Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
theemmadilemma · 23/09/2022 11:57

I've been wfh since 2018 at which time the company I work for was already issuing laptops/headsets with a view to equiping people to work from home, and slowly closing smaller (aquired) offices and allowing remote working.

My whole team has been remote since 2019 and I've noticed no real difference in productivity from those I worked in an office with previously. My offshore team is obviously different, but I can tell if they are productive or not easily enough from various system checks.

Over the past few years I would think we've moved to a nearly 70% wfh model globally, and other than keeping central offices open in major cities, the vast majority of staff now work remotely.

It did become difficult in Covid lockdown with DH starting to WFH as well, and not enough space for two offices. The person in the living area was constantly intruded on in reality, and long term I don't think it's productive to not have a completely seperate living/working area.

We have since moved and both have our own office where we wfh, some days I won't see DH from am to until he finishes for the day. It works well for everyone I know.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/09/2022 11:49

@Icanstillrecallourlastsummer I think that's part of the issue- I've had calls with TV on in background, kids coming up to the parent, dogs barking etc- I appreciate that's life but it's not ideal for either worker or customer and gives a poor impression too

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 23/09/2022 11:45

Many, although of course not all, people who provide call centre services from home are not paid loads and often don't have a proper working space and facilities. These things are important for WFH. You can't just expect employees to set up on their sofa and be productive.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/09/2022 11:40

It works well for some, not so well for others , depends on job and domestic situation and to be honest the personality and work ethic too and how much you like your job and value it. To be honest I've noticed that anything that involves call centre type activity, the service is pretty dire, but I don't know if this is the individuals slacking off or a lack of staff post Brexit and covid

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 11:38

MossGrowsFat · 23/09/2022 08:58

Not at all. I work with students entering the work place, the only ones WFH works for are those that are already privileged and able.

Firstly privileged as they need a quiet room, decent broadband, able because they need to be at a certain academic level to cope with the remoteness and extra skills that WFH require, the lack of direct support and building of relationship.

WFH will alienate a large proportion of the workforce, whilst some employers manage to be successful it requires time money and investment, something which most employers are not doing.

You mention people who are not NT, whilst there are benefits these people often need extra support put in place, when they are WFH it is easy to miss the adjustments they need.

You say not at all, but then you completely ignore the examples I mentioned of young people who were and would be excluded from jobs requiring traditional workplace attendance models due to caring responsibilities and geographical location, who aren't now. Clearly neither of these particular limitations are a privilege, and they don't become less potentially exclusionary because there exist people who have housing in more expensive areas but not broadband, for example.

Essentially what you are saying is the same point as mine. That different models work for different people, and that it's ridiculous to generalise that all people at a certain stage are better off with one model.

I take your point about adjustments, but the fact remains that some types of neurodiversity, disability and health condition will in themselves prevent those experiencing them from being able to work at all in jobs that require the work to be done in a specific location. Those of you talking up the advantages of workplace attendance for some young people need to acknowledge that cohort too.

JassyRadlett · 23/09/2022 11:35

I don't understand why those same companies find it so difficult to set reasonable targets for whatever the work is and then talk to employees if they're not met. WFH doesn't change that basic practice. But I guess it's easier to moan on the radio.

Yep. Companies moaning because employees don't want to be micromanaged remotely are announcing they have really shit management and value presenteeism over productivity and results.

Honestly - if my team are meeting (high and usually stretching) targets and expectations, both in terms of outputs and behaviours, I don't give a shit if they're sitting in front of their laptop for every minute of the day or not, or whether they've nipped out for a run or whatever.

If they're delivering what is expected of them, and those expectations are appropriate for what the organisation needs to meet its goals, then more power to them if they can tie it all up faster and go for a run or whatever.

kc431 · 23/09/2022 11:33

Fupoffyagrasshole · 23/09/2022 11:31

Complete nonsense!! I find the office difficult as people keep coming up to me asking me for stuff and can i do this that the other and then I'm just sitting there doing bits of this and that and struggling to complete things.

At home I get so much more done as i focus on things no distraction at all have my music on and I'm so much more productive tbh!!

