Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To Buy Shein??

342 replies

GarthElgarsGlasses · 22/09/2022 22:39

Hi, tempted to make some purchases from Shein and wondering whether anyone who’s bought from them would recommend their clothes or not?! Money’s right but really need some new winter clothes, however as Shein is so cheap I’m sceptical! Any experiences of their clothes welcomed! Thanks!

OP posts:
Brefugee · 23/09/2022 11:55

sorry @CakeCrumbs44 i only realised that after posting.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 11:51

Obviously a tonne several times is hyperbole and not a literal tonne,

///

Apologies that was me ... I was thinking of those who do a big shop several times a year so for holidays, Halloween stuff, Christmas bedding and tea towels, that sort of consumerism. Also all rge bloody Tik Tok and Insta idiots who buy for "likes".

EveSix · 23/09/2022 11:50

Clare Farrell is a delight on this subject, worth following or at least googling.

stuntbubbles · 23/09/2022 11:43

No one buys 'a tonne of clothing several times a year'.
Plenty do, those clothes aren’t buying themselves. There’s someone upthread talking about a recent order for a/w clothing, bedding, etc, who’s already filling their basket for the next shop. Obviously a tonne several times is hyperbole and not a literal tonne, however: Globally, around 56 million tonnes of clothing are bought each year, and this is expected to rise to 93 million tonnes by 2030 and 160 million tonnes by 2050. (Source: BBC) Someone is buying it! The high street and fast fashion model is literally designed around buying a figurative tonne or clothing several times a year!

And then what happens? Only about 12% of clothing in the UK and the US is recycled: recycling is complex! Clothes have multiple components, and not everything survives the recycling process – which itself uses energy, water and chemicals that then need to be cleaned from the water system. Most polyester fabric is actually derived from recycled plastic bottles, not from clothes, interestingly. Clothes don’t always recycle well.

CakeCrumbs44 · 23/09/2022 11:43

Brefugee · 23/09/2022 11:36

But then the argument of "it's not fast fashion because they take it to a charity shop after" falls apart if the charity shop put it in landfill anyway!

that's not the argument i'm making though. My argument is that you can't pass on FF usually because the quality isn't good enough (applies equally to charity shops, Vinted or Ebay)

The argument is that you are better off either buying better quality (hopefully more ethically produced) clothes new, or getting the better quality 2nd hand ones.

Vinted was good, now it is going the way of ebay where you have to sift through a whole lot of shit for the good stuff.

Deffo shout out to pp for the 2nd hand phones, that has been a revelation to me.

Yes I'm agreeing with you

Brefugee · 23/09/2022 11:43

Literally everything that we use today has slave labour involved somewhere down the line, be it historical or modern.
I don't see anyone boycotting Bayer for example, because it doesn't apply today

Well that is the argument that i highlighted before being made by the developing nations now: we (global north) had our bite at the cherry and now they are having theirs. So we had the Lancashire cotton mills and the dark satanic mills 200 years ago, and they are having theirs now. On a bigger scale but who are we to point the finger?

(this is not an argument i have a lot of truck with, but it is a fair point, nonetheless)

The point with Bayer is that, yes, they were fucking abominable. And they have, as have lots of other countries, paid some kind of reparations. Enough? who knows? But there are people who, for example, won't use things that came directly from research that Eichmann did, because of how it was done. I'm not sure how that all gets untangled, tbh.

Why didn't she copyright her designs before putting them out there.

sure. It is THAT easy to stop them. 🙄

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 11:42

I think it's just a discussion many of us feel strongly about so posts will come across reflecting that

Liila · 23/09/2022 11:40

'It's not a lecture it's a discussion. Perhaps you're feeling defensive?'

A discussion! Some are indeed lecturing, rtft.

Nothing to feel defensive about. Shein is no better nor worse than most high Street retailers.

KassandraOfSparta · 23/09/2022 11:39

As if Shein is bothered about copyright.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 11:39

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 11:34

@tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz The point is, whether it's one item or a hundred, they're made from slave labour.
Literally everything that we use today has slave labour involved somewhere down the line, be it historical or modern.
I don't see anyone boycotting Bayer for example, because it doesn't apply today due to it being past slavery, rather than modern slavery. Yet everyone froths about companies today using the same.
Hypocrisy at its best.

You actually can't know who is boycotting what at any point. I will later go and Google many of the brands mentioned here.

But ultimately what are you saying - that if we can't make every decision ethically it's pointless doing what we can do?

Genuinely interested to know.

And I totally get that for so many people now the ethics of shopping when trying to feed and cloth their kids is not a priority. It's very true that it's very expensive to be poor Confused

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 11:36

Mingot · 23/09/2022 11:31

My young cousin has a very small fashion business printing T-shirts that's she designed and they've stolen all of her designs.

She's heartbroken.

Why didn't she copyright her designs before putting them out there.

Brefugee · 23/09/2022 11:36

But then the argument of "it's not fast fashion because they take it to a charity shop after" falls apart if the charity shop put it in landfill anyway!

that's not the argument i'm making though. My argument is that you can't pass on FF usually because the quality isn't good enough (applies equally to charity shops, Vinted or Ebay)

The argument is that you are better off either buying better quality (hopefully more ethically produced) clothes new, or getting the better quality 2nd hand ones.

Vinted was good, now it is going the way of ebay where you have to sift through a whole lot of shit for the good stuff.

