Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
Treetip · 22/09/2022 09:20

Employers should remember there's a labour shortage and expecting applicants to jump through hoops for low-paying jobs is unrealistic.

Adultchildofelderlyparents · 22/09/2022 09:17

PurBal · 22/09/2022 06:13

Applying for jobs 20 years ago: send generic CV you have kept updated, personalised covering letter, send to hiring manager, receive reply from hiring manager (yes or no). Total time spent: 30 minutes.
Applying for jobs today: take CV, log into some kind of online portal, input data into digital form (can’t always straight copy and past because there are multiple boxes in different formats), answer three questions circa 200 words why you should get the job over someone else, complete form on inclusion, export to pdf, attach to email, write cover email, send to hiring manager, wait a month and if you don’t hear assume you didn’t get the job. Total time spent: 3 hours
If your desperate for work, imagine doing 10 or 30 of these kind of applications. Depending on the job you can also get additional online assessments.
True CVs shouldn’t be personalised to the job but an overview of the applicants background. Covering letters should be personalised and highlight particular relevant skills.

Don't forget that each portal requires you to register with a username and password, and the password criteria are always slightly different so you can't use the same one. Add on half an hour trying to remember password.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/09/2022 09:17

@EnidSpyton
I’ve withdrawn that. I forgot you’ve got the experience yourself.

TeaKlaxon · 22/09/2022 09:16

A CV generally should not need tweaking. It should be an overview of experience and qualifications and key achievements in previous roles.

Someone putting ‘looking for a role in a lab’ is actually a good example of why tailoring CVs is a bad idea. Aside from the time, the risk of sending the wrong ‘version’ of your CV and looking worse than someone who sent a generic one is too high.

I very rarely tailor my CV to specific roles. For a job I really want, I might do so by emphasising different achievements in certain roles to be more relevant to the role I’m interested in. But generally my CV gives a good and pithy description of my experience, skills and achievements so it doesn’t need tweaking.

Of course that will be accompanied by a covering letter or email, or sometimes a statement of suitability where I will specify why my CV makes me a good fit for the specific role - but that’s not the role of the CV itself.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 09:16

Noviembre · 22/09/2022 09:10

If you can't get off your phone for the duration of an interview, yes, you're unemployable.

I one said they were on their phone. Simply that they had it in their hand.

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/09/2022 09:16

This reply has been withdrawn

Withdrawn at poster's request

Mummyoflittledragon · 22/09/2022 09:14

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

If op is getting hundreds of applicants for each role, she is only going to spend a few minutes on each. It only takes this long to weed out those, who do not have the required qualifications and experience. She can then go back to the more impressive cvs, reread them and chooses the best candidates for interview. This is why it is so important for a cv and covering letter to be specific and tailor made. It is for the candidate to impress the company if they want the role.

To put it into perspective, 100 cvs at 3 mins a piece = 5 hours of work.

Scepticalwotsits · 22/09/2022 09:14

When I have hired, I took the CV checked whether it had the core requirements we asked for, if yea moved to one pipe if no checked whether they seemed to have relevant experience that could be worthwhile, if yes moved into the same pile.

then depending how many were in that pipe would read any supporting statements ans if there were any howlers or clear no fits would remove them then would go and have a call with each of them and from thag would bring forward a group to interview.

I do that because in a previous role i had a boss that would get the stack chuck half in the bin, then grab a pile of ones which fit some arbitrary criteria he had, and then threw the rest away and interviewed and hired one from that bunch regardless of suitability.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/09/2022 09:13

WhatNoRaisins · 22/09/2022 07:06

The whole thing needs a massive overhaul.

No more making people apply for anything and everything to please the jobcentre

No more of these generic and meaningless job adverts that you couldn't tailor an application to even if you wanted to

Proportionate job application processes for the role and salary

Job adverts that actually contain relevant information like where the job actually is and what the actual hours will be

There's so much time and effort wasted on this completely unnecessarily

All of this plus

Job adverts that state the salary range!

Why would a company expect a candidate to spend time applying if they can't even be bothered / are to embarrassed to say what they pay?

Seeing "Competitive package" or "compensation commensurate with experience" on an advert for anything other than a top top role is a major red flag.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 09:12

thecatsthecats · 22/09/2022 09:01

But who teaches them?

