Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
JennyForeigner · 25/09/2022 08:13

I couldn't work under any other model. We have three very young children childcare mostly at home and a home office. My husband struggles with wfh in a role where it is entirely his choice - so is in the office most days. Lastly, we live in a regional city where we have childcare and a large enough house. I didn't think I would be able to work for London-based employers again (which is about it, in my field). And here we are.

It is an absolute gift. I would be on the list of mums whose career came to a premature end without wfh. And with costs rising the way they are, we would be on our uppers.

Imho that's that this useless government are doing - tanking the economy but taking from the tiny margins people have secured by wfh.

wohmum · 25/09/2022 08:00

mondaytosunday · 23/09/2022 06:53

I think wfh suits those of a certain experience and life stage - possibly those who are already coupled up or have kids and/or are established in their field.
It may not suit those just starting out in the field of work.
When I started out, work was my social life too. Fresh out of university, new to the city, if I was stuck at home staring at a computer I would have been miserable and would not have learned anything. I would not have learned HOW to work. I wouldn't have made friends, I wouldn't have learned how the office structure works. I would not have seen how other departments operate and recognise my next job move. I would have missed so many opportunities. I would have hated it.
Now I am decades older, have a family and do not depend on work in the same way. A hybrid system would be great.

This definitely

wohmum · 25/09/2022 07:56

This

user7845209 · 25/09/2022 05:34

It's fine if you have separate office space but its not really on for workers that serve the public or do sensitive work to work where there are others present that are not involved with the company so a separate office room should really be mandatory for those sort of workers. We have two spare rooms which had to be converted to office space for WFH during the pandemic and even then I could still hear DH through the door. We are both retired now so fortunately it is not an issue and we have our rooms back.

SofaLola33 · 25/09/2022 05:34

WFH doesn’t work for me! During the pandemic I worked with an industry that was classed as a ‘key‘workplace, so though technically my role wasn’t, I took advantage of the loophole and would go in the office frequently.

At home I do not have an office and very easily distracted. I also missed interaction with colleagues and the wider work force.

I also have a teenager, even though he is very self sufficient, would fight for my attention because I was home.

Though I was glad to be home with him through the pandemic, I don’t think it is realistic to WFH with children and for it to be used as an alternative to childcare.

I work from an office now and love it but they are really good that If I need to work from home for any reason, they are happy for us too!

madasawethen · 25/09/2022 04:44

SpangledShambles · 25/09/2022 00:04

Due to existing society dynamics, wfh is a feminist issue along with all the other factors. We can finally hope to maintain careers and compete for seniority as well as having kids and spending a healthy amount of time with them. This is also a good thing for male parents as they have traditionally been sucked into commute and work without as much time with kids. This may be a traditional representation but it is also a fact. So wfh could help modernise and revolutionise life for everyone. No wonder the old guard don’t like it. It’s something worth fighting for now we have the technology to support it.

Exactly this. It is a feminist issue. We're in the midst of a digital revolution.

madasawethen · 25/09/2022 04:41

Bebethany · 24/09/2022 20:30

I could easily work remotely buy my line manager and senior lead won’t allow me to. They both WFH and I get really resentful when I hear, ‘oh I had the boiler serviced yesterday’ and ‘oh I’ve got to take the dog to the vet’ and ‘oh I’ve got a delivery coming, so got to be indoors’… I have to book annual leave for all these tasks.

Have they given a legit reason why you can't?

If there are others there who also would like to WFH, you could as a collective formally make a case for it to senior management in writing, as high up as you have to go to get the real decision makers.

madasawethen · 25/09/2022 04:37

ShootingForTheMoonLandingOnMyArse · 25/09/2022 00:49

I wouldn’t have been able to get back into work after 15 years as a SAHM if WFH wasn’t a thing. I used to be so envious of senior staff saying they were WFH in the 90’s and early 00’s when I had a long commute into London, small DC in nursery miles away and loads to do in the evening. As horrible as COVID’s impact has been, that it’s opened this way of working up as a norm is absolutely amazing IMO. There’s no way it would have happened otherwise.

I went back to work 4 days a week last year in a fully WFH job. We have been asked to go into the office for a team lunch once a month from next month which is nice to meet up.

I have a disabled adult son who would never get up and go to appointments if I wasn’t here, probably burn the house down as he can’t be left alone too long and my 12 year old was recently diagnosed with a life threatening chronic condition so I need to be able to pick him up from school and be around when he’s home, he’s had to take quite a bit of time off school so I’m here for sick days, will need to go to medical appointments which I can work round by working later on the evenings etc. No way could I cope with an in office job.

