Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

High proportion of our class with extra time in exams for 11 plus

37 replies

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:09

I have a daughter about to sit 11+ entrance exams in November/December. She is at a small prep (SW London) and after a parent meeting this morning it transpires a high proportion of our year group are accessing extra time, rest breaks, private rooms for tiger 11+ entrance exams. For context, the academic ability in the school is pretty high and a lot of these children are in higher sets for maths and English. Parents are quite open about it - it almost seems to be the norm.

My daughter has quite pronounced dyslexia - slow reading rate, awful spelling, slow processing. This is detailed in her ed psych report however she doesn't quite meet the threshold for access arrangements like extra time (which would really benefit her with comprehension for example). She has two low standardised scores but they are one point above the 84 / 89 required.

She sits in the lower 25% for ability - school have given me this info. I'm beginning to think she does not stand a chance in the exam process if children that I know to be academically very able are have exam concessions. Am I missing something? The odds really seem stacked against her.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
threegoodthings · 26/09/2022 19:16

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 26/09/2022 12:45

No, those than can afford the additional tutoring get it. You pull out all the stops to feed your children. The 11+ is a very unfair playing field as those with the parental dedication and money for tutoring are much more likely to get a place.

I don't disagree with you at all. But that's not what the thread is about

BrainPater · 26/09/2022 13:10

It was a ‘thing’ at my youngest’s school. Contact details of a local private dyslexia diagnosis centre were shared between parents. Nobody was ever not diagnosed who paid for an assessment at that one place. This was a known ruse passed on to our school by several parents with friends at another local independent school who did the same thing. About 3/4 of my child’s year were ‘diagnosed’ with dyslexia and got extra time in the 11+.
We didn’t go for a diagnosis but so many did. We’d already decided to keep them in the independent sector and they never sat the exam.
Paying for a diagnosis a child just to get extra time smelled very off to us. Some parents were very open about it, quite proud of it in one or two cases.

ThrowingSomeCrumbs · 26/09/2022 12:45

threegoodthings · 22/09/2022 23:19

I think if you have an academically able child who you know would thrive at a selective school then you pull out all the stops to make damn sure they get a place. It's why everybody tutors and I can understand people applying for extra concessions if the child is eligible.

Thing is without tutoring and concessions it would still be the same higher ability children getting the places.

No, those than can afford the additional tutoring get it. You pull out all the stops to feed your children. The 11+ is a very unfair playing field as those with the parental dedication and money for tutoring are much more likely to get a place.

Digimoor · 26/09/2022 12:16

Did you need two threads on the same topic?

XelaM · 23/09/2022 00:24

easier to get into*

XelaM · 23/09/2022 00:23

But OP if you are in London and looking at independent schools, there are some lovely schools that are more easier to get into than others.

XelaM · 23/09/2022 00:21

JockTamsonsBairns · 23/09/2022 00:17

Sorry, I don't quite understand this post.
If someone has an academically able child, why would they need to be tutoring to get a place at a selective school?

Got a feeling I'm going to be jumped on, but I'm not part of this world so just trying to understand it.

Because those tests are very hard and don't just test general knowledge. You need to be familiar with the exam format and types of questions to be able to answer them quickly enough to compete with the thousands other applicants. Have a look at a VR or a NVR paper. They are hard for adults let alone 10-year-old kids and there is higher competition per place for many of these schools than for Oxbridge.

JockTamsonsBairns · 23/09/2022 00:17

threegoodthings · 22/09/2022 23:19

I think if you have an academically able child who you know would thrive at a selective school then you pull out all the stops to make damn sure they get a place. It's why everybody tutors and I can understand people applying for extra concessions if the child is eligible.

Thing is without tutoring and concessions it would still be the same higher ability children getting the places.

Sorry, I don't quite understand this post.
If someone has an academically able child, why would they need to be tutoring to get a place at a selective school?

Got a feeling I'm going to be jumped on, but I'm not part of this world so just trying to understand it.

AuditAngel · 22/09/2022 23:51

DS (now 18) diagnosed in year 4 with dyslexia qualified for 25% extra time. Was retested this year as previous report was not adequate for Disabled Students allowance. New report confirmed dyslexia diagnosis and also diagnosed Dyspraxia. This report also recommended testing for ADHD and ASD. These are now in progress.initial testing undertaken by state school.

DD1 (15) was diagnosed 2 years ago with visual processing disorder and potentially dyslexia. Qualifies for 25% extra time. Was recommended to seek dyslexia testing, but unlikely to increase provision at this time. Testing undertaken by state school. Incidentally, subsequently diagnosed with a form of epilepsy associated with late diagnosed learning difficulties.

