Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
NeverDropYourMooncup · 22/09/2022 07:40

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 06:42

Firstly, sorry about my posting errors. I'm using my phone and I have fat fingers.
I totally understand that putting in a detailed application takes time and can be soul destroying when you get no response.
We don't ask for a covering letter or any specific questions (although I do cover motivation to apply for the role and skills and experience in a telephone screening call if they get passed the first sift).
My issue is that the CV starts with a statement like "looking for my next role in a scientific laboratory" for example when we are a charity for social care.why bother applying? You e ruled yourself out and wasted the time it took you to upload the cv.
And our job descriptions are fairly specific.

Why be so specific? It's a charity for social care - you either need support staff or admin. It doesn't matter if a lab tech applies, they've got a good chance of being able to do either without wasting time trying to rephrase 'I can make sure nobody catches some awful disease in the lab from anything I do' into 'has experience of being responsible for own health and safety' (as is clumsily stated in many job specs).

PianoHouseBanger · 22/09/2022 07:39

Agree with so many points made by PP.

When companies start being transparent, i.e putting actual salaries or bandings instead of 'competitive', working schedule etc, then I think people Will make more effort.

The amount of times I've spent hours tailoring, going through applications and interviews, to learn the salary advised after the 2nd interview, was far too low. A complete waste of time for everyone.

Oh, and wanting every applicant to have a degree, even if it has no bearing on the job advertised at all. What happened to experience.

bagboo · 22/09/2022 07:37

We've had similar recently. And we only require a cover letter and CV, not pages of online form filling.

50 applications, we're only interviewing 4. The rest were full of spelling mistakes, asking 10k over the salary offer, some cover letters talking about completely different roles, some CVs with zero relevant experience.

We're advertising for an administrator at 24k. We've had applications from previous bricklayers and beauticians who don't refer to any use of relevant systems, one says they're not good with computers, one waffles on about their interest in medieval weaponry.

CoalTit · 22/09/2022 07:32

It's called a curriculum vitae because it's supposed to give you a brief resumé of a person's career until now. Curriculum: course, road, journey. Vitae: life. The idea of tailoring it for each potential employee is absurd in itself.

Meseekslookatme · 22/09/2022 07:30

Did you acknowledge every applicant?
If not YABU.
I'm not spending a couple of hours on each application for it to get glanced at for 3 minutes and binned. That's incredibly disrespectful.
I made job hunting a full time job when I got made redundant and can count on 2 hands how many nice rejections I got.
FULL TIME searching, hours every day, and most of the employers couldn't even be bothered to send me a generic email back.
I found a job within a week of finishing my old one because my cv is good.
If my cv is good and I can't even get a rejection, how must others feel?
I now don't actively hunt if I want a new job. I switch on LinkedIn and cv library and let them come to me. And they do, because no-one seems to be able to fill positions with the crap wages they used to get away with. Bliss.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 07:25

00100001 · 22/09/2022 07:12

If you have 100 applicants, you can't spend 45 minutes carefully considering each application.

It's really a quick task to bsirt into initial rejected/look into further piles. 3 minutes is generous.

Last hire we did, we had people who only answered questions with 1-2 words. Rejected. Didn't include CV as requested? Rejected.

Skimmed over answered questions, look promising? Put them in maybe pile. Poor grammar/spelling etc... Rejected.
Skimmed over CV, relevant experience? Maybe. No experience? Rejected.

We sorted through the applications quickly.

Maybe pile gets looked at more closely.

But when people are applying for jobs employers are expecting people to spend 45 mins tailoring their CVS for each other the hundreds of jobs they are applying for.

As someone who regularly recruits for all areas of their company, it’s beyond me how you can’t scan the jobs and description of the role and responsibilities and figure out yes or no. That can be done quickly

Rather than expecting someone to write a a summary just for that job. What’s the point of the CV if all you want is a personalised summary or cover letter, specifically for your company and role.

and it sounds like you fill in an application AND want a tailored CV? You are expecting people to put in a lot of time, that you are willing to give them.

Breastfeedingworries · 22/09/2022 07:21

When looking for local roles I’ve used Zoop recruitment.

found them helpful to be honest. They look through the CVS, match skills qualifications then they do a phone interview with the candidates before they refer.

saves on the boring cv scrolls of mememe III, or charity plugs. Hard work is done, it’s a bit soulless eventually looking through so many cvs.

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 22/09/2022 07:18

It goes both ways though. Applying for multiple jobs, which is what is required when you’re unemployed is a full time job in itself and is utterly soul destroying when the employer doesn’t even bother to acknowledge that you weren’t successful.