WFH had been a godsend for me and I am very productive, much more than my full time colleague who had no DC but has dogs who she constantly needs to see to, all you can hear on calls is the bloody things barking in the background, and then constantly calls me about stupid stuff which she should be able to do herself as she’s been there longer than me! At least I can ignore her calls. I dread to think what it’d be like working in an office with her.

I have a table in the corner of the dining room with a laptop and two monitors on it so plenty of workspace, can drop youngest at school, put a wash on, hoover through, cook myself breakfast and then log on after I’ve tidied the kitchen. I walk to Tesco (5 mins away) to get stuff in for dinner at lunchtime so no rushing about or cleaning after work. No travel costs or expensive lunches, started to make my own soup. I love it!

I just want to say how much I love your post. I've saved it.

Situations like this are one reason why my company has always been remote WFH.

Dibbydoos · 25/09/2022 01:28

Hi OP, I agree it doesn't work for everyone or every job.

I love it but I also need to go to an office of location every so often cos I miss seeing people.

ShootingForTheMoonLandingOnMyArse · 25/09/2022 00:49

I wouldn’t have been able to get back into work after 15 years as a SAHM if WFH wasn’t a thing. I used to be so envious of senior staff saying they were WFH in the 90’s and early 00’s when I had a long commute into London, small DC in nursery miles away and loads to do in the evening. As horrible as COVID’s impact has been, that it’s opened this way of working up as a norm is absolutely amazing IMO. There’s no way it would have happened otherwise.

I went back to work 4 days a week last year in a fully WFH job. We have been asked to go into the office for a team lunch once a month from next month which is nice to meet up.

I have a disabled adult son who would never get up and go to appointments if I wasn’t here, probably burn the house down as he can’t be left alone too long and my 12 year old was recently diagnosed with a life threatening chronic condition so I need to be able to pick him up from school and be around when he’s home, he’s had to take quite a bit of time off school so I’m here for sick days, will need to go to medical appointments which I can work round by working later on the evenings etc. No way could I cope with an in office job.

WFH had been a godsend for me and I am very productive, much more than my full time colleague who had no DC but has dogs who she constantly needs to see to, all you can hear on calls is the bloody things barking in the background, and then constantly calls me about stupid stuff which she should be able to do herself as she’s been there longer than me! At least I can ignore her calls. I dread to think what it’d be like working in an office with her.

I have a table in the corner of the dining room with a laptop and two monitors on it so plenty of workspace, can drop youngest at school, put a wash on, hoover through, cook myself breakfast and then log on after I’ve tidied the kitchen. I walk to Tesco (5 mins away) to get stuff in for dinner at lunchtime so no rushing about or cleaning after work. No travel costs or expensive lunches, started to make my own soup. I love it!

ZenNudist · 25/09/2022 00:08

I hate going into the office, well I love swanning around seeing everyone and chatting and getting out for a pret at lunchtime but I get so little work done. I'm far too busy nowadays. Get so much more done from home, mainly working in the evening as well as day time whilst still managing to see the dc and take them to activities

I go into the office to see my local team and try and support some new junior staff. Most of my team is all over the UK and I support them much better now via teams as pre covid we would have just called each other.

Going into the office then spending all day on teams is just a waste of time. Last week I tried to grab some people for a face to face meeting but we ended up on teams to make it easier for others in other locations.

WFH is great. Did it a lot before covid when I just needed to get stuff done. Doing it all the time has really improved productivity and its difficult to go back to a slower pace of work.

SpangledShambles · 25/09/2022 00:04

Due to existing society dynamics, wfh is a feminist issue along with all the other factors. We can finally hope to maintain careers and compete for seniority as well as having kids and spending a healthy amount of time with them. This is also a good thing for male parents as they have traditionally been sucked into commute and work without as much time with kids. This may be a traditional representation but it is also a fact. So wfh could help modernise and revolutionise life for everyone. No wonder the old guard don’t like it. It’s something worth fighting for now we have the technology to support it.

Icanflyhigh · 25/09/2022 00:00

Works for me - 5 years total WFH and wouldn't change a thing!

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/09/2022 23:58

Also agree you can’t do wfh whilst being in sole charge of children (under about 10/11 really) though. Not fair on them or you.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 24/09/2022 23:57

I think hybrid is ideal. I did hybrid pre pandemic too.

