Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to feel hurt at lack of birthday effort?

60 replies

totallyimperfect · 23/09/2022 06:31

I’ll start by saying I did say to DH that I didn’t want him spending money on me (actually genuinely didn’t as like everyone it’s a bit tight at mo) but that he could maybe take a few bits of jewellery that I’ve had sitting in a drawer for ages and can’t wear with broken clasps etc to go get fixed?
I have 2 daughters, one a teenager and have always emphasised effort over cost on gifts, as like most mums I go to loads of effort so things are nice and everyone feels special on their birthday.
I was away for work for 2 days and finished early to get back to pick up youngest daughter from school and came home to some supermarket flowers and chocolates from DDs (I know this supermarket dash was a last minute thing) youngest did a picture of me which was my best present, husband gave me a card.
we had open evening at a school so spent the evening wandering round classrooms and then came home to eat ready made food, that I picked up from service station on way back from work.
I did tell my eldest I feel a bit sad at lack of effort and then felt awful for saying anything at all?
I did ask for low key birthday AIBU to feel sad for rubbish low effort birthday?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
candycaneframe · 26/09/2022 13:50

YANBU

I can never understand how people tolerate partners who make so little effort, as these posts are sadly not uncommon on MN.

Sunshinebug · 26/09/2022 13:47

I suspect you make lots of effort and then are always disappointed if others don’t do the same. Effort shouldn’t be based on reciprocation. That said, they could have done things easily to make you feel better here - perhaps next time be clearer instead of expecting them to do what you’d do, and simply suggest they cook/arrange the food.

PutinSmellsPassItOn · 23/09/2022 15:27

The problem with being a martyr is it eventually comes round to bite said martyrs on the backside......your husband did as you asked with a token gift thrown in for good measure. So don't complain about it.

C152 · 23/09/2022 15:10

YANBU to feel disappointed that they didn't make more of an effort...but I think you need to start asking for exactly what you want and not doing what many of us do and downplaying our own needs. You clearly do want some effort to be made, so say that next time.

Tuppy2 · 23/09/2022 14:53

Men usually do want to make us happy but are often a bit crap. I have found that thanking my husband for a shit meal he's cooked, crappy flowers etc and saying how special it has made me feel (as genuinely as possible) organically makes him up his game and he puts more effort into pleasing me. So before your next birthday say how he always spoils you and puts lots of effort into thinking about you and see what happens!

EatingWormsMichael · 23/09/2022 14:49

This is so common isn't it? Mothers and wives become the birthday organisers and it rarely gets reciprocated.

Unfortunately you need to give am indication of expectations eg "I'll leave it to you to book a restaurant for my birthday" - be lovely if we didn't have to but we do.

When I was a kid I had no idea what to buy my mum and thought supermarket flowers were special cos they weren't often in the house. So I'd be OK with the effort, but obvs you know her best!

singingintheshower · 23/09/2022 14:26

Was it a special birthday OP? I plan my own birthdays now so that way I get the birthday I actually want! I often arrange a weekend away with my friends/sister etc or brunch with local friends etc. I send links to things I might like DH to buy me & something small kids could get me etc. if I didn't I would just get flowers & choc which is fine but boring. I'm not really into flowers - they die & smell & drop petals everywhere & I end up cleaning it up anyway. This year myself & DH both agreed we would do our 'normal' things on birthdays as they were mid week & DD had 3 A Level exams the same week as my birthday anyway. I went to my HIIT class on my birthday (Wed night) & 5 weeks later my DH did his footy training on his birthday. We did something nice together with the kids on the nearest weekend etc. I went to cinema during the day with a friend as I'm a SAHM on my birthday. We've been together 27 years so I've learned not to expect grand romantic gestures from DH 🤣 We don't spend a lot on gifts for each other - usually just books etc. My DH is great at most things but doesn't see why birthdays are so important (unless you're a child etc). I've had disappointing ones before so now I plan my own 👏

Icantthinkof1 · 23/09/2022 14:17

There is a difference between no spend and no effort.
Cooking her favourite meal, giving a massage etc are low cost/free but would have shown that they cared.

latetothefisting · 23/09/2022 12:47

YABU to moan at your daughter (who is a child with limited money and means of getting presents), and not your husband, who is the adult.

YABU to specifically tell your family you wanted a low key birthday and then complain when you got a low key birthday
YABU to tell your husband not to spend money on you but then ask him to get jewellery clasps mended - nowhere will do that for free, and if you've got several broken pieces it could cost quite a lot!

Basically YABU to expect your family to be mind readers, and not only guess what you want without you telling them, but to second guess that what you've told them isn't what you actually want.

