Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She shortchanged me but denied it.

133 replies

dottypotter · 22/09/2022 11:44

Recently bought something from local shop/newsagents

When I got home I realised she had shortchanged me so I went straight back and showed her the change she had given me.
It was only a matter of five mins or so.

Instead of going to the till and apologising to my horror she denied it. She said she had given me the right change. It was then awkward.
Why would I go back with the money in my hand to show her what shed given me if it hadnt happened?
I just left it, as I need to go in there alot it didn't seem worth arguing. Could not believe the attitude though. Something I won't forget.
Why didn't she just apologise and go to the till and give me the missing coin?
AIBU.
No one else around at that mo just her and I.

OP posts:
ShaneTwane · 22/09/2022 13:48

Also yes its perfectly ok to question change at the till if you think its incorrect we also have people do that a lot and we appreciate being able to rectify any errors straight away. Sometimes its the customer who has mistakenly added up wrong but theres no harm.

UrslaB · 22/09/2022 13:48

No checkout assistant or retail manager will take a customer's word for it on a shortchange matter. Never. You have to check your change at the till and call them on it immediately. Even then, it is he said, she said sort of deal and it comes down to the staff being professional and taking your details, offering to check the till's taking that night/next day, and giving you a call if a discrepancy is found. If it is then you get your money and an apology.

As a teenager and student, I worked in a variety of retail jobs. You really can't trust what any customer says. Have had people claim to have given £20 when only gave a ten pound note. Had others give us literal pennies and then claim it was pound coins. On one spectacular occasion we had a fella come in and say one member of staff had short changed him about twenty minutes ago. It was 70 something pence he claimed. Till girl said she didn't even remember serving him and as we were a very busy shop, that wasn't unusual. Manager came down and apologized and said we'd check the till that night if he left his details. He went spare. Shouting, screaming, threw stock on the ground. Girl I was working with on tills at the time was 17 and she couldn't believe a grown adult would act like that. Security showed him out.

The manager let her have a tea break cause she was so overwhelmed that something she may have done wrong could have caused that scene. A couple days later she got called to the managers office and she tells her they reviewed the security footage for that whole morning she worked and the fella who claimed she had short changed him 70 p...he was never even in the shop! Never at any till. Wrote up an incident report about it and we printed a CCTV photo to go and warn other local retailers. Boss came back pretty shocked, turned out the guy had been pulling the same stunt in a couple shops down the street over the last few weeks for pennies and a few quid. Some had just given him the money to stop a scene. We had his picture behind the till then to keep an eye out.

Basically, the idea that any person is so honest, and it just happened a few minutes ago and we should trust and believe everyone is nonsense. At best, give your details and ask for the till cash out to be checked that night and give you a call if it is over. Your not owed an apology until it is proven a mistake has occured. The days of being taken at your word are gone.

TooManyMoronsHere · 22/09/2022 13:42

You sound extremely naive to be questioning why she shouldn't trust you. People do scams with this all the time. Unfortunately you're misdirecting your anger at her when yes she was wrong to give you incorrect change but quite within her right not to trust you, why should she?

JustAnotherManicMomday · 22/09/2022 13:42

She didn't go into the till because you have no idea how many people pull this one. It is your job to check your change there and then and if its wrong request they check the till on the spot. Once you leave who is to say you have not dropped it, given it away, pocketed it, spent it elsewhere or put it somewhere. Happens all the while in retail so you check at the time. She should have offered to check the till later to see if it was up by that amount but its not always doable at that moment if working alone.

Soakitup37 · 22/09/2022 13:41

Used to work in a supermarket, this was a basic rule, change mistakes are only verified at the till, after that it was your mistake not to check.

only if it was a large sum or the customer was really clearly upset that we would close the till to check the balance was correct.

iekanda · 22/09/2022 13:40

It's very difficult. Lots of customers are scammers, falsely claiming to have been short changed. Some shop workers are also scammers, deliberately giving short change, particularly if the victim is distracted with little kids. In your case, it's surprising that the assistant was so sure that you hadn't been short changed. The fact that she didn't even need to stop to consider what might have happened, to me, indicates that she likely did it on purpose.

Heyisforhorses · 22/09/2022 13:37

dottypotter · 22/09/2022 12:07

To ppl saying check your change in shop I understand that but dosent it look like you don't trust them by checking the change?🤔
Where do you do this?
What if there's a queue?
Do people personally stand there in front of the assistant and check change.
Curious?

They arent giving all your change in coppers, it doesn't take long to glance down and count quickly the few coins you get back

ShaneTwane · 22/09/2022 13:36

Once you leave the till without checking then its your problem. Im in retail. Trust me we have upwards of 15 people a day claiming to be shortchanged and demanding money back after leaving the shop. Most havent been shortchanged at all.