Right at the moment I’m wfh all the time and I think it sends you a bit loopy in the en.

Mamafromthebeach · 24/09/2022 23:45

I have wfh for years. One thing I will say is it never ever works if you have young children with no other supervision. But it did mean shorter days at nursery for them and I could easily get the dinner/bath/bed routine done without the commute.

Now my kids are older I Iike the hybrid arrangement with my new job - I do 2 days wfh and 3 days in office. For me that optimises productivity as I structure my week around that and it also works personally. I don’t think there is a blanket rule for everyone.

Cameleongirl · 24/09/2022 22:04

Wimin123 · 24/09/2022 21:12

Well I don’t think it works well for young employees and time will tell with increasing mental health issues etc - fine for senior managers and those nearing retirement. Not so good for people stuck in abusive relationships either

I can see how spending too much time on your own could negatively affect mental health, plus we all need to learn how to get on with people (in person) whom we don't really like. I don't know whether it's age-related though.

notacooldad · 24/09/2022 21:37

Well I don’t think it works well for young employees and time will tell with increasing mental health issues etc - fine for senior managers and those nearing retirement
Don't senior managers and those nearing retirement have mental health issues?
In my experience they do.

DanceItOut · 24/09/2022 21:29

I think it completely depends on the job, the company, the employee, and the home set up. Someone working from home with no one else home but the dog for example is likely going to be far more productive than someone working from home with a toddler. If everything you do is primarily via email then that works from home or office but if you need to attend meetings then I really do think those work better face to face rather than screen to screen.

my work has a hybrid working policy but it limits the number of days that can be worked from home and the policy states that the team manager has the right to request staff work all of their days in office some weeks if there is genuine need/reason. Last week the manager asked for everyone to be in the office in person because there were new staff, new customers, lots of meetings etc.

i think as long as people aren’t taking the piss and aren’t just assuming it’s a given entitlement then it’s fine.

ThinWomansBrain · 24/09/2022 21:27

I didn't like WFH - I have a very open loft style apartment that doen't lend itself to a separate office I can close away, plus living alone, I found it a bit isolating.
A hybrid working model is best for me - I have team members that don't communicate well remotely, and just harder to build team co-ordination if 100% remote, but I love a couple of days working 'alone' each week.
My "WFH" is actually renting a hotdesk space in a brilliant community spirited office about five minutes walk from home. Co-renters are really great, occasional community lunches and events, great coffee....
I kept it on even when I was between roles, & kept focussed on looking for the next one.

Macinae · 24/09/2022 21:13

I do two days in the office and three days WFH. Office days are for 121s with my team, team meetings and collaboration sessions as these things work better in person. My WFH days I do emails, project work, forecasting, quality assessing, payment approvals, write training and write ups for 121s/reviews. If I had to do these things in the office this would be near impossible as there is often an interruption.

WFH has given me and many others a better work life balance and has done wonders for my mental health as a result. I think the only people who are bothered by it are the micromanaging type. If my team are delivering on their objectives, do I care if they're having a cuppa, playing with their dog intermittently, putting washing on the line? No.

Wimin123 · 24/09/2022 21:12

Well I don’t think it works well for young employees and time will tell with increasing mental health issues etc - fine for senior managers and those nearing retirement. Not so good for people stuck in abusive relationships either

Dewix · 24/09/2022 21:08

WFH works brilliantly for me.

No commute or lunch costs.

It's meant that I've been around for my son's early years, where I would of normally had to have been in the office.

I'm around for anything needed at home & able to crack on with work.

Have a dedicated space, which helps and the option of going to the office if wanted or needed.

My industry is now competing with offers of 100% WFH since it saves the company real-estate, facilities & heating costs & means talent can be hired from anywhere without relocation.
This last paragraph is why WFH is here to stay.

SarahSissions · 24/09/2022 21:01

I was more productive working in an office- but I also used to get paid £20k more. If my job want me in the office I’ll go back- but they need to start paying me another £25k a year- and I’ll be a bit more productive- but not that much.

yes I can do more- and my boss would’ve probably said in this survey that I would be more productive- but I’d be more productive if they paid me more- and it would make no difference if I were in the office or home. I’m coasting…

FredtheCatsMum · 24/09/2022 20:51

Works for me. I've been doing it 1-2 days a week for years. I have my office days when I meet people, and my writing / quiet work days.

I don't think it works for everyone, and I've no doubt some managers can't handle not being able to see their staff, but it certainly works for some people