Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:49

Yes but I also expect your holy instruction sheet isn't suited for those with learning disabilities, is it @Quveas

Our County Council admitted that their STAR application process wasn't inclusive and they've had to engage with a disability employment charity to help reach good candidates who have dyslexia.

😊

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:47

Also, not sure if some people know this but Indeed is riddled with fake job adverts. Decent candidates are now looking elsewhere for roles.

So if you have a job open on Indeed it could be that applicants aren't sure if it's legit or not.

There was a thread on Mumsnet recently from HR / Hiring Managers saying they've had to stop using Indeed and move onto LinkedIn.

Quveas · 22/09/2022 08:44

I work in the public sector and our HR provide an instruction sheet on how to fill in the application. Literally an instruction sheet. It tells you what we are looking for in each answer, how we judge the answers, what to do and what not to do. It's written in easy, straightforward language. At the top of the application form / beginning of the online application there is advice to read the instruction sheet because it will help you to complete the best application that you possibly can. And yet still fully 50% of the applications we have clearly never read it because their applications tell us nothing. The online application process is actually probably the most frustrating because we have a portal that allows you to save all your details and answers, and reuse them in other applications to save you time. So I routinely get applications for other jobs because the person simply didn't bother to amend or change anything, and thinks that just pressing send is good enough.

Yes, applying for jobs is time consuming if you do it well. But if you can't be arsed to do it well then you really don't want the job, so don't bother to apply. Those who have applied for hundreds of jobs and still got nowhere really need to have a look at why that is - there is always a reason.

That said, I also don't want to see the "job centre is making me apply" applications (we can always tell which ones they are) which waste our time and theirs. And I also think that a more "careers guidance" approach with people is needed - for those that want to work but are struggling, that would be far more effective than sanctions. Back in "the old days" when I was younger, there were many more of these sorts of services to help people into work, rather than punishing them for not being in work.

Hoppinggreen · 22/09/2022 08:43

The position I am looking to fill in in Sales.
Its very obviously Sales, the advert says we need B2B SALES experience.
About 60% of the CVs are from people who Customer service experience instead. I understand about transferable skills but unless they make the case then they are a firm No in under 3 minutes.
I agree that some hiring processes are too lengthy and demanding for the role but some applicants can’t even get the basics right. The advert says must be UK based and quite a few aren’t

justasking111 · 22/09/2022 08:43

Our HR take the biscuit for job applications. Even an interior role it's daunting so many pages to tick box. My boss gets annoyed because they're filtered down to what Head office deem suitable and tick certain boxes. She thinks we miss some gems

Miajk · 22/09/2022 08:43

Darbs76 · 22/09/2022 06:07

It’s super annoying. I sift and interview a lot. And so many people don’t bother to read up on the style of our recruitment (and there’s an abundance of info and videos online how to do it). I recently applied for a promotion and I spent so much time tailoring my statement to the job role each time. If people can’t be bothered to make the effort to stand out in the sift then they are straight in the no pile

This is so unreasonable.

Do you know how long it takes to read up on X company, tailor your CV, write a cover letter, then often the recruitment website asks you to just type out info in your CV again. Only for the company to never even bother with feedback.

Add time for interviewing, usually a few rounds.

Recruiters/HR need to stop being lazy. Your job is to learn how to read a CV to see transferable skills, use common sense. Why do you need it all spelled out like you can't just think.

Job seekers resort to this because it's depressing and companies are shot with their recruitment, never bother providing feedback, require a silly amount of time investment. It does become a numbers game at this point.

Recruiters need to do better in their jobs.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:42

Jellycatrabbit · 22/09/2022 08:38

I'm doing a civil service application at the moment. I have to write a 750 word statement of suitability for the role - but if they get lots of applications they'll only read the first 150 words!!

And don't get me started on the recruitment blind anonymous stuff . . .

Just make sure you apply for a mix of roles because mass civil service redundancies is a regular feature on the news at the moment. Good luck 😊 x

Novum · 22/09/2022 08:41

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 08:25

@Hoppinggreen I agree, employers do not have the time to go to that sort of level for every applicant, my point is more why is that level of time investment expected from the applicant at this stage?

I'm not suggesting accepting poor CVs etc, clear errors and mistakes should get them rejected (very) quickly, but I think it unreasonable to expect a personalised CV at this stage if you are only going to read the CV for 3 minutes.

