Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

She shortchanged me but denied it.

133 replies

dottypotter · 22/09/2022 11:44

Recently bought something from local shop/newsagents

When I got home I realised she had shortchanged me so I went straight back and showed her the change she had given me.
It was only a matter of five mins or so.

Instead of going to the till and apologising to my horror she denied it. She said she had given me the right change. It was then awkward.
Why would I go back with the money in my hand to show her what shed given me if it hadnt happened?
I just left it, as I need to go in there alot it didn't seem worth arguing. Could not believe the attitude though. Something I won't forget.
Why didn't she just apologise and go to the till and give me the missing coin?
AIBU.
No one else around at that mo just her and I.

OP posts:
Starfreeze · 22/09/2022 15:14

123rd · 22/09/2022 11:49

Some shops have signs up saying to check change before leaving as errors can't be rectified afterwards.
Yabu

Yeah, this was common as I was growing up.

heartbroken22 · 22/09/2022 15:08

What a horrible person. You should have said I hope you choke on it.

TwoLeftSocksWithHoles · 22/09/2022 15:05

I bet she'd say something like "gosh if I had a pound everytime I heard someone say that..., actually thinking about it I have!"

Musti · 22/09/2022 15:00

your responsibility to check your change when you’re given it, just as it is their responsibility to check they have been given the correct amount at the time.

GreenFingersWouldBeHandy · 22/09/2022 14:57

To ppl saying check your change in shop I understand that but dosent it look like you don't trust them by checking the change?

Well you don't trust her! How long does it take to check your change? Mere seconds.

Unfortunately you left the premises without checking so the onus is on you. Otherwise if she'd just given you more change, her boss could have accused her of theft.

NonagonInfinityOpensTheDoor · 22/09/2022 14:56

It’s horrible when you realise you’ve got the wrong change and the shop doesn’t believe you though
It’s also horrible to be screamed at and abused for giving someone the wrong change when you haven’t. Happened to me quite a lot when I worked in a leisure centre. The best time was when I had just started a shift and someone came to pay for their child to swim. Came back and said I’d shirt changed as they paid with a £20. Impossible as she was the only person I’d served and only had 1 £10 note in the till. She made such a tit of herself demanding my pockets be searched and I was patted down etc. She ended up getting herself and her child removed from the building and a temporary ban from all services in the borough for being an aggressive cunt.

IGetAParkingThread · 22/09/2022 14:56

It’s a well known scam to do that and ask for the change. Oh I gave you a £20 not a £10 etc. we would take a number and call if there was an issue when counting the till at closing, but tills are regularly a pound over or under

Stangerthings · 22/09/2022 14:51

If its a shop I don't know well, I make a mental note of the last 4 numbers on a £20 note so I can prove it is what I handed over.

ifonly4 · 22/09/2022 14:43

Ideally you should have checked before leaving and raised it then. I work in a shop and our security camera can move in very close to see what you've got in your hand - if you really feel she's in the wrong, you could ask the manager to check that.

ancientgran · 22/09/2022 14:41

It happened to my husband, he immediately said they'd given him change for a £5 and he'd given them a £10. Shop owner denied it and he'd already put the note in the till so even though it was immediate he wouldn't back down. He was quite nasty about it and some of the stuff he said was offensive e.g. people like you/your type and husband is black in a very white town so he took that badly.

We left our phone number and when he cashed up he was £5 over so phoned us and we collected it. No apology for his earlier attitude. We've never been in the shop since.

I sympathise OP.

KangFang · 22/09/2022 14:26

I was short changed by a waiter at a restaurant about 2 weeks ago.
I was alone.
I know he did it on purpose.
I wouldn't leave until the shift manager sorted it out.
I was very pissed off and I made sure they knew it.

mogsrus · 22/09/2022 14:25

The lesson here is always check before walking away. You cannot prove it after leaving. The shop person possibly can by knowing exactly what’s in the till if it was closed off & reopened I’ve had this with people at work saying they were short changed or I put 20£ in & only got 10£ out, resulting in the change machine being completely emptied & recounted whilst being watched by security only to tell the person that it was bang on the nose. & they sheepishly say sorry it was my mistake

