Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this won’t work and will force more into poverty?

160 replies

KimberleyClark · 22/09/2022 12:41

Kwasi Korteng wants to cut benefits to part time workers to force them to work more hours.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/sep/21/kwasi-kwarteng-to-shrink-part-time-work-benefits-to-grow-labour-supply

you gotta love the Tories

OP posts:
Raddix · 22/09/2022 19:19

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 19:15

I think the government should run a consultation on why people don't increase their hours and then address those barriers, for example by investing in quality/affordable childcare, public transport, housing etc.

Yes this would make sense! Not penalising people by cutting their benefits because they can’t work more.

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 19:15

I think the government should run a consultation on why people don't increase their hours and then address those barriers, for example by investing in quality/affordable childcare, public transport, housing etc.

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 19:05

@FarmerRefuted sorry to hear of the difficult times you’ve had with your child’s disability.

I totally see how when you were trying to juggle everything full time it was too much. Do you not think people can do 15 hours a week though if their kids are in full time school? And if not, how many hours? If none at all, then does this extend all the way until the youngest child is 18?

I don’t want anyone to flog themselves to death and I want everyone to live with dignity, but I’m really not on board with that. There has to be some expectation of work from a health adult with school age children and I don’t think 15 hours with top up benefits is unreasonable.

yellowspanner · 22/09/2022 19:03

I think this policy is a good idea. I know two people on benefits who refuse to work more hours. It's the tax payers who are paying for them not to work. That is unfair and unsustainable. It is fair that people paid for by the taxpayers should work as many hours as possible.

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 18:59

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 18:46

@HardLanding and @FarmerRefuted i really feel for you both with shitty transport connections. I live rurally and until about 6 months ago the bus that came three times a week was my only independent form of transport, so I do empathise.

However, it’s seems from your stories that you are both active in work or education for at least 15 hours a week, to your immense credit. Why would you not expect this of other people as well? It’s really not much to ask.

I don't expect it from other people because I know how much of a slog it is to coordinate it all and how just link in the chain failing (e.g., local nursery closing down) can bring the whole thing tumbling down, not everyone has the means or the fortitude to juggle that sort of situation long term. My model also relied heavily on my mum being available to do the care pre-and-post childminder opening hours.

My model did all fall down when one of my DC was diagnosed with a disability affecting the suitability of the childcare available to me, by that point I had younger DC too and ended up leaving employment to be their full time carer for which I got Carers Allowance.

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 18:52

@RafaistheKingofClay and @Gingerkittykat I think the 12 hours moving to 15 hours thing relates to the fact that if you’re working 12 hours then you don’t have to attend regular job centre appointments. You’re left to your own devices, so the government is basically allowing you to work 12 hours and receive top up benefits with no pressure to increase your earnings. This is increasing to 15, so someone would have to work 15 hours a week in order not to be pestered to work more.

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 18:46

@HardLanding and @FarmerRefuted i really feel for you both with shitty transport connections. I live rurally and until about 6 months ago the bus that came three times a week was my only independent form of transport, so I do empathise.

However, it’s seems from your stories that you are both active in work or education for at least 15 hours a week, to your immense credit. Why would you not expect this of other people as well? It’s really not much to ask.

pointythings · 22/09/2022 18:45

@ClocksGoingBackwards firstly, after school care is not free. It's less than nursery provision, but it's still a cost and one that usually goes in tandem with the cost of uniform, school trips, school dinners etc. Children get more expensive as they get older, not cheaper.

Secondly, moving house costs money. Relocation is not as simple as you make it sound, especially with the housing market still on fire and rental costs rising very fast. Yes, people should provide for themselves - but it should be made easier for them to do so. To my mind that means focusing on those who are not already very wealthy, which is the opposite of this government's ideology.

Raddix · 22/09/2022 18:42

HOWEVER, people having kids they can't afford childcare for is quite another. Why should it be subsidised by child free people or those who made sacrifices when their own children were young?
Minimum wage barely covers the cost of commuting to work and wrap-around childcare for one school child. You break even and have nothing left to live on. It certainly doesn’t cover multiple kids or full time care before school age.

Are you saying that people on minimum wage should never have children? That only the rich should have children? We aren’t talking about feckless people having multiple kids. We’re talking about working people who can’t even afford one child.

And if people don’t have kids, who will do the jobs and pay the taxes in 30 years time when you retire?

ClocksGoingBackwards · 22/09/2022 18:41

Schools are encouraged as much as possible to provide wrap around care, and if it’s viable they usually do. I don’t think childcare is the major issue here. People know their what their earnings are and if they live in an area that has decent childcare options before they have children. People should relocate and provide as much as they can for themselves before expecting cash handouts from the state.

It makes sense to expect people to work full time or close to it if they can’t afford to live on a part time wage. It does not make sense to incentivise people to work as little as they can by giving them free money to top them up to a liveable income.

RafaistheKingofClay · 22/09/2022 18:41

Gingerkittykat · 22/09/2022 17:54

The article doesn't give enough details to be able to fully comment on it. People who are not carers, disabled or have children under 13 are expected to work 35 hours a week on UC already.