StarlightLady · 22/09/2022 13:33

I rarely use cash anymore. Use a card when you go shopping. Then this would not have arisen.

dawngreen · 22/09/2022 13:26

Always check your change before leaving the shop because -

1/ Most shops say check it before you leave
2/ A lot try to scam shops
3/ Always check your change before leaving a shop. I always checked bank notes that customers gave to me. I did not like doing it but it stopped a pair of scammers passing me dud 20 pound notes. Shops will not be offended it saves them time and money and keeps customers happy.

JassyRadlett · 22/09/2022 13:25

Is anyone else now wondering whether the coin in question was a great deal lower in value than £2?

diddl · 22/09/2022 13:24

How much are we talking about Op?

Generally you would know if you were missing a note or a notes worth of change.

I would imaging counting the change out stopped not long after the till showed what was owed.

Does anyone else remember when the notes used to be left in front of the till whilst your change was taken out?

Crazykatie · 22/09/2022 13:24

If you are paying cash or card pay attention, it’s easy to ring up extra on a card sale as well, don’t leave the shop until you have checked it’s right. Mistakes can be genuine or deliberate so don’t assume either.

TrashyPanda · 22/09/2022 13:24

so much easier just to use your card or your phone

PinkButtercups · 22/09/2022 13:22

You keep saying why didn't she count your change well why didn't you?!

The fact you said about a missing coin I'd assume it's no more than £2.

You've made a mistake, admit it, learn from it and move on.

caringcarer · 22/09/2022 13:20

Why I always use my debit card.

Pixiedust1234 · 22/09/2022 13:19

123rd · 22/09/2022 11:49

Some shops have signs up saying to check change before leaving as errors can't be rectified afterwards.
Yabu

This.

The onus is on you to check. Why didn't you?

BloodAndFire · 22/09/2022 13:18

Dollydea · 22/09/2022 13:03

Similar happened to me at my local corner shop years ago, I was 18, DD was a newborn, I hardly had anything. I'd topped up my electric by £20 & when I got home he'd only put £5 on the card.
I thought it was a mistake so went back and explained, he denied it & said I'd only given him a £5 note & refused to do anything about it.
I was shocked because I'd gone in there almost daily since being a small child as it was on my grans street, he was always friendly and had a little chat etc.

I just never went back, DD is 13 now and even on the rare occasion I'm back in the area I still don't go in.
Used to walk an extra 20 mins to one further away.

I'm sure you know this now but for something like topping up electric card, you should always get a receipt. Even if someone isn't short changing you, there can be technical errors etc.

DillDanding · 22/09/2022 13:18

All this talk of cash seems terribly old fashioned.

I don’t even take out debit cards anymore, I just use my phone or watch to pay. So much easier.

BloodAndFire · 22/09/2022 13:17

dottypotter · 22/09/2022 12:07

To ppl saying check your change in shop I understand that but dosent it look like you don't trust them by checking the change?🤔
Where do you do this?
What if there's a queue?
Do people personally stand there in front of the assistant and check change.
Curious?

So you would be embarrassed to 'look like you don't trust her', but were fine with going back in to tell her she'd short-changed you?

In answer to your questions - yes, I check my change. How long does it take? About 5 seconds to make sure you've got the right number of pound coins/fivers/tenners.

mam0918 · 22/09/2022 13:17

'Why didn't she just apologise and go to the till and give me the missing coin?'

As in £2 or under?

I would totally assume as an employee or another customer that you where either a scammer or ignorantly wrong.

You could have easily dropped it, fell out of pocket, lost in your bag or anything.

Did you really walk home with a handful of change, count it at home then return to complain a coin was missing? it sounds unhinged.

KatherineJaneway · 22/09/2022 13:13

To ppl saying check your change in shop I understand that but dosent it look like you don't trust them by checking the change?

It used to be advised that you do this so any mistakes can be rectified at the time.

daisychain01 · 22/09/2022 13:08

How much did she short change you by?

calculate the amount you're missing, put the change she gave you in an envelope with a note on it and say that when she cashes up at the end of the day, if there's a surplus then it's possibly yours, so can they contact you about it.

Can you also let the shop manager know the situation?

starfishmummy · 22/09/2022 13:06

People used to count change out

We had lots of rules when I worked in retail back on the dark ages, including counting change out twice. Once as we took it from the till and again I to the customers hand.

It takes me seconds to work out what my change should be and to count it all before I leave the till.

Dollydea · 22/09/2022 13:03

Similar happened to me at my local corner shop years ago, I was 18, DD was a newborn, I hardly had anything. I'd topped up my electric by £20 & when I got home he'd only put £5 on the card.
I thought it was a mistake so went back and explained, he denied it & said I'd only given him a £5 note & refused to do anything about it.
I was shocked because I'd gone in there almost daily since being a small child as it was on my grans street, he was always friendly and had a little chat etc.

I just never went back, DD is 13 now and even on the rare occasion I'm back in the area I still don't go in.
Used to walk an extra 20 mins to one further away.

Swipe left for the next trending thread