I have stopped judging applications headed "Dear sirs", after a lady told me that she'd been told that was the only respectful way to address a letter.

Yes, recruitment is costly. And that is exactly why you don't want to put off good recruits with BS processes. Because good staff are generally allergic to bullshit.

I won't apply if I think the application process is bunk, because it tends to be reflective of the organisation culture. And I assure you that I'm a cracking member of staff :D

My dd was taught CV writing as part of her EPQ that ran alongside her a levels.

I know we went through it at school (in the 1990s) but not in depth.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 09:11

For a bright, normal applicant it's easy to get hired

This is ableist.

Seymour5 · 22/09/2022 09:11

@Rapidtango I was redundant at 50 from a reasonably well paid job, with some management responsibility. Same company for a long time, but no high level qualifications. I knew I’d probably have to go back to basics, so I applied to the local council at a clerical level, and was successful. Five years later, I went for a different role at another LA and got it. They had very specific application forms, and applied a pretty strict sifting criteria. I didn’t find the public sector to be discriminatory age wise.

I finished full time work at 61, and found part time work. One job I had for a couple of years was in the Civil Service, again at clerical officer level, where I had to take a fairly basic numeracy and literacy test. Don’t give up!

kewinsurreylass · 22/09/2022 09:11

"I've just been through about 30 applications for a role in school, and the spelling and punctuation was awful in about half of them."
Most people leave school unable to spell or understand grammar or punctuation
When they come for interview many fall into ghetto talk or say "like" or "kinda " every 2 seconds
Just cannot employ anyone like that

Noviembre · 22/09/2022 09:10

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 07:49

Wow phone on their hands! What an outrage!

Couldn’t possibly be that they had it in their hand when they arrived and are just extremely nervous given the situation.

Must mean they are unemployable 🙄

If you can't get off your phone for the duration of an interview, yes, you're unemployable.

Brefugee · 22/09/2022 09:10

if you work in recruiting you already know that benefit claimants have to apply for roles they aren't qualified for, to keep their quota up. Shit for you, much much shittier for them. It is a waste of their (arguably more precious than your) time.

I keep a loose eye on job ads. It would help if companies (not all companies) wouldn't advertise for that one person in a gazillion who fits EXACTLY the role they want to fill, rather than being a bit more general, doing their own homework while reading the applications, and recognising that they will have to train someone to be their perfect fit.

countrygirl99 · 22/09/2022 09:10

Even when you get to interview some have clearly not read the brief. A few years ago I worked for a University that also ran very technical short courses for a specific industry. We wanted to expand the short courses and were recruiting for someone to market those courses. We sent a brief to everyone selected for interview that gave details of the course, who it was aimed at and the geographical distribution of previous intended. It was a very technical course aimed at air accident investigators and attendees were worldwide. The interviewees were asked to explain how they would approach marketing the course, not even specific actions, just a general approach to see if they had an appreciation of the market. One person came up with "I would have people in the local town handing out leaflets".

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 09:09

Windinthepillows · 22/09/2022 08:36

Well come on, getting the job application right is hardly the worst thing! I’ve been there myself, I was unemployed once for a year so it’s not like I’ve not been through it.

That’s the problem. What’s right?

Who said it was the worst thing?

The world of work is changing and plenty of people have realised that employers are not doing their employees a favour. It’s a mutually beneficial agreement. Expectations of both side should be realistic. Respect is a 2 way thing.

Noviembre · 22/09/2022 09:06

YANBU OP. We're always hiring but most of the applicants are... well. Fantasists and complete idiot's would be putting it politely. If we're not chucking out their CVs due to the garbled mangling of the English language, we're howling at the gems they think it's appropriate to put on there, like boasting about their gaming prowess as a sign of their skill and dedication, or their performing of basic household chores.

Even the ones we get in are monosyllabic with absolutely no interest in the role. No, they don't like computers much, no they don't know what cloud technology is, no they can't tell me about anything software related at all other than 'I heard it pays well.'

For a bright, normal applicant it's easy to get hired.

Bubblebubblebah · 22/09/2022 09:04

Jellycatrabbit · 22/09/2022 08:38

I'm doing a civil service application at the moment. I have to write a 750 word statement of suitability for the role - but if they get lots of applications they'll only read the first 150 words!!

And don't get me started on the recruitment blind anonymous stuff . . .

