I read a Facebook thingy where an organisation said they sent out the interview questions in advance, and were astounded that the quality of the answers they received were so much higher.
I suck at interviews. They are HIGHLY pressured for candidates. There’s a lot riding on them, a lot of etiquette and no room for error, you have no knowledge of the context or culture, or the personalities of people concerned and you have to present yourself in your best light while not being a self absorbed dick, and then answer stupid surprise questions, designed to catch you out.
How many bloody jobs are like that, really? Surely you want candidates who are well prepared, who can establish relationships, consider their answers based on what they already know. Few jobs a require such snap decisions with so little context, background or in such isolation. You’re not seeing people in any sort of realistic light. It’s like diffusing a bomb. I can never think of anything remotely relevant, until I’m on the way home. How many decisions in this job really require immediate answers with, no thinking time, no reflection, no background knowledge, no knowledge of the people you’re working with (or against) no reasrarch or fact checking and no discussion with colleagues or refining?
I’m guessing very, very few. James Bond, maybe. Everyone else seems to be in bloody meetings all the time, which is exactly the opposite.