Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

I don't want my daughter having a tablet

110 replies

lookinguponhim · 23/09/2022 08:23

DD is 4.

She is impeccably well behaved (pure luck), and I just love listening to her playing :) She doesn't constantly bug me to engage with her playing etc. she will happily sit and play with Lego, babies, teddies, dolls house, drawing, etc etc

MIL is upset with me because I don't want her having a tablet.

I'm not against them! But DD doesn't need one? She isn't a constant 'I'm bored' type and I've never felt at a loss with regards to what to do for a quick 10 mins peace and quiet. She just plays

MIL says I am against her all the time, and I should let her have one. She says I'm pushing her out and won't let her buy this for DD, and that she needs one

AIBU to refuse and put my foot down here?

My 8 year old DS is profoundly autistic. I'd give anything for him to have liked his tablet at age 4! Or even now. But he doesn't have the mental capacity to operate one, I really wish he would

So I'm not against them particularly, but I just don't see the point

She watched a few programmes on telly but no need for an actual tablet

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
ChrisTrepidation · 26/09/2022 21:51

Stand firm. She's your daughter and you call the shots.

I have 4 year old twins and they don't have tablets. I would feel exactly the same as you.

OnTheBrinkOfChange · 26/09/2022 21:48

I agree with you. I wouldn't let her either.

Thistleinthenight · 26/09/2022 21:46

I don't join anti MiL threads, but really, stop listening to the opinions of others on your parenting decisions. Especially opinions from people with a vested interest of this sort. She had her turn. Now it's yours. And my children are all adults, too.

LuckyLil · 26/09/2022 21:38

Don't let her bully you. It's your child and your decision.

user9825401 · 26/09/2022 21:33

@Sarahcoggles it was a gift.

user9825401 · 26/09/2022 21:33

@BloodAndFire yes she was 1 when she got it.

@TooMuchToDoTooLittleInclination she's not overly interested and much prefers playing. My 11 year old was more interested in his when he was 2, now he likes to chill out with it at the weekend if he's not got plans. Not obsessed with it at all.

WeightoftheWorld · 24/09/2022 19:00

YANBU, as pretty much everyone has said.

My eldest is 4. We have an old tablet that DH got for free a few years ago (long story). The only time it ever gets used is not DD during car journeys that are longer than say 45 mins or so. Which is usually only a few times a year for holidays. She asks for it for travel but never at any other time, she knows she wouldn't be given it. I find it useful for in the car especially for the past year since we had DC2 so I cant sit in the back with her anymore. However absolutely no way would I let her have her own device and/or use it more regularly. Actually I think we took it to a hospital appointment recently too - I had to talk about her to the consultant and it was sensitive topic and I didn't want her listening really so got her to colour on the tablet to divert her attention. So in limited circumstances I'm glad to have the option but they are rare.

ginexplorer · 24/09/2022 13:57

Having seen the impact of giving children a tablet or mobile phone first hand ( and I did this in Year 7) I’d say in hindsight that all screens and phones should be banned until 18 like cigarettes and alcohol.

it sounds extreme and I completely get that a lot of the secondary school work now happens on a chrome book ( which is fine if configured for school use only) but I think the addiction to screens and negatives in terms of where they lead and long term damage they cause outweighs the benefits.

At 4 years old I’m shocked to be honest you are even having to debate this topic. Trust your instincts here - you already know it’s not right for your child. You don’t need mumsnet to tell you. Your MIL is absolutely mad.

AuldReekie1905 · 23/09/2022 19:08

You're the parent, you choose. Mil needs to back off.

catandcoffee · 23/09/2022 18:00

She needs to respect your decision.
Do not give in to her wishes. I can't even understand her reasoning....🤔

WindyKnickers · 23/09/2022 17:56

My DS had a kindle fire age 3 and still uses it now at 7. Tbh because he can use it whenever he wants (within reason) the novelty has worn off and now it's hardly used. He uses it for school apps a couple of times a week and the occasional game but he'd always rather be outside riding his bike. Sometimes having too many restrictions or rules can encourage kids to try and push the boundaries. Just like the kids that aren't allowed sweets who turn into obese teens.

That said, your kid, your choice.

