Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Liz Truss MUST call a general election to make “unpopular” and “difficult” decisions that deviate from the last GE manifesto?

280 replies

CurseOfBigness · 22/09/2022 16:02

I get that Liz Truss is a keen new prime minister full of beans and ideas. I just don’t think she has the mandate to push through decisions that are “unpopular” and “difficult” if it deviates from the last general election’s manifesto.

Liz Truss plans radical shift in economic policy: New UK prime minister readies tax-cutting mini-Budget and says she is prepared to be unpopular.

This new prime minister has not gained her position by winning a general election. If she wants to radically change things and be “unpopular” then she needs to put the vote to the people.

Truss talked the talk about promoting “freedom” and not being dictated by “instructions”. But Freedom is not for free. The rule of law applies as “instructions” to help keep society civilised. Checks and balances.

Removing the cap on bankers’ bonuses is a poor PR move. Trickle down economics is problematic and already being criticised as ineffective.

Truss thinks she can do what she wants because she’s party leader and by default became prime minister. But Truss can’t afford to be “unpopular” because she needs to win a general election in her own right first.

AIBU to think Liz Truss must call a general election to make “unpopular” and “difficult” decisions that deviate from the last GE manifesto? Isn’t that how democracy works?!

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 18:43

@DownNative You’ve put forwards the UK’s historical approach towards monarchy and (lack of) divine right for British royalty. I appreciate you probably know more about that UK history than I do. Thanks for educating me (because I have learned a lot tbh).

I am saying you’re neglecting the wider British Empire history of monarchies around the world that’s also relevant and shared between East/West. The UK approach to monarchy is not the only one I’m afraid.

”By invoking the supernatural, you're showing a lack of understanding of political power and knowledge. It's not necessary.”

Based on my reading of Indian royal history that’s how it worked in India; the supernatural was enmeshed with political power.
Do you remember India in British history? India was the country that had practically all its monarchies deposed by the British by the 19th century. To the point that all was left as a reminder of Indian royalty is a diamond (Koh-I-Noor) that is shrouded in mystery and talk of supernatural power, which is now on a British Crown.

I have not made up this supernatural idea… The jewel in the crown: The curse of Koh-i-Noor. Queen Victoria was concerned enough about the supernatural aspects that the British Royal Family have a strict policy to only give it to a woman (because they think women are immune to the supernatural curse etc).

I’ll quote this extract from a well researched book too, “Ranjit’s peculiar mix of piety and power caught the attention of the authorities in London at a time when Britain was expanding its territories in the East. Not knowing what to make of the one-eyed warrior of the Punjab, they dispatched a political agent, Captain William Murray, to assess the Maharajah’s rise to power and identify his weaknesses. Murray’s initial reports were fulsome in their praise: ‘Ranjit Singh has been likened to Mehmet Ali and to Napoleon. There are some points in which he resembles both; but estimating his character with reference to his circumstances and positions, he is perhaps a more remarkable man than either.” (Anita Anand)

Ranjit Singh’s empire was untouchable during his life and his most prized possession was the Koh-I-Noor diamond that continues to kick up so much international fuss. His empire was only invaded after he died and later his ten year old child was forced to sign the enigmatic Koh-I-Noor over to the British.

Maybe you’re also lacking in understanding political power and knowledge that Britain has inherited from India. The history of the gem is that it was a sign of divine right if a monarch could wear it with impunity (it derived its supernatural ideas from Hindu scriptures as a gift from the sun god Surya).

OP posts:
DownNative · 28/09/2022 17:05

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 09:13

@JassyRadlett But our side discussion on this thread was about monarchy. Monarchy does rely on supernatural claims. Even now.

William Dalrymple could also have said ‘yeah I’m not going into the supernatural stuff because that’s obviously silly’. The Koh-I-Noor curse claims are too prevalent, including the royal family’s own treatment of the jewel. So Dalrymple gives it a fair consideration… which boils down to ‘We don’t know for certain either way’. That means: be careful.

The UK Constitution is a fallible human construct written long ago; this means it can be deconstructed and/or changed too.
The Koh-I-Noor curse (if true) has no regard whatsoever for the UK Constitution (just like how the British had no regard for the Indian constitutions the diamond was stolen/looted from).

What you’ve said about the UK constitution helps explains why the likes of Lord Dalhousie may have treated non-UK monarchies in India the way he did; he deposed practically all of them with apparent impunity. It seems Dalhousie felt he could do away with the world’s monarchies based on the UK constitution alone (and that’s dangerous, ideologically, practically and even supernaturally).

