Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel WFH has had its day a bit?

493 replies

Seaswimminginwinter · 23/09/2022 06:10

Bosses think workers do less from home - bbc article

My job doesn’t lend itself to WFH but I have noticed on nearly every thread on here about WFH, people insist that they are more productive. However, I have to admit that this doesn’t match with my experiences. But I am one person so maybe I’ve been unlucky, except this article is quite interesting about perceptions.

I also think it changes homes and areas. My own DH is WFH today and it is my day off, meaning I will spend it feeling as f I am I the way in my own home. Homes aren’t meant to be offices.

I get there are advantages but overall I don’t think it works well at all.

OP posts:
ILikeHotWaterBottles · 23/09/2022 10:30

I hate office working. Wfh suits me much better and if my company said you're coming back in, I'd say bye. There's other jobs out there for wfh, and I'm not loyal if you're going to ruin my work-life balance.

kc431 · 23/09/2022 10:29

Thing is, some people are just lazy, it’s a very hard trait to change. They have to live on this planet too! If they were sat on benefits people would moan they’re sponging off the system. If the office is what gets certain people to be less lazy, then surely it’s a good thing. I don’t know of any companies “forcing” anyone in, but if it gets some people to work a bit harder, it’s a good thing? One size doesn’t fit all and I certainly can’t relate to being more productive at home or even enjoying it.

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 23/09/2022 10:28

We love it here. We have a 4 bed home with one of the bedrooms fully kitted out as an office. When we’re done we just shut the door and that’s that. It’s our day off today and I don’t feel at all like I’m at work.

DameHelena · 23/09/2022 10:27

ThisAintNoPartyThisAintNoDisco · 23/09/2022 10:20

YANBU.
I can absolutely see the upsides for those actually doing the WFH, but when it’s my day off and dh decides to wfh, it does feel as though I’m still at work too.
Dh on a work call seems to permeate the whole house. I don’t like that part of our home is now permanently not part of our home (even though he does have another actual office he can use) And being shushed and shooed out when in my own home, if anyone says something at the wrong moment, irks me to the max🙄

Does he not have a door he can shut? (and get soundproofed if he's that loud).

My DP WFH for a while in Covid and, if he'd shushed and shooed me out while he was on a call (or if my lodger did, for that matter), they'd get very short shrift from me.
Then again, rather than them shushing and me silently resenting it, if any issues about noise/use of space etc did come up we all just talked about it and sorted it out like adults.

Spanielsarepainless · 23/09/2022 10:26

I've had to resort to getting my MP to chase up something with a public body, after my trying for eighteen months, with their excuse people WFH. The sooner these people get their backsides in gear and start doing the job they are paid to do in the place they are expected to do it, the better.

Leftbutcameback · 23/09/2022 10:26

I think it depends on your personal circumstances and the role and organisation. I agree it works really well for some, and for others about the same as being in the office.

I really feel for those who live in house shares or studios. I remember being in an office job for the first time and how useful it was to listen to calls and ask others for their opinions. That's why we sat next to our supervisors. My whole social life in a new city was also through work. There must be some poor people who didn't get to have the proper uni experience and are now missing out on the new office experience, and possibly just sat in their room at home.

queenmeadhbh · 23/09/2022 10:25

OhTheLeetleHandsAndFeetle · 23/09/2022 06:17

Works brilliantly here. I go out to work, DH WFM. He works really long hours, as has various international meetings in different time zones. WFM means he can structure his day so he can talk to China at 5 am and America at 9pm or whatever, but we still get to see him and spend time with him. He is someone who finds it easy to focus on work and is quite self-disciplined, whereas I would be forever mooching off to hang the washing out.

Stupid but genuine question…what does “WFM” stand for? Work from maison? Work from mothership? I am stumped!

Queuesarasarah · 23/09/2022 10:24

I’m hybrid but wfh some hours means I can be a mum and have a career. I do both well (if I do say so myself!) so I’m incredibly in favour of it. But I do have a colleague who is, let’s say, less than conscientious (he is a man and isn’t caring for his kids so no ‘reason’). It’s annoying and I feel personally ‘offended’ by it even though I’m not his boss and it only indirectly effects me when we work on projects together.
Things like not answering your phone or emails or returning them for days is just being plain lazy and probably nothing to do with wfh and everything to do with his personal work ethic!

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/09/2022 10:24

kc431 · 23/09/2022 10:21

I definitely wouldn’t insist on dragging other people in to the office if I ever got to management level, of course not everyone’s like me. But for me PERSONALLY, and my husband, the office is much better. I think it’s because my job doesn’t really have many meetings, and the tasks don’t really have deadlines, so it’s hard to be disciplined and concentrate on coding 8 hours a day. In my last job my manager didn’t give a shit and was always busy so I basically did nothing for a year and got severely depressed - I left.