FixItUpChappie · 23/09/2022 17:38

Personally I think parents have en mass lost their minds with tablets and other tech for their kids.
For example my sons good friend (9yrs old) now won’t talk to him or sit with him on the bus because he is busy playing video games on his tablet and doesn’t want to be bothered by talking. What what kind of generation are we raising that can’t even sit on a bus and look out the fucking window and maybe chat with their buddies to entertain themselves 🤷‍♀️

You see it everywhere - toddlers with their faces buried in their parents phones. I honestly think it’s a weird unnecessary social experiment. And as if your kids going to be a genius computer programmer because you let them play video games from age 1yr onwards in all social settings 🙄

BeanieTeen · 23/09/2022 17:36

She’s free to buy one, you don’t have to use it - you’ve made your feelings known, if she chooses to waste her money let her go ahead.

vicky46 · 23/09/2022 17:32

First of all, your daughter, your choice. So you are absolutely not being unreasonable. I will say, my daughter had one (hand me down iPad) from about 3years old. She never pestered for it, it was me who would take it with us here and there if I thought she would be bored if we were out. She never really ever asked for it. The iPad was lost (my fault, at a hotel and must have overlooked it) several months ago now, she’s never asked for it and had never asked for a new one. I was really anal about what went on it and went through l the apps, keeping and deleting as I found appropriate. She also had Disney+ and Netflix etc on there for films.
I guess what I’m saying is, they don’t have to be addictive or bad for them if that’s your main concern. But I totally am with it being your decision as her parent x

Spellcheck · 23/09/2022 17:25

Stand your ground - you’re her mum, you make the rules. You don’t have to justify anything to anyone!

JustABloodyMinute · 23/09/2022 17:09

Hold off as long as you can. We were forced into it during lockdown when primary school published all the work they expected them to complete on apps. Unfortunately they now do the same with homework.

GreenManalishi · 23/09/2022 17:06

If you don't want your 4 year old daughter to have a tablet, your daughter does not have a tablet. That's the end of the line.

No matter how pushed out, upset your MIL feels. No matter how many hissy fits she throws, or how much she claims that you are against her. In fact, the more unreasonable she is, the less notice you need to take of her.

Coybubbles · 23/09/2022 17:04

I think you’re being judgy and precious. As a parent it would be up to you how often if at all the gift was used.

My dd had access to some apps on my phone age 1 (shock horror) and a tablet aged 2. She’s not a lazy screen addict and is doing very well in school, takes part in various activities and has loads of friends. I think balanced parenting is good where kids can have access to everything in moderation…..

I would choose your battles wisely with your mil. When it comes to big ticket items like a cot etc you should absolutely be the one to choose, but equally I would try not to come across as the typical sanctimonious precious dil…again balance in all things is useful for family relations!

AgathaMystery · 23/09/2022 16:57

Stand firm. No tablets here and DC are 10

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/09/2022 16:55

JSDLS · 23/09/2022 16:53

It sounds like your little girl is also autistic, mine is too. She has a tablet (she’s 3yo) but doesn’t beg for screen time and she has lots of other activities she like to do too.

What makes you think her daughter is autistic?

broughton100 · 23/09/2022 16:54

Children don't need a tablet. They benefit far more from playing. I understand that parents resort to them for car journeys etc or when they need some uninterrupted time but if that is not you then stick to your guns. The yoto idea is a good one. You can record stories to be listened to.there are also podcasts to listen too.I agree with the idea of asking MIL to get one of those and some good picture books to go with it so daughter can listen and look at the same time. There will come a time when she will need to be computer literate but there is no rush. As for teachers naming and shaming children who don't do homework! Homework at primary level is voluntary surely. You can't assume all children have access to tablets etc and the Internet or opportunities to use them either.

MissHavishamsMouldyOldCake · 23/09/2022 16:53

No way would I give a 4 year old a tablet. Boo hoo to MIL if this upsets her.

JSDLS · 23/09/2022 16:53

It sounds like your little girl is also autistic, mine is too. She has a tablet (she’s 3yo) but doesn’t beg for screen time and she has lots of other activities she like to do too.

RobertNotBob · 23/09/2022 16:47

It's simple - your children, your rules. I love being a grandad, but it's not about what I want my grandchildren to have, it's for their parents to decide and for me to put my hand in my pocket as appropriate.
Stick to your guns

Mrscooper13 · 23/09/2022 16:47

my MIL bought both my 6yr old and 3yr old with out telling me and then I had to be a baddy for saying she had to take it back.

we have one and they can have limited time on it in the week but why else do they need one each.

I don’t understand why some MIL a want to have this power of being better. There’s plenty of other ways to give them great gifts.

Stick to your guns they will soon be moaning how quick they grow up