It would be fairer to assume they will put in twice the time as you - in the OPs case they would get 6 minutes. That 6 minutes should be enough to read the job description decide if it's appropriate to apply and to submit a pre-existing, non-personalised CV. That CV should be very good, time and care should have already been spent on it, it should be reusable for pretty much all of the roles you're applying for.

My issue is the expectation of personalisation when it's accepted it will be read for 3 minutes. It is not realistic to expect people applying for entry-level jobs to do that. In terms of applying for a promotion as mentioned in the OP, then yes, it's applying for a single job in a very specific environment and a level where the OP is likely already known - I'd expect a lot more time on it, equally I'd expect the hiring manager to spend more than 3 minutes considering OPs application for the promotion.

I don't think the work involved in reading 100 job applications is in any way comparable to the work involved in applying for a job. Self-evidently, when you're applying for a job, you're looking at something that will certainly radically affect your life for the next few months/years or even for ever; when you're sifting job applications, you're just doing one amongst a number of tasks you're assigned to do.

If you want the potential employer to spend longer looking at your application, then make the effort to tailor it to the job so you get short listed and interviewed. Quite a number of people will spend quite a bit of time looking at it in that event.

MoltenLasagne · 22/09/2022 08:41

Oh come on, at my level role (technical management) I understand it's acceptable to expect proper research into what the job is about, the salary reflects it. When I used to recruit for call centre staff on minimum wage (and we were always desperate for staff btw) it was just a hurdle that the company wanted to make them think this job was incredible.

Yes it was a decent company but you could get the same pay in McDonalds so it was basically down to were people happier to get moaned at down the phone from customers than serve fast food. And we lost a LOT of staff to McDs and Tescos after they decided they'd rather do that than work call centre in the end.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:39

Windinthepillows · 22/09/2022 08:37

@CollieWobble22 could say the same for hiring people that ‘cba’ to write a form and check it!

Yes but what about those who are frequently dismissed because of their age.

Nothing to do with spelling mistakes or CBA-ness but their AGE.

It is demoralising being discriminated against. Which is what some PP and I are trying to discuss. 😊

Jellycatrabbit · 22/09/2022 08:38

I'm doing a civil service application at the moment. I have to write a 750 word statement of suitability for the role - but if they get lots of applications they'll only read the first 150 words!!

And don't get me started on the recruitment blind anonymous stuff . . .

Windinthepillows · 22/09/2022 08:37

@CollieWobble22 could say the same for hiring people that ‘cba’ to write a form and check it!

Windinthepillows · 22/09/2022 08:36

Well come on, getting the job application right is hardly the worst thing! I’ve been there myself, I was unemployed once for a year so it’s not like I’ve not been through it.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:36

Imagine working for some of these posters!

Enough red flags for a parade! 🤣

Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 08:35

Windinthepillows, thanks for that. I'm obviously just not putting enough effort in, I see that now.

fruitstick · 22/09/2022 08:35

I'm tempted to say if you expect a tailored CV for every role, they should expect a tailored reply as to why they weren't successful.

I've applied for a few jobs recently and have heard nothing, or a blanket 'sorry you weren't successful'

It very demoralising.

Windinthepillows · 22/09/2022 08:34

@MoltenLasagne Yeah, why don’t they just give you the job when maybe 100 people have applied for it. It’s almost as if they need a way to filter the applications.

Novum · 22/09/2022 08:33

tuttifruit · 22/09/2022 06:08

Might be hard for you but it's even harder for job applicants who are expected to fill out multiple forms and individual cover letters and CVs for each job application - which often turn out to be an inactive/internal post that they have no chance at anyway. Use a recruitment agency if you cba to sift through bad ones

How is it harder for job applicants? The vast majority aren't being forced to do it. If you can't be bothered to make the effort to find out about the place you're applying to then save yourself the effort of making the application at all.

I used to work in a solicitors' firm. It was extraordinary how many applications we got from people saying how they were really keen on developing their career in a specified area of law which two minutes' research would have told them we didn't offer.

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 08:32

@BoredWithLife
I didn't mention a promotion, of course I would spend more time on internal candidates.
I don't expect a highly personalised cv either but candidates who say they are looking for a specific role, that's not even related to my role, in the opening statement are wasting everyone's time.
I think it would take a minute or two to at least ensure your cv is generic enough not to rule you out, and a minute or so more to add something in that makes it clear you have the right skills and experience. Just the opening statement would be enough.