LokiDoki75 · 22/09/2022 14:18

I’m another one who was taught to count change back, it was a good way of double checking you were handing over the right amount. I was also told never to hand over change with your hand palm down because it looked like you were hiding the amount! It’s horrible when you realise you’ve got the wrong change and the shop doesn’t believe you though. I had it happen to me when I handed over £20 and they gave me change for £10. They refused to believe I was telling the truth and made a big thing of “Well, we’ll go and check the till now then.” To which I obviously said “Fair enough, I’ll wait.” They came back a few minutes later and shoved the extra change at me, no apology or anything!

saveforthat · 22/09/2022 14:15

Yes. I always check the change at the till even if there is a queue because I have nearly been short changed many times.

girlfriend44 · 22/09/2022 14:08

TooManyMoronsHere · 22/09/2022 13:42

You sound extremely naive to be questioning why she shouldn't trust you. People do scams with this all the time. Unfortunately you're misdirecting your anger at her when yes she was wrong to give you incorrect change but quite within her right not to trust you, why should she?

Why didn't she say to the OP. Mistakes need to be raised at the time though and not afterwards
She seemed to insist she gave the right change. Her wording was wrong.

Testina · 22/09/2022 14:05

“Something I won't forget.”

You must find daily life pretty stressful.

To you, it’s obvious she made a mistake - because you have the coins to check.

To her, it’s not obvious at all - she can’t know that you’re honest, and people do lie.

Check your change in future, and don’t get yourself worked up with declarations of never forgetting!

zingally · 22/09/2022 14:05

There's not much you can do, once you've left the shop, even if you go straight back.

If this has never happened before, as far as you've noticed, I'd just chalk it up as one bad experience. But I'd be making a point from now, either way, to count out your change as you get given it, there and then.

SimonaRazowska · 22/09/2022 14:03

You need to check there and then, should not take a lot of time

You can't come back in 5 mins later 😁

Surely you know this?

SDTGisAnEvilWolefGenius · 22/09/2022 14:03

10HailMarys · 22/09/2022 12:20

Why did shops stop counting it out back to you then you wouldn't need to query,?

I got my first retail job 32 years ago and was never expected to count out the change as I handed it back the customer, in any shop I worked in. Are you posting from 1950?

I worked in Woolworths, as a Saturday girl, in the early 80s, and we were taught to count the customer’s change back to them. We also has a clip on the front of the till, and we’re told to put notes there, until we had counted the change out into the customer’s hand, before putting the note into the till - so if the customer said they gave us a £20 not a £10, we could show them their note.

OlderParents · 22/09/2022 14:02

I think it's a real shame that assistants don't count change into a customer's hand anymore.

In my recent experience people look at you like you have grown an extra head if you try to do this 😂

It takes me literally one or two seconds to glance at the change in my hand and notice if that's the right change or not. If I'm having a brain fart I'll double check but I still don't take more than say 5 seconds. This is normal, isn't a delay, inconvenience or slut on your trust of the cashier, and unless you have a medical reason why you can't, you should be doing this as a matter of habit.

Thatboymum · 22/09/2022 14:01

i don’t ever use cash now but when I did I never ever considered counting it and would deffo not have gone back to my local after leaving for a few coins. You may know your an honest person but they don’t

Dotjones · 22/09/2022 14:00

YABU to claim she "shortchanged" you without evidence to back that up. Shortchanging someone is a deliberate act, you cannot accidentally shortchange someone - that would just be an error when issuing the change.

It's similar to calling someone a liar because they said something that isn't true. They're only lying if they knew what they said wasn't true. If they believed it to be true, they are not lying.

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 22/09/2022 13:58

But OP it's a transaction that both of you should check. So don't feel shy about checking your change in front of them as you put it away. It sounds to me in your case that she may have done it on purpose. But even if she seemed to not trust you, don't take it personally - sounds as if people try it on a lot.

Hopefullysoon2022 · 22/09/2022 13:55

Is there any chance you dropped it.After all you still had it in your hand when you got home @dottypotter

AssignedSlytherinAtBirth · 22/09/2022 13:52

I think it's a real shame that assistants don't count change into a customer's hand anymore. Even though the till tells the assistant what change to give, he/she can still make a mistake when getting the change out of the till. As a shop assistant I would always at least say how much I was giving them - it protects us both.

A couple of years ago I was buying euros from the local post office and he was distracted (talking to someone) while counting them out in front of me. So I asked him to do it again - silly me, I wasn't looking, tinkly laugh - and he had short changed me by twenty euros.

Swipe left for the next trending thread