Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
Puzzledandpissedoff · 22/09/2022 10:12

Employers expect far more effort from an applicant than they are willing to give them

Initially perhaps - that's why making a quick impression matters - but not once someone's in post, when any decent employer will want to concentrate on induction, training and all the rest

I agree it's never right to leave applicants with no reply at all, even the hopeless ones who are just making up numbers for the job centre, but expecting folk to spend time over something that's been thrown together just isn't realistic

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 10:11

dutysuite · 22/09/2022 09:52

The problem I’m experiencing is some of the jobs advertised aren’t even real, I get an interview and straight away realise the interviewer just wants free consultancy on how to solve all their business problems.

True with marketing and design roles too.

People are catching on. Which is why good candidates are using other platforms like LinkedIn.

I doubt Indeed will be around for much longer. It'll turn into Reed.co.uk which is mainly fake jobs

The only jobs left on it are

  1. the public sector / third sector ones that say "apply easily with your Indeed CV" and then the job ad says "Please email for an application pack" - why even advertise on Indeed?

  2. fake jobs where they want your CV data

  3. fake jobs where they interview you immediately, get free consultancy and dismiss you

  4. the job where 400 people apply but they decide to employ their mate instead.

antelopevalley · 22/09/2022 10:11

JSA make you apply for loads of jobs when it makes zero sense.
I had a job but had to wait until DBS was completed so had 6 weeks signing on. I still had to apply for other jobs even though I had a job to go to. No way was I tailoring applications. I just sent a CV to jobs that I know I had no chance of getting. It was a stupid tick box exercise.

EspressoPatronumm · 22/09/2022 10:08

I wouldn't want your job

DogInATent · 22/09/2022 09:58

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

If an applicant has mad a genuine effort in the application and clearly meets the Essential Requirements, this will be obvious in a lot less than three minutes.

If it takes longer than 3 minutes to identify that you're suitable for the role, then all your effort in the application was wasted.

There's no gold stars for trying after primary school.

dutysuite · 22/09/2022 09:52

The problem I’m experiencing is some of the jobs advertised aren’t even real, I get an interview and straight away realise the interviewer just wants free consultancy on how to solve all their business problems.

Porcupineintherough · 22/09/2022 09:52

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

If you get 200 cvs do you really think a potential employer is going to spend an hour carefully reading each one?

3 min is generous I think. When I do it, I do an initial sift during which applications get maybe 1 min à piece. If that doesn't suggest they've met the basic criteria as laid out in the job spec, or even in some cases read the job spec, then they go in the discard pile.

Second sift get maybe 5 min a piece and basic scoring. Anything that goes to the third round will be properly read and fully scored (I'm usually down to about a dozen at this point). 5 or 6 usually get to interview.

Judging by some of the bizarre cvs I get sent through I assume the sender is fulfilling the needs of a job centre somewhere. Recently got one from a guy in financial services in the US for a niche scientific role in the UK. No relevant qualifications, no relevant experience. Spam.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/09/2022 09:52

Until the job centre stop this quantity over quality nonsense nothings going to change.

BitOutOfPractice · 22/09/2022 09:50

op I hope you are one of the rare people who is courteously prompt with rejections!

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 09:49

I think the thing that is so weird about recruitment is, that so much is expected. Until you get to a certain level.

The jobs that pay lower or middle incomes expect, portals with long winded questions, upload a CV that never fits in the right boxes so has to be done manually, research on the company and wrote a fluff piece on why you want to work for that company and so on, presentations and the like

The you get to a certain level, where people expect recruitment to be more labour intense for applicants, and it’s not at all. The job I am in now, is because The HR director knew of me through a networking event in the industry. Though we had never actually met.

When Senior people leave, we don’t advertise as such. We either have an idea who we want for the role or we use specialist recruiters and most people they would put forward we already have an idea of who they are or their company. We get a CV from the recruiter and interview and that’s that. The recruiters have so many contacts and pools of people they will head hunt.

Although when we do have an idea who we want the recruiter will do usually be informed incase they have someone better in mind and advertise the role as we should. Though I often think advertising roles when you know who you want is pointless for applicants.

I find the further I go in my career, the easier it is.

and don’t get me started on people who expect applicants to watch videos on recruitment style. Or ‘how to videos’ to know how to apply. If you have to watch instructional videos, the problem IS your recruitment style

XingMing · 22/09/2022 09:48

@MsMcGonagall ruled you out! 119 are not getting the job; your numeracy fails you! xx

MsMcGonagall · 22/09/2022 09:45

If you have 120 applicants for a role then even if all of them have done beautifully tailored applications, 111 of them are not going to get the job.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 09:44

@notalwaysalondoner Sounds like the dream. Head screwed on and progressive attitudes. Love it!

Shows that the company aren't stuck in the 90s with their awful, time consuming processes and that they strive to be better 😊 after all, time is money!

notalwaysalondoner · 22/09/2022 09:41

I also agree about simplifying the process - one of the things I love about my company and which made me accept the job is that they just ask for a CV and cover letter. Nothing else. They are also very clear about the format interviews will take, and no group exercises or other trendy stuff. I loved that - despite having tens of thousands of applicants a year they accept that actually the quickest way to both screen candidates and keep your best candidates happy is to keep the application process super super simple.

notalwaysalondoner · 22/09/2022 09:37

I agree, I work for an extremely competitive graduate employer (not in recruiting, but they get everyone to chip in on CV screening as we have tens of thousands of applicants a year) and sadly, those from the less prestigious universities are much more guilty of this in general. It makes it very very hard for us to hire from those universities, as the candidates just aren't being clear about what makes them stand out, or tailoring it enough to the role, which means we can't even offer them a first round interview. Whereas from Oxbridge or the big London schools, they are 99% of the time tailored, clear about what makes them worth interviewing over the next candidate, and specific about their achievements (e.g. 'I captain football for the university team/local village' rather than just 'I play football' which helps us differentiate leadership and time commitments for example). It's such a shame as I think it is mostly down to much better career advice and support for those universities, but it means we often can't even give the others a chance. Of course, some of the time it is just laziness, but I don't think that's the root cause in this case.

