Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
Raddix · 22/09/2022 13:49

ByTheGrace · 22/09/2022 13:42

export to pdf

Actually now you've mentioned that, I have a question for the CV reviewers here. I always send everything in pdf format, it avoids formatting issues.
DD applied for a job, I said pdf your CV, she didn't get an interview, asked for feedback and they had ruled her out because she'd sent a pdf, which wasn't compatible. So my name was mud. But what is the expected file format? Should she send Word doc and pdf? No clue on the advert, just email your CV. She'd spent bloody ages on it too.

That’s insane! PDF is the only way to reliably retain the formatting and font and layout. I’m likely to have used a font that the reader doesn’t have on their computer, so a Word document could look like shit when they open it.

dutysuite · 22/09/2022 13:48

No problem with getting an interview it’s what happens during the process I find frustrating. My husband has just been through five rounds of interviews with a company, two of those being at 7.30am, and 11.30pm and spent hours putting together the various presentations they required; however it’s all gone radio silent. He is 52 so definitely facing ageism now anyway but again, I’m starting to think this was a case of a free bit of consultancy for the company - he’s probably had a lucky escape but it’s outrageous to treat people this way.

Raddix · 22/09/2022 13:47

I always tailor my CV and cover letter. I get lots of interviews because I’m well qualified and articulate. Then I get rejected every single time as soon as they meet me and realise I’m autistic. Or maybe they don’t realise I’m autistic, but they know I have some sort of disability and they don’t like it. If I put autism on my CV I get zero interviews.

Motorina · 22/09/2022 13:45

That's crazy - PDF should be accessible for everyone. That's why I use it!

ByTheGrace · 22/09/2022 13:42

export to pdf

Actually now you've mentioned that, I have a question for the CV reviewers here. I always send everything in pdf format, it avoids formatting issues.
DD applied for a job, I said pdf your CV, she didn't get an interview, asked for feedback and they had ruled her out because she'd sent a pdf, which wasn't compatible. So my name was mud. But what is the expected file format? Should she send Word doc and pdf? No clue on the advert, just email your CV. She'd spent bloody ages on it too.

76543br · 22/09/2022 13:12

I've wondered about this before. I applied to around 5 graduate roles in 2020 (during COVID) and got interviews for all of them. My CV is not particularly impressive aside from having a first class degree from a pretty average uni, I had no extracurriculars and very limited work experience. In contrast, a lot of my friends and coursemates applied to hundreds of jobs with no luck. A year later I did the same and applied to 3 roles and got interviews for all of them. I spent a time crafting each CV and cover letter to the role, it doesn't take long but seems to make such a difference.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 13:04

Quite right @3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens - that's why this comment was shocking to see upthread

For a bright, normal applicant it's easy to get hired

I have since shared it on Twitter and LinkedIn, people are hurt and upset by this exact attitude.

3rdOfHisNameBreakerOfPens · 22/09/2022 12:57

I find it very strange that the expected standard of English and CV writing is so high for roles that do not require literacy.

Minimum wage roles that never require a candidate to pick up a pen or type, yet employers want graduate level literacy skills. Why?
Does using the right homophone translate into cleaning better?
Does not slicing commas guarantee good customer service skills.

You have to wonder, if people applying to these basic roles really had all the unnecessary skills asked for, surely they are selling themselves short.

Nevermind the fact it's direct discrimination against those with dyslexia or who are not neurotypical and unable to navigate unnecessary social bullshit.

People need to start valuing the actual skills needed for the role and not someone's ability to write reams of bullshit.

NurseryNurse10 · 22/09/2022 12:51

I've had nanny roles which have been a simple interview and then others even for nursery and teaching assistant roles which have been ridiculous. Hours spent on maths tests, English test, long drawn out application form etc. All for minimum wage. Can see why people get frustrated. It's a ridiculous system for part time or low paid work.