But those people asking you questions are probably junior and exactly the ones struggling at home as they’re stuck and can’t get hold of anyone. Your “distracted” is their “essential help”. As a junior this is one of many reasons I hate WFH - people I want to ask questions have Teams on busy/do not disturb all day, and I sit there stuck on tasks unable to ask for help. In the office I can ask in 2 minutes and get way more done.

DeepDown12 · 23/09/2022 11:33

My department is WFH (we do offer office space for those who'd rather do that - even pay co-working spaces for those who moved away but vast majority WFH fully). Our productivity increased a lot since this was introduced. As someone mentioned before - employees do a lot of international calls across several time-zones and this way they're happy to take a call at 6am and then another at 8pm but make a big break in the middle or do whatever suits them. We don't take notice when they logged in/out. I genuinely don't care and wouldn't blink if someone watched an entire movie during regular working hours provided they are still delivering what we need them to on time.

Noviembre · 23/09/2022 11:33

Our entire organisation is Pan-European and we have never had an office. Everyone's in different countries. We were WFH before the pandemic.

No problems with productivity here. But then it's a very skilled, desirable role and people work hard, take pride in it and don't take the piss.

Dutch1e · 23/09/2022 11:31

Maymaymay · 23/09/2022 10:02

I'm sure people who are ambitious are doing a great job, unfortunately not everyone is.

I've seen threads on here with tips on how to look like you are working (mouse on mirror, gadgets brought from amazon) when you are napping and not working.

Companies aren't running properly on ground level. My friend works in insurance and does everything she can to not answer the phone.

It now takes 21 days to hear back from my local council as noone is on the phone, it took 3 months to get registered with my energy company. Their phone lines still blame covid.

It's not working.

I agree, although there must be some responsibility laid at the feet of the people who (still) think you can just replicate an office or classroom environment by plonking it online.

Fully remote businesses and schools have very different processes and procedures.... we Home Ed and I work fully remotely so when the lockdowns first began I honestly thought that homeschooling groups and fully remote companies would be swamped with requests for advice on how to make this work. Not a peep.

QOD · 23/09/2022 11:31

I hate it
boring and lonely, i have no flexibility as have to work certain hours

staff turnover is now MASSIVE as new starters are given all the spiel about "huntlines" and asking questions on teams but the reality is that no one answers super quick and they are left panicked and dangling.
I also genuinely worry about the youngsters who face a life of wfh in their bedroom, not meeting real people and forming friendships with people in the canteen or by the water cooler etc
combination yes, permanent forced on you, no

Fupoffyagrasshole · 23/09/2022 11:31

Complete nonsense!! I find the office difficult as people keep coming up to me asking me for stuff and can i do this that the other and then I'm just sitting there doing bits of this and that and struggling to complete things.

At home I get so much more done as i focus on things no distraction at all have my music on and I'm so much more productive tbh!!

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 23/09/2022 11:25

urgen · 23/09/2022 11:24

Many people do say that they can put a wash on, pick up the children, even give them their tea and then make up the hours. I am convinced they dont do this. When you are client facing for example it is no good being available at 1900 when everyone has gone home.

You are convinced wrong then.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 23/09/2022 11:24

foliageeverywhere · 23/09/2022 11:22

Snap - going into work are definitely days I slack off, as otherwise you're being aggressively antisocial (and rude to anyone junior who wants to ask a "quick" question)

me too. Well not quite slacking off, but I never plan to expect to do concentration type work (I'm a lawyer, so do quite a bit of it) when I go into the office, I treat it purely as a chance to see people and do the relationship building/ socialising aspects you tend to do f2f, and meetings. I do tend to get quite a bit done on the train though - no internet and therefore no incoming emails is great for concentration!

urgen · 23/09/2022 11:24

Many people do say that they can put a wash on, pick up the children, even give them their tea and then make up the hours. I am convinced they dont do this. When you are client facing for example it is no good being available at 1900 when everyone has gone home.

foliageeverywhere · 23/09/2022 11:22

ShandaLear · 23/09/2022 11:10

I’m an academic and work from home except when I’m teaching or having a face to face meetings. I work best - marking, research, preparing lectures - in a quiet space free from interruption (my home office) and go into work when I fancy a chat or catch-up. Definitely less work gets done then, though I suppose you could call it team building!

