Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

...to say the monarchy should be subscription based

120 replies

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 11:21

There is a lot of talk that the BBC should scrap the licence fee and go to a subscription service because not everyone agrees with the BBC's political positions or find value in it's services.

I think there is even more merit in this argument when applied to the monarchy. Many people feel that monarchy is a moral wrong, or don't find it beneficial, yet are forced to support it's activity through taxation.

Instead there should be a volunatry levy to support the lifestyle of King Charles et al. Perhaps if you don't pay into the monarchy you have to pay a smaller amount to support a slimmed-down, elected head of state?

Far from being the end of a proud tradition, I think the Monarchy might make more money from this approach, with some canny marketing: allow foreigners to pay in to become subjects, stop letting commonwealth citizens be subjects for free or set up a premium subscription with benefits for paying more.

Whereas the rest of us would happily make do on the basic package: with elected King Martin Lewis doing royal visits using Ryanair, and the letter when we reach 100 coming second class.

OP posts:
Flopisfatteningbingforchristmas · 22/09/2022 13:09

arethereanyleftatall · 22/09/2022 11:28

Given 5 billion people all over the world watched the funeral, it's very possible that the (completely unknown and impossible to value) revenue and interest they create for the country far outweighs their cost.

But only 40% of people in the UK watched it.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/09/2022 13:07

Discovereads · 22/09/2022 12:35

How is this even remotely fair? Those with conventional beauty- advantaged. Those with bags of money to run a PR campaign to get votes-advantaged. Those with some entertaining talent if that’s why you mean by “juggling contest” and “finals”- advantaged.

I meant the events in the finals would be decided by the public not the winners, and the randomness is the fairness. One year the regional events might play to your strengths the next time it might not. One year might feature a juggling contest, one year might feature a bed making contest or pringle eating challenge.

But nothing has been finalised yet, there's still plenty of time to work out the kinks and address any concerns you have over my fictional contest.

CranfordScones · 22/09/2022 13:07

A desire to replace what works with what seems like a good idea at the time.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 13:06

But the UK gets more absolute tourists than Luxembourg does:

Of course it does, Luxembourg is tiny. PP I replied to picked Luxembourg, it's a stupid comparator.

If you compare UK tourism to most comparable countries we don't do that well. There is no evidence of vastly more people coming here because of the RF which is what's cited as the reason we should subsidise their lifestyle.

OP posts:
BigWoollyJumpers · 22/09/2022 13:05

and the rest open to the public perhaps managed by the National Trust or English Heritage

For which you would have to pay a large annual fee or a very large per person charge. Probably more than we pay each to the RF.

DownNative · 22/09/2022 13:00

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:28

Without all the pomp and ceremony, tourists (from overseas especially) will likely not be attracted to the UK the way they are now. We’ll be comparable with, say, Luxembourg. Wonderful place, I’m sure. But tourist appeal? Nah.

Lucembourg gets almost 4 times as many tourists per capita as us. We are under half the European average. As many PP's have said, most Royal Palaces aren't open to the public for tourism.

www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Economy/Tourist-arrivals/Per-capita#country

Luxembourg is bordered by Belgium, France and Germany. Its clearly much easier to travel there from those countries than it is to travel to island nations like the UK. The cheaper it is to travel, the more attractive a destination becomes. Travel by road is far cheaper sea or air travel.

Hence, Luxembourg has a higher Tourist Per Resident (TPR) than the UK.

But the UK gets more absolute tourists than Luxembourg does:

www.statista.com/statistics/261729/countries-in-europe-ranked-by-international-tourist-arrivals/

FlipFlopFlippedyFlop · 22/09/2022 12:57

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:39

How is this even remotely fair? Those with conventional beauty- advantaged. Those with bags of money to run a PR campaign to get votes-advantaged. Those with some entertaining talent if that’s why you mean by “juggling contest” and “finals”- advantaged.

Yeah. If the RF is about anything, it's about equality of opportunity.

😂

balalake · 22/09/2022 12:54

I think the better idea would be to have perhaps only Balmoral and Windsor used by the Royal Family, and the rest open to the public perhaps managed by the National Trust or English Heritage.

CryingAtTheDiscotheque · 22/09/2022 12:51

😂 inspired, OP!