L1ttledrummergirl · 22/09/2022 12:45

As an applicant and intelligent human being, if it's full of jargon- even if I understand it- then I move on. If it's riddled with spelling and grammar mistakes or over complicated in any way then I pass it over. If it doesn't mention a salary, or the salary is low for the job description then I don't bother.

This is the big one for me though, I have a c.v, I will write a covering letter to go with it, I will happily fill in a basic application form with additional information. What I won't do is rewrite my c.v ten different ways to fill in the over complicated forms employers seem to want.
I'm a straight forward person, this is my skill set, this is what I've achieved in that field. If it works in your vacancy then interview me to find out more, if it doesn't then move on. I've no desire to work for someone who is too stupid to extrapolate key information that they have been given.

Oh, and when you employ someone because they have skills you advertise, don't then refuse to let them use those skills because you are scared they can do that part of the job better than you.

sweetpeapea · 22/09/2022 12:44

Hmm I'm not too sure. I have a CV that if I tailored to every job I applied for I would have no time for anything else.
So I send my generic one in. I'll tailor it for a special job. It's horrific atm applying for jobs though. And really sad. Even worse, I worked in an recruitment agency and it made me sick what went on in there (I wasn't a recruiter)

Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 12:31

Blooberry, I ran a B&B - so not so much clients as guests, and they would obviously tell a prospective employer I cook a mean 'Full Scottish ' and the loos were spotless but it's a bit of an odd 'relationship'. When I've actually managed to speak to an HR person, I've explained the situation, offered on line reviews as a way of getting an idea of who I am (18 years worth!). My customer service skills are second to none, but I don't fit in a required box. I have years of prior professional experience, but many of my previous referees are, well, dead, or I have no idea where they are!

Sorry, I seem to have hijacked OP's thread with my tales of woe Grin.

Anyway, I'm doing some online training to try and improve my skills so onwards and upwards.

thecatsthecats · 22/09/2022 12:23

Eeksteek · 22/09/2022 12:07

What I’m really struggling with though, what seems absolutely impenetrable to me, is the descriptions of actual jobs. I’ve a clinical background, and I totally get that there is a certain amount of job or industry specific jargon going on. That’s fine. But from reading ads, I cannot fathom what these people actually do all day. It sounds like utter bullshit to me. You would think I am patently unsuitable for most ‘business’ jobs based on my understanding of what they are. And yet that is not true. I’ve got two degrees and have run a successful business, aside from my clinical career. I must have LOADS of skills, I pick things up quickly and I like learning and getting better at things. But I have no idea how to translate that for private sector businesses, and I can’t understand what you’re asking for. It’s like another language.

It makes me fume a bit when job descriptions like this then twat on about equality, diversity and inclusion. Because good EDI hiring means using minimal viable criteria, and clear language. It's about hiring people who COULD do the job using applicable experience, not doing a jargon dump that means even people who work in the field scratch their heads.

OriginalUsername2 · 22/09/2022 12:23

tuttifruit · 22/09/2022 06:08

Might be hard for you but it's even harder for job applicants who are expected to fill out multiple forms and individual cover letters and CVs for each job application - which often turn out to be an inactive/internal post that they have no chance at anyway. Use a recruitment agency if you cba to sift through bad ones

This. It’s ridiculous. One job application can take a whole day.

BlooberryBiskits · 22/09/2022 12:23

@Rapidtango

I'm sure it's probably a combination of my age, the fact I've been self employed for years, have no current referees, but it just seems that the application process these days is pretty much 'computer says no' and there's nothing I can do about it.

I think you have diagnosed correctly- can you reach out to your clients for a reference perhaps?

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2022 12:21

Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 12:14

Eeksteek, one of the jobs I've applied for has the following as a job description.

'We provide an enabling service to all vital services of Xx City Council. The Business Support teams are flexible and responsive and there will be opportunities to move between teams to gain experience of the services across the council.

If you are a team player who is enthusiastic and committed to providing an excellent customer focussed service, we would welcome your application.

