Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Renault grand scenic

38 replies

Brown888 · 22/09/2022 20:14

I want one. Second hand. 7 seater. Ideally about 10 years old. Love the shape and space but it's not too huge
DP thinks Renault is unreliable
Thinks I should get something more robust like a VW touran.
Aibu?
Anyone driven a Renault grand scenic? Any love stories or horror stories?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Onynx · 23/09/2022 18:07

Nissan & Renault have the same parts now. We changed to a Kia Sorento & I absolutely adore it- I'll never go back

Rollercoaster1920 · 23/09/2022 10:04

My father had one. it was nice, but electrical gremlins I'm afraid so wouldn't recommend. We have a Zafira and it's simple and cheap to run. A couple of things have gone wrong that shouldn't, but were cheap to fix. The Zafira fire recall was a bit scary though.
our brand new skoda has electrical issues too so VW group aren't the holy grail.

I like the look of the Dacia Jogger as an alternative family car - they have less superfluous electronics to go wrong. Who actually wants 'lane assist' to wrestle you for control of the car? But it's a Renault group car so the basic electrics might have a hissy fit like the Scenic.

annatho · 23/09/2022 09:59

We had one for five years and loved it - we bought it in 2014 when it was 8/9 years old and didnt have any major problems; I guess any issues had been sorted out by the time we got it.

We had the 1.9 diesel and it was a lovely refined car for cruising on the motorways as well as good for around town.

Although we loved the overall feel and high-tech nature of the car we were slightly annoyed at the complexity of some things - the front bumper had to be taken off to replace the headlamp bulbs for example - but once these were done it was all ok. I think the Scenic marks 3 or 4 may be better!

Since then we have had a Peugeot 5008 MPV (not the more recent SUV version) which I would also recommend - it has the same kind of space (if not slightly more) but is not so high tech and feels more solidly put together. But the lesson I have learned generally is that diesel is not good unless you do long journeys regularly - if you are driving around town on short trips its far better to have a petrol car.

Of course if you want a far more solid car choose a Touran but they are considerably more expensive

Sahgah · 23/09/2022 09:47

We have one , we bought it when it was 6 years old and we’ve had it another 5.5years. We haven’t spent anything major on it but the electrics warnings are on for various reasons that keep changing however it still works perfectly fine but need to get it sorted. Our petrol door also jammed shut. But it’s a 11 year old car and I would expect to have to pay for some sort of repairs on a car of that age.
The space inside is great and I’ve sat in the back seats in the boot and don’t find them too squashy. It’s easy to drive and park and we get a lot of miles for a tank of diesel.

TwinsTrollsAndHunz · 23/09/2022 09:41

It was also pretty horrible to drive, the steering was very light and didn’t feel connected to the axles at all. You could wiggle the wheel a lot and the tyres wouldn’t respond. No nuance whatsoever. The cabin was comfortable and spacious and the driving position was good but as a driver and car owner it was a horrible car.

WatchoRulo · 23/09/2022 09:41

Lunar270 · 23/09/2022 06:18

YANBU to want a Renault but your OH is right as French cars are generally terrible. Nice design but unreliable.

However he's also wrong about VW as they're no better and potentially worse. I've no idea why people still think German cars are reliable as they're not. Well screwed together, yes. Reliable, no.

www.thecarexpert.co.uk/volkswagen-touareg-2018/

www.carwow.co.uk/blog/most-and-least-reliable-car-brands-revealed#gref

^ This 100%. German cars are more expensive because you have to pay for the marketing, that's all. They are not any more reliable.
I read a recent survey by a warranty company - the top ten most unreliable cars was full of "premium" German brands.

TwinsTrollsAndHunz · 23/09/2022 09:36

I had a 2014 model. Absolute heap of shit, it cost me £1400 in repair bills in the single year that I owned it. It was just out of warranty at the time, so I’d definitely not have an older one.

