Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think this won’t work and will force more into poverty?

160 replies

KimberleyClark · 22/09/2022 12:41

Kwasi Korteng wants to cut benefits to part time workers to force them to work more hours.

www.theguardian.com/politics/2022/sep/21/kwasi-kwarteng-to-shrink-part-time-work-benefits-to-grow-labour-supply

you gotta love the Tories

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Crikeyalmighty · 23/09/2022 13:45

As I said below the gvt are constantly tinkering at the edges with things designed to appeal to those that vote for them who are mainly homeowners, often over a certain age and who have a mentality fundamentally opposed to benefits (until they themselves need them or a close family member does) - also often opposed to immigration from anywhere that isn't British speaking as mother tongue.

None of the big issues are tackled such as radical change in housing policy and social housing. Right to buy should be totally abolished in my opinion. Councils should have to allow 50% of any new building to be for social housing (of all types) - give huge incentives to insurance /pension funds to build and develop for rent at social rates. Take a good look at immigration for work purposes from offshore- why pay £5000 plus to bring people from Indonesia but anyone from EU has to jump through multiple hoops . Why not keep tax the same but fund and subsidise school holiday clubs, nursery provision for all over 1s, after school clubs, over 70s social groups etc , bring back surestart and connexions (for teens). Get more social wardens (paid) on the streets and town centres in an evening etc

Why reduce tax when the country isn't functioning in so many areas and there clearly isn't enough social investment or barely functioning services. I don't think an extra £80 or so extra a month in personal wages is going to touch the sides of sorting out the real big issues- it would be better spent and ringfenced on national issues.

Alexandra2001 · 23/09/2022 13:19

Try reading through to my second paragraph. In that paragraph I stated where issues could arise - that could be considered a constructive criticism, no? This is where exceptions will have to be made to accommodate them, such as exempting parents of kids below a certain age or those who receive Carers Allowance. In fact, many of these exceptions are already in place as this is a moving of a threshold rather than a brand new policy.
You've jumped straight on me, but not on anyone else who has spoken up for it, I notice. I've told you before that I don't just blindly support any policy that they turn up. I definitely preferred Andrew Adonis to Chris Grayling in the DfT for example

I'm not picking on you but you ve not NC'd & a very memorable name, so its easy to follow your politics and imo you do back any Tory policy, no matter how stupid, if you don't like that, don't do it or at least deny it plus we both ride bikes, so you need educating lol!

Chris Grayling gave a freight contract to a company with no ferries, even i would be surprised if you backed him.

Carers don't work FT because they already commit to 35hr per week.

Parents of young children don't usually fall into the over 50s target group.

But lots of older people have informal caring responsibilities, i used too, went PT to help my mum live independently, being available to get her to hospital or GPs was vital... it was PT (2 days a week) or nothing for mum and UC does not allow for this.

Also, not addressed how you aim a policy at a specific adult age group?

UC is a very proscriptive means of benefit delivery.

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 12:45

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 12:41

Alexandra2001 · 23/09/2022 08:55

See what i mean? never criticise a Tory policy, no matter how pointless, the total numbers involved is less than 150k people out of 5m UC claimants, the number of the over 50s in that group is even smaller.

Any ideas on how you can target a specific age group? what about a 49 yo.... vs a 65yo?
Esp an age group many employers simply don't want to employ.

Meanwhile lets give a £180 NI saving to someone on 30k p.a but £1000 saving to someone on 100k.

A carer on 18k wont even notice.

Its a smokescreen to mask their disastrous Brexit & hide their Give to the Rich Tax Cuts.

Try reading through to my second paragraph. In that paragraph I stated where issues could arise - that could be considered a constructive criticism, no? This is where exceptions will have to be made to accommodate them, such as exempting parents of kids below a certain age or those who receive Carers Allowance. In fact, many of these exceptions are already in place as this is a moving of a threshold rather than a brand new policy.

You've jumped straight on me, but not on anyone else who has spoken up for it, I notice. I've told you before that I don't just blindly support any policy that they turn up. I definitely preferred Andrew Adonis to Chris Grayling in the DfT for example.

FarmerRefuted · 23/09/2022 11:30

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 11:21

Do you people think that you just tell the dwp that you have a health problem and then bingo you are exempt from their threats of sanction

My mum had a friend whose son has or had kidney failure (I don't know if he is still alive as this was about five year ago). He needed daily dialysis, not 3-4 times a week like I think it is usually and so clearly can't work. Yet he has to constantly justify why he can't work. It is ludicrous (and a waste of resources constantly checking up on people).

A family member is an amputee, a transplant patient, has heart problems, blind in one eye, severe neuropathy, diverticulitis, and some other health issues plus is only four years away from state pension age/retirement. Super attractive prospect for potential employers, aren't they? The DWP has them in the work activity group, they have to sign on and they have to justify why they can't find a job.