FlipFlopFlippedyFlop · 22/09/2022 12:45

How about a world wide charity through which you could sponsor a royal. They charity could send out letters saying for just £50 a month, a royal can get their hair cut and for £200 a month a royal can visit a horse race of their choice. Then they can send their sponsors updates and photos.

BitOutOfPractice · 22/09/2022 12:44

LetMeSpeak · 22/09/2022 12:42

I maybe be wrong but I think the average tax payer gives 50p a months to the royal family. Knowing how dedicated royalist are I would actually think that you plan would cause them to get even more money then they already get right now. They would most likely give them even more money to show their support to the crown.

Forgive me if I'm wrong but I think that's the whole point!

LetMeSpeak · 22/09/2022 12:42

I maybe be wrong but I think the average tax payer gives 50p a months to the royal family. Knowing how dedicated royalist are I would actually think that you plan would cause them to get even more money then they already get right now. They would most likely give them even more money to show their support to the crown.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:39

How is this even remotely fair? Those with conventional beauty- advantaged. Those with bags of money to run a PR campaign to get votes-advantaged. Those with some entertaining talent if that’s why you mean by “juggling contest” and “finals”- advantaged.

Yeah. If the RF is about anything, it's about equality of opportunity.

OP posts:
donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:37

No it doesn’t. You don’t have to have a TV licence…you can legally opt out if you don’t watch live TV or the BBC iplayer. So you’re saying no one could opt out of having a ceremonial head of state. They have to purchase a subscription for one or the other- elected or RF. How would you enforce this? A fine the first time caught, prison term for repeat offences?

I was referring to how the RF works, not the BBC. It's paid from taxation, you can't opt out of taxation and yes there are fines if you try. I'm just suggesting two options.

Of course if the RF decide to offer a premium subscription that would be up to them to administer.

OP posts:
BitOutOfPractice · 22/09/2022 12:36

I love this idea OP. It could be built on the Only Fans model: Only Royals

Discovereads · 22/09/2022 12:35

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/09/2022 12:31

Yanbu, although I would also accept the monarchy being open to a challenge from the public.

We could have some sort of event every 3-5 years where anyone can enter. A bit like BGT but, where the events are decided at random.

To start there would be regional qualifiers, which could be anything from a knock out tournament of connect four to doing a 5k juggling race.

Regional would be followed by the nationals and would follow the same format, before the winners of that moving on to the finals.

The goal of the nationals would be to narrow the field of potential monarchs down to 255 individuals, who would then go on to compete in the Finals.

The reigning king or queen would be allowed to select a champion to represent them, who will recieve a bye into the finals, bringing the total contestants to 256.

Unlike the regionals/nationals the events in the finals would be decided by the public and announced a week before the event, with competitors given the week to prepare themselves.

The finals would take place over a period of 8 weeks with each week seeing the field halved until there were just two candidates who would then battle it out in a grand final with the winner going on to be the new king or queen.

A fair, fun, and potentially profitable solutions to this particular issue.

How is this even remotely fair? Those with conventional beauty- advantaged. Those with bags of money to run a PR campaign to get votes-advantaged. Those with some entertaining talent if that’s why you mean by “juggling contest” and “finals”- advantaged.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/09/2022 12:31

Yanbu, although I would also accept the monarchy being open to a challenge from the public.

We could have some sort of event every 3-5 years where anyone can enter. A bit like BGT but, where the events are decided at random.

To start there would be regional qualifiers, which could be anything from a knock out tournament of connect four to doing a 5k juggling race.

Regional would be followed by the nationals and would follow the same format, before the winners of that moving on to the finals.

The goal of the nationals would be to narrow the field of potential monarchs down to 255 individuals, who would then go on to compete in the Finals.

The reigning king or queen would be allowed to select a champion to represent them, who will recieve a bye into the finals, bringing the total contestants to 256.

Unlike the regionals/nationals the events in the finals would be decided by the public and announced a week before the event, with competitors given the week to prepare themselves.

The finals would take place over a period of 8 weeks with each week seeing the field halved until there were just two candidates who would then battle it out in a grand final with the winner going on to be the new king or queen.

A fair, fun, and potentially profitable solutions to this particular issue.