People with children aged between 3 and 4 are expected to be working or searching for work for 16 hours a week and with kids aged 5-12 for 25 hours.

It's not clear what group they are wanting to work more hours, there are no groups who are expected to work 12 or 15 hours at the moment so the article doesn't make sense.

Glad you mentioned this because I couldn’t work it out. Who are this group who originally had to work 9hrs then had it increased to 12 before it was increased to 15 today? Off the top of my head I can’t think of another group who wouldn’t already have to be looking for work under the current rules.

They’d have to be a group with a fairly specific reason for not being able to work 16hrs. People with children under the age of 3 and people with sickness of disabilities that mean they’ve been assessed as not being able to work 16hrs maybe.

DrCoconut · 22/09/2022 18:39

@GoingThatWay it seems that little gem has largely gone under the radar. Absolute arseholes. The older generation of the family were right, never trust the Tories, they will look after their rich pals and sod everyone else. Hell will freeze over before I'd ever vote for them.

Crankley · 22/09/2022 18:36

Ilostmysocks
Will this put a stop to those medical secretaries who work one day a week for consultants?
Our hospital is riddled with them and it slows things down considerably.
Either they need to up their hours or the NHS to make these people redundant.

You're absolutely right. My neighbour's daughter was working as a temp secretary. She recently worked for a consultant in the local hospital. She wasn't terribly busy and noticed a pile of files with audio tapes attached. Upon asking if she should be typing the tapes, was told by the consultant that they were being left for his secretary to return from her three week holiday. That as they were private patients the secretary would be paid extra per letter. It's not difficult to guess they will be given priority over NHS work when she got back.

lannistunut · 22/09/2022 18:32

It is just absolute bullshit - they want everyone to turn on a benefit claimant to distract attention from the massive tax handout they are about to give to the richest 10%.

Unless you are in the top 10%, you are a dipshit to fall for this yet again.

I have more in common with those on benefits than I do with the bankers getting their soon-to-be-uncapped bonuses.

HardLanding · 22/09/2022 18:29

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 18:12

Transport issues, childcare etc is not a valid excuse in my view - people are already managing these for the twelve hours they currently do so will just need to adapt for a further three.

Where I live there is one bus service running between Town A and Town B. It takes 90 minutes to get from A to B, a distance of around 15 miles. If you want to go elsewhere then you need to get a connecting bus at either Town A or Town B, the availability and timetabling of these connecting buses varies greatly. First bus in the morning is at 6am, it runs every 30 minutes until 6pm at which point it runs every hour until 10pm. After 10pm there are no buses. On Sundays the first bus is at 9am, they run once an hour, and last bus is at 9pm. On some Bank Holidays they run to Sunday timetable and on other Bank Holidays they don't run at all - for example this Christmas there is no bus after 5pm on Christmas Eve and New Years Eve and no bus at all on the 25th, 26th, 27th of December and the 1st and 2nd of January (the Bank Holidays).

They're expensive too. £6.80 return for an adult, £3.40 per child. This only covers you for that operator, the connecting buses at Town A and Town B are both operated by a different company and so need their own tickets.

As for childcare, we have one nursery for ages 0-3 and it's closing this month due to no longer being financially viable. School nursery starts age 3 but is only mornings 9am to 12pm. There is wrap around care at the First School, limited to 40 places and only available up to Year 4 (age 8 to 9). The middle school (age 9+) doesn't have wrap around care. There are eight childminders locally, they all have a waiting list and none of them serves the middle school so, again, only up to Year Four/age 8-9.

Back when I worked full time I had to get the DC up at 430, then preschool aged, and get them fed and dressed and take them to my mum's for 530 so I could get the 6am bus to work (no staff parking available), DH also got this bus. Mum would look after the DC until 8am when the childminder opened and drop them there on her own way to work. Childminder closed at 5pm so mum would collect DC on her way home and feed them at hers. DH and I would get back at 6, collect DC, take them home for bed and then do it all again the next day. It was exhausting and there is nothing more shut than having to drag a sleepy toddler out at 5am on a winter morning when really they should be in bed.

Oh sod off.

In a city centre, yes.

I’m semi rural - 25 mins drive to the nearest city.

To get to Uni (post grad), I had ONE bus to rely on, which is every hour. It goes to a small transport place. Where I then had to wait 30 mins for another bus.

Door to door, a 25 min drive was taking me 95 minutes to get there, and 2.5 hours to get back most days, as due to traffic/late bus, I’d just miss the bus back to my town, and have to wait an hour.

Fortunately I had bomb proof childcare (single parent) and a course leader who wasn’t a twat.

We ended up living here due to being made homeless, and I had to take the first house I was offered.

I passed my driving test shortly before I finished my Masters, but don’t be so fucking naive.

Subbaxeo · 22/09/2022 18:26

Notlosinganyweight · 22/09/2022 13:14

Ha ha. Benefits have been cut over the years and our economy is great now isn't it? Very robust, oh........😂

The level of ignorant shit on MN today has gone up a notch today, so the Tory bots are out oin full force clearly. Do you think they might be announcing something soon? They are trying to save themselves at our expense now.