You will be working in a reactive team supporting one of the many services within the Council. You will have excellent communication skills, the ability to deal with challenging situations and work to statutory or regulatory deadlines. You should have the ability to multitask and deal with changing priorities. It would be an advantage if you have previous experience of working with a case management system. You should be fully familiar with data protection and the use of MS Office / Office 365.'

And that's it. If it wasn't so frustrating it would be hilarious.

Sounds like business admin support? Is there a facility to contact someone for more info or an informal chat.

Bubblebubblebah · 22/09/2022 12:19

GoingThatWay · 22/09/2022 10:35

When we recruit, we ask for four essential things which are:

Must be able to work evenings and weekends.
Must have in date licence.
Must be fit and able bodied.
Must be have experience.

Some of the applications are anything but.
We get applications from single parents who say they can't work evenings and weekends, but can work daytime.
We don't work daytime!
They have no licence, could we provide it?
No!
They are disabled.
Definitely no!
They have no experience but are willing to learn.
No!
If I didn't follow the criteria, then I would be risking being sued!
We once tried advertising via the job centre. It was a complete waste of everyone's time. Never again.

Oh same.
In one job we had number of applicants requesting morning work. The place wasn't even open in morning. The hours were clearly set up in advert AND on our website...

WhatNoRaisins · 22/09/2022 12:18

I remember a thread about NHS jobs where it was claimed they have no choice but to outsource their adverts to a department that does a poor job. Why? I thought in most jobs if you did a crap job at a minimum you'd be expected to reflect on why your work was so poor and how you can improve.

Rapidtango · 22/09/2022 12:14

Eeksteek, one of the jobs I've applied for has the following as a job description.

'We provide an enabling service to all vital services of Xx City Council. The Business Support teams are flexible and responsive and there will be opportunities to move between teams to gain experience of the services across the council.

If you are a team player who is enthusiastic and committed to providing an excellent customer focussed service, we would welcome your application.

You will be working in a reactive team supporting one of the many services within the Council. You will have excellent communication skills, the ability to deal with challenging situations and work to statutory or regulatory deadlines. You should have the ability to multitask and deal with changing priorities. It would be an advantage if you have previous experience of working with a case management system. You should be fully familiar with data protection and the use of MS Office / Office 365.'

And that's it. If it wasn't so frustrating it would be hilarious.

Dixiechickonhols · 22/09/2022 12:12

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 11:21

@ADecadeAndAHalf I had the same type of interview. It was advertised as full time but said part time would be considered.

When I got to the interview, I mentioned this and I was immediately asked to leave by the woman who was interviewing me. It was so humiliating.

I actually complained to the Head Office about this woman and explained how she treated me. They were extremely embarrassed and apologised.

I went on to work elsewhere but for the same industry. We had this company on the supplier list and it was part of my role to choose who we used for that particular service. Obviously they lost all of our £200k per year business as I refused to work with the dragon (it was client facing and she was horrid!)

Good result! I do think companies forget they don’t exist in a bubble and people will work with them in future especially in niche industries or be potential customers.

Part time is a nightmare. They usually don’t advertise the hours. Makes a huge difference eg 10-2 suits mums but students don’t waste time applying, 6-10 suit students etc.
Had a quick look on indeed and only 1 pt locally has clear advert proper days and hours - a local well regarded butchers (gone further up in my estimation for a clear advert). The subway and sushi national chain ones witter on but no indication of hours or days.