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 11:21

Do you people think that you just tell the dwp that you have a health problem and then bingo you are exempt from their threats of sanction

My mum had a friend whose son has or had kidney failure (I don't know if he is still alive as this was about five year ago). He needed daily dialysis, not 3-4 times a week like I think it is usually and so clearly can't work. Yet he has to constantly justify why he can't work. It is ludicrous (and a waste of resources constantly checking up on people).

gatehouseoffleet · 23/09/2022 11:18

Maybe if the government actually took steps to stop companies forcing older workers out, there wouldn't be such a shortage

Indeed, I noticed that they were going to have new job coaches for unemployed over 50s. Well sort out employers who manage older workers out! Even my woke employer who has various diversity and inclusivity initiatives doesn't have one for older employees, despite my suggesting it.

Povertystricken · 23/09/2022 10:41

I work for the government, I look forward to them offering me the extra hours I've been asking for for the last ten years instead of the split shifts they currently offer me which stops me getting any other job to fill the gap.

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 10:35

lannistunut · 22/09/2022 19:42

She is giving so much money to the richest and very little to the poorest.

It is quite shocking to see it being done so blatantly.

A tax cut isn't "giving money". A tax cut is merely not taking it.

Crikeyalmighty · 23/09/2022 10:31

I am centre left and social minded but the current system is actually incentivising it to make more sense to not work full time if you have kids and are either alone or with a very modestly paid partner and rent .

I have got to the point where I don't blame some people, although it will bite them on the arse once kids leave home or they don't have social housing and find they need to move.

The gvt need to stop tinckering at the edges and get to the nubs of the problem and the problem is that in vast swathes of the country there simply isn't enough decent social housing- meaning that people can pay rents from wages and lower paid jobs will still make sense - not needing to be paid in benefits. The gvt need to accept that the young EU people who were here were not in the main taking other peoples jobs, they were filling gaps in the workforce that others simply didn't want to do and we now have huge price rises due to shortages in labour market amongst other things and we need to make childcare subsidised and affordable for all ages of children - there are many women just outside the level of getting any help and working full time would indeed make them worse off if they need childcare.

People think Britain is a low tax society, it really isn't if you add in NI, council tax, paying for stuff that other higher tax nations take for granted as part of general taxation. But we waste so much on paying comfortably off peoples mortgages for them on 'investment' places etc by having to pay peoples private rentals. We have just wasted £490 billion on Brexit simply to mainly appease right wing voters with no real bonuses for average people. We have a party who are constantly thinking 'how can we prop up our vote' rather than actually governing for all and to make life fairer for all -

walkingonsunshinekat · 23/09/2022 10:24

gogohmm · 23/09/2022 09:51

It's not cutting benefits, it's increasing the number of hours you need to work to be classed as working for benefits purposes. Currently it's only 9, increasing to 15 shortly. 24 seems reasonable to me for single parents, with 35 for everyone else. I'm all for giving benefits to those on low incomes but not those who can't be bothered to look for full time work

Most older people i know who work part time have genuine reasons for doing so, usually fitting around care for elderly parents, not FT carers but irregular medical appointments, house work etc.

Its targeted at the over 50s, so not single parents, its illegal to discriminate on age grounds, so i doubt this measure will ever happen.

Like all Tories policies full of shit.

FarmerRefuted · 23/09/2022 09:55

gogohmm · 23/09/2022 09:51

It's not cutting benefits, it's increasing the number of hours you need to work to be classed as working for benefits purposes. Currently it's only 9, increasing to 15 shortly. 24 seems reasonable to me for single parents, with 35 for everyone else. I'm all for giving benefits to those on low incomes but not those who can't be bothered to look for full time work

This affects roughly 120,000 people which is a tiny fraction of rhe overall number of people eligible for benefits. I'm going to guess that the majority of those 120,000 have solid reasons for why they can't increase their hours.

It's not going to save vast amounts of money, it's not going to suddenly revise the economy, it's just Tory tactics of divide and rule - giving people a demographic to blame for the shitted up mess the government has created to try and distract them from blaming the people who are in charge.

lemonyanus · 23/09/2022 09:55

If they subsidised childcare to make it actually affordable none of this would be needed. Women will suffer disproportionately from this (as usual)

FarmerRefuted · 23/09/2022 09:52

Kicking rhe people at the bottom creates a handy scapegoat for the government though: "oh we aren't the reason you're skint and everything is shit. The reason you're skint and everything is shit is because Debbie from down the road and c.120,000 of her pals are only working 12hrs a week and that mere drop in the ocean in terms of our overall spend is somehow bleeding the country dry...."