As a woman of fertile age and an immigrant, I actually veryuch welcome blind recruitments😁

UneFoisAuChalet · 22/09/2022 09:02

Very true.
I recruit in languages and the amount of CVs I get from baristas or warehouse workers who don’t speak a word of Mandarin, Russian, Polish etc…is mind blowing.

thecatsthecats · 22/09/2022 09:01

Butterfly44 · 22/09/2022 07:59

I totally agree. I recruit a fair bit and some applications are so poor, they don't seem to read the job description or person spec as there's zero evidence in the application. Straight on no pile. I don't know if kids get taught about cvs and applying for jobs in school at all; it's an important life skill to know about.

But who teaches them?

I have stopped judging applications headed "Dear sirs", after a lady told me that she'd been told that was the only respectful way to address a letter.

Yes, recruitment is costly. And that is exactly why you don't want to put off good recruits with BS processes. Because good staff are generally allergic to bullshit.

I won't apply if I think the application process is bunk, because it tends to be reflective of the organisation culture. And I assure you that I'm a cracking member of staff :D

EnidSpyton · 22/09/2022 08:57

I’m job hunting at the moment and only applying for jobs where I meet 100% of the person specification. I am very experienced, academically well qualified, etc. I also used to work in recruitment so I am excellent at writing tailored job applications and CVs.

Despite this I am not getting interviews. I am trying to move into a new but related field and my skills and knowledge are all entirely transferable. However it’s as if whoever is reading the job applications is refusing to put me through because I don’t have another institution from within that field on my CV. The narrow minded attitude of HR people is really frustrating. Either that or the position was always going to be filled internally and the advert was just them following procedure rather than actually advertising a job that was available.

So even when you do spend hours you don’t always get fairly treated. So now I feel like I might as well just create a generic application and send that in instead - I don’t have time to keep spending 3 hours on fiddly forms to just receive radio silence or rejections telling me that my experience wasn’t quite the right fit for the role despite me proving very eloquently and with plenty of evidence that it was!

I have also been on the other side though and what pisses me off is when people apply for jobs that they aren’t qualified for. I don’t mind a generic CV or covering letter but the number of people in my last role who applied for jobs without having the required qualifications we specified was ridiculous. All of them had to go straight in the bin. Not to mention the number of international applicants despite us stating clearly we couldn’t sponsor visas. I don’t understand that mentality at all - I can get having a go at applying for something you don’t 100% fit but applying for something you don’t have the required qualification to do? Surely they must know it’s a total waste of time!

Sprogonthetyne · 22/09/2022 08:56

I really wish I didn't agree, but I kind of do. I recently went back to work after a few years at home. I applied for 3 jobs, which met my skills and time commitments, spent a whole evening on each application, and got invited to an interview for each. Was offered and accepted a job after first interview (it happened to be my preferred option).

BUT, I wasn't in great financially need or claiming job seekers, so the applications were spaced out over about a month, with no pressure to apply jobs that weren't a good fit. If I'd had to prove to the job centre that I'd applied to 20+ jobs that week, or risk having my money stopped and not been able to feed the family, then I wouldn't have been able to spend hours on an application. I'd have spent at most half an hour, because otherwise there would be no possible way to apply for the required number of jobs, so probably wouldn't have had a chance of getting any.

Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 08:53

Quveas, of course unless there is a chance of feedback (good feedback), it's difficult to know what the reason is.

I've trolled through pages of on line CV examples, generic and specific, written so many covering letters that are absolutely specific to the roles I'm applying for, have changed my CV to highlight certain experience or employers.

I'm not sure what else to do, tbh. I went into our local Jobcentre to see if they could help, but because I don't get any benefits they couldn't - they had a quick look (maybe 90 seconds - seems to be about par for the course Grin ) at my CV, told me I shouldn't worry, I would get something easily with my experience (hollow laugh) and that was it.

sheepdogdelight · 22/09/2022 08:52

Your job is to learn how to read a CV to see transferable skills, use common sense. Why do you need it all spelled out like you can't just think.

Or maybe, as the person writing the CV, rather than writing something like "worked as cashier in bank" and expecting the employer to work out this means you are good at dealing with people, can manage difficult customers, proactively improved several bank processes, are good at working with a range of IT systems ...,- you could actually spell out the transferable skills for us? For all I know your job as a bank cashier just involves counting money.