I need to work around college but can do any evening and weekend and live at end of road and can walk here in 5 mins is surely what recruiter needs know not war and peace application on why I’ve a burning desire to be a ‘sandwich artist’

Eeksteek · 22/09/2022 12:07

What I’m really struggling with though, what seems absolutely impenetrable to me, is the descriptions of actual jobs. I’ve a clinical background, and I totally get that there is a certain amount of job or industry specific jargon going on. That’s fine. But from reading ads, I cannot fathom what these people actually do all day. It sounds like utter bullshit to me. You would think I am patently unsuitable for most ‘business’ jobs based on my understanding of what they are. And yet that is not true. I’ve got two degrees and have run a successful business, aside from my clinical career. I must have LOADS of skills, I pick things up quickly and I like learning and getting better at things. But I have no idea how to translate that for private sector businesses, and I can’t understand what you’re asking for. It’s like another language.

Eeksteek · 22/09/2022 11:57

I read a Facebook thingy where an organisation said they sent out the interview questions in advance, and were astounded that the quality of the answers they received were so much higher.

I suck at interviews. They are HIGHLY pressured for candidates. There’s a lot riding on them, a lot of etiquette and no room for error, you have no knowledge of the context or culture, or the personalities of people concerned and you have to present yourself in your best light while not being a self absorbed dick, and then answer stupid surprise questions, designed to catch you out.

How many bloody jobs are like that, really? Surely you want candidates who are well prepared, who can establish relationships, consider their answers based on what they already know. Few jobs a require such snap decisions with so little context, background or in such isolation. You’re not seeing people in any sort of realistic light. It’s like diffusing a bomb. I can never think of anything remotely relevant, until I’m on the way home. How many decisions in this job really require immediate answers with, no thinking time, no reflection, no background knowledge, no knowledge of the people you’re working with (or against) no reasrarch or fact checking and no discussion with colleagues or refining?

I’m guessing very, very few. James Bond, maybe. Everyone else seems to be in bloody meetings all the time, which is exactly the opposite.

smooththecat · 22/09/2022 11:54

I wouldn’t tweak my CV, a CV is a very general overview of what you’ve done in your career, how do you tweak that? A covering statement is where you say how you meet the person specification. Most recruiters wanting a specific format use an application portal rather than CV + statement. Most roles specifically forbid CVs these days anyway.

YouSirNeighMmmm · 22/09/2022 11:45

PurBal · 22/09/2022 06:13

Applying for jobs 20 years ago: send generic CV you have kept updated, personalised covering letter, send to hiring manager, receive reply from hiring manager (yes or no). Total time spent: 30 minutes.
Applying for jobs today: take CV, log into some kind of online portal, input data into digital form (can’t always straight copy and past because there are multiple boxes in different formats), answer three questions circa 200 words why you should get the job over someone else, complete form on inclusion, export to pdf, attach to email, write cover email, send to hiring manager, wait a month and if you don’t hear assume you didn’t get the job. Total time spent: 3 hours
If your desperate for work, imagine doing 10 or 30 of these kind of applications. Depending on the job you can also get additional online assessments.
True CVs shouldn’t be personalised to the job but an overview of the applicants background. Covering letters should be personalised and highlight particular relevant skills.

100%. I am hoping to never have to work for anyone again, and I am fairly experienced / professional so online forms are less likely than for more junior jobs, but I genuinely don't know how younger people tolerate it. Like having to shop around for energy suppliers (it would be better if there was one good price that we all automatically pay) it is a complete waste of time seemingly imposed by those with power simply because they don't care one little bit about the value of ordinary people's time.

Here is my CV, same as I send to everyone. (Caveat. If you are returning to an old industry maybe you'd cut down the detail about your current job and add detail to you last job in the industry you are returning to).

Here is a cover letter which helps decide whether I might be a good fit for the job and company over and above the general stuff in the CV.

Nocaloriesinchocolate · 22/09/2022 11:43

Many years ago, when, shockingly, disability discrimination was rife, I wrote in an application that one of my hobbies was teaching dance. I also, mistakenly, ticked the box saying I was disabled. In those days “disabled” meant “in a wheelchair” and one main reason why I was offered an interview was because they wanted to know how I could be in a wheelchair and teach dance! Shocking to think of now. (I got the job - which was nothing to do with dance and which could have been done in a wheelchair).