Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this won’t work and will force more into poverty?

160 replies

KimberleyClark · 22/09/2022 12:41

Kwasi Korteng wants to cut benefits to part time workers to force them to work more hours.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/sep/21/kwasi-kwarteng-to-shrink-part-time-work-benefits-to-grow-labour-supply

you gotta love the Tories

OP posts:
Overthebow · 23/09/2022 07:52

Raddix · 22/09/2022 20:49

There are plenty of vacancies out there and yet many work part time with top up benefits, there is obviously some financial benefit otherwise why do it.

Work 16 hours, get topped up to a full time salary, and look after your own kids so you have no childcare to pay.

Or work 40 hours for a full time salary and have to pay for childcare.

It’s obvious why people pick option 1. They’re massively better off!

Yes this is the problem and needs to change. It’s not right that people can choose this. Fair enough if people are genuinely too unwell to work more but not if it’s a choice.

womaninatightspot · 23/09/2022 00:28

FrankTheThunderbird · 23/09/2022 00:18

You can work full time and claim top up benefits. I did.

I work 35 hours a week so fairly full time and get roughly £800 in UC a month less if it's a five week month. More if I've paid childcare costs.

FrankTheThunderbird · 23/09/2022 00:18

Raddix · 22/09/2022 20:39

This is a policy about people working a mere 12 hours a week, not people working full time for minimum wage. Presumably if people were working full time, they’d still get the top up through benefits to help with those things.
No you don’t get top up benefits if you work full time. I’d be entitled to £1200 a year towards childcare and that’s all.

And it IS about people working full time for min wage. Because it’s about pushing people who work part time to increase their hours. A lot of them can’t, for the reasons outlined. It’s possible to work part time during school hours, get topped up with benefits and look after your kids yourself - but due to the costs of childcare it’s not possible to work more hours and pay for care.

You can work full time and claim top up benefits. I did.

somepeoplestillhaveasoul · 23/09/2022 00:11

This is literally terrifying, it's getting Victorian.
If you support this then quite frankly you have no fucking idea what you are talking about.

I have prolapses, my female organs and bowels are literally falling out of my body from childbirth complications (my children are nearly adults now) and all the highly, highly unpleasant debilitating symptoms that you can imagine come with your organs falling out, and yet I am not believed by the DWP, to be unfit for work. I absolutely cannot work more than part time, but I'll be put through this new measure and threatened with sanction and literal starvation and homelessness if I cannot increase my hours (which is what 'sanction' is by the way - no money to live on).

I wish so, so much I could work full time like I used to and have some agency in my life. You have no idea how much I wish I could just work again.

Do you people think that you just tell the dwp that you have a health problem and then bingo you are exempt from their threats of sanction, can go part time and claim all the monies??!! (the £77 a week..). It doesn't work like that. Disabled people wait months and years waiting for appeal after appeal against the 'decisions' of the dwp. The majority of those deemed 'fit for work' by the dwp are overturned at independent tribunal, which takes many months or even years. This is a proven fact.

With the state of the NHS it took me over a year to get a diagnosis even though it was more than obvious what is wrong!! What are we supposed to do?? Schrodinger's disability?? We cannot access medical care and are therefore fit to work full time??

I genuinely, genuinely, despair that some people think this is somehow okay that the Tories make the rich richer, whilst perpetrating this against low paid and disabled.

Please, please, open your eyes.

womaninatightspot · 22/09/2022 21:10

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 19:37

but if someone has a child in school 30 hours then they don’t need childcare to work 15 hours, do they? And they have a whole other 15 child free hours to commute in if they need to.

That's if there's a job available with shifts that only take place between the hours of 9.30am and 2.30pm (allowing commute time to be at school for drop off and pick up). This would also need to be term time only because the children don't just blink out of existence during the holidays. This job would also have to have no expectation that this person would be able to do extra shifts, for example to cover sick or holidays for other staff or busy periods such as sales.

How many jobs like that exist?

Tbh the only job I've found like that is hotel housekeeping suck it up with holiday clubs in summer and claim back the 85%.

It's an excellent use of my law degree, obviously!

Babyroobs · 22/09/2022 20:55

Isaidnoalready · 22/09/2022 20:53

Won't this effect people claiming carers allowance? Your restricted on how many hours you work because you need to be providing 35 hours a week care to get your £69 along with that you get the benefit of not having to job search because your a carer but you CAN work as long as you only work a couple of hours

Many people claiming carers allowance will also be claiming Universal credit but they have no work commitments as a carer so won't need to look for more hours.