That's fine, but when wider work policy which affects the lives of millions of people (and to the massive detriment of working women in particular) is made by people who can't get their act together it sticks in the throat a bit.

Namenic · 23/09/2022 10:22

I’d take a pay cut for wfh job or 1 day per week in office. If I had a choice, I won’t go back to full time in office, but I would suck it up if I absolutely had to. I’m more likely to do overtime and work weekends if I wfh and don’t have to do extra commuting hours.

kc431 · 23/09/2022 10:21

I definitely wouldn’t insist on dragging other people in to the office if I ever got to management level, of course not everyone’s like me. But for me PERSONALLY, and my husband, the office is much better. I think it’s because my job doesn’t really have many meetings, and the tasks don’t really have deadlines, so it’s hard to be disciplined and concentrate on coding 8 hours a day. In my last job my manager didn’t give a shit and was always busy so I basically did nothing for a year and got severely depressed - I left.

ThisAintNoPartyThisAintNoDisco · 23/09/2022 10:20

YANBU.
I can absolutely see the upsides for those actually doing the WFH, but when it’s my day off and dh decides to wfh, it does feel as though I’m still at work too.
Dh on a work call seems to permeate the whole house. I don’t like that part of our home is now permanently not part of our home (even though he does have another actual office he can use) And being shushed and shooed out when in my own home, if anyone says something at the wrong moment, irks me to the max🙄

Mybestyear · 23/09/2022 10:18

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 10:08

I will be flamed for this but I also said if I ruled the world, pensioners would be kept off the roads for non essential travel until after 10am to ease the rush hour traffic

Ha ha, maybe supermarkets could offer 10% off one (weekday) morning a week like B&Q does/did for the over 65s (67s?), to encourage retired people not to do their shopping on Saturday mornings!

Also far more cycle paths and (more) priority for cyclists and pedestrians to get more people out of their cars when taking kids to school. Not just for environmental reasons, but to free up the roads for people who actually need to be driving, and aren't sitting near the school with their engines running for half an hour plus.

@gatehouseoffleet - it bamboozles me. she can still drive and I cannot fathom why she would want the stress of driving during the rush hour when she doesn't need to. I'm a good 20 years plus younger and hate driving in the rush hour as everyone is so impatient.

DH was talking to a patient at work who was in his 70s and said he likes to get his clothes all laid out the night before so he could make a quick start on his shopping in the morning - he'd been a shift worker doing day and night shifts before retirement so it wasn't like he couldn't give up his morning routine. I used to imagine him sleeping on his back, body totally straight, fully-clothed so he could eject himself from bed and get going at 730am!! I myself am easing into semi-retirement and the absolute best thing is having my coffee and wandering around in my pjs until at least 10am on my non-working days!

madasawethen · 23/09/2022 10:17

In the office works well for micromanagers, slackers, people incapable of organising their own day, gossips, etc.

I don't miss the fish in the microwave fuckers at all.

WFH opens up opportunities for the disabled and carers to work and have some other adult interactions.

OP your DH can sort his problem by creating a dedicated work space.

kc431 · 23/09/2022 10:16

Mybestyear · 23/09/2022 10:11

no offence @kc431 but these are all things you can change! You say you managed to knuckle down when doing your degree and get a first so it shows you can do it. But people taking the piss like this will spoil it for others.

I’ve been WFH for 2 years now and it’s been a very unproductive 2 years! At uni I couldn’t do any work at home, only the library, and it’s a similar story now. The knuckling down kind of hinges on being in a work-y place surrounded by other people also working. A lot of people I speak to also say they take the piss a lot. I probably get more done in my 1 office day than the rest of the week! Everyone is different and I’m just giving my POV.

jeaux90 · 23/09/2022 10:14

Tech industry we have been doing this for years, especially hybrid working.

Works really well, gives flexibility and better for the environment.

Thepeopleversuswork · 23/09/2022 10:14

@kc431

For me, WFH hasn’t been a good thing. As a naturally lazy person I find it really hard to motivate myself and not get distracted at home. I’m someone who does best under micromanaging. I’ve always needed to be in a “place of work” to knuckle down and concentrate - the only reason I got a first at uni is because I went to the silent section of the library and sat there 6 days a week! When I can knuckle down I’m really good at my job. At home I’m scrolling on my phone, on the Daily Mail, cleaning etc. I’m writing this now instead of working! In the office my manager sits in front of me so I have to actually work.

Thanks for your honesty... but many of us are not like this and we get tired when people like this tar us with the same brush.

I have a team member who is very evangelical about how everyone needs to be in the office eight hours a day five days a week. This person cheerfully admits to being a "dosser" when she's at home and is permanently chatting and making teas etc when she's in the office.

I'm someone who has been forced to be single minded at work because I'm a lone parent and I have to work twice as hard as anyone else not to fall behind and to counter any suspicion that I might be a pisstaker. I find working at home vastly more productive mainly because I don't get dragged into gossiping, time-wasting and pointless office politics from people who are more interested in this than in the actual work itself.