Next time TELL THEM 'I don't want anything expensive for my birthday but do want some presents, ideally with some thought to go into it, for example chocolates/flowers are fine but make sure they are ones I like. A thoughtful message written in a card is lovely. Can someone else plan/make tea and buy a cake.'

EmeraldSpo · 23/09/2022 12:27

@ChristmasFluff are we siblings? 😅

ChristmasFluff · 23/09/2022 12:25

My mother used to do this 'oh, don't spend money on me for my birthday!' It was a horrific double-bind - if you didn't pull out all the stops, she would have a mardy. If you did, she'd moan about the price of every little thing. If you made her something, she'd shove it in a drawer, never to be seen again. If you tried to cook she'd be breathing down you neck and then throw you out of the kitchen.

I'm probably over-sensitive to the smell of burning martyr because of this (not just this, she was a fucking nightmare in general), but the way you didn't address this with your husband and only your daughter also got me feeling like I've been in her shoes.

JulieMarooley · 23/09/2022 12:25

To be fair, taking jewellery to get fixed is the kind of daunting horrendous task I put off for years/decades/forever.

It needs online research, then potentially going somewhere during working hours, or on a precious Saturday, twice!

It would have been amazing but I don’t blame him.

EmeraldSpo · 23/09/2022 12:25

Sorry OP YABU. When I was 16 I had a part-time job working for my dad and made essentially pocket money. I went to Tesco with about £6 and bought my mum a card and chocolates using up all I had left as her birthday gift.

A few days after her birthday we had an argument about something unrelated and she told me she knew I'd bought her a Tesco value birthday card and berated me for not caring enough about her.

Now as an adult her birthday is a constant source of anxiety for me as I feel that no matter what I do it won't be good enough and end up leaving myself skint to not disappoint her.

It was wrong to make this your teenage daughters problem

MumCanIDoThat · 23/09/2022 12:22

myleftventricle · 23/09/2022 12:17

Anyone who doesn't play stupid mind games or who prefers to be honest in their relationships.

Exactly. Op yabvu, if you wanted a bit of fuss then say it. stop playing these games with your family, it's awful and manipulative because you are setting them up to fail. I like a fuss on my birthday, so that's what I get. I Don't play the martyr running around everyone else and then sit and play mind games. You got what you asked for and that's on you.

myleftventricle · 23/09/2022 12:17

daisyjgrey · 23/09/2022 12:14

Who in their right mind, when told by someone "I don't want a fuss for my birthday", believes them?

Anyone who doesn't play stupid mind games or who prefers to be honest in their relationships.

myleftventricle · 23/09/2022 12:16

You said don't spend anything and the only thing you did mention was getting some old jewellery fixed which doesn't exactly scream birthday. Just because you make an effort doesn't mean they're going to know you want the same when you have said don't spend anything. Just be clear in future - don't spend money please do get the jewellery fixed for my birthday as that would be an inexpensive but much appreciated gift, please also arrange dinner and if the kids think about getting chocolates then I like x chocolates and not y. It's not difficult. If people actually said what they wanted and didn't expect people to guess then the world would be a better and happier place.

daisyjgrey · 23/09/2022 12:14

Who in their right mind, when told by someone "I don't want a fuss for my birthday", believes them?

Dixiechickonhols · 23/09/2022 12:10

I find I have to be quite specific - I’d have made it clear cake was an essential.

hopeishere · 23/09/2022 12:06

I've given up expecting reciprocal birthdays. I now make it clear what I want in terms of food (restaurant or a take away) and present. It saves grief all round.

totallyimperfect · 23/09/2022 12:03

😂 true

OP posts:
totallyimperfect · 23/09/2022 12:01

I did actually suggest this too him as a nice thing to do for my birthday

OP posts:
Marvellousmadness · 23/09/2022 10:12

You are being not only unreasonable but also being rediculous.

You can't say A
And then expect B

id you feel like shit
You did it to yourself

Id you want effort
Tell Him what you want
Dont let him guess
And never tell a man that you dont want anything (or for him not to spend money on you)as they will do EXACTLY as you asked

JamesBondOO7 · 23/09/2022 09:41

You got what you wanted so stop being a silly billy.
By all accounts you have a great DH

I feel like you every year bang on about wanting nothing not even a card then sulk when it happens. My family call my "grumpy" in private.

80sMum · 23/09/2022 09:37

RedHelenB · 23/09/2022 06:39

Yabu. If you wanted a fuss then you should have said so.

This! I think if you want everyone to make a big fuss about your birthday, you'll have to spell it out and tell them exactly what it is that you want them to do. Otherwise, they will simply do whatever they think is appropriate.

mamabear715 · 23/09/2022 09:27

Belated Happy Birthday, @totallyimperfect
(Start planning your next one now.. I suggest printed-out pics of what you fancy, stuck all over the house..) ;-) xx

Swipe left for the next trending thread