DD2 currently not diagnosed, but at this age, nor was DD1!

georgarina · 22/09/2022 23:43

YANBU
It's well known that parents game the system in this way - getting private assessments to qualify for extra time etc. V common in my experience

bluejelly · 22/09/2022 23:23

There are some excellent non-selective state schools in London. And children who are well-supported at home can do well in most schools.
Passing the 11+ is really not the only route to happiness/success.

threegoodthings · 22/09/2022 23:19

I think if you have an academically able child who you know would thrive at a selective school then you pull out all the stops to make damn sure they get a place. It's why everybody tutors and I can understand people applying for extra concessions if the child is eligible.

Thing is without tutoring and concessions it would still be the same higher ability children getting the places.

PinkPlantCase · 22/09/2022 23:19

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:33

They are privately obtained reports.

You can only obtain these reports privately.

Gonnabegrandma · 22/09/2022 23:17

I personally wouldn’t put a dyslexic child through the 11+ . . 2 of my sons are severely dyslexic and are dyscalculus too. The younger had no interest and is happy as a lark in early 20s with a practical job . Elder went and sat 11+? And was totally gutted at not passing . The school would not apply for extra time ect and this hung over him for a long time . He finished school git into uni without us getting an education plan from local authorities. They tested him and he was severely dyslexic!! Instantly given all the help he needed extra tutors scribes computers and computer programs . His life was transformed!! But for a long time he wouldn’t accept that he is actually way above average Intelligence ( also tested at uni ) the 11+ Can have far reaching consequences and thus younger child never sat it . And yes he has a degree in journalism!!!

Redlocks28 · 22/09/2022 23:14

Are you talking about the 11+ or entrance testing for fee-paying schools?

Sigma33 · 22/09/2022 23:12

You've already bought her an advantage with a small independent prep. If she isn't achieving academically despite this, then she probably isn't selective school material, if she doesn't have SN.

Find her a school where her talents and abilities will be recognised and celebrated. Maybe even, crazy thought, that she is amazing in her own way, a kind, generous person who makes the world a better place.

Lisad1231981 · 22/09/2022 23:07

It's a complicated issue.
Extra time is only really helpful if there is a physical or educational reason for not finishing. Being dyslexic doesn't qualify you automatically, and it has to level the playing field, no one should have an advantage. Also if you don't have the knowledge no amount of extra time will help.
My eldest had rest breaks due to her physical disability and a laptop but most people would assume she wouldn't need it because she was in top set for everything.

noomchikka · 22/09/2022 23:05

Has your DD got a diagnosis of dyslexia? It's confusing from your post.

gogohmm · 22/09/2022 22:58

Dd is dyslexic so got extra time - her school arranged the testing - it's to level the playing field not advantage them. Dd1 also gets separate room, rest breaks and extra time due to various sen, again this is to ensure she has a chance to achieve what her teachers knew she could do (she still messed up 2 a levels because of panic attacks and dropped out of university once due to not being able to do online testing

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:55

We are not sitting for grammars but a range of independents - most children are sitting for Indies with some applying to grammars as well.

OP posts:
SpiderinaWingMirror · 22/09/2022 22:46

Surely the 11 plus is designed to determine the top 25%? If your dd is in the lowest 25% why put her through the exam?
Dd3 was behind right through until last year primary when she got to average. Now she is in year 10 and has been assessed as being allowed 25% extra time, a word processor and a reading pen. She is set 2/6 for English and 3/6 for maths.

watcherintherye · 22/09/2022 22:43

Would lowest 25% pass the 11+?

You have to ask lowest 25% of what? It might be possible for some in the lowest 25% of a selective cohort with particularly bright children to pass the 11+. Lowest 25% of pupils in a non-selective setting, not so likely.

OutDamnedSpot · 22/09/2022 22:37

I mean this gently, but if she’s in the lower 25% academically, is the 11+ / grammar school really the best idea?

ByTheGrace · 22/09/2022 22:34

And you are buying your privately educated child an advantage in the 11+ against a state school pupil. That's just life.

A lot of kids will have older diagnoses, the NHS doesn't reassess every year - my child's diagnosis is a few yrs old. She meets the threshold, there has to be a threshold somewhere.
Also as someone who attended a grammar school, I'd be wary of squeezing a very borderline child in, they would be better in the middle/top of a comp rather than at the bottom of a selective.

Treetoppers · 22/09/2022 22:33

They are privately obtained reports.

OP posts: