Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To say that when applying for jobs some people should just make more effort?

286 replies

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 05:52

I hear all the time that people have applied for 'hundreds' of jobs and not even had an interview. I hear this from graduates as well as more mature candidates.
I've been recruiting to my team over the last year and advertised about 7 or 8 roles. They BFF e been fairly popular and I have sifted around 120 cvs per role in the first two weeks.
My point is that only about 10% of applicants ensure their cv is tailored to the role.
I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly.
Most CVs start with a statement looking for a career in science' when the role is complaints manager for example.
By making a few changes to a CV so it highlights the skills for the role you want would be easy to do but very few even try.
So I'm not surprised people have no luck in their job search when they can't be bothered with the application.
AIBU to think this is the reason they are rejected?

OP posts:
Randomcommentary · 22/09/2022 08:20

GhostFromTheOtherSide · 22/09/2022 07:18

It goes both ways though. Applying for multiple jobs, which is what is required when you’re unemployed is a full time job in itself and is utterly soul destroying when the employer doesn’t even bother to acknowledge that you weren’t successful.

I agree that you have to put at least some effort into applying for a job but let’s be honest here, when you’re spending 35 hours plus a week applying for jobs not all of them are going to be your dream job.

And from the applicant’s perspective, the number of spelling and grammatical mistakes I’ve seen in job adverts is shocking. I mean truly shocking. And actually embarrassing when one of the criteria sought is “attention to detail.” If you want the applicants to put in the effort then so should the employer.

And there is 0 excuse for not sending a rejection. None what so ever, given that most jobs are applied through via online portal and they have the ability to build in a generic email when they reject that application.

Also “attention to detail” is a stupid criteria. It goes without saying. No-one is going to think “oh attention to detail isn’t one of my qualities so I won’t apply”.

Employers need to write better criteria especially for lower level job. Vague sound bites like “attention to detail” help no-one, applicant or employer.

Having had more professional and well paid jobs previously I have recently applied for more entry level positions in other fields. I’m amazed at the lower down you go the more vague the descriptions are because the people writing the adverts and job descriptions don’t really have a clue about the role. I temporarily had a role and the description for my replacement was so out of touch with the actual role it like a different job, but all the sound bite HR phrases were in there.

Dogstar78 · 22/09/2022 08:19

I have just been through the recruitment process. It took me a solid day to apply for 2 maybe three jobs. That was for jobs with the same title in the same sector.

I take out the key competencies and expectations as the focus was different depending on the role. Initially I spent a day or two working on a skeleton covering letter with statements I could import for the most popular requests in the JD. I spent a couple of days updating my CV, but rarely make tweeks to this for each job. It's the cover letter I spend time on. As a recruiter, I spent a lot of time on the letter as this is where you can convey your passion for the sector, role and highlight relevant experience.

I agree, having to cut and paste out bits from my CV and then rework them for a slightly different purpose for their portal was very annoying and time consuming. The D&I stuff and the basic details don't take long. The only benefit I see is that my logging back into the portal you can keep an eye on progress with your application. Being on the otherwise, it is way easier to manage recruitment with an online system. I did also have an organisation that asked for feedback on the process. I have also been asked verbally in interviews for feedback.

I interviewed for jobs two years ago and again this summer. Both times I was successful with my first application. I guess this is very rare, but more time, less applications seems to work for me. Reading the application and preparation for interview information is key. So.e organisations have specific ways of recruiting, like the Government and FAANG companies.

I can see how you can apply for hundreds of jobs, as I have seen applications where people are clearly applying for anything with little thought. We had names that were blacklisted in our system for doing this. Or they are lying and haven't really done anything!

Hoppinggreen · 22/09/2022 08:11

BoredWithLife · 22/09/2022 06:18

"I spend about 3 minutes looking at each applicant so need to be impressed quickly."

Just curious, if you are only willing to give there application 3 minutes, how long are they supposed to give creating it? I get that it is often seen that the employee is "giving" someone a job/chance but the same is true in reverse the applicant is "giving" the company their skills.

Why do you expect serious effort on the applicants part if you're only willing to offer 3 minutes?

