Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want my daughter having a tablet

110 replies

lookinguponhim · 23/09/2022 08:23

DD is 4.

She is impeccably well behaved (pure luck), and I just love listening to her playing :) She doesn't constantly bug me to engage with her playing etc. she will happily sit and play with Lego, babies, teddies, dolls house, drawing, etc etc

MIL is upset with me because I don't want her having a tablet.

I'm not against them! But DD doesn't need one? She isn't a constant 'I'm bored' type and I've never felt at a loss with regards to what to do for a quick 10 mins peace and quiet. She just plays

MIL says I am against her all the time, and I should let her have one. She says I'm pushing her out and won't let her buy this for DD, and that she needs one

AIBU to refuse and put my foot down here?

My 8 year old DS is profoundly autistic. I'd give anything for him to have liked his tablet at age 4! Or even now. But he doesn't have the mental capacity to operate one, I really wish he would

So I'm not against them particularly, but I just don't see the point

She watched a few programmes on telly but no need for an actual tablet

OP posts:
BettyBoops · 23/09/2022 16:45

Absolutely YANBU, you are the parent and mil needs to respect your boundaries.
My DD is 5 and very similar in terms of play happily entertains herself for hours with a fantastic imagination. Myself and DH both decided we didn't want DC to have tablets/consoles etc until they are older and she uses my tablet for any school work (numbots reading eggs etc)
My dad wanted to buy her a tablet last year and we said no, he wanted to buy her something 'more than just another toy' so we happily compromised on a kids echo dot so that she can listen to music & stories in her room.
Would a similar compromise work with MIL?

Cakeorchocolate · 23/09/2022 16:40

YANBU.
Absolutely stick to your guns as you feel it's right for your dd at the moment.

I got dd one for her 7th birthday. I regret it. She is obsessed with it.

If she's not on it, she's nagging me for it, constantly. So it's just another job to keep saying no!

We ended up confiscating it for most of the summer. While she did frequently ask me for it back, it wasn't nearly as much as a standard week when she is allowed to use it. I very reluctantly gave it back so she can do homework for school on it. I would have happily left it shut away for a lot longer forever? though!

fruitbrewhaha · 23/09/2022 13:43

I bought my DDs tablets for their 8th birthday.

They had a bit of access to an ipad prior to this but not much.

LettuceJones · 23/09/2022 13:38

It takes minutes to learn how to use an ipad. They don't need to build up to it when they are four like they are learning to play the cello.

If a child doesn't know how to use an ipad or a laptop when they start school, it's completely fine. They will pick it up in no time at all.

Parents who say their dc need to be 'tech savvy' or they will be left behind are often the ones who don't teach them to ride a bike because they have a scooter or tie their shoe laces because they have Velcro shoes.

There are many ways to prepare your child for the world.

Tomorrowisalatterday · 23/09/2022 13:29

Mine do have tablets - but I am under no illusion that it's ideal.

I would second the idea of putting your MIL on the idea of a yoto player though instead. Your daughter sounds like she would love it - they do a lovely interactive daily podcast where they get kids to draw things etc

Snowpaw · 23/09/2022 13:24

Also - kids that age need so much exercise - anything that encourages a child to sit still and motionless is not good. My HV says they need 3 hours of exercise a day. When you add on top of that time for meals / helping with meal prep, bath, play, looking at books etc there shouldn't be much time in the day for anything else.

katenutzs · 23/09/2022 13:10

Stick with your stance on this, My grandaughter did not have one until she was 7 as she was exactly as you describe your DD. Now she can take it or leave it and only ever stays on for less than an hour an not every day.

Cactuslove · 23/09/2022 13:03

This is the only thing I really draw a line on. I think once ypu open that can of worms r.e. tablets and phones it's a done deal. My 4 yr old watches TV, plays with his lego, colours in etc. I just don't want what will inevitably be an addiction to hand held technology to start now at 4 yrs old. He has got a yoto player that he only has at bed time... perhaps your mil could look at that? Plays a kids radio station and reads books that you can buy separately... also has educational podcasts.

notnownorma · 23/09/2022 13:01

Ilostmysocks · 23/09/2022 12:21

You might not have a choice @lookinguponhim

Once they're at primary school they're expected to do Sumdog or Rockstars timetables amongst other educational apps.

We too didn't want to go down the tablet route but had no choice once teachers started naming and shaming those who didn't partake in educational app based homework.

They don't need their own to do that, surely?

BloodAndFire · 23/09/2022 13:00

Ilostmysocks · 23/09/2022 12:21

You might not have a choice @lookinguponhim

Once they're at primary school they're expected to do Sumdog or Rockstars timetables amongst other educational apps.

We too didn't want to go down the tablet route but had no choice once teachers started naming and shaming those who didn't partake in educational app based homework.

You don't need a tablet for those. My kids also had to do TT Rockstars and Sumdog. I either let them use my laptop, or (post covid) one of the old laptops I turned into a Chromebook for home schooling.

There is absolutely no need at all for a child to have their own personal tablet in order to do 20 mins of TT Rockstars or whatever.

notnownorma · 23/09/2022 13:00

Cosycover · 23/09/2022 08:30

I'm surprised she hasn't asked for one yet tbh.

My 5 year old asked aged 3 so she could watch YouTube videos that she watched in nursery.

