Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to get a doberman puppy with a 7 year old child?

135 replies

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 10:16

just that, would this be just the worst idea?

to train them as a family pet, with classes and not leave them alone together, but is it inherently a stupid idea?

we have cats as well and are trying for another baby.

OP posts:
Mrsmuggles · 22/09/2022 13:31

Have a look at a Manchester Terrier, great family pet and looks like a small Doberman.

peekabooer20 · 22/09/2022 13:28

Hey, I was around 5 when we got a doberman and my brothers were both in their teens. He was a lovely family pet, never had any issues with me or my brothers, I would snuggle up to him in his bed etc. However my mum did her homework and did a lot of training with him; classes, private dog trainer, loads and loads of socialisation etc. So I think if you are prepared to do this then there is no reason why you shouldn't have a lovely pet, however if you would rather not, then better to get a more docile breed as it's not worth taking any risks of things going wrong.

BeanieTeen · 22/09/2022 13:27

Why does your DH want a Doberman so much?

Xmassprout · 22/09/2022 13:23

Doberman aren't the easiest of dogs, not because of aggression but they need decent training with consistent boundaries. Train them well and they can be big softies.

I absolutely would not get a puppy while trying for a baby, even if you don't work.

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 22/09/2022 13:23

You'd only be setting the dog up to fail.

With the 7yr old, maybe fine, but if it's not then it's the dog you will get rid of.
New baby, crying a lot, grabbing, etc, if the dog gets distressed then it's the dog you will get rid of.
If either of the kids trip, fall on the dog, and the dog snaps back, it's the dog you will get rid of.
Do you know how your cats will respond to living with a puppy/dog? If they cats are unhappy it's the dog you will get rid of.

andtheweedonkey · 22/09/2022 13:19

I don't think you'll have cats for much longer if you get any dog, let alone a doberman...

NDN got a puppy, something non-fluffy, then got pregnant.
The dog was rehomed in less than a year.

Wouldloveanother · 22/09/2022 13:15

I grew up with a Dobie. My very naive parents decided that with small children and no prior dog owning experience, a Doberman would be great choice 🤪

He was the best dog ever. I still miss him. Intelligent, loyal, patient. Put up with all sorts of shit from my toddler brother and never became aggressive. Funny, prone to those weird fits of silliness where they suddenly go berserk and get the zoomed.

Downsides: the guard dog instinct is very very strong and he really disliked strangers/postmen etc.

But, that was my dog. They are powerfully build and strong dogs, and I wouldn’t have one around toddler DD or a baby just in case. We have a cockerpoo who is daft and gentle but even then she is never allowed to be on her own with DD and DD is monitored very closely to make sure she is being gentle and not irritating the dog.

My advice would be to wait and get one when your kids are 5+. Or to get a smaller and weaker breed. It just isn’t worth the risk.

mintich · 22/09/2022 13:10

I grew up with a Doberman, they are lovely dogs. Just make sure you have the time ypu need to train them, walk them etc.

marmaladepop · 22/09/2022 13:02

Lastqueenofscotland2 · 22/09/2022 10:28

with just a 7 year old, fine, not with a baby on the way.
One caveat is they can be a bit iffy with strangers if not socialised well, which could impact play dates etc

Absolutely this regarding play dates. And also a baby and a puppy is a terrible idea.

Randomword6 · 22/09/2022 12:39

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 11:52

Hubby showed me lots of videos of adult and puppy dobermans with babies and young children and asserted that with proper training and boundaries it would be completely safe.

I think it's not worth the risk but nothing will happen without agreement of course that's why I came here.

Yes, I've had dogs, all rescue, and we are against buying dogs in general but would have to buy from a proper breeder from a puppy because of the child issue.