I am currently sifting CVs. I am doing it alongside my usual responsibilities so my initial look is probably 3 minutes. I only remove the definite no’s at that point though and the rest get more time.
Unfortunately if there is a typo or similar it’s very unlikely I will give it more than the 3 minutes

cocktailclub · 22/09/2022 08:10

@CollieWobble22
Agree I made errors but I wasn't complaining about typos. I was complaining about no effort to even make it look as if you have a vague interest in the role on offer by removing a statement that makes it clear you have no interest in a role. And with respect I'm not applying for a job here.

OP posts:
00100001 · 22/09/2022 08:10

00100001 · 22/09/2022 08:09

HR might. But I doubt it, as they're dealing with around 300 a day.

And also, once bitten, twice shy.

Did this once, and then had a few dozen responses asking why? Can we be reconsidered? Takes forever!

Doormatnomore · 22/09/2022 08:09

I agree with @Hearthnhome I’m my last job there was some
illness/covid/general timing issues at work and I was asked to help out recruiting. I ended up sifting all the cvs but it turns out it had already been done. When we compared answered they had used wildly different criteria to me, for example they had rejected someone because they lacked “breadth of experience”, but they had a masters in the exact thing we needed, a job that didn’t need a degree at all. It was like advertising for a shoe designer, having Manolo Blahnik apply for a £19k job and reject them because they’d only worked for 1 company. Was the weirdest meeting but really hammered home how applying for jobs isn’t a science.

00100001 · 22/09/2022 08:09

Arbesque · 22/09/2022 07:56

But do you send a quick email to the reject pile letting them know their application has been unsuccessful?

HR might. But I doubt it, as they're dealing with around 300 a day.

CoverYourselfInChocolateGlory · 22/09/2022 08:09

I agree, OP. We recently advertised for an entry level role in Indeed and got over 100 applications. However only three of them had read the ad properly and submitted what was required.

CollieWobble22 · 22/09/2022 08:07

This makes me sad. But it goes both ways actually.

  1. HR manager contacted me on a Sunday and gave me 12 hours notice for an interview. When I said I couldn't arrange childcare in that time (Summer holidays) she said "either you want the job or you don't"

  2. 14 page application forms from the 2000s (this is very common!)

  3. Part time, NMW marketing role - being asked to write a 500 word blog post and present a SWOT analysis for 30 mins in front of the board. The blog post was later used on their site but no job offer. Nobody got the job.

  4. You apply for the role and spend ages on Covering Letter and CV...But no matter how good you are, it has been offered to a mates mum despite the fact she has no experience.

Recruitment agencies are the worst though. Just yesterday I was asked to add skills to my CV which I didn't actually have. They directly told me to lie. Main recruiter in the County - If I say no then I've probably burnt a huge bridge.

But OP, you yourself made so many errors due to fat fingers. Case in point.

Calmdown14 · 22/09/2022 08:07

Oh god yes. You are so right.

We had a very basic entry level role. Great opportunity to get into a good employer. Very few set requirements other than good organisational skills, IT proficient, can use social media.

Even those working in Tescos could have pulled out the relevant bits of what they do there (stock rotation, dealing with rotas etc) .

But we got hundreds who wanted entry into a completely different field, who didn't meet any of the essential requirements on paper. Looking at their CV their roles must have met it but it's not my job to work this out, you need to tell me! Especially in a role where being able to select the relevant bits of information is key. If you can't do this on the application then there's little hope.

I also assume these are the 'I've applied for hundreds ' bunch and I really want to tell them to just apply for 10 jobs well. It's so frustrating on their behalf

Bubblebubblebah · 22/09/2022 08:01

Yanbu. I've seen cvs in number of my jobs and am sometimes Confused
Quantity vs quality doesn't work unless it's lower paid less "skilled" jobs.
Most recent is someone applying for senior job with experience in field required (it is really needed to know what the job is about), and we got bunch where people absolutely ignored requirements (some obviously didn't even read it). This is an application you do test first to submit. They spent time on going through process then submitted something that was vague and in no way relevant. Such a waste of time for them (and us). Friends in other firms report similar issues. We don't even require some major tailoring fgs.