Sounds like the UK Constitution has a lot to answer for in India and to their deposed monarchies. It’s more like an arrogant colonial attitude and maybe even a fatal mistake… Dalhousie didn’t know what he was messing with when he caught his “hare” (I.e. the diamond).

@CurseOfBigness you said, "The UK Constitution is a fallible human construct written long ago; this means it can be deconstructed and/or changed too."

All Man made constructs are fallible, but this doesn't actually change the discussion.

You're incorrect that the UK Constitution was written long ago - it's more accurate to say it was started long ago.

But it has undergone a LOT of changes since. It's often referred to as a Living Constitution which is a strength. It is NOT static since it isn't codified. The US Constitution is static since it is codified and very narrowly written so as to make changing it very, very difficult.

All humans in the distant past before the Enlightenment believed in and relied on the supernatural, including to justify power. But invoking the supernatural has been completely irrelevant since 1689 especially. Absolute Monarchs such as James II and Louis XIV lost to William of Orange who became a Constitutional Monarch under Parliament essentially.

By invoking the supernatural, you're showing a lack of understanding of political power and knowledge. It's not necessary.

DownNative · 28/09/2022 16:52

CurseOfBigness · 26/09/2022 23:53

No, the Monarchy hasn't literally been Divine Right for centuries and this was settled by the Glorious Revolution of 1689.

I’m saying Glorious Revolution of 1689 settled amongst non-divine people means very little because the whole idea of Divine Right is that it comes from God (or something divine), not people. Divine right is not granted by Parliament (because they are not the givers of divine right… ).

Black Rod can slam the door on the monarch… but not the divine (divine can probably walk through doors like a ghost, you know, Holy Spirit ghost… 😝).

So how can parliament (or people or anyone not divine) claim to have removed the monarchy’s Divine Right to anything? It’s not their place.

Divine Right is not Parliament’s jurisdiction. To suggest so is ludicrous…

And even if Glorious Revolution of 1689 claimed to have settled the Divine Right matter then, you don’t know if God decided to reinstate divine right. That’s God’s prerogative with divine right…

My point is. You don’t know. No one knows Divine Righty things. That’s a spiritual matter and above Parliamentary sovereignty.

"I’m saying Glorious Revolution of 1689 settled amongst non-divine people means very little because the whole idea of Divine Right is that it comes from God (or something divine), not people. Divine right is not granted by Parliament (because they are not the givers of divine right… )."

No, the Glorious Revolution of 1689 settled the Constitution and the Monarchy for people of all backgrounds.

Religious or otherwise, all had to accept that Parliament is the Supreme Legislator and Authority in England as it originated there. This carried on in the United Kingdom of Great Britain and has remained so ever since.

It is Parliament who keeps the Monarch on the throne. Indeed, Charles II gave Parliament a blank sheet in response to the Restoration of the Monarchy terms and conditions. In other words, an acknowledgement that Parliament is Supreme. Not the Monarch. The Glorious Revolution of 1689 absolutely cemented this into the UK Constitution and political life.

"Black Rod can slam the door on the monarch… but not the divine (divine can probably walk through doors like a ghost, you know, Holy Spirit ghost… 😝)."

This proves you're not paying attention and certainly not reading a thing.

Black Rod is appointed by the Monarch and is the Monarch's representative in Parliament.

Hence, the Commons slams the door shut in the face of Black Rod ever since Parliament trumped the Monarch in terms of political power.

"So how can parliament (or people or anyone not divine) claim to have removed the monarchy’s Divine Right to anything? It’s not their place."

On the contrary, it's is within Parliament's power to destroy the idea of the Divine Right and the power a Monarch used to derive from this in the past before the Restoration in 1660 and the Glorious Revolution in 1689.

"Divine Right is not Parliament’s jurisdiction. To suggest so is ludicrous…"

Political power IS Parliament's jurisdiction. Monarchs in the past only stayed on the throne due to their own political power. Hence, why Kings for centuries led their armies onto the battlefield in contrast to modern military practice where commanders never do.

If a Monarch can no longer remain the Supreme Power, they're subordinated. That's precisely what Parliament did and once power was consolidated brought the Monarchy back on their own conditions.

"And even if Glorious Revolution of 1689 claimed to have settled the Divine Right matter then, you don’t know if God decided to reinstate divine right. That’s God’s prerogative with divine right…"

Circular Reasoning Fallacy.

"My point is. You don’t know. No one knows Divine Righty things. That’s a spiritual matter and above Parliamentary sovereignty."

Circular Reasoning Fallacy. A Fallacy is an error in logic and reason.

