Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 11:42

Blooberry, everything. I'm applying for temp, contract, full time, part time. It's incredibly demoralising, especially when we keep being told businesses are desperate for staff. Our local council was after 6 customer services assistants, both full and part-time, minimum wage roles, pretty standard requirements (good communication skills etc etc), it took 90 minutes to complete the application, including 3 long form STAR questions and I found out yesterday my application is not being progressed. I'm sure it's probably a combination of my age, the fact I've been self employed for years, have no current referees, but it just seems that the application process these days is pretty much 'computer says no' and there's nothing I can do about it.

Considering I have 10 years working life left, I'm probably a better bet than many younger people who will want to progress their careers and move in a few years, whereas I'm happy to stay put.

averageavocado · 22/09/2022 11:38

Dreamstate · 22/09/2022 10:53

If someone is only spending 3 minutes to review a CV, this will be why I just take the key words from the job application and drop them into my CV, job done. CV is just a way to get you into the door for an interview. I won't spend hours perfectly tailoring my CV if you only have 3 minutes to look at it.

the 3 mins is the starter
then if you get past that, then we look deeper in

averageavocado · 22/09/2022 11:36

Bubblebubblebah · 22/09/2022 09:04

As a woman of fertile age and an immigrant, I actually veryuch welcome blind recruitments😁

as a recruiter I like them

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 11:21

@ADecadeAndAHalf I had the same type of interview. It was advertised as full time but said part time would be considered.

When I got to the interview, I mentioned this and I was immediately asked to leave by the woman who was interviewing me. It was so humiliating.

I actually complained to the Head Office about this woman and explained how she treated me. They were extremely embarrassed and apologised.

I went on to work elsewhere but for the same industry. We had this company on the supplier list and it was part of my role to choose who we used for that particular service. Obviously they lost all of our £200k per year business as I refused to work with the dragon (it was client facing and she was horrid!)

BlooberryBiskits · 22/09/2022 11:21

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:29

@Rapidtango welcome to the 3.6% unemployed club!!

Frequently being told by Hiring Managers / HR that I'm "older than our usual applicant!"..... I'm 36!!

People always say "they aren't allowed to say that" but they always do...

😔

@Rapidtango : sorry to read about your experience

Are you also applying for temp/contract roles? This might be a way to get a role quickly so you can refresh your ‘employed’ status & then move on

Darbs76 · 22/09/2022 11:09

ADecadeAndAHalf · 22/09/2022 06:41

@Darbs76 and how many jobs did you apply for alongside applying for that promotion? Did you read up on the application process for each one? It sounds like you only applied for the one job. If you multiply that "so much time" you spent for 3-4 jobs a week, do you not see that people just don't have time amongst their other commitments?

As pp said, it's soul destroying. My last interview went something like this:
spend half a day writing cover letter and tailoring cv.
Apply - fill out online form ~1 hr
get automatic confirmation.
Hear nothing. Wait. Assume it's unsuccessful.
Monday evening 5 and a half weeks later, get phone call at 730pm. Interview on Wednesday at 9.
Cancel everything on Tuesday to prepare.
Wednesday start interview. Within the initial conversation about job role and discussion of duties went something like
interviewer "no, this is a full time role".
Co-interviewer "she wrote on her cover letter 20-40%" ( I did, in bold).
Me " the job is advertised as part time, any %"
Interviewer "well that's a mistake. There's no point continuing the interview, thank your for your time."

And you wonder why people don't sit and tailor their cv to each and every job they apply for?

I applied for 6 jobs and got 2 offers. I’d always adjust each application as it’s always obvious if you throw in a statement geared for another job. You need to adjust it for the requirements of each role.

Eeksteek · 22/09/2022 11:08

I just applied for a job. I don’t interview well, so I need a strong application, and the job was a very good fit for me flexibility-wise, so I put a lot of effort in, and I got offered the job. It took hours and hours. For only just beyond minimal wage. Obviously I filled in the ten page application form, and spent several hours thinking about the questions I answered. Then I went to an interview day, with four forms of ID. The interview was fine, just a bit of hanging around (I’ve had to put in whole days for entry level jobs before, so far, so good). I read everything sent to me pre-interview, researched the company, reviewed my experience and tried to consider what may be asked at interview based on my knowledge of the role and how I would use incidences from the past to answer them. They sent a list of possible questions, and I spent two days practicing answers and trying to think up positive ways to frame ‘I would like to make some money with as little stress and impact on my family as possible’ and tosh about where I see myself in five years and what my goals are (keep my kid alive. Not freeze!). They asked none of these questions.

Ten days later, Then they asked me to submit ID to their online portal (again), for THREE references, and another lot of online portal box ticking.