OP posts:
Windinthepillows · 22/09/2022 08:32

I agree. If you’re desperate for a job/want a job you can amend and tailor a job application. Tasks in your job will take more than 30 minutes, if you can’t be arsed now why should someone hire you. It’s also a bit of respect to get the actual application right and not leave your previous application details on. I don’t agree with the soul destroying comments, yes it’s shit job hunting, nice been there, but you have to put some effort in.

MoltenLasagne · 22/09/2022 08:31

I wish companies would stop asking "why do you want to work at Generic Employer Ltd?" for basic entry roles.

All they are asking is for the candidate to blow smoke up their arses when if the candidates were being honest they'd say "I'd quite like to be able to pay my bills and buy food and I've looked at the job description and think I could do a decent enough job to not get fired in the first day."

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:29

@Rapidtango welcome to the 3.6% unemployed club!!

Frequently being told by Hiring Managers / HR that I'm "older than our usual applicant!"..... I'm 36!!

People always say "they aren't allowed to say that" but they always do...

😔

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 08:27

Calmdown14 · 22/09/2022 08:07

Oh god yes. You are so right.

We had a very basic entry level role. Great opportunity to get into a good employer. Very few set requirements other than good organisational skills, IT proficient, can use social media.

Even those working in Tescos could have pulled out the relevant bits of what they do there (stock rotation, dealing with rotas etc) .

But we got hundreds who wanted entry into a completely different field, who didn't meet any of the essential requirements on paper. Looking at their CV their roles must have met it but it's not my job to work this out, you need to tell me! Especially in a role where being able to select the relevant bits of information is key. If you can't do this on the application then there's little hope.

I also assume these are the 'I've applied for hundreds ' bunch and I really want to tell them to just apply for 10 jobs well. It's so frustrating on their behalf

Exactly how I feel.
It's not my job to work out how your skills might fit. You need to make it clear quickly. Or at least don't explain how you are looking for a career in a totally different industry then wonder why you don't get an interview.

OP posts:
BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 08:25

@Hoppinggreen I agree, employers do not have the time to go to that sort of level for every applicant, my point is more why is that level of time investment expected from the applicant at this stage?

I'm not suggesting accepting poor CVs etc, clear errors and mistakes should get them rejected (very) quickly, but I think it unreasonable to expect a personalised CV at this stage if you are only going to read the CV for 3 minutes.

It would be fairer to assume they will put in twice the time as you - in the OPs case they would get 6 minutes. That 6 minutes should be enough to read the job description decide if it's appropriate to apply and to submit a pre-existing, non-personalised CV. That CV should be very good, time and care should have already been spent on it, it should be reusable for pretty much all of the roles you're applying for.

My issue is the expectation of personalisation when it's accepted it will be read for 3 minutes. It is not realistic to expect people applying for entry-level jobs to do that. In terms of applying for a promotion as mentioned in the OP, then yes, it's applying for a single job in a very specific environment and a level where the OP is likely already known - I'd expect a lot more time on it, equally I'd expect the hiring manager to spend more than 3 minutes considering OPs application for the promotion.

Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 08:23

I agree with Lindy2. I'm currently job hunting and it's absolutely soul destroying. I've applied for 24 jobs, mostly minimum wage or salary a couple of pounds an hour above. I have years of experience in the particular sector I'm applying for, but have been self employed for 18 years while raising kids, so of course have no current referees, and it doesn't take a genius to work out I'm well on the wrong side of 50.

So I complete the arduous online applications, provide real life examples using STAR method (hmm), tailor my CV, upload my CV, send in personal statement, wait, hear nothing, assume have not been successful.

Except in the case of local government or civil service roles, where at least you get to hear they're not interested. Although the job descriptions for these roles are so full of corporate speak it's often quite difficult to work out what the job entails. Lots of reference to stakeholders but little information on what you'd be required to do.

The fact that many profoundly junior roles (admin assistant, telephone customer service etc) appear to require a degree. Why is that?

When I was last in the labour market you could contact a recruitment agency, send in your CV, have a chat on the phone or even a face to face meeting with an agent to properly explain your CV, gaps therein, slightly unusual work history etc. They could see you were neat, clean, reasonably articulate. Now, you can't speak to a living soul.

Even companies that state they're willing to provide feedback if you're unsuccessful usually don't, or if they do it's so generic that it's worthless.

I have at least 10 years before retirement. Even at minimum wage that's heading towards £200K that won't be coming into our household over the next 20 years because I'm starting to think I'm on the scrap heap.

Swipe left for the next trending thread