Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this won’t work and will force more into poverty?

160 replies

KimberleyClark · 22/09/2022 12:41

Kwasi Korteng wants to cut benefits to part time workers to force them to work more hours.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/sep/21/kwasi-kwarteng-to-shrink-part-time-work-benefits-to-grow-labour-supply

you gotta love the Tories

OP posts:
LakieLady · 22/09/2022 17:55

I checked the details of this today, and it won't apply to people with health issues or disabilities. I suspect their criteria for exemption from this will be people being assessed as having limited capability for work or in receipt of PIP.

The worrying thing is that I suspect this will be another thing that is discretionary and there will be a lack of consistency in decisions and no monitoring to ensure equal treatment of all groups.

I deal with clients from approx 8 different job centres. One JC in particular makes decisions that are much tougher on claimants than most of the others.

Gingerkittykat · 22/09/2022 17:54

The article doesn't give enough details to be able to fully comment on it. People who are not carers, disabled or have children under 13 are expected to work 35 hours a week on UC already.

People with children aged between 3 and 4 are expected to be working or searching for work for 16 hours a week and with kids aged 5-12 for 25 hours.

It's not clear what group they are wanting to work more hours, there are no groups who are expected to work 12 or 15 hours at the moment so the article doesn't make sense.

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 17:46

@VioletInsolence but we’re not taking full time here, we’re talking working an extra three hours a week. If someone really can’t manage that then they should absolutely get PIP. Most people can manage it though, and could easily fit them in around school hours, so they absolutely should.

VioletInsolence · 22/09/2022 17:44

If they’re going to do that then they need to make PIP more available. A lot of people will be working part time hours because that’s all they can manage but they are considered too well to claim PIP.

It makes me so angry that people don’t understand that not everyone can work full time and they’re not lazy!

NurseryNurse10 · 22/09/2022 17:42

Yes, my job is seen as crap but someone has to do it. So many undervalued jobs which are essential to the running of society but paid peanuts for doing it. Some people work 48 hours in a nursery but if you're earning minimum wage then it doesn't amount to much. For the level of stress and work it's shocking.

TheLostNights · 22/09/2022 17:36

Nurseries struggle to staff the rooms during the week. No way would they be able to staff them at weekends. Take it from someone who knows.
This is in response to the poster who said childcare should be available of a weekend.

Neverendingdust · 22/09/2022 17:22

NotQuiteUsual · 22/09/2022 16:00

I work the maximum I can to get the 30 hour childcare but without having to pay for more hours ontop because my pay is shit and I couldn't afford that. We still qualify for UC even with me working mid time hours and my husband full time. It's ridiculous that we can work so many hours between us and it's still such low wages we need top ups.

I work in a special needs school. I'm the sort of keyworker that everyone was clapping for in 2020. But in 2022 I can't afford to heat my house, but can't afford the childcare to up my hours. And don't tell me to get a better paid job because society needs someone to do my job. When people say minimum wage can't rise, they're basically saying people who do jobs like mine don't deserve to be warm and fed.

And don't tell me to get a better paid job because society needs someone to do my job. When people say minimum wage can't rise, they're basically saying people who do jobs like mine don't deserve to be warm and fed.

You’re situation seems similar to my Sister. Basically trapped, and like you said someone has to do that job so why not just increase the pay? Her DP also works full time and yet they never seem to fully achieve anything- not quite in dire poverty but not exactly able to live exciting lives because the system just won’t let them.

Mumof3girlsandaboy · 22/09/2022 17:21

Madamecastafiore · 22/09/2022 12:50

Yes it's a good idea. In work benefits are ridiculous, it means employers don't have to pay a decent living wage because the government makes up the shortfall.

When the benefits came in years ago quite a few of the mums at school dropped their hours and went part time because they actually earnt more being part time and claiming benefits. How is that economically sustainable?

This

Ilostmysocks · 22/09/2022 17:17

Will this put a stop to those medical secretaries who work one day a week for consultants?

Our hospital is riddled with them and it slows things down considerably.

Either they need to up their hours or the NHS to make these people redundant.

I've been a patient of my consultant for years. Long enough to know the secretary was initially full time (good), then maternity, then 3 days (good), then maternity and now 1 day a week (awful, never available and always playing catch up).

Takes the absolute piss.

I work part time so I get it. But I don't think I'd be effective doing less than 3 days a week. I certainly wouldn't want my colleagues or customers to suffer from doing such few hours!

MangyInseam · 22/09/2022 17:13

AlmostSummer21 · 22/09/2022 15:08

The shortage of childcare is one thing. Employees expected to work for peanuts, unsurprisingly finding different sectors.

HOWEVER, people having kids they can't afford childcare for is quite another. Why should it be subsidised by child free people or those who made sacrifices when their own children were young?

I am ALL FOR benefits when people find themselves in shitty situations, but when they're of their own choosing (couples on benefits having 4 kids etc) then not so much, no. Plenty of people working as little as possible to maximise benefits, just means there's less for those who actually need them through no fault of their own.

people need to think first as well, zero hours contracts work well for SOME people, so they shouldn't be stopped entirely.

we need growth so we can afford higher wages.

Ultimately society needs children to continue to function, and it needs them to be well cared for and to grow up to be productive people. People without children are no different in this regard, they benefit from the outlay and work done by parents.

There isn't a problem in the UK of people having too many children, if anything there aren't enough for the kind of stability desired by most people. (They could of course look at a slow decline, but that would require a whole different attitude to the economy and won't happen, instead they will try to make up with immigration which means citizens benefiting from the work of parents in other countries they don't have to contribute to.)