It's highly frustrating when these same people turn around and say people can't be trusted to WFH and should all be forced in.

Annoyed200722 · 23/09/2022 10:13

It works very well in DHs team. He works in a global role and has always ha so calls at very strange times. He used to leave he house at 7, get home around 7-8 and often had evening calls. We never saw him. Since lockdown, his team has been more efficient, he has achieved more thy an ever before (probably because he's not constantly knackered from his commute), and we get to see him more. His life is so much more balanced, and clearly his work is better. He has now gone over to hybrid working, and this seems to work well too.

Thistleinthenight · 23/09/2022 10:12

I've done it on and off for 30 years. It works fine if you're disciplined and goal oriented.

Mybestyear · 23/09/2022 10:11

kc431 · 23/09/2022 10:06

For me, WFH hasn’t been a good thing. As a naturally lazy person I find it really hard to motivate myself and not get distracted at home. I’m someone who does best under micromanaging. I’ve always needed to be in a “place of work” to knuckle down and concentrate - the only reason I got a first at uni is because I went to the silent section of the library and sat there 6 days a week! When I can knuckle down I’m really good at my job. At home I’m scrolling on my phone, on the Daily Mail, cleaning etc. I’m writing this now instead of working! In the office my manager sits in front of me so I have to actually work.

I do want to progress and not stay at the same level forever, but WFH is definitely hindering me in that. I live an hour from the office so come in once a week, but if I lived locally I’d be in every day. My husband is exactly the same as me. Spends all day watching Youtube and football. I also prefer the social side of the office, putting on makeup, nice clothes and driving with the radio on. Much better mental health than slobbing around at home in a tracksuit.

no offence @kc431 but these are all things you can change! You say you managed to knuckle down when doing your degree and get a first so it shows you can do it. But people taking the piss like this will spoil it for others.

apairofblueeyes100 · 23/09/2022 10:11

I have been happily remote working since the start of the pandemic and have moved recently to a hybrid working policy so going into the office 1-2 days a week.

I was initially dreading it but I have enjoyed the interactions with colleagues I haven't seen in person for a long time, going out for a coffee etc. There are definite benefits of face to face meetings for communication, training and the general building of relationships.

However ..... my office days are far less productive, I get less actual work done. I am in an analytics role so really benefit from a quiet working environment - something I don't get in an open plan office.

Generally though, hybrid working is here to stay - something I am quite happy about.

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 10:08

I will be flamed for this but I also said if I ruled the world, pensioners would be kept off the roads for non essential travel until after 10am to ease the rush hour traffic

Ha ha, maybe supermarkets could offer 10% off one (weekday) morning a week like B&Q does/did for the over 65s (67s?), to encourage retired people not to do their shopping on Saturday mornings!

Also far more cycle paths and (more) priority for cyclists and pedestrians to get more people out of their cars when taking kids to school. Not just for environmental reasons, but to free up the roads for people who actually need to be driving, and aren't sitting near the school with their engines running for half an hour plus.

Mybestyear · 23/09/2022 10:08

ASimpleLampoon · 23/09/2022 10:00

I was WFH years before covid on account o f my and my child's disabilities, no affordable or suitable childcare and no family support. Not very well paying or many hours but a lifeline that kept me sane and in the workforce and less isolated. If WFH had been a thing years earlier I might as saved the career I worked so hard to get and lost.

@ASimpleLampoon - I'm sorry to hear that about your career - that must have been devastating for you. I really hope a good thing to come out of the pandemic is that companies are more flexible so that people are helped into employment when they have challenging circumstances and are retained when their circumstances change. 💐

Wheredoestheblackfluffcomefrom · 23/09/2022 10:07

My industry have been doing hybrid for 21 years. It’s a mature model when people are mature, trustworthy and work hard.

I have various spaces around the house that I can work from. I put work away at the weekend

kc431 · 23/09/2022 10:06

For me, WFH hasn’t been a good thing. As a naturally lazy person I find it really hard to motivate myself and not get distracted at home. I’m someone who does best under micromanaging. I’ve always needed to be in a “place of work” to knuckle down and concentrate - the only reason I got a first at uni is because I went to the silent section of the library and sat there 6 days a week! When I can knuckle down I’m really good at my job. At home I’m scrolling on my phone, on the Daily Mail, cleaning etc. I’m writing this now instead of working! In the office my manager sits in front of me so I have to actually work.

I do want to progress and not stay at the same level forever, but WFH is definitely hindering me in that. I live an hour from the office so come in once a week, but if I lived locally I’d be in every day. My husband is exactly the same as me. Spends all day watching Youtube and football. I also prefer the social side of the office, putting on makeup, nice clothes and driving with the radio on. Much better mental health than slobbing around at home in a tracksuit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread