Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
Hearthnhome · 23/09/2022 07:37

How can WFH had its days when people did it long before the pandemic. People act like it didn’t exist. The truth is, lots of employers didn’t want to allow it when they could. There’s quite a few reasons. Some valid. Some not.

If someone isn’t performing in their job it’s the managements job to manage them, no matter where they are working. That may include the individual having to be in office for more training or similar.

WFH never worked for everyone. Even before 2020. It doesn’t suit all jobs, all people or all families and households.

We had teams that went back to the office within weeks because it didn’t work for them. Their job roles didn’t suit it. One team was brought back in the middle of last year, because their performance really dipped. My teams are back 1 day a week and it works. They are less productive on the day they are in. The office is distracting, people stopping by to chat or even ask a genuine question will chat for a bit as well.

The systems are slower at work and they don’t seem to be able to resolve it. Office politics piss people off. My team work with confidential information that we can’t discuss in an open plan office. Jumping on teams when we are all at home is so much easier than trying to find a free meeting room when an issue occurs and needs to be quickly resolved.

I think most Companies problem with WFH is that they have inadequate management that don’t manage. Either they have brought in and promoted the wrong people or don’t give the managers the support they need to manage behaviour.

The myth that office workers are productive is based on ‘if you can see them they must be working. If you can’t see them they must be slacking’. In my 23 years of working I have seen so many people waste so much time when in the office. Being in the building has never, ever, been an indicator of productiveness.

NewPapaGuinea · 23/09/2022 07:35

Not commuting for 3 hours a day certainly helps my productivity.

TiktokFamousDog · 23/09/2022 07:35

It works for us but we have lots of space and both have our own office. We wouldn’t want to go back to working in the office.

MossGrowsFat · 23/09/2022 07:35

WFH does not help new starters (ie our children) it only helps those that are already established.

greenacrylicpaint · 23/09/2022 07:34

I disagree

at home I can get stuck in and finish a lot of work.
there are too many coffee with colleagues distractions and meetings at the office for that.

a mix of both is ideal imo. 2 days in the office and the rest from home.

Blahblablahblahblah · 23/09/2022 07:33

@Lulumo if your contract is wfh, that doesn’t sound right.

blebbleb · 23/09/2022 07:32

babyyodaxmas · 23/09/2022 06:17

It works if you have a dedicated space to do it in and a door that closes

Yes I agree. It's harder for young people who live in shared housing working off a laptop on their bed. Also could be quite isolating.

CrabbitBastard · 23/09/2022 07:30

I'm disabled. I'm definitely more productive. I am less tired and even work more hours as I'm not wasting time commuting. I don't have bitchy colleagues to deal with or see every day. The only downside is that I don't get out as much so I'm less active and fatter!

Ohtsd · 23/09/2022 07:29

The effect of wfh on others that live in the house is something that is not always considered.

Lulumo · 23/09/2022 07:28

It allows more disabled people to work. I would not be able to work from the office each day due to health conditions so I took a WFH part time job. Now they are pushing me to go into the office regularly and I’m having to push back, I do have a WFH contract . The alternative to WFH for me is not to work at all.

ToastofLandon · 23/09/2022 07:28

I’ve been working remotely for a year now, the whole team (in tech) have always worked that way so it’s completely set up for it and there’s offices you can go to if you do want to come in.

As a new person person coming in though, it’s made it really hard to forge relationships. Doing that remotely is just not the same, you can’t replace face to face contact. I honestly feel I’ve drifted slowly and slowly into depression because I don’t have that social element I used to have with work, that I didn’t realise until recently how much I needed it.

So no I’m not surprised remote working 24/7 doesn’t work well for everyone. So much learning and innovation comes from bringing people together in person, with all the tech in the world you can’t recreate it online and I balance is definitely needed.

MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 07:26

As a manager, I have clear, observable evidence that some people in my team are significantly less productive when wfh. However, that doesn't mean that everyone is less productive at home, and evidence actually shows that that isn't the case.

We are therefore managing our hybrid model on an individual basis. If staff are delivering what we need them to do while wfh, then they can carry on doing so. If they are delivering less than we expect, then we ask them to come back into the office so that we can monitor and support them more closely for a period. If performance improves, then they can trial wfh again to see if it can be sustained.

It's fair and it's transparent and it's flexible. Everyone is in the office at least 2 days each week, as there is some work that needs to be done f2f. Some people choose to be in the office every day because it helps their mental health or because they don't have a suitable space to wfh etc. I imagine a few might choose to do that in the winter if it's expensive to heat their homes.

I do wfh some days but actually prefer going into the office now...wfh is convenient but it's so isolating. Teams meetings just aren't the same as actually seeing people!

GnomeDePlume · 23/09/2022 07:26

From what I have seen, the people in my current and previous workplace calling for others to get back into the office are doing so for their own personal benefit. These are the people who want to socialise at work. They want to get back to informal chats over coffee, team lunches etc.

SheWentWest · 23/09/2022 07:25

For introverts it's amazing. Working without constant noise and irrelevant chatter and having No one talk at you when you are taking a break. I used to end very day at the office with a massive headache and now I feel so much better. The work wasn't the problem it was the constant enforced socialising.

cheninblanc · 23/09/2022 07:24

Works great for me, I do 3 days at home and 2 in onsite. My dh the same and we love it

Scottishgirl85 · 23/09/2022 07:24

Works perfectly for us. We are lucky to have 2 offices in our home so it doesn't impact family/home life, can close the door at weekend! It has enabled us to see our children so much more, do school drop-off and pick-ups, dishwasher and washing machine whilst kettle boiling etc. Utterly invaluable. I get way more done in my silent study vs chit chatter in office.

BiologicalKitty · 23/09/2022 07:23

Sestriere · 23/09/2022 07:21

😉 three together two wherever?

