Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Buy Shein??

342 replies

GarthElgarsGlasses · 22/09/2022 22:39

Hi, tempted to make some purchases from Shein and wondering whether anyone who’s bought from them would recommend their clothes or not?! Money’s right but really need some new winter clothes, however as Shein is so cheap I’m sceptical! Any experiences of their clothes welcomed! Thanks!

OP posts:
Liila · 23/09/2022 10:51

'I do have a phone, yes. You’re telling me that it would be as easy for me to exist in modern society with no mobile phone as it would be not to buy a new dress from Shein?'

I'm saying stop policing others prople's choices. Clothes from Shein may well be essential for some people who can't afford expensive locally sourced stuff. Stop judging others. The whole of the high street comes from China.

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 10:50

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 23/09/2022 10:35

That's just a copy & paste from one of those far right sponsored "Life was better in the 70s so stop being woke" Facebook pages. 🙄

So many people looking for so many reasons why they don't need to try. The one I can empathise with is the PP that said life's tough, sometimes you just want one thing that's new for your kids. I can see that. Been there years ago.

Is it?
Do you think everyone has FB and no mind if their own?
Do you seriously think that everyone relies on shit like FB for information?
You're being silly.

Cantanka · 23/09/2022 10:49

RobertaFirmino · 23/09/2022 10:43

Choice, time and money. That's what people need to buy ethically. What if the charity shops don't have the black trousers you need urgently? What if you do not have time to trawl through Vinted etc.? What if a wire has popped out on your only bra and you've only got £6 spare?

I'm not a Shein shopper myself but I do understand that not everybody can afford principles, especially in an emergency.

Well I understand that people buy new sometimes, especially when they need something. I think that’s true of most of us. We have to be realistic most of us are consumers to a greater or lesser extent.

I think the issue is unapologetically buying lots of brand new unethically made high fashion items on top of the plenty of clothes you already own, to be worn once or twice then sent to landfill.

I agree we have to be realistic but some of the posters on this thread haven’t been buying only what they need or only in an emergency.

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 10:46

KassandraOfSparta · 23/09/2022 10:26

All the whataboutery, @GoingThatWay . ALL the nonsense about buying stuff from companies involved in a regime 80 years ago, when none of us were alive and none of us were consuming. As opposed to consciously choosing, now, in 2022, to buy cheap shit from enslaved labour in China.

I really hate this argument that unless you have spent your entire life, living in a cave knitting your own clothes from nettles, you have no right to an opinion. It's a very lazy justification for having no moral compass.

And the poster "filing her basket" with cheap tat decorations/landfill from China, shame on you.

You obviously missed the point, but never mind.

Cantanka · 23/09/2022 10:44

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:38

'There is a difference between getting in a car, or buying food shopping, or owning a mobile phone, as compared with shopping from shein. The latter is just totally unnecessary and people could very easily stop it with little adverse impact on their life.'

Well of course you'll say it's different because you probably have a car and a phone. Get the bus! Use a landline. Be ethical all the time rather than selectively ethical if you want any credibility,

I do have a phone, yes. You’re telling me that it would be as easy for me to exist in modern society with no mobile phone as it would be not to buy a new dress from Shein?

You can’t see that one is a totally unnecessary luxury and the other is pretty much a necessity if you want to participate in modern society? And I am acknowledging my privilege, and trying to mitigate my own footprint with my phone - I don’t buy the latest phone when it comes out or upgrade when I can, but use a phone till it breaks. My current one is cracked to fuck and years old, but still works. Your attitude is I’ll do what I want without a second thought and don’t give a shit.

The mental gymnastics you are engaging in to justify the fact you have no moral compass at all are staggering.

RobertaFirmino · 23/09/2022 10:43

mamabear715 · 23/09/2022 10:26

@GoingThatWay Good points. I was just about to ask (in a non snarky way, really wanting to know) which clothes companies DO have a good record re human rights? Everyone's posting 'don't buy from HERE' but not where TO buy from?