I used to have a pick and mix cv for myself. It was about 5 pages and I always picked items to put together cv which would be more tailored to the role I was applying. Worked well! Got quite a few interviews, 2 job offers when I was changing careers😱 It saved time on applications. The only extra time slent really was at the beginning to create the different parts.

jessieminto · 22/09/2022 08:00

I'm recruiting right now and struggling to get applications due to the combo of our location and salary. SMT know this but would rather wait it out.

I get more applications from other countries, people without any relevant experience at all or from people who don't know where the location is and realise they can't get there on public transport. It's very frustrating.

OTH - I'm also looking to move on. I can't be bothered with these long application processes, log in to this portal, upload a CV here etc. if it's a 1 click apply and my CV wooshes off then great. Otherwise, I'm too tired and drained to log in on a PC. I'm doing it off my phone or not at all.

Butterfly44 · 22/09/2022 07:59

I totally agree. I recruit a fair bit and some applications are so poor, they don't seem to read the job description or person spec as there's zero evidence in the application. Straight on no pile. I don't know if kids get taught about cvs and applying for jobs in school at all; it's an important life skill to know about.

bob78 · 22/09/2022 07:59

I know job hunting can be a bit arduous, but considering how much of your life a job takes and the lifeline it is in your financial security I don't think spending time on applications is a tall ask. Recruiting is challenging so you need to get it right, a CV in isolation tells you very little (unless actually we'll written which is a rarity) I change jobs every couple years and take quite "strategic" steps in that I'm not applying in bulk to wide ranging roles, I don't understand the mentality of applying to everything with little effort (excepting job centre applicants, they can normally be sifted out with ease) there is a lot of support out there to help people, many of the applications I have seen are pure laziness, especially when graduates, there are no excuses, go to your career shop.

KatherineJaneway · 22/09/2022 07:58

Recruitment cost a lot of money and time and comes with pitfalls for the company. The reason you have an online portal is because asking for CV's comes with the threat of 'You didn't give me the job because I'm X' I had one chap email and ask if I didn't give him the job because he is Muslim. No matey, you didn't get the job as this was customer service based with a lot of face to face time with staff and customers and on his application he'd said he prefers working alone away from people.

You see a lot of awful applications, people who have no relevant experience, CV's that are not tailored in the slightest. When they get the job some then try and bargain non negotiables.

thecatsthecats · 22/09/2022 07:58

Sounds like you're bad at sifting.

I sift as they come in. We include a basic instruction for all applications - CV and cover letter. Which knocks out about 1/3. The ones written in crayon - another 1/3.

The remaining 1/3 aren't all tailored, but frankly I'm not arrogant enough to think that these people all want a job specifically with me.

Good recruitment I've seen at the moment includes your CV, plus giving a few short answers in lieu of a cover letter. I've even had questions given to me before an interview - because smart companies have copped on to the fact they want the best person for the job, not the one with the most time to work on the application.

Arbesque · 22/09/2022 07:56

00100001 · 22/09/2022 07:12

If you have 100 applicants, you can't spend 45 minutes carefully considering each application.

It's really a quick task to bsirt into initial rejected/look into further piles. 3 minutes is generous.

Last hire we did, we had people who only answered questions with 1-2 words. Rejected. Didn't include CV as requested? Rejected.

Skimmed over answered questions, look promising? Put them in maybe pile. Poor grammar/spelling etc... Rejected.
Skimmed over CV, relevant experience? Maybe. No experience? Rejected.

We sorted through the applications quickly.

Maybe pile gets looked at more closely.

But do you send a quick email to the reject pile letting them know their application has been unsuccessful?

00100001 · 22/09/2022 07:54

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 07:25

But when people are applying for jobs employers are expecting people to spend 45 mins tailoring their CVS for each other the hundreds of jobs they are applying for.