Discovereads · 22/09/2022 12:28

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:24

And how would you deal with the problem of free loaders? Under this system, you’d have to force everyone to buy one subscription or the other.

That's fine, it's how it works now. Don't forget that most people want to pay for the experience of being subjects, not merely citizens and it really doesn't cost that much compared to, say, a sky subscription.

The elected HoS would be the lowest cost option providing only basic ceremonial duties. Unless the RF decide to cut costs.

No it doesn’t. You don’t have to have a TV licence…you can legally opt out if you don’t watch live TV or the BBC iplayer.

So you’re saying no one could opt out of having a ceremonial head of state. They have to purchase a subscription for one or the other- elected or RF. How would you enforce this? A fine the first time caught, prison term for repeat offences?

The elected HoS would be the lowest cost option providing only basic ceremonial duties. I wouldn’t be so sure about that….security alone is the bulk of the costs and we can’t have our HoS elected or otherwise being assassinated or stalked.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:28

Without all the pomp and ceremony, tourists (from overseas especially) will likely not be attracted to the UK the way they are now. We’ll be comparable with, say, Luxembourg. Wonderful place, I’m sure. But tourist appeal? Nah.

Lucembourg gets almost 4 times as many tourists per capita as us. We are under half the European average. As many PP's have said, most Royal Palaces aren't open to the public for tourism.

www.nationmaster.com/country-info/stats/Economy/Tourist-arrivals/Per-capita#country

OP posts:
KimberleyClark · 22/09/2022 12:26

stripeyzeb · 22/09/2022 12:06

The royal family costs the average UK taxpayer £1.29 per year. The BBC costs £159 per year.

The BBC at its best is educational and entertaining.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:24

And how would you deal with the problem of free loaders? Under this system, you’d have to force everyone to buy one subscription or the other.

That's fine, it's how it works now. Don't forget that most people want to pay for the experience of being subjects, not merely citizens and it really doesn't cost that much compared to, say, a sky subscription.

The elected HoS would be the lowest cost option providing only basic ceremonial duties. Unless the RF decide to cut costs.

OP posts:
Eeksteek · 22/09/2022 12:22

Takingturnstogether · 22/09/2022 11:29

Disneyland attracts lots of people with its princesses etc. Could the monarchy be made to work the same way?

I think it more or less does. Without all the pomp and ceremony, tourists (from overseas especially) will likely not be attracted to the UK the way they are now. We’ll be comparable with, say, Luxembourg. Wonderful place, I’m sure. But tourist appeal? Nah. The RF definitely adds to our world ‘status’ and image, and definitely brings money here. As much as they cost to maintain? I don’t know. But they should definitely be few in number and putting the hours in being regal, and not be maintained if they CBA or disgrace themselves. Can’t have it both ways.

Joystir59 · 22/09/2022 12:21

DangerNoodles · 22/09/2022 11:26

I'm far from a die hard royalist, but realistically if we were to be given a vote, the people will want to keep the monarchy as it is. Half the world watched the funeral, most of the UK watched it, that's very telling of how popular they are.

Not necessarily. I binge watchd the funeral, enjoyed it thoroughly. Not a royalist though. Can't stand them.

Discovereads · 22/09/2022 12:19

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 11:46

So how would it work with a subscription, given that there would also have to be some officially funded head of state? or would this be the Prime Minister (please no)?

As I suggested in the OP. There would be two ceremonial heads of state, costing the same per person as now, one of them elected. They would be funded according to who subscribed to each.

I reckon the elected one only needs about £20 million for a bit of basic head of stating (I'd do it for that) so if a fair number of people join that service costs would come down.

It's all about modernisation and using the free market to make an old, inefficient state monopoly work better. Thatcher would have approved.

And how would you deal with the problem of free loaders? Under this system, you’d have to force everyone to buy one subscription or the other. Otherwise the majority of people will choose to pay nothing at all.

donquixotedelamancha · 22/09/2022 12:17

Sorry, forgot to include the link to the costs of monarchy breakdown. I should caveat this by saying that no-one actually knows the true figures, these are estimates. All the more reason for a more transparent, modern monarchy.

d3n8a8pro7vhmx.cloudfront.net/republic/pages/66/attachments/original/1604050270/Royal-Expenses-Report-2017.pdf?1604050270

OP posts:
Swipe left for the next trending thread