Snap - going into work are definitely days I slack off, as otherwise you're being aggressively antisocial (and rude to anyone junior who wants to ask a "quick" question)

DillDanding · 23/09/2022 11:20

I get twice as much done when I wfh and do a far longer day.

if I go into the office I waste so much time chatting and mooching around the shops.

mewkins · 23/09/2022 11:20

Wherearemymarbles · 23/09/2022 10:59

I wfh 1 day a week often on Friday. The nature of my job allows me to arrange my week and morning so that basically from lunch onwards i am monitoring emails only. If something comes up then i work.

i think biggest problem with wfh is the temptation that if you finish a piece of work at 4pm then its job done, down tools. Whereas as if you’re in the office then you find something else to do.

Or just faff about on the Internet watching the clock til home time😂

MrKlaw · 23/09/2022 11:19

no it hasn't. If your work isn't suited it may be difficult for you to understand for those that it is suited to.

Also I find the hypocrisy from companies frustrating.

If we want to wfh for less commuting time/cost, better work/life balance - we're called lazy.

before Covid, when companies were asking us to hotdesk because they didn't want to move to bigger premises, or they specifically rented smaller premises - thats 'efficient'.

Before covid, companies would hire india/china/eastern europe based staff to keep employee costs down and we'd have remote teams mixed up across time zones and have to handle that - that is 'efficient' so even if we were all in the office, we'd still not all be in the same office.

they want their cake and eat it. Too bad.

Dutch1e · 23/09/2022 11:19

I've been fully remote for almost 15 years so I'm not sure WFH has "had it's day."

I think it's fair to say that, post-Covid, people have a better understanding of their preferred working style and are gravitating towards companies who offer it.

I've noticed that WFH skivers are less able to fluff around the office distracting those of us who like to get things done. They're easier to mute on Slack than in person.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 23/09/2022 11:13

Explaintome · 23/09/2022 11:07

I worry for the future where wfh is so prevalent.

People insisting that they'respnlich more productive because of fewer distractions don't understand that those distractions are valuable to te overall development of the business. All the tines you interrupted a colleague to ask for help weren't important.

It's good for people well establishing in careers who don't want to get involved in developing the next generation IMO.

I also think that whilst some people may be more productive at home, the majority aren't.

SOme of them are valuable. Some are really not. Plus, there are ways to keep the benefits if people just adapt to different means of communications.

I do think that some face to face is good. I try make it into an office at least once a month to keep relationships going. Maintaining relationships can be tricky if you never see people in person. That said, I work for a global company, most of the people I work with are abroad. I still try to see him in person from time to time, but if anyhting it's strengthened by relationships with them as we, as a company, have become a lot better at communicating virtually.

Starfreeze · 23/09/2022 11:13

I am much less productive working at home. And lonely. I don’t like it. It’s normal for me to speak to no one in my working week. I lose concentration easily. Two or three days a week in the office would suit me.

ShandaLear · 23/09/2022 11:10

I’m an academic and work from home except when I’m teaching or having a face to face meetings. I work best - marking, research, preparing lectures - in a quiet space free from interruption (my home office) and go into work when I fancy a chat or catch-up. Definitely less work gets done then, though I suppose you could call it team building!

JassyRadlett · 23/09/2022 11:08

Hybrid is nice if you live locally and don't mind popping in for a few days a week, but if you live quite far away (which I do), and have your own working space all set up at home (which I do), then 3 days of office work is so unbelievably disruptive. Plus, with everyone coming in on different days, there's never a full turnout for in-person meetings anyway.

I disagree - it's obviously a personal thing though. My commute is over an hour each way.

Crucially though we have a core day for the team to be in the office and don't allow any online meetings (except with other parts of the team who are in other offices) on that day so we can maximise face to face collaboration. Hybrid as an unmanaged free for all is quite fraught I think.

kc431 · 23/09/2022 11:08

I personally love working with other people and enjoy the “buzz” of the office. The introverts are more vocal on social media about how much they hate their colleagues. If I hated my colleagues I’d find another job, to me it’s important that I like and get on with them. TBH I’d have picked a more sociable job like doctor or teacher but they all seem to involve long hours/abuse from the general public/rubbish pay.