It looks like you're trying to dig yourself right out of the hole you've dug for yourself. I note you've dropped your original claims of undemocratic means to power via the current PM.

The Constitution is clear - its democratic.

JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 16:52

Ah, my misunderstanding. As the only other person who participated in the discussion, when you said the discussion (rather than your research) had opened your eyes to the British mindset, it was a reasonable but clearly incorrect inference.

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 16:20

JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 14:43

You've assumed I'm British - I'm not.

Sorry about undermining your sneery post!

@JassyRadlett Erm… I didn’t mean you personally. You weren’t around in the 18th/19th century, were you?

When I said ‘mindset of the British’ I clearly meant the colonialists in the 18th/19th century who were deposing Indian monarchies. Makes sense now that the British mindset towards monarchy and divine right in general was influenced by the UK constitution (that you have helped explain was settled by men in 1689 and the Enlightenment). British mindset of a disposable monarchy (and a rubbishing of divine right ideas) extended towards the colonies - this makes more contextual sense now.

In contrast, the Indian monarchies I’ve read about were always treated like gods on earth, hence divine right was still held sacred there. Deposing their own King/Queen would have been viewed as sacrilegious because of the the association with divinity.

If the British colonialists didn’t hold the same view of divine right of royals for their own monarchy (due to the UK constitution as you’ve described) then it makes sense why they didn’t take the sanctity of Indian royalty seriously. Instead they projected the UK constitutional ideas of disposable monarchy onto the Indians.

But it seems the idea that divine right of monarchy was so ingrained in Indian culture and psyche, that when Queen Victoria declared herself Empress of India she was almost deified by some.

Monarchy without divine right makes less sense because royals claim to be special people in some way. What’s the point of royalty if there’s nothing divine about it? That’s the point.

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 14:43

You've assumed I'm British - I'm not.

Sorry about undermining your sneery post!

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 14:25

JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 14:11

I think we'll have to agree to disagree on the relevance and factual basis of your many assertions. 🙂

😊

Thanks for discussion. It has helped me understand the mindset of the British who went into India and deposed their monarchy. If they thought their own monarchy was disposable, then why not others?

But of course, one looks after their own 😉

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 14:11

I think we'll have to agree to disagree on the relevance and factual basis of your many assertions. 🙂

CurseOfBigness · 28/09/2022 09:13

JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 07:44

Outside your comfort zone?

Nope, just honestly not that interested in discussing anything that relies on claims of the supernatural. Largely because they can't possibly be honestly debated. But also because it had utterly nothing to do with UK constitutional principles which is what was being discussed. It takes two to shift a discussion onto a new subject; I'm politely declining on this count.

@JassyRadlett But our side discussion on this thread was about monarchy. Monarchy does rely on supernatural claims. Even now.

William Dalrymple could also have said ‘yeah I’m not going into the supernatural stuff because that’s obviously silly’. The Koh-I-Noor curse claims are too prevalent, including the royal family’s own treatment of the jewel. So Dalrymple gives it a fair consideration… which boils down to ‘We don’t know for certain either way’. That means: be careful.

The UK Constitution is a fallible human construct written long ago; this means it can be deconstructed and/or changed too.
The Koh-I-Noor curse (if true) has no regard whatsoever for the UK Constitution (just like how the British had no regard for the Indian constitutions the diamond was stolen/looted from).

What you’ve said about the UK constitution helps explains why the likes of Lord Dalhousie may have treated non-UK monarchies in India the way he did; he deposed practically all of them with apparent impunity. It seems Dalhousie felt he could do away with the world’s monarchies based on the UK constitution alone (and that’s dangerous, ideologically, practically and even supernaturally).

Sounds like the UK Constitution has a lot to answer for in India and to their deposed monarchies. It’s more like an arrogant colonial attitude and maybe even a fatal mistake… Dalhousie didn’t know what he was messing with when he caught his “hare” (I.e. the diamond).

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 28/09/2022 07:44

Outside your comfort zone?

Nope, just honestly not that interested in discussing anything that relies on claims of the supernatural. Largely because they can't possibly be honestly debated. But also because it had utterly nothing to do with UK constitutional principles which is what was being discussed. It takes two to shift a discussion onto a new subject; I'm politely declining on this count.

walkingonsunshinekat · 27/09/2022 22:04

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 22:45

Under the Customs Union, VAT would be charged by the retailer's country with nothing due at the other end. Now that the UK is not in the CU, the product is being exported so no VAT is due at the retailer's country, but it must be paid in the purchaser's country. There were some teething troubles to begin with as people ended up wrongly being charged VAT at both ends because sellers hadn't appreciated the change. All seems fine now - the last time I imported anything from the continent, the seller paid the UK VAT, rather than that in his own country.