Brown888 · 23/09/2022 09:32

Thanks all for your stories
I do lots of motorway miles so don't want to risk a failure at 70mph
Didn't realise VW touran was similar so thanks for that
I did like ford cmax but doesn't have 3 full size seats in the back but might have to compromise

OP posts:
Billybagpuss · 23/09/2022 07:18

I had one, lovely to drive, very comfortable but bloody hell it was a money pit. The worst was I was driving to my mum to take dd to cinema and the gorgeous display showing everything from speed, mileage to what radio station I was on went phut, phut, splot and disappeared. Had to be completely replaced and lost the mileage count. Then some coils kept going at a £200 a time that caused power loss. It was a nightmare.

lalaloopyhead · 23/09/2022 06:59

We have had ours for 13 years and it is honestly the best car I've ever had. We have 3 DC and the three full size seats in the back meant oldest wasn't squashed in the middle between two car seats. The extra seats in the back were great for taking friends out, though you would t want to go too far in them.

We chose it as being the biggest car inside with smallest outside. Being able to move and remove each back seat individually has been brilliant too. The amount that can be fitted in the back is amazing.

We've never had any issues and only repairs have been making maintenance things like tyres/brakes etc

Kids are adults/teen now but still really handy for Uni moves, tip runs, IKEA trips and holidays. It is also really comfortable to drive.

I assume ours won't have many years left (56 reg) and when it's gone I am going to miss that car!!

JustBkind · 23/09/2022 06:27

Hated ours. Had one years ago and only had it for 5 months before exchanging it for a Ford CMax - much better and more reliable. The Grand Scenic felt like you were driving a tin!
Have Volvo XC60 now, best car I’ve ever had (although do like Audi too)!

Lunar270 · 23/09/2022 06:18

YANBU to want a Renault but your OH is right as French cars are generally terrible. Nice design but unreliable.

However he's also wrong about VW as they're no better and potentially worse. I've no idea why people still think German cars are reliable as they're not. Well screwed together, yes. Reliable, no.

www.thecarexpert.co.uk/volkswagen-touareg-2018/

www.carwow.co.uk/blog/most-and-least-reliable-car-brands-revealed#gref

OnlyOpenMouthToChangeFeet · 23/09/2022 03:26

I had a brand new Scenic on Motability and loved it. After only 18 months the engine management light came on, and the engine went into 'get you home' mode, and would only go at 50mph, which was dangerous as on the M1. Had to have the full onboard computer replaced twice to solve the problem. Then just 5 months later, again on the motorway, the car just stopped. The electrics failed completely, car stopped and windows all mysteriously opened, and even hazard lights wouldn't work. I was stuck on the motorway with 3 children under 3, very dangerous.

Luckily Motability gave me an early replacement on the car (usually have for a minimum of 3 years), and the following year stopped providing them on the scheme altogether as the electrics were so unreliable.

Unfortunately French cars seem inherently unreliable, although German cars I've never had a moment of trouble with.

gleegeek · 23/09/2022 00:52

We've literally just said goodbye to our 2011 trusty Renault scenic😭It had done 120,000 miles and had been the most reliable car we've ever had. But things were finally starting to go wrong and we could feel big bills were around the corner... So, younger models we'd have like a shot but I suspect after 10 years everything seems to fall to pieces!

RhubarbFairy · 22/09/2022 23:41

SavoirFlair · 22/09/2022 23:27

It’s as good as your input about a tiny family hatchback when the OP is asking about a specific model of MPV, but thanks also for your cool car story

My engine management light 'story' was about the Scenic!

I'll spell it out for you.

Comfortable drive.
Flexible seating.
Spacious.
Loads of hidden storage.
Decent spec eg built in sat nav.

Filter sensors get shirty if you don't drive it on a long straight road at high speeds regularly, resulting in a light that proclaims imminent doom.

Also, the headlights are a pain to change if they go.

loubieloo4 · 22/09/2022 23:39

We had ours for a few years, the space was great along with the storage just a shame it cost us thousands in regular breakdowns. I would avoid like the plague.

Now have a Audi Q3 which I love ❤️

teletone · 22/09/2022 23:34

Absolutely 100% avoid. I would not have another one if it was the last car on the planet. Great for the first couple of years then an absolute nightmare. Renault are awful to deal with and will do anything to wriggle out of warranty repairs.
Notorious for gearbox issues. Wanted £3000 for a new gearbox unit in warranty.
Have had a Zafira, C4 Picasso, Kia Carens and now a BMW Gran Tourer. All so much better.