Blimey. Hope to god you didn't give her one.

MumCanIDoThat · 23/09/2022 12:52

My 6yo doesn't have one and hasn't even asked. He knows that he can use the family tablet but doesn't really ask further than that. I don't see any need for a 4yo to have a tablet.

Snowpaw · 23/09/2022 12:50

Stand your ground OP - I have had a few people gently enquire if my nearly 4 yr old would like a tablet for Christmas etc - always answer no! Like yours, she plays imaginatively very well and for long periods of time. If she's ever clingy or whiney or hard to occupy its usually because she's hungry or tired, and giving her a tablet at those times won't help. Food and rest will!

They will live their adult lives in worlds surrounded by screens. I want to give her a world without them for as long as possible. I think its damaging for young brains to have such instant gratification that tablets provide.

CakeCrumbs44 · 23/09/2022 12:29

It's your decision. I wouldn't be surprised if MIL gets her one for Christmas without consulting you though, and then you'll be the bad guy for not letting her use it.

My 5yo uses an Amazon fire (it's not "hers" though). It has a 30 minute a day timer and she doesn't play it every day, doesn't watch videos on YouTube and is always supervised. I think it's quite good to have technology available with strict limits so they get used to that being the way and (hopefully) don't expect free reign when they get other technology later. But if you don't want her to have one, that's up to you and nobody else

Ilostmysocks · 23/09/2022 12:21

You might not have a choice @lookinguponhim

Once they're at primary school they're expected to do Sumdog or Rockstars timetables amongst other educational apps.

We too didn't want to go down the tablet route but had no choice once teachers started naming and shaming those who didn't partake in educational app based homework.

OperaStation · 23/09/2022 12:21

Absolutely stick to your guns. No child needs a tablet.

Your MIL sounds extremely hard work and doesn’t appear to have any boundaries.

Dacadactyl · 23/09/2022 12:20

Stick to your guns OP. You are 100% right. Keep them away from screens as long as possible.

BloodAndFire · 23/09/2022 12:19

Textboxmm · 23/09/2022 12:06

Tablets don’t prepare kids for a world of tech, they prepare them to be consumers and that’s it.
until they learn to code, which they will in primary school.

I agree 100%. My kids have never had one, they are now 12 and 9 and learning coding in a class (outside school). The idea that a child of 4 (or even, insanely, a baby of 1!) benefits from staring at and swiping a screen is a convenient fiction that suits parents and manufacturers, and does absolutely bollock all to benefit children.

www.nytimes.com/2019/11/04/well/family/screen-use-tied-to-childrens-brain-development.html

Confusion101 · 23/09/2022 12:17

Tech companies have literally designed tablets and apps to be addictive! There's a reason big tech names don't let their children have tablets / phones until teenage years! They know what they've designed and the potential damage of the addictivness.

"oh put you can parent to manage it" yeh until your child is screaming and bawling for hours on end because all they want is the game on the tablet (extreme case of addictivness there obviously but it happens!!).

Yes there are plenty of pros to using one in this ever growing technological world but at age 4 when she is able to entertain herself in other ways defo stick to your guns.

MarshaBradyo · 23/09/2022 12:11

No they don’t I agree. They are entirely intuitive and addictive and created to be that way

op I’d avoid, you’ll probably find in secondary online will feature more with friends but no rush to get used to it early

Textboxmm · 23/09/2022 12:06

Tablets don’t prepare kids for a world of tech, they prepare them to be consumers and that’s it.
until they learn to code, which they will in primary school.

Textboxmm · 23/09/2022 12:05

Too young, she absolutely does NOT need a tablet. If granny wants to be the hero ask her to get your child a Waterstones gift card or Book Token gift card to the same value and then take your DD every other week to choose books, games and art supplies for herself.
that way she’s getting something frequently from granny that she can share with her, talk to her about and that value on a Book Token card will last a year or more easily!

your child will be bombarded with screens at every turn, apps, games, at school all of which will claim to be educational.
bitbif you want a child to read, buy them books and read to them. If you want them to count plays games and puzzles.

Noviembre · 23/09/2022 11:46

MugginsOverEre · 23/09/2022 10:20

She doesn't need one at 4 years old.

Yet.

We must remember that times are changing. Screens and devices are a normal everyday part of life now and it won't change. Just like we won't go back to riding horses and carts instead of cars or playing hoops and sticks instead of Xboxes.

Those rare parents who are vehemently against any form of device and strictly limit screen times are doing their children a disservice. But that's not something you need to think about yet.

Tablets are used by bored parents and toddlers. They are a useless tool for the technically competent. If you want your child to gain technical skill and competence they need to learn how to use real computers, to type, to use a mouse, basic file management, software management and troubleshooting.

Swiping a cartoon tablet isn't making them tech workers of the future. It's making them useless. They cannot type, they can't install software and trying to upskill them is a struggle.

Noviembre · 23/09/2022 11:41

Stand your ground. Mail sounds way too involved and obsessed. It's not her kid.

Yack02 · 23/09/2022 11:33

I wish my child had been so good at independent play. If he had been I would have held off the iPad for WAY longer.

Your MIL is an idiot. Firstly who does she think she is undermining you? Secondly you have the holy grail of a child that will entertain themselves without nagging for constant interaction. Long may that continue I say!