Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 10:05

Irrespective of whether people WFH or not, the mad rush hour commute when half the population needs to be on the road/train at the same time is outdated and frankly ridiculous in this day and age

Yes exactly this.

Maymaymay · 23/09/2022 10:05

ginghamstarfish · 23/09/2022 09:44

Surely most government offices, civil service should be going back to the office, at least part time, as we have seen a clear decline in services such as passports, driving licences etc and no doubt much more. Of course some who WFH are honest and work their full hours (or more in some cases) but there are also many who take advantage. Just heard on R4 this morning that many companies say that wfh staff are less productive, and any attempts to remotely monitor are met with howls of outrage

I agree ! Something needs to change at this level.

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 10:04

Surely most government offices, civil service should be going back to the office, at least part time, as we have seen a clear decline in services such as passports, driving licences etc and no doubt much more

There's a difference between the central government offices in London and elsewhere, which are not customer-facing, and therefore people can work anywhere; and customer-facing call centres etc, where you need to be in the workplace to get the job done properly. Although the DVLA delays weren't and aren't down to WFH, they were down to people not working at all and going on strike. Passport delays are probably simply down to demand.

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 23/09/2022 10:03

Dh works from home 3 days a week and he's top of the billable hours chart by a reasonable margin. I think it's personality to a degree, he likes being able to structure those days around the family but he also does way more than his contracted hours per week across the average week. Personally I like the separation of home/work and would never want a job involving wfh.

Mybestyear · 23/09/2022 10:03

Hybrid working is the way to go! My job lends itself to WFH part of the time. I could probably do 90% from home but chose to do a roughly 50-50 split.

I've been saying for years (way before Covid) that big companies should be made to facilitate hybrid working where appropriate. For context, I am a nurse but in a mixed clinical/office role and DH is a hospital based health care professional so I know lots of people don't have the option to WFH. I will be flamed for this but I also said if I ruled the world, pensioners would be kept off the roads for non essential travel until after 10am to ease the rush hour traffic - my 70 plus year old neighbour likes to get her shopping done by 9am so she can have 'the rest of the day to herself' to basically sit and watch TV or potter around in the garden - and she goes every day as otherwise she is just 'storing the stuff for Morrisons'!! WTF.

By facilitating a proportion of the workforce to WFH as appropriate, we could massively cut pollution, reduce the commute time for those who need to travel to work/school run/hospital appointments etc, protect the roads from wear and tear etc. Hybrid working means that supporting businesses such as coffee shops would still have customers - okay so maybe fewer but people would be more likely to spend more/treat themselves on the days they were in the office as they would be saving on petrol/bus and train fairs etc. When I was full time in the office, I always took my own lunch as the commute was very expensive but now when I am only in a few days, me and my colleagues always go out for lunch and a social catch up so we definately spend more in the surrounding cafes.

I think it shoud be more 'official' though eg help with heating/electricity costs for employees WFH. And employers should be made to demonstrate efficiency and tackle employees taking the piss and support those not able to function as well at home eg by providing the correct equipment. It really annoys me when people claim to be just as efficient/more efficient WFH yet when you contact the company , you get a message saying they will take longer to respond as people are WFH!!! People can't have it both ways.

Irrespective of whether people WFH or not, the mad rush hour commute when half the population needs to be on the road/train at the same time is outdated and frankly ridiculous in this day and age.

Maymaymay · 23/09/2022 10:02

I'm sure people who are ambitious are doing a great job, unfortunately not everyone is.

I've seen threads on here with tips on how to look like you are working (mouse on mirror, gadgets brought from amazon) when you are napping and not working.

Companies aren't running properly on ground level. My friend works in insurance and does everything she can to not answer the phone.

It now takes 21 days to hear back from my local council as noone is on the phone, it took 3 months to get registered with my energy company. Their phone lines still blame covid.

It's not working.

katepilar · 23/09/2022 10:02

I am not sure whether the post is about you thinking people are not right saying they are more productive when working at home or about you not feeling comfortable on your day off with a husband working from home.

