Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Buy Shein??

342 replies

GarthElgarsGlasses · 22/09/2022 22:39

Hi, tempted to make some purchases from Shein and wondering whether anyone who’s bought from them would recommend their clothes or not?! Money’s right but really need some new winter clothes, however as Shein is so cheap I’m sceptical! Any experiences of their clothes welcomed! Thanks!

OP posts:
Discovereads · 23/09/2022 09:14

Liila · 23/09/2022 09:12

'They want fashionable clothes that fit and don't break the bank. Most of the high street is made in China or Bangladesh.'

This. Shein just cuts out the middleman and sells direct.

They do that too. But again, they also use slave labour. Having some ethical cost cutting mechanisms in place doesn’t excuse the elephant in the room of slave labour.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 23/09/2022 09:13

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 09:09

They are needs if someone has lost lots of weight what are they supposed to wear ? Or their clothes don't fit anymore? 🤣

I'm losing lots of weight. I order from Vinted! Not rocket science. 😵‍💫
Most of what I've bought in smaller sizes is new, under a tenner and I'll re-list it when I'm done.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 09:13

X posted with you Choopi sorry, must RTFT in future Grin

Liila · 23/09/2022 09:12

'They want fashionable clothes that fit and don't break the bank. Most of the high street is made in China or Bangladesh.'

This. Shein just cuts out the middleman and sells direct.

Discovereads · 23/09/2022 09:11

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 09:09

They are needs if someone has lost lots of weight what are they supposed to wear ? Or their clothes don't fit anymore? 🤣

Aren’t you the provocateur
You may need clothes but you don’t need to buy new clothes made by slaves, there are other options just as cheap and far more ethical.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 23/09/2022 09:11

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 09:04

Most of the high street are made in sweatshops if you never shop on the high street ok but most people do. I've just spent £180 on a dress which the label says made in China , my branded hoodies say made in Bangladesh. If you have to replace entire wardrobes with DC or massive weight loss and don't want to spend loads on each piece they are fine. Vinted are ok but it relies on people selling clothes I want in my size.

You can check if your brands sign up to the Bangladesh Accord- H&M, Zara, Uniqlo did.

Discovereads · 23/09/2022 09:10

If you have to replace entire wardrobes with DC or massive weight loss and don't want to spend loads on each piece they are fine.

Its not fine at all. Every £ you save is blood money. It’s money you have ripped out of the hands of a slave/child slave labourer who should be getting it to better their lives but instead are being literally worked to death while being forced to live in abject squalor with barely enough food to survive.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 09:09

m.youtube.com/watch?v=st5Ij9fz754

This is worth a watch

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 09:09

Discovereads · 23/09/2022 09:06

No one “needs” or is forced by being poor to buy clothes made by slaves! You can buy cheap clothes at the same price or lower without buying from companies like SHEIN.

It’s not a “need” to refuse to buy second hand. It’s not a “need” to refuse to go to jumble sales where each item of clothing is 50p.

New clothes are not needs, it’s trampling on those worse off than you. I’d rather wear my clothes until they fall apart than buy something produced by a slave.

It’s your demand for the products they make that keeps them in slavery.

They are needs if someone has lost lots of weight what are they supposed to wear ? Or their clothes don't fit anymore? 🤣

itrytomakemyway · 23/09/2022 09:07

I decided a few years ago that I was no longer going to contribute to throwing yet more perfectly good clothes into landfill. I also worked out just how much money I had wasted over the years buying clothes that I really did not need.

I went through my wardrobes and sorted all of my old clothes that were lingering in the back and started to wear them again - nothing at all wrong with them, I had just got bored with them.

I am now only buying clothes that I actually need, when things needs replacing. If I have a wedding or event to go to I have been borrowing dresses for that 'one off' event from my sisters, or buying second hand on ebay. This is actually also very practical as our High Street actually has so few shops left now it is very dfficult to buy in person. I currently need new boots. The only shoe shop in town is Clarks, and I just cannot justify spending what they are asking for shoes in there.