It'll be disabled people next and then wider claimant groups, just watch. The narrative of "deserving" and "genuine" vs "undeserving" and "piss takers" will be ramped right up so they can justify further cuts to welfare and cuts to services.

Absolute cunts the lot of them. They wouldn't piss on you if you were on fire but they would probably find a way to bill you for the heat generated.

gogohmm · 23/09/2022 09:51

It's not cutting benefits, it's increasing the number of hours you need to work to be classed as working for benefits purposes. Currently it's only 9, increasing to 15 shortly. 24 seems reasonable to me for single parents, with 35 for everyone else. I'm all for giving benefits to those on low incomes but not those who can't be bothered to look for full time work

tiger2691 · 23/09/2022 09:47

The government need slaves to service the requirements of the rich, powerful elite, that's whats the benefit bashing is about. They: the elite, tory and rich dont give a fuck about poor people. Trickle down has never worked, apart from widening the gap between rich and poor.

shinynewapple22 · 23/09/2022 09:00

pinok · 22/09/2022 16:10

What about making sure companies and rich people are paying the right amount of tax? Why do the tories always look to the people at the very bottom with the very least

Absolutely.

Alexandra2001 · 23/09/2022 09:00

Wibbly1008 · 23/09/2022 08:26

I agree, but sadly I think the whole political system is the same- labour and Tory. I don’t trust either, I think they are all out of touch and full of horseshit. There is no one to vote for, they are all liars.

Thats what the Cons want you to believe, believe it and you might as well stick with the Cons.

Labour wouldn't have been in for 15 years (by the time of the next GE) almost no one of the present Labour front bench was in Blairs Govt.

So saying they are all the same simply isn't true.

Labour and Con policies are at complete odds now, very clear dividing lines.

newnamethanks · 23/09/2022 08:55

I know what's going to Trickle Down on us and it's not the small change from Kwasi Kwarteng's pocket. More of the same. We have surrendered our country to the economics of a third world state run by grasping financial illiterates.

Alexandra2001 · 23/09/2022 08:55

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 08:08

The article says that it's targeted at the over 50s who overwhelmingly will not be the demographic unable to work more than 15 hrs/week due to childcare issues.

The group who may have a real issue will be those who have kids under the age of three, as free childcare isn't available.

See what i mean? never criticise a Tory policy, no matter how pointless, the total numbers involved is less than 150k people out of 5m UC claimants, the number of the over 50s in that group is even smaller.

Any ideas on how you can target a specific age group? what about a 49 yo.... vs a 65yo?
Esp an age group many employers simply don't want to employ.

Meanwhile lets give a £180 NI saving to someone on 30k p.a but £1000 saving to someone on 100k.

A carer on 18k wont even notice.

Its a smokescreen to mask their disastrous Brexit & hide their Give to the Rich Tax Cuts.

RedAppleGirl · 23/09/2022 08:38

These subsidies need to be paid for.
These past 2 yrs people have had subsidies for:
Salaries/wages-furlough.
Grants
Loans
Heating bills
Help to eat out.

Now suggesting childcare so people can work an extra 3 hrs a week.
I'm not so sure whether quantitative easing for the people is a good investment, it's all getting a tad out of hand. The government does have the power to print and spend, however, the expenditures do have to have a meaningful return.
I'm not sure plugging the holes in the economy is the right approach.

Wibbly1008 · 23/09/2022 08:26

DrCoconut · 22/09/2022 18:39

@GoingThatWay it seems that little gem has largely gone under the radar. Absolute arseholes. The older generation of the family were right, never trust the Tories, they will look after their rich pals and sod everyone else. Hell will freeze over before I'd ever vote for them.

I agree, but sadly I think the whole political system is the same- labour and Tory. I don’t trust either, I think they are all out of touch and full of horseshit. There is no one to vote for, they are all liars.

Xenia · 23/09/2022 08:23

It is a big concern for many people in full time work, that they are working very hard to pay high costs like their rent, heating, after school care and yet others who could work (not those unable to work) are choosing to work part time whilst the state makes up the difference.

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 08:23

MereDintofPandiculation · 22/09/2022 15:08

The same problems apply to fixed hours contracts, where your employer guarantees, say, 10 hours work, but expects you to come running in as needed just as if you were on zero hours.

And they'll average that 10 hours/week over something like 11 weeks which means that you can still end up with no hours in a given week. Stopping this sort of exploitation is something that is really difficult to legislate for - especially because you don't want to throw the baby out with the bathwater as zero-hour contracts are quite useful for some employees (such as students), provided that the employer is genuinely flexible.

DdraigGoch · 23/09/2022 08:08

The article says that it's targeted at the over 50s who overwhelmingly will not be the demographic unable to work more than 15 hrs/week due to childcare issues.

The group who may have a real issue will be those who have kids under the age of three, as free childcare isn't available.