I have the experience that with my job when I am at home and get to sit down at the time that suits me I am way more productive then at work when theres people around me or I am just not physically or mentally at best for work. I have been working from home since years ago so have fairly long experience with this, not just over the last two years. My colleagues who now get one day a week to wfh if they want to say the same. It very much depends on the work you need to do and if you are able to actually make yourself sit down and put the hours in.

ASimpleLampoon · 23/09/2022 10:00

I was WFH years before covid on account o f my and my child's disabilities, no affordable or suitable childcare and no family support. Not very well paying or many hours but a lifeline that kept me sane and in the workforce and less isolated. If WFH had been a thing years earlier I might as saved the career I worked so hard to get and lost.

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 10:00

I've worked from home in some capacity since 2005. But I agree you need dedicated space, you can't be expected to tiptoe around someone. If you don't have the space they need to go into the office or work in a local co-working hub.

his commute was a 30min cycle and he hasn't replaced that exercise which isn't good I often do a "fake commute" where I go out for a 20 minute walk before work/the school rush starts. If I miss the morning window, I go out for a walk at lunchtime, and try to do at least 2 miles.

SummerWinterSummerWinter · 23/09/2022 09:58

I would have resigned from my career if WFH hadn't appeared - I couldn't handle the two hours each day of commuting, and then having to sometimes work until 11pm and still being an hour away from the office.

The working until 11pm still sometimes happens, the deadlines still happen, the work still has to get done to the same level - except now, I can work to get the job done, then close my laptop and go to bed.

I am definitely more productive, and happier (therefore more willing to work hard). Depends on your industry and role I think.

SleeplessInEngland · 23/09/2022 09:52

ginghamstarfish · 23/09/2022 09:44

Surely most government offices, civil service should be going back to the office, at least part time, as we have seen a clear decline in services such as passports, driving licences etc and no doubt much more. Of course some who WFH are honest and work their full hours (or more in some cases) but there are also many who take advantage. Just heard on R4 this morning that many companies say that wfh staff are less productive, and any attempts to remotely monitor are met with howls of outrage

I don't understand why those same companies find it so difficult to set reasonable targets for whatever the work is and then talk to employees if they're not met. WFH doesn't change that basic practice. But I guess it's easier to moan on the radio.

browneyes77 · 23/09/2022 09:46

I think the problem is that too many people think WFH only came in because of Covid.

Whereas many of us have been working efficiently and productively from home for years because our job is a remote role.

I’ve been working in my field based job for nearly 9 years. It’s a regional role. It’s always been WFH because of the nature of the role and because we only have 1 office and that is 100 miles away from where I live. So I can hardly pop into the office.

Plenty of us have been working from home productively and with high performance for many years before Covid reared its ugly head. WFH is not a new concept.

Roselilly36 · 23/09/2022 09:45

We all wfh, home of 4 adults, not a covid thing, something DH & I have done for years. We do have a custom designed & built garden office through, makes life easier.

Chipsahoy · 23/09/2022 09:44

My dh has been remote working for 11 years now and it was always called that not wfh. We have accepted he always needs a dedicated office space so have purchased homes accordingly. I can imagine if you aren’t set up for it then it must be much more difficult. I think that’s part of the problem. A few more years down the line and those things may improve. However certainly plenty of people simply cannot afford an office in their home. So I don’t see how it’s sustainable for so many employers to have remote working only.
In the past before we moved rurally, my dh would work in a co working centre for free which may be an option for some people. It was provided by a university

ginghamstarfish · 23/09/2022 09:44

Surely most government offices, civil service should be going back to the office, at least part time, as we have seen a clear decline in services such as passports, driving licences etc and no doubt much more. Of course some who WFH are honest and work their full hours (or more in some cases) but there are also many who take advantage. Just heard on R4 this morning that many companies say that wfh staff are less productive, and any attempts to remotely monitor are met with howls of outrage

OhmygodDont · 23/09/2022 09:43

I agree it does depend on the job though.