Then they sent a THIRTY PAGE post application pack for ‘preferred candidates’. (Don’t think I do have the job at all, actually) which required (among other utterly tedious and unnecessary things) a work history since I left full-time application with zero gaps (I’m 44. It took ages and no one will read it, because it’s not at all relevant) my references (again) and another lot of box ticking about criminal records and right to work etc etc (which I have ALREADY DONE. Possibly twice)

Apparently, if anyone ever wades through that and my referees can string two words together, I then get to have ANOTHER interview, where they will check my ID for a third time (which has already been done and photographed in person and submitted online. What they will gain from doing it a third time via teams is anyone’s guess. I can’t imagine). Then there are two training days, probably about an hour to learn how to do the job and the rest mandatory crap. If I make it through them, I can start earning money. I will not make payroll for October, even if I do start on the 10th and don’t expect to see any money until the end of November.

This is for a temporary fixed term contract of 12 weeks. It pays slightly above minimum wage, but very little. I applied in August, and expected to start on October 10, but I think that is very unlikely now. They have just cancelled the training days which should have been next week, and will rebook when they get references, so I can’t book child or petcare, because I don’t know when it will be. I applied because I am broke and needed the money, but it seems beyond ludicrous that a job I am massively overqualified for can require SO much of my time and effort, and so long before I see a penny. For 11 quid an hour for 12 weeks. It’s utterly disproportionate.

I appreciate this is not a high level role. But I am still a person, and my time is HUGELY valuable to me and my child, and that has obviously been considered by no one. Clearly if the job truly requires this lengthy and complex process of vetting of my skill and experience to get, it should not be so poorly paid. And if it does not, I shouldn’t have to wade through it. You can’t have it both ways, employers!

latetothefisting · 22/09/2022 11:07

To be fair the same applies both ways.
When I was last job hunting about 7 years ago a huge number of the application forms were ridiculous - either over complicated (asking you to enter every single gcse separately for a role that needed at least a degree), or didn't work at all, asked you to enter all the information in your cv and then attach the cv as well, asked you to provide evidence of about 15 essential criteria then only gave 300 words to do it in....

Phone interviews outsourced to hiring companies that couldn't answer any of my questions about the job....

It should be a rule that all hiring staff have to fill in their own form/go through their own application process before it goes live!

Just an application could take several hours so if people are trying to do several a day/week it's a huge chunk of time, particularly if they are already working full time!

averageavocado · 22/09/2022 11:07

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

thats pretty standard, when you are trying to recruit, you want someone who bothers to make an effort, you can (nomally) only choose 1, and why bother with someone who isnt that invested.

its not hard to tweak your cv for the role you are applying for

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 11:02

1950s recruiters 🤣🤣

hardboiledeggs · 22/09/2022 10:58

anotherbrewplease · 22/09/2022 05:57

They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks

Can you please make a bit more effort with your opening post, as I can't really understand it?

Well done on sifting through a lot of CVs and critiquing them.

😂

WatchoRulo · 22/09/2022 10:55

ByTheGrace · 22/09/2022 10:48

Job adverts that state the salary range!

This a thousand times over. Lack of salary transparency just demonstrates that the company wants to employ as cheaply as possible, I just scroll on by. And before anyone states that the role will be obvious from the job description, some employers like to big up their roles in the way some applicants like to over-egg their CVs.

I had this recently - a recruiter full of enthusiasm sent me details of job they said they thought was perfect for me - I agreed but pointed out that there was no salary - I replied with my current salary and expressed a desire not to take a pay cut and they very sheepishly admitted they were looking to pay about half that....

Dreamstate · 22/09/2022 10:53

If someone is only spending 3 minutes to review a CV, this will be why I just take the key words from the job application and drop them into my CV, job done. CV is just a way to get you into the door for an interview. I won't spend hours perfectly tailoring my CV if you only have 3 minutes to look at it.

WatchoRulo · 22/09/2022 10:51

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:36

Imagine working for some of these posters!

Enough red flags for a parade! 🤣

Yep. The world of work is changing - I can see that I am (gasp) 60.

I've just quit an 85K a year job to go back to freelancing.

Freelancing is a joy.

Drop in CV, quick chat - OK, you're in.

No twatting about with endless 1950's style pearl-clutching busy work.

It's no wonder we have low productivity - everyone's doing pointless bullshit busywork jobs like impersonating 1950s recruiters.

ByTheGrace · 22/09/2022 10:48

Job adverts that state the salary range!

This a thousand times over. Lack of salary transparency just demonstrates that the company wants to employ as cheaply as possible, I just scroll on by. And before anyone states that the role will be obvious from the job description, some employers like to big up their roles in the way some applicants like to over-egg their CVs.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2022 10:48

I was applying a couple of years ago and found the public sector type organisations forms took hours, were not set up for specific role I was applying for (no where to put prof qualifications that were essential for role) and often didn’t even get an acknowledgment or email to say not successful.
Teen DD recently applied for pt job. Only one bothered to reply and she got job. Rest still seem to be advertising on and off, I definitely think less of businesses that can’t even be bothered to say no or if you don’t hear by x date you are unsuccessful.
Wooly job advertisements and unclear hours. If it’s essential to have x qualification or work weekends make it absolutely clear.