As someone who regularly recruits for all areas of their company, it’s beyond me how you can’t scan the jobs and description of the role and responsibilities and figure out yes or no. That can be done quickly

Rather than expecting someone to write a a summary just for that job. What’s the point of the CV if all you want is a personalised summary or cover letter, specifically for your company and role.

and it sounds like you fill in an application AND want a tailored CV? You are expecting people to put in a lot of time, that you are willing to give them.

Sometimes having the CV and the application form together is really helpful.
People aren't always consistent in their job history between the two.

Also, we don't ask paragraph/suitability questions etc. So having their CV is a useful tool to check against their other skills. Like if they can put a basic CV together, or write a short and to the point summary at the top.

CVs have revealed way more than the application form. One memorable applicant sent in a 9 page long CV 😁

bagboo · 22/09/2022 07:51

PianoHouseBanger · 22/09/2022 07:39

Agree with so many points made by PP.

When companies start being transparent, i.e putting actual salaries or bandings instead of 'competitive', working schedule etc, then I think people Will make more effort.

The amount of times I've spent hours tailoring, going through applications and interviews, to learn the salary advised after the 2nd interview, was far too low. A complete waste of time for everyone.

Oh, and wanting every applicant to have a degree, even if it has no bearing on the job advertised at all. What happened to experience.

We put the salary range and working hours on the ad and still get bonkers applications.

JustDanceAddict · 22/09/2022 07:50

I have a CV that I make tweaks to depending on the role. However I agree with the PP above who says that even for admin roles these days you often have to complete a long-winded application form which takes hours and sometimes not even get an acknowledgment. Years ago it was mainly covering letter and CV which to me is much easier and it’s not hard to tailor your application well.
i have also sifted through and omg the dross that comes through. It is incredibly difficult to recruit as there may be 1 in 100 applications worth interviewing (not even taking into account non-tailored CVs, they just have no relevant experience.

Hearthnhome · 22/09/2022 07:49

ColinRobinsonsfamiliar · 22/09/2022 07:41

yes op!
And then after sifting through them all, inviting people for interview and they turn up in flip flops and jeans or have their phones clutched to their hands… not on mute!!!

Very very frustrating.

Wow phone on their hands! What an outrage!

Couldn’t possibly be that they had it in their hand when they arrived and are just extremely nervous given the situation.

Must mean they are unemployable 🙄

Textboxmm · 22/09/2022 07:46

‘Might be hard for you but it's even harder for job applicants who are expected to fill out multiple forms and individual cover letters and CVs for each job application - which often turn out to be an inactive/internal post that they have no chance at anyway. Use a recruitment agency if you cba to sift through bad ones’

this. And at least you’re getting paid to do it…

TiredButDancing · 22/09/2022 07:46

I have a weird sideline in helping people with their cvs - indo it for friends and family. But... actually, I increasingly think the cv is an outdated tool. Or one that should go back to basics (job titles, companies and dates only) because it makes "writing a cv" a key skill for getting a job even if that job is "chief washer upper".

Having said that, i do think that whether it's via cv, LinkedIn, cover letter etc, a LOT of people are really bad at understanding that they are not entitled to a job. I once posted asking for freelancers on LinkedIn and was absolutely horrified at the responses.

It's a minefield.

sheepdogdelight · 22/09/2022 07:44

I've recently been recruiting for a job that wasn't entry level (salary 35-40K - would expect the person to have at least several years' experience) and likely that most candidates weren't "trying to get the job centre off their back", but already in work and looking for a move.

So many of the applications were poor. We asked for CV and covering letter - many candidates sent one and not the other. Many candidates had either just finished university or had no experience in the field, when it was clear they needed relevant experience. A lot of CVs were so generic it was hard to work out if they had the relevant experience or not. Covering letters tended to say "very excited about this job" but didn't say why they thought they were a good candidate. One memorably said "I am very interested in working for Network Rail". My company is not Network Rail.

We read every word of every CV, but we have minimal time to "read between the lines". You need to spell stuff out.

ColinRobinsonsfamiliar · 22/09/2022 07:41

yes op!
And then after sifting through them all, inviting people for interview and they turn up in flip flops and jeans or have their phones clutched to their hands… not on mute!!!

Very very frustrating.

Swipe left for the next trending thread