Choice, time and money. That's what people need to buy ethically. What if the charity shops don't have the black trousers you need urgently? What if you do not have time to trawl through Vinted etc.? What if a wire has popped out on your only bra and you've only got £6 spare?

I'm not a Shein shopper myself but I do understand that not everybody can afford principles, especially in an emergency.

howaboutchocolate · 23/09/2022 10:42

Liila · 23/09/2022 08:58

It must be lovely to live in a world where one only purchases locally sourced ethical garments. Or even a delightful smock from vinted which may do for lunch out with the WI or whilst wafting about Waitrose

In the real world there is a cost of living crisis, people need cheap clothes for their families and shein provides a perfectly good service.

How many clothes do people need though? Society seems to have normalised having vast wardrobes with dresses and coats and trousers and tops of every colour etc. There's no need. Buy better but buy less.

Kids need more as they keep growing but there's ways to make stuff last - buy big and roll up sleeves etc. But people don't do it because they can buy loads for cheap instead.

It's only been the last couple of generations when people have had so many clothes. Before that unless you were rich, you had some practical day clothes and one or two "Sunday best" outfits that lasted forever. Kids lived in hand me downs that were repaired if needed. Surely that's more frugal in a cost of living crisis than seasonal Primark or Shein hauls.

Fast fashion has destroyed any sense of normality of how many clothes a person needs.

stuntbubbles · 23/09/2022 10:42

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:35

'can you not see the link between buying loads of crap from somewhere like Shein and the apocalyptic predictions of what their future might look like?'

More worried about Putin and his threats regarding anything apocalyptic tbh rather than a 5quid top from Shein versus a 30quid top from Zara who possibly use very similar production systems impactpolicies.org/en/news/226

Putin’s goal is to control Ukraine’s food production and therefore control a bigger slice of the global food supply, to ready Russia against the coming long-term worldwide food security crises the climate emergency has in store. His war, Shein, Zara – it’s ALL related to the climate crisis. And people on this thread who are against Shein aren’t advocating for switching to Zara at all – they’re saying that the world is full of clothes (and shoes, furniture, crockery, ~stuff) already, does anyone really need more new things Vs buying second-hand?

LindaEllen · 23/09/2022 10:41

I've bought a few bits from there and honestly never had an issue. Came well packaged, fits well, washes well..

I fully plan on buying more from there.

greenhousegal · 23/09/2022 10:41

Vicliz24 · 23/09/2022 10:38

Seriously and with no hidden agenda try charity shops . You can buy fabulous quality clothes for the same price as Shein and not have the fast fashion guilt

Charity shops don't have online shopping and delivery. That's the way many people shop these days correct? And charity shopping is fine if you have a few nearby with decent stock and have time to browse.

Meili04 · 23/09/2022 10:39

mamabear715 · 23/09/2022 10:26

@GoingThatWay Good points. I was just about to ask (in a non snarky way, really wanting to know) which clothes companies DO have a good record re human rights? Everyone's posting 'don't buy from HERE' but not where TO buy from?

You can look for clothes made in the UK they are expensive though. I've bought a few pieces. I'm betting most of MN don't have any UK made clothes but preach about sustainability. makeitbritish.co.uk/best-of-british/uk-clothing-brands/

Vicliz24 · 23/09/2022 10:38

Seriously and with no hidden agenda try charity shops . You can buy fabulous quality clothes for the same price as Shein and not have the fast fashion guilt

Queensize · 23/09/2022 10:38

Vinted is the way to go. Good quality brands for a couple of pounds. I used to work in a high end shop and sold a lot of things I got for 'uniform' cheap as chips and like new condition. I'm sure a lot of sellers are similar.

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:38

'There is a difference between getting in a car, or buying food shopping, or owning a mobile phone, as compared with shopping from shein. The latter is just totally unnecessary and people could very easily stop it with little adverse impact on their life.'

Well of course you'll say it's different because you probably have a car and a phone. Get the bus! Use a landline. Be ethical all the time rather than selectively ethical if you want any credibility,

greenhousegal · 23/09/2022 10:37

Lecturing people as to how they should shop, behave, and consume comes across as bloody high and mighty and is a sure way of getting people to ignore you. Despite meaning well.

Buying from Shein is not illegal. If it is so bad then maybe Governments should be boycotting the importation of their products by law. Aw but Free Trade Agreements you know?

It starts at the top, not with one person on their uppers or liking the look of something buying from them.

Gr33ngr33ngr4ss · 23/09/2022 10:35

KassandraOfSparta · 23/09/2022 10:26

All the whataboutery, @GoingThatWay . ALL the nonsense about buying stuff from companies involved in a regime 80 years ago, when none of us were alive and none of us were consuming. As opposed to consciously choosing, now, in 2022, to buy cheap shit from enslaved labour in China.

I really hate this argument that unless you have spent your entire life, living in a cave knitting your own clothes from nettles, you have no right to an opinion. It's a very lazy justification for having no moral compass.

And the poster "filing her basket" with cheap tat decorations/landfill from China, shame on you.

That's just a copy & paste from one of those far right sponsored "Life was better in the 70s so stop being woke" Facebook pages. 🙄

So many people looking for so many reasons why they don't need to try. The one I can empathise with is the PP that said life's tough, sometimes you just want one thing that's new for your kids. I can see that. Been there years ago.

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:35

'can you not see the link between buying loads of crap from somewhere like Shein and the apocalyptic predictions of what their future might look like?'

More worried about Putin and his threats regarding anything apocalyptic tbh rather than a 5quid top from Shein versus a 30quid top from Zara who possibly use very similar production systems impactpolicies.org/en/news/226

stuntbubbles · 23/09/2022 10:33

Cantanka · 23/09/2022 10:31

The entire western way of life is predicated on an immoral basis. We pretty much all live a life of privilege here in a nation of plenty. Some of us acknowledge it and try to do better, others just use whataboutery to justify continuing to do what the fuck they want regardless of anyone else.

There is a difference between getting in a car, or buying food shopping, or owning a mobile phone, as compared with shopping from shein. The latter is just totally unnecessary and people could very easily stop it with little adverse impact on their life. Not owning a mobile phone or not buying food is really rather harder for people to achieve. It’s not the same thing at all.

👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

RIPQueen · 23/09/2022 10:32

Cantanka · 23/09/2022 10:31

The entire western way of life is predicated on an immoral basis. We pretty much all live a life of privilege here in a nation of plenty. Some of us acknowledge it and try to do better, others just use whataboutery to justify continuing to do what the fuck they want regardless of anyone else.

There is a difference between getting in a car, or buying food shopping, or owning a mobile phone, as compared with shopping from shein. The latter is just totally unnecessary and people could very easily stop it with little adverse impact on their life. Not owning a mobile phone or not buying food is really rather harder for people to achieve. It’s not the same thing at all.

Well said

RIPQueen · 23/09/2022 10:32

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:30

Exactly.

That’s a bit like saying there’s no point recycling because you have a car and use an airplane.

aka the sort of stupid shit Nigel Farage would say

Cantanka · 23/09/2022 10:31

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 10:16

If you want to go down the ethics route then take a good look at yourselves.
Got a headache? Pop a paracetamol from Bayer.
Doing the housework or decorating? Careful, the chemicals are most probably produced by BASF or AGFA, which are the satellite companies of IG Farben, who produced Zyklon B.
Admire or own a Smeg, AEG, Miele, Siemen domestic appliance? Oh dear.
What are those components in your electronic devices? Oh they'll be a chip produced in a Chinese sweatshop.
Clothes from H&M, Zara, even Marks and Spencer among others. Tsk Tsk. Up there with Shein for slave labour.
Need to go out in motorised transport? Have shopping delivered? That will be driven on the fuel produced in the middle east, mainly by slave labour.
Japanese products and cars? They have a terrible human rights record.
Let's not forget recently the Russians echoing the camps of Hitler by sending 2.5 million Ukrainians, including 38.000 children into so called ' filtration camps ' which use interrogation, torture and murder to ' determine loyalty ' of those Ukrainians.
So when you're beating your drums about ethnicity and environment, take a good look at yourselves.
Each and every one of us have used, still use, owned or still owns a product made in a sweatshop somewhere in the world where human rights is laughed at.
So, I'll carry on buying from where ever I choose and you carry on your own way.

The entire western way of life is predicated on an immoral basis. We pretty much all live a life of privilege here in a nation of plenty. Some of us acknowledge it and try to do better, others just use whataboutery to justify continuing to do what the fuck they want regardless of anyone else.

There is a difference between getting in a car, or buying food shopping, or owning a mobile phone, as compared with shopping from shein. The latter is just totally unnecessary and people could very easily stop it with little adverse impact on their life. Not owning a mobile phone or not buying food is really rather harder for people to achieve. It’s not the same thing at all.

stuntbubbles · 23/09/2022 10:31

@BrownOrangeRed I quit my fashion career 10 years ago to work in the sustainability sector and atone for my sins, at a B-corp that donates significant profits and pro bono time. And you assume correctly, I don’t shop at those places. Nor do I fly, drive a petrol car, whatever whataboutery you want to throw my way, etc etc. Pissing about on Mumsnet – with its concurrent energy use and all the history of its threads held on servers, and the footprint that entails – is probably my biggest environmental sin.

How about you?

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:30

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 10:16

If you want to go down the ethics route then take a good look at yourselves.
Got a headache? Pop a paracetamol from Bayer.
Doing the housework or decorating? Careful, the chemicals are most probably produced by BASF or AGFA, which are the satellite companies of IG Farben, who produced Zyklon B.
Admire or own a Smeg, AEG, Miele, Siemen domestic appliance? Oh dear.
What are those components in your electronic devices? Oh they'll be a chip produced in a Chinese sweatshop.
Clothes from H&M, Zara, even Marks and Spencer among others. Tsk Tsk. Up there with Shein for slave labour.
Need to go out in motorised transport? Have shopping delivered? That will be driven on the fuel produced in the middle east, mainly by slave labour.
Japanese products and cars? They have a terrible human rights record.
Let's not forget recently the Russians echoing the camps of Hitler by sending 2.5 million Ukrainians, including 38.000 children into so called ' filtration camps ' which use interrogation, torture and murder to ' determine loyalty ' of those Ukrainians.
So when you're beating your drums about ethnicity and environment, take a good look at yourselves.
Each and every one of us have used, still use, owned or still owns a product made in a sweatshop somewhere in the world where human rights is laughed at.
So, I'll carry on buying from where ever I choose and you carry on your own way.

Exactly.

Cantanka · 23/09/2022 10:28

BrownOrangeRed · 23/09/2022 10:26

I have 2 kids, my house is already filled with clutter.

Out of curiosity, if you're so against the rumoured sweat shop/child labour style brands, other than making snide sarcastic comments to people online about purchasing from them, what are you doing? Are you raising awareness of the conditions? Are you working with aid groups, human rights groups to end it? Are you going to the factories and documenting the "slavery" to show the world? Are you creating your own ethical and affordable products as an alternative? Are you contacting manufacturers regarding their slave policies, their workers rights? Are you actually doing anything? Also if you don't shop from Shein because you're so against their workers conditions, I assume you also don't shop at H&M, Next, Primark, Amazon and many many other well known brands who do the whole "we're ethical and support workers rights/safe working conditions" act.

Do you literally not care at all about your childrens future, or can you not see the link between buying loads of crap from somewhere like Shein and the apocalyptic predictions of what their future might look like?

Im genuinely curious as to how you can give so little of a shit that you’re bullishly showing off about the way you are needlessly polluting the planet.

Icanstillrecallourlastsummer · 23/09/2022 10:27

I wouldn't. For ethical reasons. To me a £4 top isnt' worth someone basically working as a slave.

I would also expect the quality is pretty poor, and I am not a fan of disposal fashion.