Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
MrsBennetsPoorNerves · 23/09/2022 08:59

ancientgran · 23/09/2022 08:53

I wonder how it is affecting young people new to a job. Do they get the same mentoring and support. I think back and remember how much I picked up from listening to more experienced staff dealing with things and being able to ask a quick question.

Personally I've had issues when phoning a business and the person at home can't access something, then you get a promise of a call back within x hours that never happens. Drives me mad.

Honestly, I think it's difficult to provide the same level of support and mentoring for young people @ancientgran. We have identified this as a specific problem, which we're currently trying to find creative ways of addressing.

MossGrowsFat · 23/09/2022 08:58

PerfectlyPreservedQuagaarWarrior · 23/09/2022 07:55

Whenever MNers say this, it's always very clear that they have a particular type of 'our children' in mind.

More wfh opportunities are going to be extremely helpful to my neurodivergent child who wouldn't cope a full day in an office environment, for example. They're going to benefit those of our children who don't live within commuting distance of the best job markets. They're going to open up more opportunities to young people looking for an entry job they can balance with caring responsibilities.

Not at all. I work with students entering the work place, the only ones WFH works for are those that are already privileged and able.

Firstly privileged as they need a quiet room, decent broadband, able because they need to be at a certain academic level to cope with the remoteness and extra skills that WFH require, the lack of direct support and building of relationship.

WFH will alienate a large proportion of the workforce, whilst some employers manage to be successful it requires time money and investment, something which most employers are not doing.

You mention people who are not NT, whilst there are benefits these people often need extra support put in place, when they are WFH it is easy to miss the adjustments they need.

user1487194234 · 23/09/2022 08:57

For people who can choose to do it then I am sure it works very well
For customers,I think the jury is still out

ancientgran · 23/09/2022 08:53

I wonder how it is affecting young people new to a job. Do they get the same mentoring and support. I think back and remember how much I picked up from listening to more experienced staff dealing with things and being able to ask a quick question.

Personally I've had issues when phoning a business and the person at home can't access something, then you get a promise of a call back within x hours that never happens. Drives me mad.

Dotjones · 23/09/2022 08:53

I hate my days in the office. My role requires the space to think. It's impossible to think sometimes in an open plan office when there are salespeople shouting into their phones in one direction and people idly chatting in the other.

My own experience is I'm more productive at home. If nothing else it cuts out all the chit chat and interruptions I face in the office.

I understand why bosses dislike it - if they can't see what we're doing, they assume we're doing nothing. It says a lot about their mentality though and the fundamental lack of trust management have in workers actually working of their own accord.

OooPourUsACupLove · 23/09/2022 08:51

Pengwinn · 23/09/2022 06:53

Younger people are used to online communication and are very adept at building relationships that way

I think this plays a part in why many are terrible at communicating in person, not just at work. Its definitely a set of skills that's going down the pan and imo will lead to everyone being more isolated in tbe future.

I work for a global company and often work closely and effectively with colleagues for years before meeting in person.

Without fail, every time I've met someone face to face, no matter how well we alreasy worked together before, the relationship still notched up a gear, while relationships that may have been hard work for a long time get much easier.

MintJulia · 23/09/2022 08:50

YABU. I work for a small tech company. We don't have a full office any more so we can't go back to full time office working. For us, it's permanent.

We have one room in a Regus-type building, plus a meeting room once a month.
We can fit about a third of the staff into the ordinary room. The younger London-based staff who don't have space at home, work in the office more often. Those with houses go in once a week.

Month on month, we're up 76% on last year, so I don't think it's hit business levels, and I do far more hours now because I don't have to commute any more.

If they asked me to go back to the office full time, I'd resign. I'm 59, I have no desire to commute any more and this works.

Autumn2022 · 23/09/2022 08:49

Ohtsd · 23/09/2022 07:29

The effect of wfh on others that live in the house is something that is not always considered.