Riverlee · 22/09/2022 10:47

Haven’t read the whole thread, but I agree with you, op.

Used to work in a camping shop. We’d get cvs on a daily basis from teens looking for work. Some letters would talk about their interest in computers, science etc but nothing relevant to shop work (eg customer service) and/or camping. Several had spelling mistakes also. No wonder they didn’t get an interview!

NeedAHoliday2021 · 22/09/2022 10:41

applications should be cv plus covering letter. I recently spent hours applying for an nhs role thinking I’d just have to adapt for the second nhs role I wanted to go for. Nope, one was on the old and one on the new system. It didn’t auto transfer so I had to re input all the info. The ask for covering statement was also totally different. By that time it was too late to rework my statement for new criteria (that you couldn’t see until you reached that page). To be fair, it was a senior role so I expected it to a degree but a band 2 applicant would have the same process. I think companies should be realistic in their expectations and those applying should try. It works both ways.

GoingThatWay · 22/09/2022 10:35

When we recruit, we ask for four essential things which are:

Must be able to work evenings and weekends.
Must have in date licence.
Must be fit and able bodied.
Must be have experience.

Some of the applications are anything but.
We get applications from single parents who say they can't work evenings and weekends, but can work daytime.
We don't work daytime!
They have no licence, could we provide it?
No!
They are disabled.
Definitely no!
They have no experience but are willing to learn.
No!
If I didn't follow the criteria, then I would be risking being sued!
We once tried advertising via the job centre. It was a complete waste of everyone's time. Never again.

Hollyhocksarenotmessy · 22/09/2022 10:34

I recruit, and I've also moved jobs a few times in the last 5 years, so I sympathise with both sides.

The only time I was on jobseekers about 5 years ago I was lucky enough to have a sensible coach, who set me a target of 5 actions a week, which could be applications, contacting an agency etc.Other people were being set 25 actions a week. You get sanctioned if you don't complete and record on-line all your actions. People are forced to scatter-gun applications.

It's a waste of their time and our time.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 22/09/2022 10:31

And from the applicant’s perspective, the number of spelling and grammatical mistakes I’ve seen in job adverts is shocking. I mean truly shocking. And actually embarrassing when one of the criteria sought is “attention to detail.” If you want the applicants to put in the effort then so should the employer.

I think a previous poster answered this best when they said;

"attention to detail is a stupid criteria. It goes without saying. No-one is going to think “oh attention to detail isn’t one of my qualities so I won’t apply”. Employers need to write better criteria especially for lower level job. Vague sound bites like “attention to detail” help no-one, applicant or employer."

I'd add to this and say that attention to detail isn't a catch all skill. In your case it apparently means you are looking for someone who can spell and has a good grasp of grammar.

In my role attention to detail would translate as someone who can spot errors in forumlas, data, and outputs.

Even then there are levels within the specific area. There's a world of difference between the "attention to detail" someone needs to use a spellchecker after they've written an email/internal comms compared to the level required to proof a contract or edit a statutory/public report.

So instead of saying "attention to detail" you need to state what it is you actually want from your applicants.

MsMcGonagall · 22/09/2022 10:27

XingMing · 22/09/2022 09:48

@MsMcGonagall ruled you out! 119 are not getting the job; your numeracy fails you! xx

Bugger!

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 22/09/2022 10:26

Noviembre · 22/09/2022 09:10

If you can't get off your phone for the duration of an interview, yes, you're unemployable.

How do you have a phone on your hand, Hearth? Is it surgically attached ( no surprise there) ? Or is it a feat of prestidigitation , suitable for applicants to a circus?

Or are you just making an involuntary point about the people for whom you are advocating ?

MediumDwarf · 22/09/2022 10:25

I’m surprised even 3minutes is spent reviewing applications on a first screen. Hence, I click easy apply on LinkedIn, or share my profile with the recruiter or job poster.

It’s designed to be a digital CV. Everything is there experience wise to see, and if they feel I’m a good fit, they can contact me.

If the apply button links to workday or the company portal and requests an account be created, I’m off!

I would never spend time writing a cover letter or answering questions either. However, I can understand why that is useful to hire graduates or entry level candidates with no experience on their CV, but for experienced hires a CV should be sufficient to determine if you want to interview them.

No excuses for spelling errors though!

AnotherAnxiousMess · 22/09/2022 10:16

I agree. I only apply for jobs I really want and so tailor my CV and covering letter for each, I almost always get to interview stage. However, this does take more time and if people are on job seekers, they have to apply for so many jobs a week, so I do understand why people just send out generic CV’s… not effective at all though.