Isaidnoalready · 22/09/2022 20:53

Won't this effect people claiming carers allowance? Your restricted on how many hours you work because you need to be providing 35 hours a week care to get your £69 along with that you get the benefit of not having to job search because your a carer but you CAN work as long as you only work a couple of hours

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 20:52

@Raddix sure they are, lucky them! That’s why people sometimes have limited sympathy when the prospect of them working 15 hours rather than 12 arises…

Its not my job to raise other people’s families, sorry.

Queuesarasarah · 22/09/2022 20:51

People are working part time because of either poor health or caring responsibilities. At a time when NHS has massive backlogs, provision for special needs and disabled children is extremely poor and social care is on its knees this policy seems particularly idiotic. Perhaps they might do better to fix some of these issues and people would choose to work more hours.

Some reason jobs are unfilled that they could actually helpfully work on are that inflation means some jobs don’t pay enough to live on, and we no longer have EU workers nor do many sectors have sensible visa schemes.

Seriously, let’s all agree never to put these idiots in charge again.

Babyroobs · 22/09/2022 20:51

Namedifferentorquestion · 22/09/2022 20:45

I'm not sure of the current benefit system but when my children were at school there were parents that worked 16 hours and claimed tax credit and working tax credit and purposely didn't work full time because the tax credit top up was enough to make up the difference.

I think if you have a number of children then working less hours does work out better since no childcare to pay for and more time with children.

There are plenty of vacancies out there and yet many work part time with top up benefits, there is obviously some financial benefit otherwise why do it.

Lone parents on tax credits can still work just 16 hours right up until their kids leave education. I have a friend who was doing this until recently. Now her child has left education and the tax credits ahve stopped she is scrambling to find a full time job. I'm sure there are not a huge number who stay on 16 hours for this long but it does happen.

Raddix · 22/09/2022 20:49

There are plenty of vacancies out there and yet many work part time with top up benefits, there is obviously some financial benefit otherwise why do it.

Work 16 hours, get topped up to a full time salary, and look after your own kids so you have no childcare to pay.

Or work 40 hours for a full time salary and have to pay for childcare.

It’s obvious why people pick option 1. They’re massively better off!

Namedifferentorquestion · 22/09/2022 20:45

I'm not sure of the current benefit system but when my children were at school there were parents that worked 16 hours and claimed tax credit and working tax credit and purposely didn't work full time because the tax credit top up was enough to make up the difference.

I think if you have a number of children then working less hours does work out better since no childcare to pay for and more time with children.

There are plenty of vacancies out there and yet many work part time with top up benefits, there is obviously some financial benefit otherwise why do it.

Babyroobs · 22/09/2022 20:41

With Uc at the moment, if one of a couple is working then often the other is put in a light touch group where they barely have to look for work at all. But the minimum earnings that the working one needs to earn for the other to be in the light touch group is currently around £567 per month, rising to £782 per month this month. I just find it incredible that up to now, one of a couple can earn just £567 a month and the other have no real work commitments or need to search for work yet able to claim UC. Unless I am misunderstanding the rules? If I have understood correctly then things absolutely need to change as Uc is just as bad as the old working tax credits system where couples could work just 24 hours a week between them to be topped up by working tax credits.

Raddix · 22/09/2022 20:39

This is a policy about people working a mere 12 hours a week, not people working full time for minimum wage. Presumably if people were working full time, they’d still get the top up through benefits to help with those things.
No you don’t get top up benefits if you work full time. I’d be entitled to £1200 a year towards childcare and that’s all.

And it IS about people working full time for min wage. Because it’s about pushing people who work part time to increase their hours. A lot of them can’t, for the reasons outlined. It’s possible to work part time during school hours, get topped up with benefits and look after your kids yourself - but due to the costs of childcare it’s not possible to work more hours and pay for care.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 22/09/2022 20:15

Minimum wage barely covers the cost of commuting to work and wrap-around childcare for one school child. You break even and have nothing left to live on. It certainly doesn’t cover multiple kids or full time care before school age.

This is a policy about people working a mere 12 hours a week, not people working full time for minimum wage. Presumably if people were working full time, they’d still get the top up through benefits to help with those things.

Are you saying that people on minimum wage should never have children? That only the rich should have children? We aren’t talking about feckless people having multiple kids. We’re talking about working people who can’t even afford one child.

There is a lot of space between being on minimum wage and being rich. We’re not talking about working people who can’t even afford one child despite doing a full working week, we’re talking about people working part time, maybe for minimum wage, maybe for more. People working part time for a low wage are never going to be able to afford a child without increasing their earnings somehow, so no, they shouldn’t be having children because raising children isn’t free.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 22/09/2022 20:06

@ClocksGoingBackwards firstly, after school care is not free. It's less than nursery provision, but it's still a cost and one that usually goes in tandem with the cost of uniform, school trips, school dinners etc. Children get more expensive as they get older, not cheaper.