Haha indeed! I asked my manager yesterday if a GP waiting room should be added into the FAQs.

Muststopeating · 23/09/2022 07:22

GorgeousLadyofWrestling · 23/09/2022 06:28

I have worked in tech start ups for several years and it’s very common there anyway, so was fully used to it. If I had the energy, a hybrid set up is best, affording the benefit of both the office and the flexibility of working from home.

But I have 3 primary aged children, I work in senior leadership…those two things needed a compromise and that was working from home. It’s just so much easier to get all the family stuff done in the morning before 9am, sit down to my desk and work really productively, go for a run at lunch and put a wash on, get several more hours of work in but also be home for the kids when they come home (we have an after school nanny) and be there to put dinner on. Those hours I’m not losing to the commute make all the difference in my home and working life 🤷🏻‍♀️

This!!

I have a 1, 3 and 5 year old. I also live in very rural Scotland. Wrap around care etc doesn't exist here. DHs job has very unpredictable days/hours and often requires him to be away for a week or two.

I left one of the worlds biggest Tech companies that prides itself on its 'flexibility' to work for a tiny bespoke consultancy after my second baby. They offered me part-time and working from home with an excellent salary.

If it hadn't been for that company I doubt I'd have made it back to the workforce.

WFH gives me the flex to start early, work late... but also allows me the chance to get a load of washing on (all of 5 mins while kettle boils) or do drop offs/pick ups.

The client I work for gets more than their pound of flesh but I am still able to maintain some level of sanity.

Please remember that WFH has made work accessible for many WOMEN before you suggest its had its day.

Its not for everyone but for some its everything.

Sestriere · 23/09/2022 07:21

BiologicalKitty · 23/09/2022 07:05

@Sestriere I'm almost 100% sure we work for the same org.

😉 three together two wherever?

Ohtsd · 23/09/2022 07:20

He definitely needs a separate place to work, I'm retired and it was a right pain when DH worked in the house, in the end he worked in the caravan on the drive, even when he was in the spare room I could still hear his calls. An office in the garden is a good idea, luckily he is retired now but long term I think we would have converted the outbuilding

KILM · 23/09/2022 07:19

Sestriere · 23/09/2022 06:35

I’ve long said this (under various usernames). I’ve WFH since 2006, and my employer first introduced it in 1999. It was a massive success, but then they realised that being in the office also had huge benefits too and started to reduce WFH and bringing people back.

Cut to the pandemic, due to our history, lifting and shifting 1000s of employees home quickly was a breeze. But now, two years on a formal policy has been launched this very week with the clear expectation that all employees will be expected in three days a week and can work from wherever two days. Because, given the chance to work hybrid without a policy meant people simply didn’t come in. Now they are expected in with the rest of their team. Our pass cards enable the company to monitor this. There is still some flexibility for appointments, caring responsibilities etc. it’s not all bad. I work for a huge household name.

we need to do this for the new recruits to learn, develop and grow as well.

there’s an article on BBC news about the same thing. Microsoft are expected in 50% of the time, Apple have been called back, Tesler are expected in five days.

Others will follow.

I think we might work at the same employer. Respectfully (as you are right, there are benefits on an individual level in the right circumstances) i feel like you've missed out in your post that your employer (if we indeed work for the same one which i think we might) is going through an unbelievable attrition crisis due to pay and conditions like forcing people to work from offices that are hours away from where they live, in a sector where competitors will offer completely remote to candidates and stick to it.
This company is struggling to recruit because they recruit people on the basis its 'flexible working' like other tech companies, then once the person starts they discovered they are actually expected to do a 3 hour commute to sit in an office alone on Teams calls with colleagues scattered around the world. So people quit within months of getting here.
Word appears to be getting out about this, as they dont pay market rate, so if they dont offer fully remote how can they possibly expect to recruit any talent worth having. Obviously the movement in tech (and the sector the employer is in) is very high across the board, but this employer has put itself in a position where consumer services are going to be impacted because of the recruitment and retention crisis from pay and WFH.

Autumn2022 · 23/09/2022 07:19

Younger people are used to online communication and are very adept at building relationships that way.

that’s something I’ve really struggled with. I’m 32 so not sure where you’d place me. But started a new job and spent 2 days in the office when lockdown hit. A team of 20 and 2.5 years in I have met maybe half a dozen. I’ve found that really tough.

macthekwife · 23/09/2022 07:16

the problem there is he is using the living space as an office, that's not fair at all. He needs to have a separate space. Mine uses the bedroom, which is fine, I stay downstairs. I work in the lounge but my work is contract and I can do it at any time and it doesn't take any paper or set up, just me and my laptop which isn't in the way of anyone.

The thing about WFH is you cut out travel and lunch which at work can just be time-consuming and expensive and may not sustain you properly. I can make a lovely lunch, a fresh salad, my husband gets a cooked meal at lunch and teatime and it does make you more productive as you're not comfortable.

But some people need that work environment and it's just an individual thing. There are people who use WFH to slack of course. I've seen it myself.

Ohtsd · 23/09/2022 07:14

I think my probate case worker is working from home....

MrsJBaptiste · 23/09/2022 07:14

I WFH with one day a week in the office. I am so much productive at home, I'm logged on by 8am and finished and ready for the gym by 5pm. The day I'm in the office, I don't get there until 9am due the the commute, get very little done as people take it as an opportunity to ask things in person (which they absolutely should and is the point of the day in the office) then stay until 6pm so I can have an hour after everyone else has left and am home by 7pm.

However, we built a garden office so I'm out of the way of the family and it makes working that bit more bearable! I can log on, zone out and have my meetings in peace which is a far cry from the first year when I had a camping table in the corner of the kitchen...