Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to get a doberman puppy with a 7 year old child?

135 replies

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 10:16

just that, would this be just the worst idea?

to train them as a family pet, with classes and not leave them alone together, but is it inherently a stupid idea?

we have cats as well and are trying for another baby.

OP posts:
Yack02 · 22/09/2022 11:42

What's more baffling, isn't that you are considering a Doberman, but that you're trying for a baby. Therefore, a puppy of any breed is a bad idea right now!

Unless you're super experienced and incredibly motivated then please do not consider this.

Imagine having to do 2/3 walks a day in the winter in the pissing rain and wind whilst being heavily pregnant. Then when the baby arrives, are you seriously going to have the motivation and energy for all of this?

I had two puppies and 4 adult dogs when I was pregnant. I'm a very experienced dog owner and it damn near finished me off. DON'T DO IT!!!

Carmakomelian · 22/09/2022 11:40

Fillystine · 22/09/2022 11:29

I feel the need to defend Dobermans here! We got one as a puppy and a year later had a baby. He was the best dog we’ve ever had. Sweet, gentle, lovely with our son (although very little spacial awareness and quite clumsy) and adored our cats. As long as they are socialised and given sufficient exercise they are no different to any other dog. The worst dogs to have as pets are the ones who are given little to no training or stimulation because people mistake the ‘safe’ family type breeds like cocker spaniels and labs as easy, and offer no training, boundaries or exercise. Those are the types of dogs who are potentially dangerous.

I have never met an aggressive Doberman. I have met a lot of aggressive labs, possessive and snappy cockers and truly vile border collies however! The common denominator in all of these breeds is the lack of training and exercise.

One solitary post was an ignorant opinion on dobermans. All the other posts were that getting a large, powerful, dog which requires lots of attention, socialisation and training, when you're trying for a baby, is not a wise idea.

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 11:38

DameHelena · 22/09/2022 11:32

Some very ill-informed comments on here about Dobermanns.
OP, I'd suggest you post in the Dogs section to get (hopefully) less daft responses.
Regardless of breed, though, I'd think a child AND a baby with a new puppy (which are time- and energy-consuming) is a lot to take on.

I get that, but I don't work so there is that.

OP posts:
macthekwife · 22/09/2022 11:37

greenhousegal · 22/09/2022 11:26

Provocative post IMV and I doubt the OP is serious.

I wouldn't waste any time responding to state the bleeding obvious here.

Don't be such a conspiracy theorist. My partner wants one and I'm seeking advice as I think it's a bad idea.

OP posts:
caringcarer · 22/09/2022 11:37

Don't get a dog with a baby and another child on the way. Wait until children are 6 and 4. I would always choose a smaller dog with a good temperament. I have a friend who shows her 3 Dobermans and they are awesome dogs but need a lot of attention and long walks and training to a high standard and to keep them mentally stimulated. She tells me they are not dogs for people who don't have a good amount of time to spend on them. Her youngest child was 10 when she got her first Doberman. They had a golden retriever before that but died at 14.

Sausagenbacon · 22/09/2022 11:35

Ridiculous. I wouldn't get any dog if I was trying for a baby

DameHelena · 22/09/2022 11:32

Some very ill-informed comments on here about Dobermanns.
OP, I'd suggest you post in the Dogs section to get (hopefully) less daft responses.
Regardless of breed, though, I'd think a child AND a baby with a new puppy (which are time- and energy-consuming) is a lot to take on.

SlashBeef · 22/09/2022 11:31

Absolutely not.

Isthisexpected · 22/09/2022 11:29

Madness. Are you really bored or unsatisfied with life? You must be deeply unfulfilled and need to find something to fill the void to consider going through the puppy and baby list in this order.

Fillystine · 22/09/2022 11:29

I feel the need to defend Dobermans here! We got one as a puppy and a year later had a baby. He was the best dog we’ve ever had. Sweet, gentle, lovely with our son (although very little spacial awareness and quite clumsy) and adored our cats. As long as they are socialised and given sufficient exercise they are no different to any other dog. The worst dogs to have as pets are the ones who are given little to no training or stimulation because people mistake the ‘safe’ family type breeds like cocker spaniels and labs as easy, and offer no training, boundaries or exercise. Those are the types of dogs who are potentially dangerous.

I have never met an aggressive Doberman. I have met a lot of aggressive labs, possessive and snappy cockers and truly vile border collies however! The common denominator in all of these breeds is the lack of training and exercise.

greenhousegal · 22/09/2022 11:26

Provocative post IMV and I doubt the OP is serious.

I wouldn't waste any time responding to state the bleeding obvious here.

Carmakomelian · 22/09/2022 11:23

Yes, you'd be mad. I have a smallish dog and my youngest child is a 7 year old. The dog has had every bit of training going, good genes and we have put hours and hours into his behaviour, seen a behaviouralist etc. But certain things set off his anxiety and he has occasionally shown aggression towards my youngest. I can't ever leave them alone for a second. I can't risk the dog being looked after by anyone with visiting children. It is enormously stressful and upsetting. My comfort is that the dog is not physically capable of seriously injuring a 7 year old and my child is old enough to stay out the way of the dog and understand rules around dogs. It is very likely that they'll be fine together in a couple of years as both child and dog get older (the pre teen has never had an issue with dog). If he was a doberman I'd have rehomed by now (if I could find a home for him), if I had a baby I'd also likely have had to rehome. It's just irresponsible.