I was meaning i still pay vat in say France if i buy product x in a shop in france.

On imports, for my interest i still can't get anything sent to me from EU, always comes up "wont ship to uk" if its over £135 - its a pia as you see stuff available in EU but not in UK.

I don't know of any EU outfit that has got round this unless they set up a UK branch.

DdraigGoch · 27/09/2022 20:13

God tends to be linked to war memorial stuff for a reason…
Because when staring death in the face, people will grasp at anything that might remotely help them. When mobilisation happens, suddenly the Padre is a very popular man.

CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 19:53

@JassyRadlett ”Yeah I'm not going to get into Crown Jewels and curses, that's even further down a very bizarre rabbit hole than this discussion.”

Outside your comfort zone?

I brought the Koh-I-Noor into discussion because you specified “UK Monarchy”. I was just showing that UK Monarchy has become a hybrid monarchy and undergone some ‘mixing’ through its colonial exploits (especially the illegally and immorally obtaining Crown Jewels like the Koh-I-Noor that was taken from a ten year old child who had been forcibly separated from his mum).

It’s a bit arrogant to assume there’s no curse on the Koh-I-Noor when you don’t know everything… it was never a UK crown jewel. So, how can you say whether or not there is a curse?

Actually it was Lord Dalhousie who dismissed the possibility of the Koh-I-Noor’s curse. Then he sleep walked into the 1857 Indian Rebellion (that started the independence movement and by 1947 the Second World War had helped India secure its victory). Some have put it down to the curse of the Koh-I-Noor (in 1857 the British thought it was the Koh-I-Noor’s malignant influence).

Eastern approaches to deities is very different to some Western ones.

William Dalrymple has written a book in the diamond called “Koh-I-Noor: History of the World’s Most Infamous Diamond”. Read the last chapter where he addresses the curse issue… quite interesting. And he’s a credible historian too.

P.S. I realise my username says curse but that’s just the title of the book I recently read by legal scholar Tim Wu “The Curse of Bigness: Antitrust in the New Gilded Age”. Nothing to do with the Crown Jewels!

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 19:41

And as we all know, the succession only goes to the firstborn up to a point, and ultimately Parliament can intervene as it so ably did with the Act of Settlement and much more recently with the Succession to the Crown Act - which was the bit where they went 'actually, girls should be treated equally in the succession from now on'. And it can also be argued that Parliamentary government left Edward VIII with no option but to abdicate. So not even the succession is inviolable by Parliament.

Both Parliament and monarchs in this country know where the mandate lies; British people (and the other realms) just really like ceremonial stuff and pageantry and aren't massively motivated by sweeping constitutional change for the sake of it.

JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 19:31

Yeah I'm not going to get into Crown Jewels and curses, that's even further down a very bizarre rabbit hole than this discussion.

You're right that it was used as a mandate for power until that mandate shifted to Parliament (in the UK) or shifted even further by ditching the monarchy altogether.

But I think your logic is skewed on the question of whether power derived from the divine - and therefore the mandate is divine - or whether the power is one largely of strong, rich institutions (the church as institution rather than religion, using religious belief to entrench power, the aristocracy and nobility using their land, money and swords to entrench power) and then using the idea of divine right to keep the people in line. The power derives from the institutions, not the almighty.

I'm not saying that some monarchs - in all countries - didn't believe that God had made them born special, in the same way as some Americans think God specifically favoured them by having them be born in the US, and the US as a country as being a divinely inspired creation that is 'special' in the eyes of God.

That doesn't mean that either is actually the act of God rather than the belief of the deluded.

And I totally agree with you that having a Head of State who is there due to accident of birth is a very odd system. I think most people do, but tradition and comfort with a system are strong drivers. And if you asked most people, it's the tradition and the 'it works so don't change it' is the driver for retaining it, rather than 'God put him there, don't mess with God.'

It's also odd to have clergy in your legislature, but here we are...

CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 19:14

@JassyRadlett ”No UK monarch has claimed divine right for centuries.”

But non-UK monarchs have claimed divine right to rule and also wielded their absolute powers skilfully. It matters to the UK monarchy because they have taken mystical Crown Jewels that were associated with divine right. The Sikh King Ranjit Singh prized the Koh-I-Noor as sacred.

And there’s supposed to be a God curse involved in the Koh-I-Noor. Held by the UK monarchy and they’re superstitious enough of it to only give it to a woman. Way after 1689 and the Enlightenment.