You don't have to be a conspiracy theorist to mistrust those videos. Of course they won't show the dogs getting stressed and aggressive. I know two children who were bitten, thankfully not badly, by a small happy dog, just because they were left alone and couldn't stop hassling the dog. It would take seconds for things to go so badly wrong. But it does seem as if you want to get people worked up over your I'll advised plans. Let's hope that's all they are.

Magicpaintbrush · 22/09/2022 12:38

Your DH is an idiot - don't be swayed by him!!! Why anyone would get a new puppy of any breed when they are about to have a newborn baby is beyond me. It's completely stupid. What's the rush??? I wouldn't even get a pug puppy if I was pregnant, let alone a large breed like a doberman! Is he planning on being a stay at home dad to look after all these babies, children, cats and puppies - or will that all fall to you????

Yack02 · 22/09/2022 12:23

Ok so you're experienced and have had rescues before, that's something at least! Back to my previous point though, not sure if you've had a puppy or young adult dog in your previous pregnancy and then with a subsequent baby/toddler/pre schooler?

If you have and are fully aware of how bloody hard it is and still want to proceed then go for it.

But if you haven't, please don't put yourself through it. Just wait a few years.

economicervix · 22/09/2022 12:18

Lol
Yes. Definitely. If you want your life to be as difficult as possible and every second hell on earth go for it! Babies are bad enough without a biting, incontinent huge mammal around too.

What exactly about that breed appeals to partnerhubby? A status dog? What’s appealing about having a hard work puppy plus a newborn? The mind boggles.

greenhousegal · 22/09/2022 12:07

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 11:37

Don't be such a conspiracy theorist. My partner wants one and I'm seeking advice as I think it's a bad idea.

You did not mention anything about it being a bad idea in your view, or that it was your partner's suggestion, who is now your Hubby. That was quick!

The partner/hubby might be the problem here not the doberman!

Suzi888 · 22/09/2022 12:07

“Hubby showed me lots of videos of adult and puppy dobermans with babies and young children and asserted that with proper training and boundaries it would be completely safe.” On Instagram? There are loads of that type of video on Instagram - that include breeds that are banned in the U.K, American pit bulls etc. Thing is they have had a ton of training and exercise and then take a cute video for five mins when the dog is drained of all energy and docile/well behaved and I’m sure some are. Some of those owners spend all day with the dogs- that’s how they make their money. Some of the larger breeds prefer a man etc. You may be lucky, you may not. It’s a hell of a risk.

I wanted to rehome a young Canary dog and posted for advice here (which was a bit of a shit show) but I had a few really helpful pm’s from real life owners who gave me insights in to those dogs. I know I am likely too soft to own such a powerful breed. DH has owned such breeds (before the horror stories) and never had a problem.

Remember puppies chew and will steal toys etc. You’ll probably require a dog walker and an area the dog can be kept separate at certain times. It’s just fraught with danger, even accidents with claws etc. I don’t think it’s fair on the dog either to put it in that position.
I also looked at Boerbel- pups and there aren’t many reputable breeders, but the one I looked at actually states that it’s not fair to put a dog in the position of having to deal with everything that goes with children.

You may find that reputable Doberman breeders won’t sell you a pup with your personal circumstances.

serenghetti2011 · 22/09/2022 12:07

Why now? I think you either need to have a dog/puppy or a baby doing both is such a lot of work. Wait until the baby is older and your son is older. When you have more time and energy to actually spend on the dog. A bad first year can affect the test of a dogs life and if you’re not all in because you’ve got your hands full with a baby and tired etc it’s not fair on a puppy. Both puppy and baby need to be prioritised.

I don’t have an opinion on the breed as I don’t know much about Dobermans it’s not a breed I would choose and I’d question your partners motivation for getting one and the timing.