GeorgiaGirl52 · 22/09/2022 11:19

In the USA, Dobermans are known as one of the "uninsurable" breeds. People who own this breed are denied homeowner's insurance or required to pay extra premiums for a "dangerous"breed.

LilacPoppy · 22/09/2022 10:53

Newborn and Doberman puppy! Obviously not.

10HailMarys · 22/09/2022 10:50

Wait, just seen you're trying for a baby. Of course you shouldn't get a bloody Doberman, then. You probably shouldn't get a dog at all at this point.

Crazycrazylady · 22/09/2022 10:49

Honestly

What is wrong with you!!
Why on earth would you risk that with all the safer breeds available to you.

10HailMarys · 22/09/2022 10:48

Dobermans can be absolutely lovely but they are not an easy breed. They need A LOT of exercise and A LOT of training and A LOT of attention and stimulation and I personally wouldn't have one with cats. They are also very large and extremely strong.

Have you had dogs before? Have you had a large guarding breed before?

Personally, I don't think a Doberman is the right breed for the majority of families. They're a dog-trainer's dog, basically. You would almost certainly be much better off with an easier and somewhat smaller breed.

GreenManalishi · 22/09/2022 10:44

Well, it wouldn't be the worst idea, but that's not how you get a good outcome is it? Choosing things that aren't The Worst?

I'm wondering, what is making you think it might be a good idea?

Have you raised a puppy? Are you an experienced large breed dog owner? Could it be that you are broody, and you're fixating on something small and sleek and cute with big eyes? Don't do it.

I can tell you that Dobermans are not a dog for an inexperienced owner, add in a baby, and you'll be on a one way trip to the shelter about a year later with a nightmare on a lead. Don't set yourself or a dog up to fail like this, wait until the kids are older. The key to this is timing. Don't do it.

Lovemusic33 · 22/09/2022 10:39

It’s not a breed I would chose with young children, not saying they are a bad breed but they do have traits which would concern me. They are guard dogs, can be barky and over protective, they may guard their food and toys and would need a lot of training. I wouldn’t want one near a new born or young children. I would wait until you have a newborn and then rethink the situation. Having any puppy when you have a newborn is hard work, a puppy is sometimes harder work than a baby 😬

eyeslikebutterflies · 22/09/2022 10:33

Oh, I missed the bit about you trying for a baby. In which case, NO. My last but one dog died when I had babies. I waited until the youngest was 9 before getting our current dog. Toddlers and dogs (any dog) are not a good mix, in my view.

Federal · 22/09/2022 10:33

I love Dobermans And they can be good family dogs providing they are socialised and trained well. Like any breed.
Dobermans can be protective towards their family so play fighting with friends would concern me.
But not as much as you planning for a baby. Getting any dog would be an idiotic thing to do right now.

Whinge · 22/09/2022 10:32

PineappleWilson · 22/09/2022 10:29

I'd be more concerned about you thinking of having any dog, if you're trying for a baby. Any dog + crawler / toddler / small person with no impulse control really doesn't work. No particular reason why a doberman would be better / worse than any other bread.

I agree with this. A 7 year old and getting a puppy is one thing, but a 7 year old a puppy and planning for a baby in the near future is a bonkers idea.

eyeslikebutterflies · 22/09/2022 10:31

Dobermans aren't prone to violence. In fact, as a breed, they're known to be brilliant family dogs and great with kids. OP, the main thing you need to do is find a reputable breeder, preferably registered, where you can check parents/grandparents - both for health and for temperament. You'd do this with any dog, obvs. Def don't get one from a backstreet breeder, puppy farm etc.

A puppy will grow with your child. Invest in good training classes, continue training throughout their lives (esp in the tricky 'teenage' phase), have the discipline to commit to a proper routine with adequate exercise, and give your child some of the responsibility for that training and exercise. If done right, they could have the most amazing relationship and learn a lot from it - as I did, aged 10, with our first family dog.

You'd do this with ANY dog. It's not hard but it is a commitment - and it's that commitment that matters much, much more than the breed you choose.

(Sorry if you already have/had dogs and know all this already!!!)

HumbleApe · 22/09/2022 10:30

Are you aware of the health issues in the breed? Tbh I wouldn't expect any responsible breeder to allow you to have a pup if you are likely to have a baby on the way.

GasPanic · 22/09/2022 10:30

Why do you say in the post title "7 year old child" and then in the main body "trying for a baby" ?

You don't strike me as someone who is really thinking this through.

Maybe it is a better idea to get your family situation stabilised before thinking about what the most appropriate pet is.

Only you know whether "trying for a baby" is likely to equal "a baby" in the near future.