I am more than happy to wear vintage or secnd hand - call it what you will. I always wash clothes I buy like this, so I just don't see the problem. Those posters who are appauled at wearing something someone else has worn, can I ask you a question - do you stay in hotels? Do you think the sheets you sleep n, or the towels you use are brand new just for you. Of course not, they will have been slept in and used by many, many people before you. A second hand dress is likely to have only been worn by one other person. That new dress you are wearing - chances are it has been tried on by other people before you put it on. And don't get me started on people who buy clothes, wear once for a special occasion and then take back to the shop for a refund. Lots of things we wear might have been worn by someone else.

It really is time for us to stop wasting resources and money on fast fashion. Anyone who buys clothes knowing that they were produced cheaply through the misery of others should hang their head in shame.

Discovereads · 23/09/2022 09:06

Liila · 23/09/2022 08:58

It must be lovely to live in a world where one only purchases locally sourced ethical garments. Or even a delightful smock from vinted which may do for lunch out with the WI or whilst wafting about Waitrose

In the real world there is a cost of living crisis, people need cheap clothes for their families and shein provides a perfectly good service.

No one “needs” or is forced by being poor to buy clothes made by slaves! You can buy cheap clothes at the same price or lower without buying from companies like SHEIN.

It’s not a “need” to refuse to buy second hand. It’s not a “need” to refuse to go to jumble sales where each item of clothing is 50p.

New clothes are not needs, it’s trampling on those worse off than you. I’d rather wear my clothes until they fall apart than buy something produced by a slave.

It’s your demand for the products they make that keeps them in slavery.

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 09:06

Stayathomenamechange · 23/09/2022 09:03

One of the things I find depressing is how popular it is among teens/tweens/students. We keep hearing that they're the generation that cares more about environmental and human rights issues, they're appalled (rightly) by Britain's role in the slave trade... but at the same time they want their slave-made Shein haul in individual ziplock bags.

I realise that there are plenty of young people into thrifting, vintage etc, but I feel that there's significant overlap between those two groups.

I'm not there yet with my two dd's, they're not yet bothered about clothes or labels, but how do parents of teens navigate this?

They want fashionable clothes that fit and don't break the bank. Most of the high street is made in China or Bangladesh.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 09:05

Choopi · 22/09/2022 23:22

Like others have said if money is tight shop second hand. Shein is the worst company out there for fast fashion. The ethics behind the whole thing is dreadful.

It's also the wsy they drive demand too. I've seen an article which shows they launch something like as many new lines in one month as the likes of Mango and Zara doom three months.

No one needs new stuff that often.

Most returns apparently end up in landfill too as processing them is too expensive compared to cost.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 23/09/2022 09:05

Liila · 23/09/2022 08:58

It must be lovely to live in a world where one only purchases locally sourced ethical garments. Or even a delightful smock from vinted which may do for lunch out with the WI or whilst wafting about Waitrose

In the real world there is a cost of living crisis, people need cheap clothes for their families and shein provides a perfectly good service.

Take it you've never actually been on Depop or Vinted?

You could get your kids clothes both cheaply & ethically without a smock or a Waitrose in sight.

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 09:04

Most of the high street are made in sweatshops if you never shop on the high street ok but most people do. I've just spent £180 on a dress which the label says made in China , my branded hoodies say made in Bangladesh. If you have to replace entire wardrobes with DC or massive weight loss and don't want to spend loads on each piece they are fine. Vinted are ok but it relies on people selling clothes I want in my size.

Stayathomenamechange · 23/09/2022 09:03

One of the things I find depressing is how popular it is among teens/tweens/students. We keep hearing that they're the generation that cares more about environmental and human rights issues, they're appalled (rightly) by Britain's role in the slave trade... but at the same time they want their slave-made Shein haul in individual ziplock bags.

I realise that there are plenty of young people into thrifting, vintage etc, but I feel that there's significant overlap between those two groups.

I'm not there yet with my two dd's, they're not yet bothered about clothes or labels, but how do parents of teens navigate this?

scissorsandsellotape · 23/09/2022 09:00

I know about Shein
How do you find out the welfare record for a company?
I saw some bits at chichi london

WildfellAnne · 23/09/2022 09:00

Cosycover · 23/09/2022 08:36

I bought my DD her some winter clothes from Shein.