Absolutely. I works for me as I have a dedicated office room and invested in a big monitor and docking station. Not everyone can do that. Especially not junior staff living with their parents.

middleager · 23/09/2022 08:48

It works extremely for my husband and me.

I have a role that has always worked well remotely. I wfh 1-2 days per week pre pandemic.
The office was always too distracting, groups of colleagues, chatting all day, phones going, too hot, too cold, office politics. I have always been more productive at home.

DH started wfh in the pandemic - we both have different rooms - and he saved on 3hrs of commuting a day. He's due back in the office 2 days a week, because those who chose to go back are asking when everybody else is!

At my work, there are some people who also choose to go in, either because their particular roles don't work at home, they don't have space, there are small kids (grandkids) at home, or they simply prefer it. Most of these though are the workers who - even before the pandemic - like to socialise at work, and chatter all bloody day, go out for lunch etc. All had never wfh pre pandemic and said they prefer office work. Fair enough.
Their return is up to them, but they are now threatening to spoil it for the rest of us, asking when others will return. Deliberately asking those of us who do prefer wfh on Teams calls if we're still wfh (er yeh, I'm on a Teams call with you).

It's not fair on those of us who have quiet spaces, who are fine working remotely, who don't need to socialise at work, and who have wfh for years. These are not young people by the way - these are women, like me, in their 40s/50s.

There seems to be a culture/mindset still that being seen at one's desk is a measure of productivity. And a culture that if you can't/don't want to wfh then nobody should. The irony is, that when I was in an office with those workers, they spent all day nattering and I could not focus.

luxxlisbon · 23/09/2022 08:48

I love how overall you don’t think it works well but you don’t even do it!
Ive worked flexibly since pre pandemic, my partner only as a result of covid. We both do about 2 days at home and the rest out or in the office.
Hybrid working offers a while range of benefits for the employees and employers.
I thought we weee beyond the days of presenteeism, it’s quite archaic.
In actual face a hybrid work model is actually a cost saving for businesses.

Bluebal · 23/09/2022 08:48

Also to add I put my children in childcare most days too as its impossible to work well with them at home so it doesn't save me any money there. My colleagues who work from home with their children there aren't very productive. My eldest goes to breakfast club and afterschool club 4 days a week and my youngest does 8am-5:30pm in nursery 5 days.

sweetpeapea · 23/09/2022 08:48

I love wfh as does my dh. I hope I never have to go back! Don't begrudge those that disagree but I certainly have only seen advantages in our households, not least dh actually sees the dc now!

TimeAtTheBar · 23/09/2022 08:47

DH gets much more done at home. He works overtime because he has no commute. No interruptions from people in the office. No pointless in person meetings, he can work through zoom calls etc.

He’s a software designer so his output is easily measurable. When the company were making noise about coming back into the office he was able to show them hard evidence of how much more productive he is wfh.

We do have a home office though, and no toddlers or distractions. He couldn’t do it from the kitchen table with a two year old hanging off him.

Glittertwins · 23/09/2022 08:47

Works for us too but we have our own areas in the house with closed doors and a good wifi connection. We can get errands done when time would have been spent walking to /from canteen for drinks for example. I certainly know from my annual review I have been productive the whole of last year.

KeepOutingMyselfAnotherNameChange · 23/09/2022 08:46

ErrolTheDragon · 23/09/2022 08:42

My local council are still WFH. I used to be able to walk into the office and speak to someone (usually had to wait 5-10 mins, if at all). Now I have to ring them. The phone is answered, if at all, after about 50 mins. Then there was the man at a call centre who went on and on and on about his family, children, illnesses, etc, etc. When I said (very politely) that I really just needed the answer to my question because I had a lot to do, he said he was WFH and hated it, and wanted to talk to people.

Hopefully that was anomaly and not a pattern that the private sector generally can make wfh work, staff answering calls professionally etc as I've found but the public sector has a long wait and staff being completely unprofessional as in that case!
(Our only interactions with the council recently have been via Internet and absolutely fine)

My local council are the same!! They have a backlog going back to Jan as they are all WFH and nothings getting done.