What to do with children isn't really a question of individuals, it is a matter of larger social structures. Modern globalism wants both parents working as close to FT as possible and most people have little choice but to do that. So - childcare is required that is affordable under that scheme which is almost certainly going to have to be socialized to be affordable on a population level.

The other possibility would be to have an economy where a family could live on one wage and parents could take care of their own children for the most part unless they decided to work at a job well paying enough to provide for childcare.

Part of the problem is if you have the former system in place, it becomes almost impossible for all but the rich to opt out and stay home with kids. So almost everyone has to be on board with that.

MrsPear · 22/09/2022 17:11

@HermioneWeasley if there is such a shortage of workers then why is there still discrimination against returning workers?

Skolo · 22/09/2022 17:09

The more you rely on the state, the more you are at its mercy. which is why you should work more hours if you can

Raddix · 22/09/2022 17:08

I hope there are going to be exemptions for people with health issues, disabilities or caring responsibilities which restrict their working hours. Or alternatively there needs to be more state support to relieve these people of their responsibilities and free them up for paid work. I would love to have my responsibilities taken off my shoulders so I could work more hours!

MintJulia · 22/09/2022 17:07

The minimum has been 12 hours a week, so four lunchtimes bar maiding a week entitled people to benefits.

Now it'll be five lunchtimes a week to give access to those benefits. It's hardly a major ask.

I'm a single mum, I've worked 40 hours a week since the end of maternity leave and it hasn't been a problem. I'm late 50s and still doing it. I carried on doing it while being treated for breast cancer so I'm struggling to see why people whose children do not have additional needs would find this an issue.

SpilltheTea · 22/09/2022 17:07

Only if they up the pathetic minimum wage. You can't blame the part time workers when they'd be worse off working full time.

Overthebow · 22/09/2022 17:06

RedAppleGirl · 22/09/2022 16:59

The over 50s decided to opt out and make new changes mid covid. We don't need government policies to push this group into work. Just leave them alone.
This age group is pretty stable.
What the government needs are incentives for the 16-plus age groups. They also need to address the ridiculous muddle of the minimum wage.

That’s fine, leave them alone as long as they aren’t expecting benefits to sub them for not working much. I don’t have a problem with people not working as long as they are paying for it themselves.

RedAppleGirl · 22/09/2022 17:02

caringcarer · 22/09/2022 16:58

@RedAppleGirl, this will affect over 50's who claim UC just as much as under 50's. What gave you idea it won't affect over 50's who claim UC?

The article mentions policies on UC and the over 50s.
The over 50's are now under-represented in the employed market. They were the group that shrunk the most.
That's why I've made a separate point.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 22/09/2022 17:00

I don't have any problems with this policy. I think it's reasonable to ask people to work more than 15 hours a week

RedAppleGirl · 22/09/2022 16:59

Overthebow · 22/09/2022 16:36

That’s fine as long as you don’t expect the tax payers to pay for you to not work. If you can fund it yourself then great.

The over 50s decided to opt out and make new changes mid covid. We don't need government policies to push this group into work. Just leave them alone.
This age group is pretty stable.
What the government needs are incentives for the 16-plus age groups. They also need to address the ridiculous muddle of the minimum wage.

caringcarer · 22/09/2022 16:58

@RedAppleGirl, this will affect over 50's who claim UC just as much as under 50's. What gave you idea it won't affect over 50's who claim UC?

caringcarer · 22/09/2022 16:55

Also I agree employers should pay a fair rate for the job. There should be no need for government to have to top up wages so people can feed their children. Minimum wages need to rise to at least £12 per hour and more in London.

caringcarer · 22/09/2022 16:52

@pointythings, childcare is expensive. People who work in child nurserys have to be paid at least minimum wage too. The government already pays some money towards 2 year olds and a bit more towards 3 years old children. Those on UC who work also get help towards childcare so they can work. If you go back just 28 years there was no government help towards childcare. People who had children had to sort out childcare with family or arrange to pay a childminder themselves. Now government helps fund childcare for all 2-3 year olds and those on UC. I have lived through a recession and it is absolutely awful. People who have secure jobs are made redundant with little warning. If the economy is in recession employers stop taking on new staff. People fall into debt and have houses repossessed. So even though it Will be tough the government has to do all it can to try to avoid a recession. If that means those who only work a few hours but claim benefit but who could work a few more are asked to do so that is better than a long recession. It also means the benefits are better targeted at those like the disabled who can't work more hours. 2 full days a week or 3 hours a day is not unreasonable and no one is forcing people to do it if they don't want to, just don't expect to be paid to choose to stay home all the time.

Getoff · 22/09/2022 16:42

It seems reasonable to me to ask people to try to work more than 15 hours a week, if they want to claim benefits.

Apparently this will affect very few people, so that's another good reason not to be enraged by it.

Overthebow · 22/09/2022 16:39

RedAppleGirl · 22/09/2022 15:41

Why don't the government leave the over 50's alone? I know that in 5 yrs I'll be 54 and I'm semi-retiring. I've had enough of working.

That’s fine as long as you don’t expect the taxpayer to pay for you not to work. If you can find it yourself than great.

Overthebow · 22/09/2022 16:36

RedAppleGirl · 22/09/2022 15:41

Why don't the government leave the over 50's alone? I know that in 5 yrs I'll be 54 and I'm semi-retiring. I've had enough of working.

That’s fine as long as you don’t expect the tax payers to pay for you to not work. If you can fund it yourself then great.

Swipe left for the next trending thread