I don’t actually work with anyone. Although we are a department our work is solely ours individually and we only “work together” if some numpty has underestimated the time needed to complete a job. Even then it gets cut down into smaller part so I will do part A, next person does part B etc.

TheMoops · 23/09/2022 09:43

I don't like listening to someone washing the dishes while on a call with me....

If anyone is actually doing that then they're just unprofessional and would be regardless of where they worked.

TheMoops · 23/09/2022 09:42

Works brilliantly for me.
I wfh 3/4 days a week and I'm probably more productive as I don't have people interrupting me.

As a parent to a young child it has also helped me develop and progress in my career as I have a degree of flexibility.

Ninjasan · 23/09/2022 09:38

YANBU. I've never worked from home - even in the middle of Covid. I know exactly which company's employees work from home. I choose different suppliers. Nobody ever answers emails, there are always many people cc'd but no reply. Nothing is ever solved so I take our business somewhere else. Councils are the worst offenders but also other big companies (shipping lines, agents). I don't like listening to someone washing the dishes while on a call with me....

stopwindingeachotherup · 23/09/2022 09:34

DS got his first job, his team wfh 4 days a week so he really struggled to get a handle on what the job entails as asking questions involves emailing or phoning rather than just turning to someone next to you. He didn’t make his probation and I think in part it was down to lack of training and being left to get on with it. Sure, it’s a bonus to those already settled but Think it’s really tough for those just starting out and I feel really sorry for them.

TheTeddyBears · 23/09/2022 09:32

I wfh and I love it. On the times I went back to the office I can't get anything done. I chat to everyone and it's very noisy. I end up having to log on at night to catch up. I can get more done at home and if there are quieter times I can get on with some housework (doesn't happen very often). I wouldn't go bk to being office based now. I also use my lunch break to pick my dd up from school and then go bk to working once I've sorted her out with drink/snack.

I actually don't like it if dh is home when I'm working it puts me off. I often work from kitchen but we are doing some bedroom shuffles shortly and I will be making the spare room my office.

gretr · 23/09/2022 09:31

I only get about 50% of the work done that I can do at home if I go into the office - so many distractions. My quality of life has improved and it has made me a lot more productive. Just my experience, but those who have pushed for everyone to come back are those who are pretty work-shy and rely on presenteeism to show they’re working, rather than actually doing any work!!

Owlsinmybedroom · 23/09/2022 09:30

I am more productive working from home, I did it pre pandemic.

More to the point, working from home allows someone like me, with multiple disabilities, to get a better job and work more hours than I could ever hope to do in an office etc.

Working from home has been shown countless times in the pandemic to be more beneficial to disabled people, yet every week it seems there is another thread on here moaning about people working from home.

Must be nice to be able to work out of the home without having to spare a thought for the people who find that too hard.

I bet there is a cross over between the people who moan about WFH and the people who moan about those on benefits (like you know disabled people who can't work outside the home)

Franca123 · 23/09/2022 09:29

Some of these posts complaining about wfh show a lack of knowledge about utilising the various tools available. Screen sharing is brilliant for the type of work I do. Digital whiteboards to collaborate on brain storming. Teams. My teams is going constantly with people asking me quick questions or calling me to run something past me. In the office, in person, I used to find that volume of contact overwhelming and tiring. Via teams, I bang it out making sure everyone I work with is aligned and understands my direction. In my role, I often need to say something multiple times to finally get everyone heading in the same direction. Teams is excellent for helping me do this. I employ a lot of women with young children. Right now I have two pregnant women. They tell me all the time what a life saver wfh is. Many are like me whereby travelling to the office is a major strain on their family life.

TirisfalPumpkin · 23/09/2022 09:27

I love it - as a person with a developmental disability who can’t hack the commute/office environment, for the first time in my life I’ve got a shot at a career. Asked for this as a reasonable adjustment before, not possible, until covid hit and suddenly it was.

I’ve now got a perm role with contractual home working, when before I was temping and struggling to manage the health impact of the job. Have been able to coach and train others remotely, take on additional responsibilities, even step in for management, and my productivity is not far off double what it was in the office.