Alopeciabop · 22/09/2022 11:58

Why a Doberman specifically?

milawops · 22/09/2022 11:53

I wouldn't and not because it's a Doberman. I've had one and think they are amazing dogs but any puppy takes so much effort to train that if you do have another child it will be a logistical nightmare. I have a 7 year old GSD and 2 children, an 18 month old and a 5 month old and between the 3 of them I'm constantly ripping my hair out and that's with a fully trained placid dog that I know if great with kids. But she still can't be left alone with them. Im still constantly watching to make sure the 18 month old isn't bothering the dog or trying to steal her food or make her give dolly a horsey ride or whatever other way she's thought of to torment the dog on any particular day. A puppy would tip me over the edge. Of course you might handle stress better than me, most people do to be fair Smile

Ahwig · 22/09/2022 11:53

My in laws have had dogs forever, normally a poodle. My husband and I popped into see them and didn’t have our 3 year old with us for once. They had bought. Doberman and this was the first time we were seeing her. It was near Christmas time and my mother in law offered me a mince pie. I was just putting it to my lips when the Doberman literally hurdled over the sofa I was sitting on snatching the mince pie in the way. I was horrified. They thought it was funny. I said to my husband on the way home I didn’t think it safe to take a toddler there. He fully agreed. 2 months later he but my mother in law quite badly and had to be put down. I’m not blaming the dog because he didn’t know any better as had no training at all but I’m so glad I stuck to my decision and didn’t take my child there.

macthekwife · 22/09/2022 11:52

Hubby showed me lots of videos of adult and puppy dobermans with babies and young children and asserted that with proper training and boundaries it would be completely safe.

I think it's not worth the risk but nothing will happen without agreement of course that's why I came here.

Yes, I've had dogs, all rescue, and we are against buying dogs in general but would have to buy from a proper breeder from a puppy because of the child issue.

OP posts:
Randomword6 · 22/09/2022 11:52

Is this a real question? I think it's nice people have taken this seriously but it goads me.

mumpower3 · 22/09/2022 11:48

I grew up with various dogs. A doberman being one of them. Soppiest dog ever. But ALOT of hard work went into it. They are a big breed who need all the hours you have and more. Mixed with a baby? Probably not a good idea. They can be very territorial.

No puppy/breed is born dangerous!! Its the owners fault how "dangerous" the dog becomes.

LightDrizzle · 22/09/2022 11:47

I love Dobermans but voted YABU because you are trying for a baby. I wouldn’t recommend any puppy in that situation unless your partner doesn’t work and is at home.

If you have a partner who works it will be you taking the dog out to toilet train 16 times a day, cleaning up accidents on your hands and knees, keeping nippy puppy and excited 7/8 year old apart, trying to train multiple times a day on top of other domestic chores and with a demanding baby after disrupted sleep.

Someone will lose out. Your older child, your baby, the puppy. If you have the stamina of an SAS soldier maybe the only person to lose out will be you, in reality it’s likely puppy, older child and you will lose out. At least.

ShoesCoatandBag · 22/09/2022 11:46

Doberman are lovely dogs in my experience. Quite boisterous as puppies though and get big quick.

Never met an aggressive one. Never met adult one that isn’t calm. Have met many that are afraid of their own shadow, leaves and men with hats.

Suzi888 · 22/09/2022 11:43

Flyingwithoutwing · 22/09/2022 10:19

Why the hall would you get a dog prone to active violently if you have kids. That’s diabolical parenting. Get a spaniel or something. FGS!

If you look at spaniel rehoming you’ll find a hell of a lot of them are a bit risk or have bitten.

I love dogs. I have a dog and DD grew up with a dog as did I.

But having /trying for a baby and adding any dog to the mix (or indeed a cat/ any pet really) is going to be extremely hard work. Training, socialising, house breaking, my God you are in for it and I honestly don’t think you’ll have the time.
Dobermans are humongous! 😂🤷🏼‍♀️Even the dog moving around normally (never mind a puppy) will send a baby /toddler flying!

I would wait until the youngest child is around 7 if they are dog savvy and you’ve owned dogs before.
A Doberman is a guard dog, they can make excellent family pets but YOU need to know what you are doing.