I don’t think parliament has any jurisdiction over non-UK crowns or jewels… or does it?

I have some knowledge on that particular history. See also the Crown Jewels chat.

OP posts:
CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 18:57

JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 18:48

Divine Right (if it’s a thing) can’t be dictated by parliament… because they’re not divine. The divine grant would come from a God. That was how this digression started I think.

Divine right isn't a thing. No UK monarch has claimed divine right for centuries. And it has never actually been a thing rather than a technique to cement power.

Divine right was used as a mandate for power. The claim to the crown comes through that mandate…

Just reading up Divine right of kings

“It stems from a specific metaphysical framework in which a monarch is, before birth, pre-ordained to inherit the crown. According to this theory of political legitimacy, the subjects of the crown have actively (and not merely passively) turned over the metaphysical selection of the king's soul – which will inhabit the body and rule them – to God. In this way, the "divine right" originates as a metaphysical act of humility and/or submission towards God.”

That is how the Royal Family’s line of succession works, isn’t it?

Charles is King now because he was firstborn to the Queen.

Anyway, that is an outdated way to choose a Head of State if there’s no divine mandate involved.

As it stands we have an unelected Head of State (because apparently even God had no part in this because there’s apparently no such thing as divine right).
And we have a PM who was voted in by something like 0.3% of the electorate (and all members of the conservatives).

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 18:48

Divine Right (if it’s a thing) can’t be dictated by parliament… because they’re not divine. The divine grant would come from a God. That was how this digression started I think.

Divine right isn't a thing. No UK monarch has claimed divine right for centuries. And it has never actually been a thing rather than a technique to cement power.

TheRubyRedshoes · 27/09/2022 18:26

@JassyRadlett

Excellent post on the enlightenment.

CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 18:20

@JassyRadlett ”Anyway - leaders throughout history have used religion to cement their power and encourage obedience and conformity.”

I hear this presented as a bad thing by a lot of atheists.

Tbh… if religion was used to encourage obedience and conformity then I don’t think it’s necessarily bad because that’s how to create cohesion, cooperation and peace. Less disturbances to the peace. Religion served a useful function…

I'm not even sure what overall point you're trying to make

No point really. Just a discussion trying to imagine how god is supposed to work according to various groups.

Monarchy is one group that has ‘God’ attached to it. Seems silly now that they don’t mean ‘God’ anymore… why not just say what it means now?

Divine Right (if it’s a thing) can’t be dictated by parliament… because they’re not divine. The divine grant would come from a God. That was how this digression started I think.

OP posts:
CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 18:12

*family and friends

OP posts:
CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 18:11

JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 17:09

(This thread a LONG way from whether Liz Truss should or must call an election.)

We digress!

Based on my own experience with close family and friend from abroad.

They assume Monarchy is a God show based on how it’s presented. I’ve tried seeing it from their perspective and I get what they mean. Because that is the propaganda of the shop window.

They’re from Republic countries where they elect a Head of State. So Monarchy as unelected Head of State is baffling and unfair to them anyway. But if God chooses the monarch as Head of State then that makes a tiny bit more sense - less likely to question when ‘it’s a God show’.

See what I mean?

OP posts:
JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 17:09

(This thread a LONG way from whether Liz Truss should or must call an election.)

JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 17:08

(I'm not even sure what overall point you're trying to make - is it about the intrinsic nature of monarchy being divine grant, or is it what it appears to be to outsiders? God causing Brexit and Covid and world wars to punish us for removing absolute monarchy, or the impression amongst the daft that he/she/it did?)

Anyway - leaders throughout history have used religion to cement their power and encourage obedience and conformity. Not particularly linked to any particular religions but one theory about the rise of monotheism, and in particular the idea of an omniscient deity, is that it coincided with larger societies and was often better vehicle for societal control than a bunch of gods who lived on a hill, etc.

In a deeply religious society that's full of folk terrified of going to hell, if the priest and the king tell you that the king was put there by God so you need to do what the king says, then people did it, mostly. And that cemented the power of both priests and kings, particularly when kings enforced theological rules as much as priests promoted the idea that kings were chosen by their god.

JassyRadlett · 27/09/2022 17:01

CurseOfBigness · 27/09/2022 16:57

Monarchy is internationally recognised though.

Different playing field.

In what way does that affect its intrinsic nature?

Even if 'famous abroad' was relevant to whether God plays a part or not, our Parliament, for example, is fairly well known abroad. Mother of Parliaments, Westminster system, all that...

Swipe left for the next trending thread