Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 08:05

SirCharlesRainier · 23/09/2022 08:03

Bosses who think WFH means lower productivity have massively underestimated just how unproductive I managed to be while in the office.

Love that!

NuNameNuMe · 23/09/2022 08:05

It works if you have a dedicated space to do it in and a door that closes

I agree with this. It works if you have an office space at home to go to, and come away from. I'm torn. When I'm in the office I enjoy people, the shops at lunchtime etc, but the office itself is not fully optimised for ME the way it is at home. I think hybrid is the way, use the office for people things, and home for concentration. I've been massively more productive at home, but that may not be a totally good thing to jump from one meeting to the next without even a break to walk between floors or meeting rooms.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 08:04

Forebt · 23/09/2022 07:56

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior true but it doesn’t work for everyone.

Yes. Didn't say it did. The whole point is not to generalise.

In this specific example, young people and new starters doesn't simply mean those ones who are like the person making the claim and found office based working beneficial to them. If what posters actually mean is people like me will find it harder to work from home as new starters, they should say that, rather than assuming all young people have the same traits and advantages as they did.

RampantIvy · 23/09/2022 08:03

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH

Mine does.
I think it works well because of the type of job, the right people and excellent leadership. I get more done at home because I have fewer distractions. I am pretty focussed anyway, and the type of work I do isn't the type that you can spend time procrastinating.

I go to the office once a week.

NotQuiteUsual · 23/09/2022 08:03

WFH with some flexibility has been a genuine life changer for us. We could buy a house in a cheaper area(with the boss very happy for us and supportive). DH is around more with the kids since he's not sat on a forever delayed train. He can do the school run and make yo the time after. His MH is so much better for it and because he's very introverted he works a lot better without people around distracting him.

Although before we moved, when DH had to work in the dining room(which was the through room to the kitchen and toilet) he absolutely struggled. It only works if you have a suitable space to do it. But in this day and age there's no reason why WFH shouldn't be an option for suitable jobs.

GoldenOmber · 23/09/2022 08:03

In my experience - for my type of job - there is a productivity issue but it’s not about people slacking off at home. People tend to be better at some tasks at home (getting through their inbox, quiet writing, process-based tasks), but anything that involves collaboration or innovation as a team rather than an individual doesn’t work so well. Hybrid is a good compromise.

SirCharlesRainier · 23/09/2022 08:03

Bosses who think WFH means lower productivity have massively underestimated just how unproductive I managed to be while in the office.

JassyRadlett · 23/09/2022 08:02

That article should be titled 'Bosses admit their lack of capability, having no objective way to measure productivity beyond feelings and not having the skill to motivate and maintain performance in their workforce without standing over them all the time.'

Honestly, any manager who says that they 'feel' or 'know' their staff are less productive WFH without having any performance or productivity metrics, any analysis of the tasks that are more/less productive remotely, and at least a fleeting sense of shame that they are so bad at their jobs that they can't get results without being in the same building as their workforce, should be sacked on the spot.

From my experience in very different workplaces since the pandemic, and teams who were either part remote or at a minimum geographically dispersed, there are some tasks that are naturally more productive in person (eg creative and collaborative work) and those that are more productive remotely. That doesn't mean that either should be fully enforced and managers need to be creative around to overcome the natural shortfalls of a particular way of working. For example, I have teams in Dundee, Aberdeen, London and Cardiff. We are rarely all going to be in the same place, and I'm rarely going to be standing over them to check they're working and not surfing the sidebar of shame. That doesn't mean I throw in the towel on collaborative work, it means I work harder to make the more difficult things work.

I also know which of my team members are more productive than others, and those whose performance dips in different settings and on different tasks.

Hybrid is working pretty well for us. It's not perfect and it's got shortcomings but we've exceeded our performance targets and improved productivity year on year without breathing down people's necks.

Treesandsheepeverywhere · 23/09/2022 08:02

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Also states:
I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices
So @Seaswimminginwinter has every right to post and talk about it.

Forebt · 23/09/2022 08:02

Gosh. People get very frothy around the mouth about this topic don’t they.

Dont worry I’m not about to protest for office working out there but I don’t like it and the post asks for opinions.

ErrolTheDragon · 23/09/2022 08:02

I personally think that WFH is the spawn of Satan. I am sick of not being able to ring up any organisation and have a sensible conversation with someone which isn't interrupted by children/dogs/postmen. Either that, or whoever I'm ringing up wants to tell me their life story, presumably because they are missing the social side of being at work. It's a bloody nightmare, and one of the very worst things about Covid.

Really? We've done quite a lot of phoning banks and service providers over the last couple of years. I've only once heard a kid in the background (during lockdown when the schools were closed) - mostly we've found that the phone is answered faster than it used to be.

Forebt · 23/09/2022 08:01

@Hearthnhome That’s nice but no not really.

Forebt · 23/09/2022 08:00

Also depends on the role doesn’t it, my new role is the type where you learn by osmosis and niche area. Also don’t other people miss all the skills you pick up being around multidisciplinary teams etc?

Hearthnhome · 23/09/2022 08:00

Forebt · 23/09/2022 07:55

Try bring a trainee and just wfh, it’s shit, you don’t learn anything. I’m looking for a new job now because I hate it so much. There’s no culture or way of networking and when you do finally get into a meeting it’s all about the one person that hogs the mic and their personal life.

I’m glad some people get a positive experience though.

I would bet a years wages, that employee was poor when everyone was in the office. Showed by the fact that haven’t come up with a plan that works. It shows they don’t give a shit.

ErrolTheDragon · 23/09/2022 07:57

Obviously it depends on the job and the person. I've WFH since 1995, and also 1989-1991 when it was significantly harder to do as there was only dialup email. I write scientific software, with colleagues in different time zones. It's the sort of thing where working flexibly, quite often picking up emails late in the day, sometimes working in the evening can make it very productive. Its also the sort of job where there's a lot of thinking and problem solving - quite often if I'm stuck, half an hour pottering in the garden seems to allow my subconscious to find a solution much better than sitting at a desk.
If you're the sort of person who isn't very self-motivated and/or doesn't enjoy their job (for itself, rather than the social aspects) then it won't be a good fit for you.

Forebt · 23/09/2022 07:56

@PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior true but it doesn’t work for everyone.

incywincyspiders · 23/09/2022 07:55

I work hybrid so have a direct comparison of my productivity at home vs at work and I can tell you I am SO much more productive at home than I am at work.

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 07:55

MossGrowsFat · 23/09/2022 07:35

WFH does not help new starters (ie our children) it only helps those that are already established.

Whenever MNers say this, it's always very clear that they have a particular type of 'our children' in mind.

More wfh opportunities are going to be extremely helpful to my neurodivergent child who wouldn't cope a full day in an office environment, for example. They're going to benefit those of our children who don't live within commuting distance of the best job markets. They're going to open up more opportunities to young people looking for an entry job they can balance with caring responsibilities.

Forebt · 23/09/2022 07:55

Try bring a trainee and just wfh, it’s shit, you don’t learn anything. I’m looking for a new job now because I hate it so much. There’s no culture or way of networking and when you do finally get into a meeting it’s all about the one person that hogs the mic and their personal life.

I’m glad some people get a positive experience though.

KathyWilliams · 23/09/2022 07:53

I personally think that WFH is the spawn of Satan. I am sick of not being able to ring up any organisation and have a sensible conversation with someone which isn't interrupted by children/dogs/postmen. Either that, or whoever I'm ringing up wants to tell me their life story, presumably because they are missing the social side of being at work. It's a bloody nightmare, and one of the very worst things about Covid.

If my husband has been WFH, we would have been divorced far sooner than we were. I would have loathed having someone around the house during the day. Houses are homes, not offices.

blebbleb · 23/09/2022 07:53

Ohtsd · 23/09/2022 07:46

You do need a very large house as even when DH was in the spare room I could still hear him on calls if I was upstairs, our house is not that big but fortunately no DC and I don't think he would have been able to work in the caravan if it was very cold

Yes you definitely need the space. My husband works from home 99% of the time. We have a 2 bed small terraced house and he works in the lounge (long lounge so hidden in the corner and we can move past without being seen on camera). Overall it's great as he can avoid the long commute and see our son more and do pickups, and I'm in the office m-f. It is annoying if I'm at home with my toddler though as we can't really go in the living room for massive chunks of the day. Husband doesn't mind us coming in but I'm sure it's distracting and looks unprofessional with a toddler shouting. We could do with more space to make it work!

stuntbubbles · 23/09/2022 07:52

I’m timesheeted and my billability is calculated at the end of the week: it’s ALWAYS higher working from home than in the office. In the office I get dragged into watercooler chats, my work is slower because the office is open-plan and full of young people loudly bantzing whereas my role is “head down, focus, do a thing”, and there’s generally a million in-office meetings that aren’t replicated virtually so I get to skip those WFH, get my hours done, clock off early.

I also get to do nursery runs, laundry, cooking and a sly bit of quiet DIY – paint stripping, painting – in camera-off calls. Doesn’t affect my work performance.

GeneralSOneill · 23/09/2022 07:51

I think it depends on your work. Hybrid works well for us. We visit service users at home so WFH adds lots of travel time to visits that people don't make up, but trying to do teams meetings in a busy office is just really hard so hybrid is very effective.

DH WFH permanently and is much more productive than he was in the office - no long lunches in town and works during his commuting times and as his home office is set up permenantly he'll often go back to work after dinner.

We're lucky that our home office is in the loft conversion so away from the rest of the house and doesn't feel invasive at all.

Notreallyhappy · 23/09/2022 07:51

Oh yes...can my OH go back now so I can have my home back..😬

HRTQueen · 23/09/2022 07:50

It has to work for the team not just foe the individual

I’m my experience few who have taken up working form home since 2020 it works as well for the team no matter how productive they claim they are

also gives them more time to arrange more team meetings for the rest of us who don’t have the time to sit in another meeting