Bubblebubblebah · 22/09/2022 09:35

Indeed not LinkedIn 🤦

Bubblebubblebah · 22/09/2022 09:31

Tbh if hundred people didn't apply for jobs they are not even 25% suitable for, companies would probably have time to answer everyone and wouldn't need super long weeding out application processes.

People don't even have to be 100% match, 75% can do if that 75% are the core skills and knowledge. But getting 30 75% and 368 10% matches. I think it's understandable many places can't answer to everyone.

When I worked in sme in hospitality we got 600 cvs. 500+ were very obviously not intended to help get a job. We did not have capacity to reply to all. Though places like linked in are now making it easier.

Brefugee · 22/09/2022 09:29

deffo agree about salary range. Stop wasti

ng people's time with this.
Also agree that i expect, as an absolute minimum: acknowledement that my application has arrvied (robo-email is fine) and i expect an answer full stop no matter how far i get. I have contacted well-known companies after 2 months to ask why no reply - and given them chapter and verse on how much of people's time they are wasting only not to have the basic decency to send a generic "sorry, no" email.

And from the applicant’s perspective, the number of spelling and grammatical mistakes I’ve seen in job adverts is shocking. I mean truly shocking. And actually embarrassing when one of the criteria sought is “attention to detail.” If you want the applicants to put in the effort then so should the employer.

I have a friend who sent a job application to the CEO with all the mistakes and suggested improvements for clarity marked in red. It was a bloody mess. He invited her for an interview, and she met a few of the directors, including the ones responsible for recruiting. They offered her a job. She sent back their offer letter with all the mistakes and suggested improvements marked in red and turned them down. We know a few people who have worked there now and again, nobody stays long.

As for OPs assertion a few pages ago that it's not their job to decide if their open roles fit a candidate's qualifications/experience - meh. Up to you. But my last two jobs i got have been because i sent an application on spec and asked if they had anything that suited me.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 09:26

@girlmom21 I'm just not "normal" enough 🤣🤣🤣

DarkShade · 22/09/2022 09:25

Darbs76 · 22/09/2022 06:07

It’s super annoying. I sift and interview a lot. And so many people don’t bother to read up on the style of our recruitment (and there’s an abundance of info and videos online how to do it). I recently applied for a promotion and I spent so much time tailoring my statement to the job role each time. If people can’t be bothered to make the effort to stand out in the sift then they are straight in the no pile

I totally understand this from your perspective, and for any job that I really wanted I did this. But the reality is that when you are jobsearching you simply cannot go and read all these pages and watch every online video for every job, there is not enough time. I guess people try and strike a balance by sending in standard CVs that are a bit tweaked.

It's madness what companies want from you now just to be interviewed. Psychometric tests, a video introducing yourself (!!), a video demonstration of you performing a task, a written paragraph about how you've handled problems.... my siblings in Christ, just look at my CV and call me in or not, we're all busy!

girlmom21 · 22/09/2022 09:24

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:36

Imagine working for some of these posters!

Enough red flags for a parade! 🤣

Don't worry about it, they'll never recruit us Grin

Cw112 · 22/09/2022 09:24

In fairness a lot of people aren't aware of what someone is looking for from a cv/application thinking I'll tell more at interview and don't realise they need to demonstrate every point in the person specification. It's not something we're really properly taught so I don't think it's lack of effort as much as lack of understanding. Also when you're really trying to seek work and are sending out loads of applications it's super demoralising and time consuming so I think people can start to get quite disheartened which maybe shows in their application.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 09:23

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/09/2022 09:13

All of this plus

Job adverts that state the salary range!

Why would a company expect a candidate to spend time applying if they can't even be bothered / are to embarrassed to say what they pay?

Seeing "Competitive package" or "compensation commensurate with experience" on an advert for anything other than a top top role is a major red flag.

I agree with all this.

Including recruitment staff who contact you, set up a call to tell you basically nothing about the role, who it’s for or where it is or what it pays. They only want to tell you that if you are short listed, after that call.

Expecting people to take out to phone interview when they don’t even know if they want the job is ridiculous.

DogInATent · 22/09/2022 09:23

The best piece of advice I was given about applying for jobs was simple:

Always remember that the first person that reads your application/CV does not want to give you the job

They want to clear the dross as fast as possible to spend time on the serious applications. If, on the first pass, your application gets as much as 3 minutes attention then the system is being generous. First pass is to weed out everyone that doesn't obviously meet the Essential Requirements. This is why you must tailor each application to the role. If it's not immediately obvious that you meet the Essential Requirements for that specific role you have much lower chance of advancing to interview.

It will take half-a-day minimum to put a single application together. No, you won't get feedback if you're rejected before the interview stage. If you reach interview but are unsuccessful you'll have to ask for feedback if you want it.

mumda · 22/09/2022 09:20

If you make the process simpler you will have better recruitment.

What do you actually want to know? If your application process needs video and pages of information then I think it's you whose messed up not the candidates.