SavoirFlair · 22/09/2022 23:27

RhubarbFairy · 22/09/2022 23:19

My Grand Scenic was a diesel and my commute was 25 miles each way. Not on motorways. That was not my commute when I bought the car, but these things change.

My Mini is petrol and my new commute is 10 minutes on foot. I bought the Mini because I'd had over a decade of having the sensible family car, it was my turn to have the fun one that I bought for me, not everyone else.

But thanks for your input.

It’s as good as your input about a tiny family hatchback when the OP is asking about a specific model of MPV, but thanks also for your cool car story

vdbfamily · 22/09/2022 23:25

We are on our second. Tall family of 5 and we all fit just about. The plus 2 seats were useful when kids were small but not great for teenagers, although middle seats move forward to give more leg space behind. We have not had any major issues.

RippleQueen · 22/09/2022 23:24

Renault Scenic ....avoid too unreliable. We had 2 and they weren't good. Nor want the Citroen either. VW Tiguan was brilliant and Kia Sportage was too.

Malbecfan · 22/09/2022 23:23

I had a Grand Scenic from new. It was always in and out of the garage with various warnings and component failures. The ride was comfy but it was too unreliable. I then bought a new Touran. I did 130k miles in it in 7 years and didn't have a day's trouble. Utterly reliable, if a bit lower spec than the GS. I then bought another Touran.

I play the double bass and it sits on a trolley. There are hardly any vehicles that take it attached to the trolley. The Touran's boot is really good if you only use 5 seats. The seats in the boot aren't great but DH and adult DDs are happy to travel up to an hour in them.

RhubarbFairy · 22/09/2022 23:21

SavoirFlair · 22/09/2022 23:13

What is your AIBU @Brown888 ?

seriously?

Avoid the Scenic.And the Touran, laudable as it is, won’t have the same space.

Your best bet in this class is a Galaxy or a SMax from Ford, but neither are seen as “middle class” enough by the chattering folk that matter, which is why they never get recommends on this forum .

I had the Galaxy as a courtesy car just before I sold the Scenic. I absolutely loved it. If I got another big car, that would absolutely be the one.

RhubarbFairy · 22/09/2022 23:19

SavoirFlair · 22/09/2022 23:14

Is your Mini a diesel @RhubarbFairy ?

is your commute less than 20 miles, and not on motorways?

then you bought the wrong car for your lifestyle

My Grand Scenic was a diesel and my commute was 25 miles each way. Not on motorways. That was not my commute when I bought the car, but these things change.

My Mini is petrol and my new commute is 10 minutes on foot. I bought the Mini because I'd had over a decade of having the sensible family car, it was my turn to have the fun one that I bought for me, not everyone else.

But thanks for your input.

SavoirFlair · 22/09/2022 23:14

RhubarbFairy · 22/09/2022 23:06

I traded mine in last year for a Mini. I do still miss it occasionally. It was comfortable, a lovely drive and I loved the built in sat nav and digital screen.

It got pissy about my commute though and scared the crap out of me when it changed the whole screen to a red 'engine failure hazard' alert. I practically crawled to the garage. Turns out my filters were full of gunk and 'a nice run on the motorway doing 50mph+ should clear that'. It did but the warning would come back on periodically. Finally stayed off when we drove it to France. That cleared it properly.

The boot seats offer very little legroom, but we only used them occasionally anyway.

The Mini is fun to drive but definitely not as comfortable or flexible.

Is your Mini a diesel @RhubarbFairy ?

is your commute less than 20 miles, and not on motorways?

then you bought the wrong car for your lifestyle

SavoirFlair · 22/09/2022 23:13

What is your AIBU @Brown888 ?

seriously?

Avoid the Scenic.And the Touran, laudable as it is, won’t have the same space.

Your best bet in this class is a Galaxy or a SMax from Ford, but neither are seen as “middle class” enough by the chattering folk that matter, which is why they never get recommends on this forum .