Bluebal · 23/09/2022 08:45

I work from home, I have the option to go into the office but it's a 4 hour round trip for me. I still chose to do it once every other week but when I do I am no where near as productive, the noise of the office is too distracting for me and I save the tasks that I need to concentrate on for when I am at home.
I have to give myself strong boundaries at home. For example I work 9-5 contacted, I inevitably do more hours than this but I make a point of not logging on until just before 9am and using my time in the morning to do bits and bobs round the house. Ultimately I get work done quicker when I am home, I find client calls easier from home too.

KeepOutingMyselfAnotherNameChange · 23/09/2022 08:45

I agree. The only time I WFH was when I had covid and it was rubbish. I did barely anything. Not productive at all. My DB WFH in a flat when my SIL has a primary aged child, toddler and baby in the livingroom. She feels like she has to go out everyday.

ErrolTheDragon · 23/09/2022 08:42

My local council are still WFH. I used to be able to walk into the office and speak to someone (usually had to wait 5-10 mins, if at all). Now I have to ring them. The phone is answered, if at all, after about 50 mins. Then there was the man at a call centre who went on and on and on about his family, children, illnesses, etc, etc. When I said (very politely) that I really just needed the answer to my question because I had a lot to do, he said he was WFH and hated it, and wanted to talk to people.

Hopefully that was anomaly and not a pattern that the private sector generally can make wfh work, staff answering calls professionally etc as I've found but the public sector has a long wait and staff being completely unprofessional as in that case!
(Our only interactions with the council recently have been via Internet and absolutely fine)

economicervix · 23/09/2022 08:42

Are you jealous, OP? 😄 The Daily Mail scum rag is fuming about WFH, are you a journo?
Id never work in an office. WfH has zero downsides. If bosses want to be breathing down labourers necks, that’s their problem to cry about, who cares.

SpidersAreShitheads · 23/09/2022 08:39

I used to be a manager in a technical role at a finance company and it was an absolute bastard trying to get any work done in the office between 9-5pm. All the managers ended up working really long hours - either coming in at 6am or working til 9pm just to get the actual work done.

I work so much better without people around me.

As it happens, I've been self-employed and WFH for almost 13 years now. It's weird for me hearing everyone talking about WFH and it being so controversial when I've done it for such a long time. I wouldn't ever want to return to an office environment. I love WFH (I'm a copywriter/editor/proofreader).

If it doesn't work for you, then fine. But really, is it such a big deal if a conversation gets interrupted occasionally if it means that society has a much healthier work/life balance?! WFH allows some people to see their children more, spend less time commuting - which is also good for the environment! - spend less money on transport, and be able to manage their commitments with less stress. Other countries have been offering this for years, and are far better than the UK at promoting a balanced lifestyle.

I've just been dealing with a really stressful house move, a mortgage that went tits up, and planning permission which involved about a million different organisations (or at least it bloody felt like it!) - all of which involved multiple phone calls. I didn't have any issues at all speaking to people. No interruptions.

I know iWFH is not for everyone and that's absolutely fair enough. Of course it won't suit everyone. But this snotty attitude that people who WFH aren't pulling their weight really is nasty, and uncalled for. Surely COVID taught us all that life really is too short for this kind of bollocks and petty- mindedness?!

Fairnair · 23/09/2022 08:33

No, I don’t think WFH has had its day at all. There are jobs which obviously cannot be done from home, or not very easily, but a lot of Administrative, customer service roles etc. can.

My husband is an administrator in a financial type role, and he is now working a hybrid system, usually 3 days at home, and two in the office. There is flexibility, when we both had Covid earlier in the year he did not go into the office for about two weeks (the legal isolation period, free testing etc. had just stopped), worked from home, & similarly when his Mum had an eye op he went to stay with her, but worked from his Mum’s house. My husband has a set number of cases he has to do in a day to meet targets, it is very easy for his boss to see whether he is slacking or not (most days he exceeds his target now). 0n days he has been in the office sometimes he has to log back onto his laptop to finish off a case if there have been too many distractions in the office etc.

Companies are trying to save costs, & some are doing this by either getting rid of their office space all together, or like the Company my husband works for have reduced the amount of space they rent. They use to rent two floors in a city centre location for approx. 100 staff, but have reduced to one floor, & can now only fit approx. 70 people in the office at a time, so the hybrid system works well for them, there is a computer system where the employees book a workstation.

I also think that in the future the Companies which offer more flexible working arrangements, will find it easier to attract staff.

mewkins · 23/09/2022 08:32

@Seaswimminginwinter if your job doesn't lend itself to working from home then you're not really in a position to make that judgement. I was employed in my current job to work from home. It's in my contract and it IS how I work. I started as a home worker and the induction etc has all gone smoothly. As a single parent it works well for me. I get the work done, I work hard (and can work late if needed) and I still get to be around for the kids. It really is a step forward for working parents.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/09/2022 08:30

These attitudes are really damaging for people like me.

WFH has basically enabled me to be able to do my job. I'm a lone parent so working from an office is physically challenging due to school and childcare considerations and prohibitively expensive. I've just about got through my daughter's primary school career because my firm is flexible enough not to mither me about presenteeism.

The pandemic was a nightmare but the post pandemic approach to WFH has been revolutionary for people like me in that its normalised something which should have been normal for decades.

It isn't only a selfish consideration for me. It's also productivity. I am about four times more productive at home than I am in the office because a) I'm not on a train for three hours, b) I'm not dicking around making tea and gossiping. People who struggle to motivate themselves when working alone seem to really struggle with the idea that others are self-driven.

In my office currently there's a real polarisation between the people who realise that remote or hybrid working is now a normal and natural part of life and those who basically want to wind the clock back to 1999 just because they are jealous of other people's inability to self-motivate.

Yes there are some benefits of office working: its better for younger staff learning on the job and mentoring etc. But these advantages are overstated and being used as an excuse for backlash against other people (mainly mothers who have childcare commitments) for doing their jobs efficiently.

KathyWilliams · 23/09/2022 08:29

ErrolTheDragon · 23/09/2022 08:02

I personally think that WFH is the spawn of Satan. I am sick of not being able to ring up any organisation and have a sensible conversation with someone which isn't interrupted by children/dogs/postmen. Either that, or whoever I'm ringing up wants to tell me their life story, presumably because they are missing the social side of being at work. It's a bloody nightmare, and one of the very worst things about Covid.

Really? We've done quite a lot of phoning banks and service providers over the last couple of years. I've only once heard a kid in the background (during lockdown when the schools were closed) - mostly we've found that the phone is answered faster than it used to be.

My local council are still WFH. I used to be able to walk into the office and speak to someone (usually had to wait 5-10 mins, if at all). Now I have to ring them. The phone is answered, if at all, after about 50 mins. Then there was the man at a call centre who went on and on and on about his family, children, illnesses, etc, etc. When I said (very politely) that I really just needed the answer to my question because I had a lot to do, he said he was WFH and hated it, and wanted to talk to people.

DashboardConfessional · 23/09/2022 08:28

I did 3 months WFH as a financial services admin when I had just started and it was an actual nightmare. Trying to find out which broker the caller had had a missed call from, getting questions I couldn't answer with nobody to ask, and having to post documents back and forth instead of passing them desk to desk. DH however loves WFH and has been doing it since 2018.

I'm all for it in general - we benefit massively. But I'm not so sure certain jobs have to offer hybrid. In my quasi-reception role you don't necessarily (I stress necessarily) want someone who wants WFH because they hate noise and people (as opposed to someone who wants WFH for caring/commute reasons).

Swipe left for the next trending thread