Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High proportion of our class with extra time in exams for 11 plus

37 replies

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:09

I have a daughter about to sit 11+ entrance exams in November/December. She is at a small prep (SW London) and after a parent meeting this morning it transpires a high proportion of our year group are accessing extra time, rest breaks, private rooms for tiger 11+ entrance exams. For context, the academic ability in the school is pretty high and a lot of these children are in higher sets for maths and English. Parents are quite open about it - it almost seems to be the norm.

My daughter has quite pronounced dyslexia - slow reading rate, awful spelling, slow processing. This is detailed in her ed psych report however she doesn't quite meet the threshold for access arrangements like extra time (which would really benefit her with comprehension for example). She has two low standardised scores but they are one point above the 84 / 89 required.

She sits in the lower 25% for ability - school have given me this info. I'm beginning to think she does not stand a chance in the exam process if children that I know to be academically very able are have exam concessions. Am I missing something? The odds really seem stacked against her.

OP posts:
Testina · 22/09/2022 22:32

“Parents I spoke to today are submitting ed psych reports that are 2 years old”
Privately obtained reports no doubt. Again, just buying advantage as you are.
You can afford a small prep - so just continue to pay for the school that suits her best. Given her ability, that’s unlikely to be one demanding an 11+ pass.
So lucky you not to have to worry about the parents buying their way through the 11+ process. It’s unfair to sone children - but won’t impact yours.

noomchikka · 22/09/2022 22:26

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:15

Parents I spoke to today are submitting ed psych reports that are 2 years old. Their children have moved significantly academically since Y4 (by their own admission).

My DD's diagnosis from age 12 is valid throughout school, college, university and beyond. She isn't going to 'grow out' of her dyslexia as she advances through academia.

noomchikka · 22/09/2022 22:24

I don't really understand what you describe about your daughter's 'quite pronounced dyslexia' and then this not qualifying her for any access arrangements. I mean this genuinely, not being sarcastic. But my 12 year old was just assessed for dyslexia and had a very spiky profile - some areas she did very well in but the areas where there were deficits were quite pronounced.

My DD diagnostic assessment says she is entitled to min 30% extra time for exams, a small room and sympathetic marking for SPAG and her assessor described my DD as not having a 'full dyslexia profile." So I don't understand what you mean by 'quite pronounced'. What do you mean?

luxxlisbon · 22/09/2022 22:23

Do you believe all these other kids are having the requirements skewed so the can get extra time?
Otherwise I don’t really understand your issue. If someone does meet the requirements for extra time based on a variety of factors then another child isn’t being disadvantaged by the playing field being levelled.

Parents are quite open about it
Why shouldn’t they be? There is no shame in dyslexia/ ADHD etc.

AloysiusBear · 22/09/2022 22:20

Yanbu. I suspect this something that can occur in the private sector - a (former) friend essentially opinion shopped for an ed psych report (costing a huge sum) that ticked the right criteria for extra time to be granted.

I know that recently in the state sector schools are seriously wising up to expensive private ed psych reports that seem to produce a diagnosis for any middle class child who's parents can afford them & are not granting concessions in most cases.

I've never yet heard of anyone come away from a private ed psych having been told their child simply isnt academically inclined.

Goawayangryman · 22/09/2022 22:19

There has to be a cut off point somewhere for extra time. Dyslexia, ASD, and ADHD are all relatively common. Lots in one class could just be down to chance. 2 years is fairly up to date for dyslexia assessment. It's not about how much progress someone has made but about their inherent struggles with language, working memory and processing speed.

Unexpecteddrivinginstructor · 22/09/2022 22:17

I would be aimimg to look at a more specialist school which can support her needs more.

NiceTwin · 22/09/2022 22:16

This seems a thinly veiled dig at those who qualify for extra time.

Worry about your own dd and not about other people's dc's.

abovedecknotbelow · 22/09/2022 22:15

If she's in the bottom quarter then no I wouldn't put her through the exam.

Dts are dyslexic, very dyslexic. But conversely very academic. They got extra time in the SATS. I think it was six minutes. The extra time will never sort their shit spelling so we didn't put them for 11+.

If not want my child to go to a grammar if they are in the bottom quarter anyway, they'll struggle.

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:15

Parents I spoke to today are submitting ed psych reports that are 2 years old. Their children have moved significantly academically since Y4 (by their own admission).

OP posts:
Testina · 22/09/2022 22:13

YANBU to think some children’s parents and schools are unfairly advantaging them.

But then, you’ve bought an advantage for your daughter over some other children, so what’s fair and what’s not?

Would lowest 25% pass the 11+?

NameChangeOclock · 22/09/2022 22:12

If she does not meet the threshold then it would be unfair for her to have the adjustments. Just because a child is in the top set or academically gifted does not mean they don’t also have SEN. The children getting adjustments will have met the threshold for them.