True, and I would support free or heavily subsidised childcare, even for children below school age and even if it cost more than providing the benefit money. Either way, people should still be bale to afford children before they have them.

IrisVersicolor · 22/09/2022 19:47

That old chestnut - incentivise the rich by paying them more, incentivise the poor by paying them less.

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 19:45

There are quite a few jobs near me that can be done in school hours and I live in the back of beyond. Thinking particularly cafes, supermarkets, schools, secretarial work etc.

For holidays, the government should definitely do more for affordable childcare but parents also have to plan ahead with clubs etc and budget for that accordingly. That is the tough reality for all parents at the moment so the ones working 12 hours now expected to work 15 are no different in that respect.

RafaistheKingofClay · 22/09/2022 19:45

At least she admitted it live on national TV too. None of that waffle pretending that the rich aren’t getting richer and the poor aren’t getting poorer that Boris would have given.

lannistunut · 22/09/2022 19:42

Lifeisaminestrone · 22/09/2022 19:37

Liz Truss has only been in Government for a couple of weeks and is making some radical changes!

She is spending big money by removing the additional NIC and providing more support for fuel.

Tough decisions need to be made and they won’t please everyone. She is taking quite a different direction from the former Tory leaderships.

I like it that’s she’s taking decisive action that she believes is in the best interest. Cameron and May tried to please too many people and failed. Johnson was a joke and just in it for his own self interest.

I was impressed by her helping with the Iranian hostages.

Will her new policies help the economy… I’m not sure yet… they aren’t ones I’d have made. But I think she is trying, so I’m not going to judge her yet.

I’m sitting on the fence at the moment….

She is giving so much money to the richest and very little to the poorest.

It is quite shocking to see it being done so blatantly.

Lifeisaminestrone · 22/09/2022 19:37

Liz Truss has only been in Government for a couple of weeks and is making some radical changes!

She is spending big money by removing the additional NIC and providing more support for fuel.

Tough decisions need to be made and they won’t please everyone. She is taking quite a different direction from the former Tory leaderships.

I like it that’s she’s taking decisive action that she believes is in the best interest. Cameron and May tried to please too many people and failed. Johnson was a joke and just in it for his own self interest.

I was impressed by her helping with the Iranian hostages.

Will her new policies help the economy… I’m not sure yet… they aren’t ones I’d have made. But I think she is trying, so I’m not going to judge her yet.

I’m sitting on the fence at the moment….

FarmerRefuted · 22/09/2022 19:37

but if someone has a child in school 30 hours then they don’t need childcare to work 15 hours, do they? And they have a whole other 15 child free hours to commute in if they need to.

That's if there's a job available with shifts that only take place between the hours of 9.30am and 2.30pm (allowing commute time to be at school for drop off and pick up). This would also need to be term time only because the children don't just blink out of existence during the holidays. This job would also have to have no expectation that this person would be able to do extra shifts, for example to cover sick or holidays for other staff or busy periods such as sales.

How many jobs like that exist?

RafaistheKingofClay · 22/09/2022 19:36

@cowskeepingmeupatnight that makes more sense. If I’m right from googling this isn’t really about hours. It’s about the earnings threshold which doesn’t seem to have changed with the minimum wage so was equivalent to working fewer hours.

Re: After school care. Not only is it not free but holiday care can be extortionate. Easily possible to spend much more per day on childcare for 2 children than you earn as a single parent in a low wage job.

the government could choose to change a lot of things to make working easier. Instead it largely seems to go for actions which will make the poor poorer during a cost of living crisis. All made worse by the fact that the Tories fucked up UC when they introduced it and rather than trying to fix it they seem to be deliberately trying to break it more.

AntlerRose · 22/09/2022 19:30

Logically you can drop your child at school, commute somewhere, do your work, commute back without needing childcare in term time. But realistically there arent lots of jobs offering those terms.

cowskeepingmeupatnight · 22/09/2022 19:28

@FarmerRefuted but if someone has a child in school 30 hours then they don’t need childcare to work 15 hours, do they? And they have a whole other 15 child free hours to commute in if they need to.

I’m all for tackling barriers to employment but I don’t see many barriers to working 15 hours a week (3 more than the current expectation) if you’re a healthy adult with school age children.

I had my first job at 12, juggled 3 jobs while I took my GCSE exams, left home at 16 and worked 30 hours while at college. After uni I juggled unpaid internships with bar work for a few years until finally starting my career. Currently work around 50 hours a week with regular, extended periods of travel to humanitarian disaster zones. It’s hot, the foods normally shit and I have semi-permanent jet lag some months. I’m sorry but I really don’t buy that another woman my age can’t put in 15 hours a week cos she’s got an 8 year old in school or whatever.

Swipe left for the next trending thread