there are more cases where babies have died by being hit by a car, whilst on a pavement, than in a parked car. Certainly, it's safer to leave them in the car at a petrol station. But then sometime always says 'but what if you get runover and they don't realise there's a baby' failing to realise that if you took the child, both would be run-over 😉

I think it's acceptably safe, but society says no, even though we let our babies take higher risks daily.

MomwasCasual · 23/09/2022 12:01

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 11:06

@Tanith I think they can turn their head generally speaking from when they're born. Little babies spit up/ vomit loads, even in their beds, but are able to turn their heads. That's one of the reasons they should sleep on their back, so they just automatically turn their head when they vomit, on their front they may inhale the vomit from the bed. It's harder for them to turn their head in a car seat. But then you run that risk any time you drive with a baby in the car, they could vomit and choke on it. It's actually happened to my baby and he was OK. Thankfully. But I couldn't do much but pull over in a safe place and help him then.

If this has already happened to you, I'm confused why:

a) You would still consider leaving the baby unattended in the car

and

b) Why you would ask the PP:

Why would the baby choke ? Sorry just wondering, is this something I need to be worrying about at all times ?

🤔

Bookworm20 · 23/09/2022 12:01

For a 3 minute drop off and baby was asleep?
Yes I would leave baby asleep in the car.
Guess I'm a terrible parent judging by the fact I appear to be the only one who would though.

The chances of anything happening, like a car crashing into you, in that 3 minutes is so remote. The car is stationary, parallel parked on a residential street, and locked. And its 3 minutes.

Baby is at far more risk of being in an accident whilst the car is actually being driven.

So upon my basic risk assessment, I wouldn't wake a sleeping baby for the sake of a 3 minute drop off under the circumstances you've described.

Chickpea17 · 23/09/2022 12:00

I would but only if I could see the car.

Tanith · 23/09/2022 11:58

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 11:06

@Tanith I think they can turn their head generally speaking from when they're born. Little babies spit up/ vomit loads, even in their beds, but are able to turn their heads. That's one of the reasons they should sleep on their back, so they just automatically turn their head when they vomit, on their front they may inhale the vomit from the bed. It's harder for them to turn their head in a car seat. But then you run that risk any time you drive with a baby in the car, they could vomit and choke on it. It's actually happened to my baby and he was OK. Thankfully. But I couldn't do much but pull over in a safe place and help him then.

In a car seat, a baby’s movement is restricted, particularly if they’re using a headrest.

You say you have experience of your baby vomiting in a car seat. You stopped the car and helped him.
It’s a good thing you hadn’t left him alone in the car, isn’t it?

Topgub · 23/09/2022 11:57

@YellowTreeHouse

What a load of rubbish

As if ss have the time or inclination to investigate something like that.

🙄

YellowTreeHouse · 23/09/2022 11:55

engalaaand · 23/09/2022 11:43

Great way to waste everyone's time.

No, it wouldn’t be a waste of anyones time.

It shows a lack of sound judgement, so they would be interested in other risks you might think are acceptable to take with your children.

There is a huge chance here that someone sees you do it/knows you have two kids and reports you to SS.

Ariela · 23/09/2022 11:54

No, I would use a ring sling, drop that over your head, hoick baby out into sling, take older child in, then reverse process

caringcarer · 23/09/2022 11:50

I think I'd leave in nursery car park but not on street. As someone said what if something happened to you and no one knew baby in car alone.

StridTheKiller · 23/09/2022 11:47

I wouldn't OP, but neither would i judge you if you did.