I agree that you have to put at least some effort into applying for a job but let’s be honest here, when you’re spending 35 hours plus a week applying for jobs not all of them are going to be your dream job.

And from the applicant’s perspective, the number of spelling and grammatical mistakes I’ve seen in job adverts is shocking. I mean truly shocking. And actually embarrassing when one of the criteria sought is “attention to detail.” If you want the applicants to put in the effort then so should the employer.

And there is 0 excuse for not sending a rejection. None what so ever, given that most jobs are applied through via online portal and they have the ability to build in a generic email when they reject that application.

00100001 · 22/09/2022 07:12

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

If you have 100 applicants, you can't spend 45 minutes carefully considering each application.

It's really a quick task to bsirt into initial rejected/look into further piles. 3 minutes is generous.

Last hire we did, we had people who only answered questions with 1-2 words. Rejected. Didn't include CV as requested? Rejected.

Skimmed over answered questions, look promising? Put them in maybe pile. Poor grammar/spelling etc... Rejected.
Skimmed over CV, relevant experience? Maybe. No experience? Rejected.

We sorted through the applications quickly.

Maybe pile gets looked at more closely.

35965a · 22/09/2022 07:09

WhatNoRaisins · 22/09/2022 07:06

The whole thing needs a massive overhaul.

No more making people apply for anything and everything to please the jobcentre

No more of these generic and meaningless job adverts that you couldn't tailor an application to even if you wanted to

Proportionate job application processes for the role and salary

Job adverts that actually contain relevant information like where the job actually is and what the actual hours will be

There's so much time and effort wasted on this completely unnecessarily

Very true ^

35965a · 22/09/2022 07:09

I think employers expect far too much from applicants most of the time. You spend 3 minutes looking at a CV when it takes hours to fill in application forms on each online portal. For shit jobs too. No wonder some may accidentally send the wrong CV, they’ve probably got about 15 tailored versions saved.

CrystalCoco · 22/09/2022 07:08

It's not unreasonable at all to expect this. It's been a long time since I've been in the position of sending out CVs but it was a given that I'd tailor/tweak my CV to the position I was applying to - I don't know where I picked up that piece of advice but it should be standard.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/09/2022 07:06

The whole thing needs a massive overhaul.

No more making people apply for anything and everything to please the jobcentre

No more of these generic and meaningless job adverts that you couldn't tailor an application to even if you wanted to

Proportionate job application processes for the role and salary

Job adverts that actually contain relevant information like where the job actually is and what the actual hours will be

There's so much time and effort wasted on this completely unnecessarily

bob78 · 22/09/2022 07:05

I recruited for a role around graduation season so had lots of graduates applying, I was shocked at how poor their attempts were, do unis not have career shops any more?! Such basic stuff like not tailoring, I gave one person an interview simply because they actually did say why they wanted the role which felt like a victory!

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 06:54

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 06:42

Firstly, sorry about my posting errors. I'm using my phone and I have fat fingers.
I totally understand that putting in a detailed application takes time and can be soul destroying when you get no response.
We don't ask for a covering letter or any specific questions (although I do cover motivation to apply for the role and skills and experience in a telephone screening call if they get passed the first sift).
My issue is that the CV starts with a statement like "looking for my next role in a scientific laboratory" for example when we are a charity for social care.why bother applying? You e ruled yourself out and wasted the time it took you to upload the cv.
And our job descriptions are fairly specific.

That’s not tailoring to the role. That’s tailoring to the wrong role. They tailored it for one role, and either couldn’t be bothered or forgot to remove it.

Wanting to work in a lab isn’t something that’s on a ‘generic’ CV.

There’s a good chance that a lot of those CVS are being sent by people on job seekers, as they will get sanctioned if they don’t apply for roles. They want to work in a lab but are wxekctes to apply for any roles. Understandably, they are just applying for any they can and may accept one if they happened to get while they pursue working in a lab. Who can blame them for doing it when they worried about losing money for not apply for jobs, even if they don’t want it.

Hardbackwriter · 22/09/2022 06:52

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

It's supply and demand though, isn't it? When I recruit in my area we always have a lot more applicants than jobs so I can be fairly picky and the applications that have very little time put into them will be very quickly ruled out (and the work also requires a lot of attention to detail and good writing skills, so I think it's reasonable to rule out applications which don't show those). My organisation can't recruit developers and business analysts despite repeatedly trying - it's a different job market and we just don't pay enough despite using all the flexibility available within our (public sector) pay scales - and I think they'd accept a napkin with 'I can do computers' scrawled on it in crayon as an application at this point. Both employers and applicants have to be reasonable about the situation they're in.