5 leggings and top sets
3 tshirts
2 dresses
2 coats

£75.

She will out grow them for next year so this seems economical to me.

It’s economical for you, at the expense of the slaves and the environment. Why does your child need two coats?

Liila · 23/09/2022 08:58

It must be lovely to live in a world where one only purchases locally sourced ethical garments. Or even a delightful smock from vinted which may do for lunch out with the WI or whilst wafting about Waitrose

In the real world there is a cost of living crisis, people need cheap clothes for their families and shein provides a perfectly good service.

Brefugee · 23/09/2022 08:57

There is absolutely zero chance that anyone on this thread has never purchased something with an unethical background.

this is also true. But the majority of people drawing attention to unethical practices do try, where possible, to buy ethically. Most people i know do. And most of the under 30s i know would rather by 2nd hand anyway. etc

It isn't realistic to expect 100% of consumers and their purchases to buy from, say Community Clothing. (look them up) That's never going to happen. But if lots of people pay attention and do what they can, it will make a difference.

And put pressure on governments and companies to up their game in terms of human rights and sustainability. It benefits all of us.

DrBlackbird · 23/09/2022 08:54

KassandraOfSparta · 23/09/2022 08:37

@DrBlackbird the problem is. Those of us who know all this and are appalled are not buying from Shein.

Those who are buying do not care. Or think their desire for cheap clothes is more important. Or their grandchildren's desire.

Yes might be true @KassandraOfSparta but possibly they’re buying because they’re unaware about the conditions in which these ultra cheap clothes are being made. How would they know if they’d never read about it? With information, perhaps some posters will rethink their purchasing options.

Thanks to OP for asking the question in the first place.

@Cosycover of course all our purchases has some unethical impact even if it’s ‘just’ environmental. However, it is incorrect to say all firms are equally unethical. That’s just not true. H&M, for example, was one of the first clothing firms to sign the Bangladesh Accord despite not having clothes made in the Rana Plaza, which collapsed in 2013 killing over 2000, mostly young women, working there making inexpensive clothes for the western markets.

You can make a difference, albeit small, by choosing carefully.

Brefugee · 23/09/2022 08:54

On top of the environmental and human rights issues, they blatantly rip off the designs of smaller companies who are actually making clothes thoughtfully and ethically.

yep. Not only slave labour and bad for the environment, but ripping off small companies. Often set up by women on maternity leave etc

Discovereads · 23/09/2022 08:53

Liila · 23/09/2022 08:49

Lots of products are made in China. Shein cut out the middle man and supply direct to the customer instead of selling to UK stores who then hike the prices massively.

Shein clothes are good quality, last well unlike Primark stuff. Take about a week to 10 days to arrive.

That’s not why they’re so cheap. And just like any nation, there are both paid workers working for ethical companies and there are the unpaid slave labourers working for human traffickers. You can’t lump all “made in China” products under one umbrella.

ferretface · 23/09/2022 08:52

Just buy from vinted or eBay. There's loads of BNWT items on there if something that's been worn a couple of times bothers you (it shouldn't).

I used to love Primark especially in my twenties when I didn't have a lot of spare cash so I do get that these companies provide something that is useful when you're having to make ends meet but at the time I hadn't realised how to use eBay etc to get what I was looking for (and vinted didn't exist then).

My tips:
Identify the type of item you are looking for and the style. Also good to have a list of quality brands in your mind that sell the type of thing you are looking for.
You can filter to identify only new with tags items on most platforms if that's preferable.
Vinted allows offers and many sellers will accept them. Many sellers also have bundle discounts set up which can provide further savings. There are a lot of people decluttering on vinted and I would say it is generally easier to get a bargain on there than eBay which has a lot of professional sellers.

Liila · 23/09/2022 08:49

Lots of products are made in China. Shein cut out the middle man and supply direct to the customer instead of selling to UK stores who then hike the prices massively.

Shein clothes are good quality, last well unlike Primark stuff. Take about a week to 10 days to arrive.