Deffo shout out to pp for the 2nd hand phones, that has been a revelation to me.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 11:35

Liila · 23/09/2022 11:30

'Now compared to someone who buys a tonne of clothing from Shein several times a year they definitely aren't the same'

Yes we've established some people's unethical choices aren't as bad as other people's unethical choices. Just because apparently.

No one buys 'a tonne of clothing several times a year'. They probably buy the same amount as they usually did just for cheaper and as I posted upthread places like Zara that charge far more also have had questions raised about their production.

'So unless it's 100% sustainable living don't bother?'

Don't bother lecturing others.

It's not a lecture it's a discussion. Perhaps you're feeling defensive?

EveSix · 23/09/2022 11:35

Can the slavery-apoligists quit with the 'ethically produced garments are unaffordable' schtick. Using this argument to prop up one's inclination to persist in buying un-ethically produced garments is disingenuous.

Buying second hand is affordable, and available to everyone. Sure, ethically produced garments are great, but from an environmental view point, pre-loved is a snippet better.

And it isn't just clothing, all items we could conceivably ever need can be bought second hand.

I literally buy all our clothes, bar logo school uniform items (FB or PTA sale), pre-loved on eBay. Here's how:
"Hm, need dress for work. Fancy a long one."
Type "tiered maxi dress" in search bar.
Filter for item location (UK only).
Filter for condition (used).
Filter for size, sleeve length, material.
Scroll through list of items.
Select possible purchases.
Make offers, place bids or buy-it-now.

Repeat for trainers, bedding sets, school uniform, ovenware, swimwear: you name it. Takes moments from the comfort of your sofa. Anyone with an internet connection can do this.

My DC and I look smart and love wearing clothes and using household items which we have obtained in transactions which have not caused suffering to other humans or the environment. Looking at my own DC, living fairly frugal but comfortable lives -how can I blithely condemn other women and their children to lives of forced labour?

HappyMackerel · 23/09/2022 11:35

Awful for human rights and the planet, and bad quality! If money is tight I would try charity shops and second hand like Ebay or Vinted x

KassandraOfSparta · 23/09/2022 11:34

Mingot · 23/09/2022 11:31

My young cousin has a very small fashion business printing T-shirts that's she designed and they've stolen all of her designs.

She's heartbroken.

And there's nothing she can do as they are based in China. But hey! cheap t-shirts! 🙄

GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 11:34

@tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz The point is, whether it's one item or a hundred, they're made from slave labour.
Literally everything that we use today has slave labour involved somewhere down the line, be it historical or modern.
I don't see anyone boycotting Bayer for example, because it doesn't apply today due to it being past slavery, rather than modern slavery. Yet everyone froths about companies today using the same.
Hypocrisy at its best.

littlemissdizzy00 · 23/09/2022 11:34

I made an order once and sent everything back. Clothes are cheaply made and poorly sized.

Mingot · 23/09/2022 11:31

My young cousin has a very small fashion business printing T-shirts that's she designed and they've stolen all of her designs.

She's heartbroken.

Liila · 23/09/2022 11:30

'Now compared to someone who buys a tonne of clothing from Shein several times a year they definitely aren't the same'

Yes we've established some people's unethical choices aren't as bad as other people's unethical choices. Just because apparently.

No one buys 'a tonne of clothing several times a year'. They probably buy the same amount as they usually did just for cheaper and as I posted upthread places like Zara that charge far more also have had questions raised about their production.

'So unless it's 100% sustainable living don't bother?'

Don't bother lecturing others.

KassandraOfSparta · 23/09/2022 11:30

But then the argument of "it's not fast fashion because they take it to a charity shop after" falls apart if the charity shop put it in landfill anyway!

Well we don't send it to landfill, but 95% of Shein, Boohoo etc is certainly not fit for sale. So it goes off to recycling which yes is better than landfill but still doesn't wipe out the energy and resources used to make it in the first place.

So many people have forgotten that recycle only comes AFTER reduce and reuse.

Stayathomenamechange · 23/09/2022 11:28

adriftabroad · 23/09/2022 10:59

Most of Europe does not have Charity shops.
Most people do not stock pile SHEIN products, they get the odd thing (usually for teens)

I have never bought anything from SHEIN but if my 14 year old wants to, she can. The PP who slated tweens and said "I am not there yet with my DCs" No, you are not.

Posters are now just piling on for the sake of it.

That poster was me - I wasn't "piling on", was genuinely curious as to how people navigate this issue with their teens seeing as lots of parents DO care, and I'll be there in a few years! Also didn't mean to "slate" anyone, but there is a hypocrisy of denouncing slavery in the old days, but turning a blind eye to it when it's still happening now.

AM453 · 23/09/2022 11:28

adriftabroad · 23/09/2022 10:55

Crikey, can everyone shut up about bloody vinted.

Like FFS, Ive been on there and all the clothes are so ugly.

tellmewhentheLangshiplandscoz · 23/09/2022 11:27

Liila · 23/09/2022 10:38

'There is a difference between getting in a car, or buying food shopping, or owning a mobile phone, as compared with shopping from shein. The latter is just totally unnecessary and people could very easily stop it with little adverse impact on their life.'

Well of course you'll say it's different because you probably have a car and a phone. Get the bus! Use a landline. Be ethical all the time rather than selectively ethical if you want any credibility,

So unless it's 100% sustainable living don't bother?

Hmm
GoingThatWay · 23/09/2022 11:27

@WowStarsWow So am I, because I'd rather buy mine what they want, rather than what I think they should have.