Gosh, I assumed someone was being ironic-is that post for real?

Livelovebehappy · 22/09/2022 18:23

I agree tbh. But there should be a big overhaul of the childcare system, as working full time, you’re practically working for nothing after you’ve paid the nursery.

pointythings · 22/09/2022 18:19

@caringcarer yes, childcare is expensive. When I had two DDs in nursery, that ate up two thirds of my monthly take home pay. These days it would be 98%. This country can't have its cake and eat it. Fund childcare properly - that means subsidising it, yes - and pay childcare workers properly too. Then we can talk about making people return to work or face having their benefits cut.

Skodacool · 22/09/2022 18:18

ClottedCreamAndStrawberries · 22/09/2022 14:16

Tell me again why people shouldn’t work more?

For one or more of the reasons pp have been stating in their replies.

RaininSummer · 22/09/2022 18:17

If it's done carefully and applied to those who have no reason not to work more then it's a good thing I think. I know people with 3 kids where only one of the couple works 20 hours a week. No reason they can't do more other than they want 'family time'. Pretty cheeky.

sashagabadon · 22/09/2022 18:16

I am neutral on this. I work with a fair few that work part time as UC tops them up. They could work full time but choose not to. Once their kids leave school they’ll loose the UC ( or some of it) and talk about working full time then. They mostly have teens not kids that need childcare.
I get their logic and I don’t blame them but it is irritating when they basically get similar in their pocket as those working full time.

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 18:12

Transport issues, childcare etc is not a valid excuse in my view - people are already managing these for the twelve hours they currently do so will just need to adapt for a further three.

Where I live there is one bus service running between Town A and Town B. It takes 90 minutes to get from A to B, a distance of around 15 miles. If you want to go elsewhere then you need to get a connecting bus at either Town A or Town B, the availability and timetabling of these connecting buses varies greatly. First bus in the morning is at 6am, it runs every 30 minutes until 6pm at which point it runs every hour until 10pm. After 10pm there are no buses. On Sundays the first bus is at 9am, they run once an hour, and last bus is at 9pm. On some Bank Holidays they run to Sunday timetable and on other Bank Holidays they don't run at all - for example this Christmas there is no bus after 5pm on Christmas Eve and New Years Eve and no bus at all on the 25th, 26th, 27th of December and the 1st and 2nd of January (the Bank Holidays).

They're expensive too. £6.80 return for an adult, £3.40 per child. This only covers you for that operator, the connecting buses at Town A and Town B are both operated by a different company and so need their own tickets.

As for childcare, we have one nursery for ages 0-3 and it's closing this month due to no longer being financially viable. School nursery starts age 3 but is only mornings 9am to 12pm. There is wrap around care at the First School, limited to 40 places and only available up to Year 4 (age 8 to 9). The middle school (age 9+) doesn't have wrap around care. There are eight childminders locally, they all have a waiting list and none of them serves the middle school so, again, only up to Year Four/age 8-9.

Back when I worked full time I had to get the DC up at 430, then preschool aged, and get them fed and dressed and take them to my mum's for 530 so I could get the 6am bus to work (no staff parking available), DH also got this bus. Mum would look after the DC until 8am when the childminder opened and drop them there on her own way to work. Childminder closed at 5pm so mum would collect DC on her way home and feed them at hers. DH and I would get back at 6, collect DC, take them home for bed and then do it all again the next day. It was exhausting and there is nothing more shut than having to drag a sleepy toddler out at 5am on a winter morning when really they should be in bed.

GoingThatWay · 22/09/2022 18:10

In the same sentence, they lift the bonus cap for bankers.
Which means the poor are forced to work more hours and still be on the breadline, while the rich get richer.
Not at all typical Tory hey!

walkingonsunshinekat · 22/09/2022 18:08

hattie43 · 22/09/2022 15:43

I can see the logic and the country needs more workers . I'm also thinking they know tax paying people are very fed up for others to sit on benefits at their expense when they aren't disabled . Liz Truss has said a few things that make me realise she doesn't want people reliant on benefits indefinitely and all the ' carrots ' will be aimed at workers .
Ultimately benefits keep people in poverty so if there is a push to get people that can into the workplace I think it's good thinking outside the norm .

There is no logic as the numbers working just 12 hours (the current min) is very small, so even if they all went to FT, it would make little difference.

How about making work more attractive? why not lift the cap on care worker bonuses? that seems to be the answer for the 'city.

As for Carrots? its a threat to cut monies, so all Stick i'm afraid.

All this has come about since Brexit, they are now having to introduce every more desperate policies to make up for their disastrous exit from the EU.

LakieLady · 22/09/2022 17:57

pinok · 22/09/2022 16:10

What about making sure companies and rich people are paying the right amount of tax? Why do the tories always look to the people at the very bottom with the very least

Because Tories are always gonna Tory.

Swipe left for the next trending thread