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 06:42

Firstly, sorry about my posting errors. I'm using my phone and I have fat fingers.
I totally understand that putting in a detailed application takes time and can be soul destroying when you get no response.
We don't ask for a covering letter or any specific questions (although I do cover motivation to apply for the role and skills and experience in a telephone screening call if they get passed the first sift).
My issue is that the CV starts with a statement like "looking for my next role in a scientific laboratory" for example when we are a charity for social care.why bother applying? You e ruled yourself out and wasted the time it took you to upload the cv.
And our job descriptions are fairly specific.

OP posts:
girlmom21 · 22/09/2022 06:41

I'll spend a long time tailoring my application for a role I actually really want but if I just need a job I generally don't bother and just send something generic, like when I was made redundant. I got offered an interview for every single job I applied for.

Lots of recruiters aren't looking for key experience, they're looking for previous job titles that intrigue them.

In my current role (which I did spend a bit of time but not loads updating my CV for) the recruiter told me the reason my application stood out was my experience.
My experience was completely irrelevant to the job, there were just some decent job titles and clients on there.

ADecadeAndAHalf · 22/09/2022 06:41

@Darbs76 and how many jobs did you apply for alongside applying for that promotion? Did you read up on the application process for each one? It sounds like you only applied for the one job. If you multiply that "so much time" you spent for 3-4 jobs a week, do you not see that people just don't have time amongst their other commitments?

As pp said, it's soul destroying. My last interview went something like this:
spend half a day writing cover letter and tailoring cv.
Apply - fill out online form ~1 hr
get automatic confirmation.
Hear nothing. Wait. Assume it's unsuccessful.
Monday evening 5 and a half weeks later, get phone call at 730pm. Interview on Wednesday at 9.
Cancel everything on Tuesday to prepare.
Wednesday start interview. Within the initial conversation about job role and discussion of duties went something like
interviewer "no, this is a full time role".
Co-interviewer "she wrote on her cover letter 20-40%" ( I did, in bold).
Me " the job is advertised as part time, any %"
Interviewer "well that's a mistake. There's no point continuing the interview, thank your for your time."

And you wonder why people don't sit and tailor their cv to each and every job they apply for?

EmeraldShamrock1 · 22/09/2022 06:39

Yanbu.
Would a good cover letter highlighting strengths and interests in the job being advertised be okay? Is it?

Tumbleweed101 · 22/09/2022 06:38

We are pretty relaxed about CV and cover letter but we do need responses from people with the right qualification. We have asked for level 3 qualification in childcare for roles where we need qualified staff and get CV from people who have never set foot in a nursery.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 06:35

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

That’s summed up what I was trying to say, but so much better.

Employers expect far more effort from an applicant than they are willing to give them.

The world is changing. People are realising employers aren’t doing them a favour. It’s a mutually beneficial transaction.

Unescorted · 22/09/2022 06:32

Could it be that your job description is a bit crap. Ours are vague description of a generic job that someone once did with a few up beat organisational statements and a list of values chosen because they make a good acronym.
At our last recruitment round we got over 100 CVs for an entry level admin job, mostly from people who have been unable to decipher the word soup we use. It is not the applicants fault that we are unable to articulate what the job is and the type of person who would be suitable.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 06:29

There’s actually 2 sides of this

Yes people could put more effort in, in some cases.

But in a lot of cases employers are expecting too much in return for an entry level job at 22k a year. I have a couple of entry level roles. The CVs that HR were not passing on because it ‘wasn’t tailored’ or ‘not the right sort of admin experience’ or ‘CV could have been better’

A colleague emailed me a basic CV from a. Friend of a friend. I set up and interview with myself and another director who was also looking for someone (the person was aware there was 2 jobs available). We both liked her and between the 3 of us decided the role for the other Directors area would be better for her. She is doing brilliantly.

When I emailed HR to say we had found someone for one role, they were not happy with the CV and wonder why I had interviewed in the first place. At which point I told them to stop pre checking CVS and just send them to me, now I check all my own. Pain to do.

But we are missing good people, because we expect far too much effort from people for the job.

Its easier and quicker and I have found better people than HR did. And this isn’t a dig at HR, they take direction from the MD. It’s him that’s a pain over these things. But I generally ignore him. Which is harder for them to do.

Stichintimesavesstapling · 22/09/2022 06:21

I agree but also cvs have very poor validity (they don't predict performance on the job) and reliability (no one is the same so you can't fairly compare them) so yabu for using CVs and covering letters when you could design a selection process that is more bespoke and role related.

On the plus side of you are finding a lot can't be bothered then you've got a nice self selection mechanism happening.